Preview

court case

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
538 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
court case
There have been events that incriminate public school teachers and other employees for having improper sexual influence and connection with their students have occurred across the country. Having students fall victim to sexual predators within a safe establishment during school, school outing, or even when participating in after school activities is unacceptable and causes potential for liability charges. In student injury cases such as Hansen vs. Board of Education, the court observed a pattern with careless hiring, neglectful supervision, and unconcerned retention. It is important to cautiously screen all candidates, conduct suitable evaluations, and to create an environment that allows teachers to have witnesses. This environment will provide adequate monitoring and a comfortable environment for staff and students.
In Kelly G. v Board of Education of the City of Yonkers, a student and her guardians filed a lawsuit to retrieve damages for what they described as negligence and sexual harassment by a school music teacher. The plaintiff stated that the music teacher made vulgar and improper sexual statements towards her as well as inappropriately touched her in sexual way. When this trial came to court, it was dismissed, the complaint granting judgment to the defendants.
The plaintiffs requested another trial that would focus on the negligence of proper supervision of students. The Supreme Court of New York Appellate Division Rational Decision stated that the governing council for schools could not be held accountable for the teachers’ actions, but it can be held accountable for careless hiring, neglectful supervision, and unconcerned retention. Various court decisions state that a “necessary element of such causes of action is that the employer knew or should of known of the employee’s propensity for conduct which caused the injury.” Also, the court stated that, “a school owes a duty to adequately supervise the students in its care, and may be held

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Elk Grove Unified School District et al. v. Newdow et al. 542 U.S. 1 (2004)…

    • 1101 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The case was between Hosanna-Tabor Lutheran Church and School against Equal Employment opportunity commission. The church ran school that offered Christ centered education. One of their employees was Cheryl Perich who taught both secular and religious subjects. She began working for the school in 1999 and was committed to giving quality services in her education and leading prayers. In 2004, she suffered a certain condition known as Narcolepsy and she had to quit teaching on a disability leave. In 2005, she notified the principal that she could resume her duties on February that year after the doctors had cleared her of her condition. The principal informed her that she had to wait a little longer because she had been replaced. She was angry and threatened to sue the school, which led to her firing.…

    • 642 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Bristol School Case Study

    • 1068 Words
    • 5 Pages

    This brief is in regards to the Bristol School District and their policies. A seventeen-year old student, Suzie, attended Central High School in Bristol, Virginia. During Suzie’s relationship with her boyfriend, Cyrus, she sent him some very revealing photographs of herself. After their relationship ended, Cyrus forwarded some of the most revealing photos to upper classmen in the school. This began to draw unwanted attention to Suzie. It became such a disruption in the school, Suzie’s parents contacted the school principal, Mrs. Sheevers, and forced her to investigate and appeal the situation thoroughly. Principal Sheevers, then confronted Cyrus, who denied having and sending the photographs. Then Principal Sheevers sent the school’s security officer to find Cyrus’s phone to check it for the photographs. When Cyrus didn’t have his…

    • 1068 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    These cases appeared some thirty years ago but set the stage for government intervention and laws to protect teachers. It also set a precedent in the procedures regulating substitutes and the hiring process. In a Michigan case an elementary school student was injured playing "kill" at recess under the supervision of a substitute teacher. It was common practice in the school for the game to be played and the principal was aware of its use. The student filed suit naming the absent teacher, the principal and the school district as defendants. The court felt that the use of the game was inappropriate and constituted negligence. (Cook v. Bennett, 1979) In determining the liability of the regular classroom teacher, the court noted that the "threshold element of a negligence case is that there must exist a duty. . . . "(Cook v. Bennett, at 610) Although the teacher owed a duty to exercise reasonable care over students in his charge, this duty "is coterminus with the teacher's presence at school. Supervision implies oversight. In order to oversee student activity, a teacher must be present to observe and control." (Cook v. Bennett, at 610) The court found that the regular teacher, by not being present at the school owed no duty to supervise his pupils and was therefore, not liable. The school district, though normally liable for the negligence of its employees, was protected by governmental immunity by Michigan law. In contrast, the court ruled that the supervisory function of the principal was ministerial in nature and not protected by immunity. The principal enhanced the likelihood of the injury by failing to properly supervise the teacher and by failing to establish rules and guidelines for the safety of the pupils. Thus she was found…

    • 1690 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Looking at John Cornelly, the plaintiff in this case, I see a young man with a promising future. Cornelly has never been convicted in a court of law of misconduct. Though this is not enough proof of his innocence, it is clear that his conduct was driven by external factors. First, Cornelly has readily admitted that he has had an affair with his class teacher. The latter appeared in criminal proceedings and is awaiting sentencing over rape charges to which she pled guilty. It is clear that Cornelly fell into her trap and this might have been the genesis of his misconduct. Being an adult, the teacher is to blame for the corrupting of this minor. She ought to have protected him from any conduct that was against state law. Cornelly’s possession…

    • 913 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    For example, a principal who was reassigned to the central office was not entitled to a hearing since he would continue to receive his regular salary and benefits; deprivations related to professional satisfaction and reputation did not constitute actionable injuries. In contrast, the Sixth Circuit reasoned that a collective bargaining agreement specifying that teachers may not be transferred except for “good cause” and “extenuating circumstances” established a property interest in a particular position in a specific…

    • 433 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    1.1 This is the appellant’s skeleton argument for his appeal. The arguments to quash the conviction under s. 18 of the Offences Against the Person Act 1861 (OAPA) are based on the misdirection’s made by the judge during the trial. There are three main misdirection’s for the appeal, which can render the conviction unsafe, include: Consent, causation and intention. The appellant Billy was convicted under s.18 OAPA of the offences against the person act for causing grievous bodily harm to the victim Anita.…

    • 1766 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Teachers, police officers etc. are being charged with statutory rape, people who are supposed to be the leaders of this country. According to a news report in The Daily Times a 23-year old Jordan Harris was arrested for having sexual relations with one of his 16-year old students at his home. But later released on a 25,000 bond. If someone is employed to be a teacher, then all students should not be looked at as someone they can mess around with. Schools are a place to learn and be protected by the school staff, not to be preyed on. In this particular case Jordan Harris was already once in trouble with another school district for allegations of messing with another minor student. If he was already on the spotlight for this once before then why was he giving another chance at a different school? The schools should take more precautions before hiring people. This man was in a student teacher program and they weren’t even sure that he was a graduate of the…

    • 1063 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Case Study

    • 784 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Peter Lewiston was terminated on July 15, 2008, by the governing board of the Pine Circle Unified School District (PCUSD) for violation of the district's sexual harassment policy. Prior to Lewiston's termination he was a senior maintenance employee with an above-average work record who had worked for the PCUSD for eleven years. He had been a widower since 2003 and was described by his coworkers as a friendly, outgoing, but lonely individual. Beverly Gilbury was a fifth-grade teacher working in the district's Advanced Learning Program. She was twenty-eight years old and married and had worked for PCUSD for six years. At the time of the incidents, Lewiston and Gilbury both worked at the Simpson Elementary School, where their relationship was described as “cooperative.” The following sequence of events was reported separately by Lewiston and Gilbury during the district's investigation of this sexual harassment case.…

    • 784 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    State Law: Tort Law

    • 1207 Words
    • 5 Pages

    If a student wanted to take a teacher to court for negligence the four elements would have to be present. The teacher must have a duty to protect students from unreasonable risks, the teacher must have failed in the duty by not exercising a reasonable standard of care, there must be a causal connection between the breach of the duty to care and the resulting injury and last there must be some actual physical or mental injury resulting from the negligence (Drye, J.M., 2013). Some students will start a fight in the hall way and when a teacher tries to break it up pulling one student in to a different room or down the hall way by the arms or wrist, that student will try to take the teacher to court for violating their…

    • 1207 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Lawcase

    • 3139 Words
    • 13 Pages

    The petitioner Mrs Rashmi Luthra(Petitioner) lawfully married Mr Rahul Luthra as per the Special Marriage Act, 1954 on 16th November,2005 which has been registered by the Registrar of Mumbai (Marriage Certificate).The Marriage has also been performed as per the Hindu rites and ceremonies on 23rd Nov,2005.The expenses for the marriage ceremonies were borne by the petitioners father(Bill of the expenses) The Reception of the marriage was held on 24th Nov 2005,and the expenses of the marriage reception was equally paid by both the parties as per the understanding . The total expenses for the marriage spent by the petitioners father is approximately Rs 10 lacs. On 27thNov, 2006 a daughter was born out of the wedlock, named Tiessha in Indore who is in the care and custody of Rashmi Luthra…

    • 3139 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    There is an evolving judicial construction of teachers' roles in Canadian jurisprudence. Judges continue to examine the social and educational significance of teachers through the varied misconduct cases that they are encountering in their courtrooms. There has been an increase in recent years of litigation surrounding teacher conduct. Cesare and Manley-Casimir outline three main issues that have caused controversy and debate in both judicial and educational environments. The first issue surrounds the definitions of teacher misconduct within provincial statutes. As judges are dealing with situations not outlined or clarified within the statutes, they are led to establish their own definition of the role of a teacher, thus justifying their decisions as to the conduct of teachers. Each province indeed has a professional code of conduct, yet these documents can be interpreted as quite vague and unclear in a legal sense. The second issue arises from temporal and spatial circumstances. When alleged misconduct…

    • 1930 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Litigation

    • 1345 Words
    • 6 Pages

    When a conflict between two parties arises and there is a need to resolve an issue, the parties often have to resort to a form of litigation. There are two major routes that can be taken in this instant. The traditional form of litigation (trial, jury etc.) or non-traditional litigation (mediation, arbitration etc.). There are reasons for the parties choosing the way that they go, and this paper will outline the two types of litigation and the reasons that a party would choose one over the other.…

    • 1345 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    case law

    • 592 Words
    • 3 Pages

    To understand what the Case Law is and what is the importance,purpose and history of the same and thereby getting a better understanding of the role and relevence of Case Law in India.…

    • 592 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Court

    • 2185 Words
    • 9 Pages

    CONSTITUTIONAL COURT, GAUTENG (REPULIC OF SOUTH AFRICA) CASE NUMBER: 10/2012 In the Appeal between: HEAD OF THE DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT, FREE STATE APPELLANT…

    • 2185 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays