Preview

Is Compassion Really a Crime? Analysis of "A Crime of Compassion" by Barbara Huttmann

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
909 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Is Compassion Really a Crime? Analysis of "A Crime of Compassion" by Barbara Huttmann
Is Compassion Really a Crime?

Imagine standing in a hospital room watching a man suffer in agonizing pain day after day and not being able to do anything about it. This is the situation that Barbara Huttmann faces in her essay "A Crime of Compassion." Huttmann, a nurse, is forced to watch Mac live in agonizing pain without legally being able to let him die. The message that she displays in her essay is suffering people should be permitted to die if they aspire to do so. Using various rhetorical devices, Huttmann portrays her message by first introducing Mac to the reader, then illustrating his suffering and finally letting him die.

Huttmann opens her essay by introducing Mac, a young police officer who is diagnosed with lung cancer. She uses imagery to recall the day that Mac first "walked into the hospital with 32 pounds of attack equipment, looking as if he could singlehandedly protect the whole city, if not the whole state" (420). This image allows the reader to visualize and characterize Mac prior to his cancer. Contrastingly, Huttman later illustrates the Mac's condition six months after he is diagnosed. At this point Mac has lost "his youth, his wit, his macho, his hair, his bowel and bladder control, his sense of taste and smell and his ability to do even the slightest thing for himself" (420). Huttmann creates contrasting images to show the horrific changes Mac has gone through due to his diagnosis. In the first image, Mac is depicted as a super heroic figure who is indestructible. As he enters the hospital, he carries with him a fearless attitude that enables people to look to him as a figure of protection. However, in the second image, his health has disintegrated and he has wasted away to nothingness. He can no longer perform basic tasks let alone protect anyone. While not yet relating to the message, these images begin to show the tragic course of events that Mac has fallen into in comparison to the previous state of his life.

Huttmann continues her

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    In writing his novel, In Cold Blood, Capote’s primary purpose is to convey his opposition towards the death penalty. Through the stylistic elements of rhetorical appeals, a selection of detail, and imagery Capote reveals the attitude he holds against this unreasonable form of justice.…

    • 773 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The author make's a statement which is a bit too extravagant, "…compassion will lead us to the abyss of moral nihilism." – Hyperbole.…

    • 2675 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Huttmann uses inverted syntax when describing Maura’s deterioration. Mac continues to endure his treatments and resuscitation each time he stops breathing. Huttmann shows how this harms Mac but also describes how it is, “also long enough to watch Maura’s transformation from a young woman into a haggard, beaten old lady,” (1). The use of inverted syntax in this sentence tells the reader that Maura transformed but does not reveal how until the end of the sentence. This device helps Huttmann portray the message of feeling guilty to her audience. She makes the audience feel guilty for what has happened towards Mac and his loved ones.…

    • 320 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the passionate essay, “On Compassion,” by the respected Barbara Lazear Ascher, the author convincingly depicts her view towards how she feels about why people show compassion. Ascher’s purpose is to demonstrate to the reader the different classes of society and allow the reader to think about how people may appear compassionate but naturally have a fear that causes them to carry out compassionate acts. The author effectively and steadfastly builds the essay by utilizing an observant and speculative tone, a series of figurative language and an emotional appeal in order to convey her outlook towards the homeless and compassion.…

    • 211 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Dubus Andre Killers

    • 912 Words
    • 4 Pages

    It is pure torture for a mother or father to see the man that took away from them, something that can never be returned, their child. “He walks the goddamn streets,” (103) Matt says. Matt did not think that the justice system would release a man like this on bail. This murderer is now tending to his daily routines without a care in the world, while the victims of his injustice helplessly watch. They watch as the killer of their child is shopping at a local grocery store; Buying skirt steak and quart of two percent milk while they wait in line to buy flowers for their dead son’s tombstone. Watch as that same man, who has shattered a mothers bond, is enjoying a Saturday afternoon at a local barbershop for his weekly high and tight haircut. “It’s killing her,” said Matt. Dubus writes “she can’t even go out for cigarettes and aspirin” (103) without seeing him. Not only has he killed their child, he is now killing them indirectly.…

    • 912 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    A true story of how a man was tried, convicted, and sentenced to death, May God Have Mercy exposes the imperfections in the criminal justice system and how it led to the death of an innocent man. Roger Coleman's case became the main story on nightly newscasts and prominent television shows such as Larry King Live, Nightline, Good Morning America, and the Today Show. Many crucial, yet harmful decisions were made that ultimately resulted in an innocent man's execution at the death house in Greensville, Virginia. The police, the prosecutor, and the Judge can all be held responsible for Coleman's death. However, the reason Roger Coleman was not acquitted of the murder of Wanda McCoy in the first place and thus in a position to be executed was because his original lawyers, Steve Arey and Terry Jordan, did not provide him with adequate representation, as required by the Constitution of the United States of America.…

    • 1746 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    James Rachels argues that in the case of a terminally ill patient who suffers from unimaginable pain, it is sometimes morally acceptable kill him via active euthanasia. Rachels defends his argument through the story of Jack. This story serves to describe the excruciating and incessant pain that many of the terminally ill face. It seems as though the only way Jack and many other hopeless patients could escape this agony is through death. Rachels claims that since Jack was going to die relatively soon anyway, there was no point in forcing him to suffer the pain caused by his disease. As long as Jack asked for death, it would be morally acceptable to end his misery.…

    • 419 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Many people all over the world are suffering from diseases. Diseases such as multiple sclerosis, cancer, parkinson's disease, heart disease and many others. Suffering from diseases not only effects the person suffering but the families and even our health care system. Suffering at the end of our lives has become an acceptable part of life in many parts of the world. This documentary, How to die in Oregon, explores: the issue and the laws of the right to choose when to die, the three main drugs used for this procedure, how medicare will pay for this drug before they will chemotherapy- something that may prolong life, the number of people who have used this drug,and the fact that they can get this drug even if they do not plan to use it. This paper will use the information from this documentary as the basis of an ethical examination of the laws in place for the one's who suffer. First, I will briefly…

    • 731 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    They don’t understand unnecessary pain to death scenarios. What is the point of putting your life or the life of another on the line for simple life pleasures – winning wars, eating dinner, etc. The authors of these pieces believe there is a mystery in behavior when facing death. In contrast, Dillard appears to be more curious as to why suffering falls more harshly on some people than others. Cummings tends to be more pessimistic about the outcome of patriots and why they bother to throw themselves into a death…

    • 1011 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    One of the most effective ways Moore draws our attention is by using real testimonies. By interviewing Americans who have been wronged by the health care system, he cleverly intertwines rhetoric to create a strong argument for universal health care. For example, after he presents the audience with a logos appeal, an ethos and/or pathos appeal will follow, or vice versa. Like a chain reaction, the appeals go hand in hand, making the viewer feel as if what they are seeing is real and not exaggerated. From the beginning, “Sicko” relies heavily on ethos and pathos to show that the health care industry is not sympathetic to the medical needs of Americans. One example of this is the story of a man named Tracy who had kidney cancer. His hospital refused to perform surgery on him and Tracy died soon after his wife challenged the hospital on the issue. Tracy’s wife, Julie, says that Tracy wanted to know why a good person like him had to be put into such an unfortunate situation. Here, Moore uses different techniques to get the audience to feel sympathy for this family. When the film first introduces us to Tracy and his family, we see segments of home videos depicting a happy family. As Tracy’s wife gives the interview, she tells an unfortunate story of Tracy’s death and how their health insurance failed them which further grabs the audience’s sympathy. She is interviewed in such a way where we feel as if she is in the living room with us; she seems like a friend or neighbor, and we sympathize for her loss. We are made to feel that his death was preventable. Further, we learn that despite Tracy’s wife being employed in the very hospital that provided them with so-called health care, they were denied treatment even though Tracy’s brother was a perfect donor. Essentially, she was working for the very people who were denying her family the care they need. Through the use of ethos…

    • 1408 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Tuesdays with Morrie

    • 1187 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Despite his parents’ request to study law or medicine, Mitch graduated from the college aspiring to become a musician. He moved to the New York City with the same ambition. Mitch’s parents had a lawyer and a physician as his possible self. On the other hand, Mitch had created a different possible self of himself- a successful musician. Even after trying hard for a while, he wasn’t able to make things fall into his tray. In the mean time, he saw his uncle die from pancreatic cancer at a very early age. He saw failure, pain, and death all at once; and realized he wasn’t immune to these things. Actually he felt them very close, and time was running out before he could do anything to defeat them.…

    • 1187 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    She had been in the hospitals for days and weeks in order for the doctors and nurses to remove or stop the tumor. However, the solution was temporary, so the doctor offered Brittany an estimation that she would live about 5 to 6 months. She had tried everything to stop cancer, but there was no cure. She also didn’t want her family to see her suffering from this painful disease. Brittany had been suffering for months and had to make a decision; as a result, she decided to do a study about death with dignity. This research helped her to find the solution for her and her family. Therefore, Brittany moved to another state to process her desire, wish even though the process was lengthy. After experiencing this moving process in order to get that prescription from a physician, she felt a relief that she no longer had to deal with her pain. Before taking this prescription to the process of dying, she wanted to celebrate her husband’s birthday and her family during her final weeks before she died. Nevertheless, she was asking questions about why people had to tell her that her choice was wrong, she shouldn’t follow that procedure, and she should listen to other opinions because people think they are…

    • 705 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Persons and Others

    • 763 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Lorraine Code writes Persons and Others from a rather sympathetic point of view as she tells us in the first page and explains that her response may be extremely different if she had read As We Are Now from a different characters perspective. She states, “ My reading is a partial one in that I take the protagonist, the first person narrator, at her word about how things are for her; hence I work from a presumption of the veracity of her experiential reports. Were I to reread the novel from the position of a different character, my take on it might be quit different. But my purpose here is to try, from the standpoint of someone who is disempowered, to understand the moral requirements of situations where people have others in their care who are extraordinarily vulnerable to assaults upon their sense of self.” I believe this is Lorraine Code’s thesis, everything she covers in her essay can be related back to those three sentences. I agree with just about everything Code says in her response to the novel. She makes good points about how it is unjust that this elderly woman is having trouble maintaining…

    • 763 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    In Barbara Huttman’s essay "A Crime of Compassion" she addresses these points and this very controversial question: When is it lawful and moral to take the life of another person? Her patient Mac had cancer, although he and his family wanted a DNR, during 1983 only the doctor could sign a code status. The doctor refused to sign one for Mac. Huttman said that she resuscitated Mac "52 times in just one month." Is it fair to make someone suffer through pain day in and day out, just waiting to die? Huttman disobeyed hospital…

    • 1111 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    Dying may be seen by many as a burden, but in Hans Jonas’s article, “The Burden and Blessing of Mortality,” dying is analyzed as not only a burden but also a blessing. By employing rhetorical modes such as division, definition, and illustration, Jonas paints a beautiful picture of how one should view death and the many views in which one can look at its foreboding shadow.…

    • 573 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics