Preview

Could the South Have Won the Civil War?

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1851 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Could the South Have Won the Civil War?
"In all history, no nation of mere agriculturists ever made successful war against a nation of mechanics…You are bound to fail." Union officer William Tecumseh Sherman to a Southern friend.
"Why did the North win the Civil War?" is only half of a question by itself, for the other half is "Why did the South lose the Civil War?" To this day historians have tried to put their finger on the exact reason for the South losing the war. Some historians blame the head of the confederacy Jefferson Davis; however others believe that it was the shear numbers of the Union (North). The advantages and disadvantages are abundant on either sides of the argument, but the most dominate arguments on why the South lost the war would be the fact that state 's rights prevented unification of the South, Jefferson Davis poor leadership and his failure to work together with his generals, the South failed to gain the recognition of the European nations, North 's superior resources made the outcome inevitable, and moral of the South towards the end of the war.
First, the South couldn 't have won the civil war because state 's rights prevented unification of the South. The very issue that created the Confederacy helped to destroy it. In waging war, the South faced problems of politics and government that greatly complicated its problem of economic mobilization. No one would deny the troublesome effect of the conflict generated by differing ideas of how best to protect liberty and to organize southern society for the war effort. Southern people insisted upon retaining their democratic liberties in wartime, which proved fatal for the South. They had to struggle with a "confederacy formed by particularistic politicians [that] could hardly be expected to adopt promptly those centralists polices which victory demanded" (Donald, p. 26). Individual state governors fought bitterly with Jefferson Davis to prevent him from consolidating power to fight the war. They withheld troops and


Cited: Beringer, Richard. et al. Why the South Lost the Civil War. Athens: University of Georgia Press, 1986. Boritt, Gabor S. Why the Confederacy Lost. New York: Oxford University Press, 1992 Donald, David. et al. Why the North Won the Civil War. London: Collier Macmillan Publishers, 1960. Gallagher, Gary. The Confederate War. Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1997.
Continue Reading
View Writing Issues

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Chapter Summary: The Road To Disunion
    • 232 Words
    • 1 Page

    Chapter Summary: The Road To Disunion

    This book focuses on the of number southern black and white who opposed the confedecy. He documented in The Road to Disunion, that anti-Confederates got strength from the weakness of slavery in the Border South, while slavery stunted population growth. The author argues that the varying support of the upper and lower South contributed to the fall of the Confederacy placing most of the blame on anti confederalist. He states that anti-Confederate whites undermined the Confederacy by remaining outside the nation while slaves unified form within and enlisted into the Union Army. Both groups guaranteed that the Union would have more men for the army which cause the Confederacy to lose because anti-Confederates waged war against Confederate southerners. That author also discusses the neutrality of the border slave states that made the Confederate war effort vulnerable. Losing nearly half of the slave states neutrality and the support for the Union army's invasion damaged the geography and population that the Confederacy could use for its defense.…

    • 232 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Analysis: Why The North Won The Civil War
    • 241 Words
    • 1 Page

    Analysis: Why The North Won The Civil War

    In Why the North Won the Civil War, Henry Steele Commager believed that there were multiple causes that led the confederacy to their defeat and that it was “an inevitability in history.” While many historians believed the North won due to their economic, military, diplomatic, and social aspects, Richard N. Current stated that the Union won the Civil War due to their “fundamental economic superiority.” He believed the North sustained a vast and overwhelming economic superiority in men and materials, giving them “an advantage of almost five to two” in everything. The Union succeeded because they were productive with their economy, unlike the Confederates.…

    • 241 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Why the North Won the Civil War by David Donald: Reflection on the economic, military, diplomatic, political, and social reasons the South lost.
    • 1300 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Why the North Won the Civil War by David Donald: Reflection on the economic, military, diplomatic, political, and social reasons the South lost.

    Historians have argued inconclusively for years over the prime reason for Confederate defeat in the Civil War. The book Why the North Won the Civil War outlines five of the most agreed upon causes of Southern defeat, each written by a highly esteemed American historian. The author of each essay does acknowledge and discuss the views of the other authors. However, each author also goes on to explain their botheration and disagreement with their opposition. The purpose of this essay is to summarize each of the five arguments presented by Richard N. Current, T. Harry Williams, Norman A. Graebner, David Herbert Donald, and David M. Potter. Each author gives his insight on one of the following five reasons: economic, military, diplomatic, social, and political, respectively.…

    • 1300 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    How Did Harriet Beecher Stoowe Influence The Civil War
    • 775 Words
    • 4 Pages

    How Did Harriet Beecher Stoowe Influence The Civil War

    The other main reasons are the control of the government, economy, states' rights, abolitionism, and the election of 1860. Although the focus revolved around slavery a lot of the tension that led to the war was from how the South felt it had no power when it came to making decisions. “As new states were added to the Union, a series of compromises were arrived at to maintain an equal number of “free” and “slave” states” (Hickman 1). However; as new states were added they were all being declared “free” states without the South having any say in the matter. Fearing they were losing power the South turned to the states' rights argument, stating that the federal government didn't have the right to change the laws of slavery in states whom already own slaves (Ayers). Things grew worse during the abolitionist movements which called for an end for slavery, whether it be immediate or gradual. This caused many disputes among the people which often led to biblical disputes (Hickman1). Harriet Beecher Stowe's Uncle Tom's Cabin should the cruelty of the Fugitive Slave Act and gave support to the abolitionist movement. The election of 1860 was the final straw. With the election of Abraham Lincoln as president, they feared all was about to change. “The North with its growing population and increased electoral power had achieved what the South had always feared: complete control of the government by the free states”(Hickman 2). After the election the South immediately began to discuss seceding from the Union. The secession of the South was the ultimate leading factor for the North to go to war, in order to keep the country united…

    • 775 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Essay On Why Did The North Win The Civil War
    • 510 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Essay On Why Did The North Win The Civil War

    Time. Time was the key reason for the North's victory and was achieved through a combination of the first and second reasons. As the war progressed the Union's blockade, largely a paper tiger at the beginning due to the fact that the Navy didn't have enough ships to properly enforce it, became a real blockade that slowly strangled the Confederacy to death. And as the war progressed the South, even before the end of the prisoner exchange, was losing men it could not afford to lose to attrition. Supplies and transportation of supplies. As stated in the first reason, the North was less dependant on Europe than the South was for supplies. There should be little doubt that the South was able to manufacture supplies needed to fight the war, but never in amounts it needed. Industry in the North was a bit larger than it was in the South and was thus able to out produce that of the South. But being able to out produce the South was all well and good unless the South could get the supplies to its troops in the field faster. It then became important to capture major railroad junctions and thus cut off the South's ability to move supplies in a timely…

    • 510 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Better Essays

    Why the South Lost the Civil War
    • 1101 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Why the South Lost the Civil War

    When the Confederate Army General Robert E. Lee surrendered to the Union Army General, Ulysses S. Grant at the Appomattox Courthouse on April 9, 1865, many considered the Civil War to be over. The fact that the North was victorious over the South was accepted and the process of reconstruction began in America. It was never openly discussed on why the North defeated the South. However, the question began to slowly arise over time on why the South lost the Civil War. Many historians have become interested in this question and many reasons have been given on why the South lost the Civil War. Lack of manpower, shortages of supplies, and inferior leadership and government were the three main reasons on why the South was defeated in the Civil War.…

    • 1101 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
    Read More
  • Powerful Essays

    why the war came
    • 1105 Words
    • 5 Pages

    why the war came

    Why the North Won the Civil War by David Donald; Richard N ... - Jstor…

    • 1105 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    How Did The South Have The Right To Do Without A Civil War
    • 467 Words
    • 2 Pages

    How Did The South Have The Right To Do Without A Civil War

    Imagine the United States without a Civil War. We would be a much greater and stronger nation. I believe that the South didn’t have the right to fight for their way of life. Due to their attitude on slavery, they created a war that was dreadful. In the war, was the bloodiest day in US history, and the entire war caused 650,000 deaths.…

    • 467 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Civil War Over Slavery
    • 94 Words
    • 1 Page

    Civil War Over Slavery

    I agree that the Civil War was fought over slavery. While I do think there were other contributing factors it seems like slavery was the main issue between the North and the South. The South was upset about Abraham Lincoln’s election and the fact that the Republican Party was against the expansion of slavery into new territories. The possibility of the end of slavery was a threat to the South who had an agriculturally based economy that relied on the use of slave labor, if slavery were to end then their economy would…

    • 94 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Post-Civil War Reconstruction
    • 765 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Post-Civil War Reconstruction

    The Civil War managed to divide the United States into two sections incapable of negotiating a way to effectively work together. When the war ended in 1864, with the Union taking the victory, it left America in ruins and from there America started the reconstruction process in an effort to restore the glory that once was. Although Reconstruction had the complete intentions of creating an even better America than before, it unfortunately regressed because of things such as Black Codes, the inauguration of Andrew Johnson, and the formation of hate groups such as the KKK. It is with these examples that make the statement, “While the north won the war, the south won reconstruction”, ring true.…

    • 765 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Powerful Essays

    Gettysburg: Turning Point of the War
    • 1849 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Gettysburg: Turning Point of the War

    Bibliography: Beringer, Richard E., Hattaway Herman, Jones Archer, and Still William N. Why The South Lost The Civil War. University of Georgia, 1986.…

    • 1849 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Could The Civil War Been Avoided
    • 527 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Could The Civil War Been Avoided

    I think the Civil War could not have been avoided because it seemed like the only way to stop the South from seceding from the Union. The South developed their wealth from the slaves that picked cotton and tobacco. They sold these crops to other countries who needed them and developed wealth from these other countries. If the North stopped this, the South would not be able to make as much money. The Dred Scott Decision was a deciding factor about the war.…

    • 527 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Was the Civil War fought over Slavery?
    • 678 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Was the Civil War fought over Slavery?

    The Civil War was the bloodiest war in all of America's history.But some things still remains a mystery in the Civil War.There were many reasons to how the Civil War was cause.A lot of people thinks that slavery was the cause,but it is only one of the many causes.Slavery, Economy, and State's Rights were the main cause to the Civil War.The slavery brought tensions,many differences in economy,and fighting for a cause.Tensions rose as Republicans and Democrats fight for a solution in slavery,the North and South many differences in their economy,and reasons to fighting in the Civil War.The Civil War was fought for slavery, economy, and State's Rights.…

    • 678 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    The Lost Cause: Influence Of The Confederacy
    • 983 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The Lost Cause: Influence Of The Confederacy

    The Lost Cause influenced the honor and commencement offered to the Confederate heroes, and deemphasized the importance of slavery in their fight; without regard to the limitations due to the poor economic situation they were left in when the war ended. The purpose of Lost Cause of the Confederacy was to spread the idea that the American Civil War was not centralized around slavery, but was a struggle to preserve the Southern way of life, and their rights as states. While on the surface the actions taken by the Lost Cause advocates seemed not to focus on politics, it was perhaps underneath it all a political matter.…

    • 983 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    The Turning Point Of The American Civil War
    • 962 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The Turning Point Of The American Civil War

    The American Civil War is probably the most horrific episode in American history. The two belligerents of the war were the Union army, comprised of the northern states, and the Confederate army, comprised of the southern slave states which had voted to secede from the Union. In essence, the North did not want the South to secede from the Union because the North relied on the South for agriculture. On the other hand, the South wanted to secede because they had grown tired of the federal government intervening in their states’ affairs; they were concerned about maintaining their states’ rights, as well as their slavery-driven economy.…

    • 962 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More