Preview

Critical Summary Safe Area Gorazde

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
978 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Critical Summary Safe Area Gorazde
Abandonment and Neglect in Gorazde.
In his “Safe Area Gorazde” Joe Sacco describes his experience visiting a Muslim enclave during the Bosnian War of 1991-1995. Tragically, this work is based on testimonies of residents of Gorazde, allegedly a UN-protected area where Bosnian Muslims are able to take refuge to avoid the ethnic cleansing perpetrated by the Serbian army. Gorazde is anything but protected which Sacco demonstrates throughout the book by ridiculing the UN and the US who are able to and responsible for protecting the residents of such enclaves, but instead turn a blind eye to what was going on. “…the U.N. extended safe area status to other Bosnian enclaves, including Gorazde. But the U.N. had yet to work out what the concept meant”, Sacco says (Sacco, 148). These designated “safe” areas are completely abandoned by the authorities who promise to watch over them, despite being some of the most dangerous places on Earth. The entire world seems to ignore the brutalities going on there – the destruction of towns, massacre of men, raping of women, and the murder and neglect of children. The residents have nowhere to go, have no hope, and little or no access to basic necessities. These conditions and the abandonment which leads to them is the central theme of this work. Sacco wants us to feel this situation and he succeeds. By the end of “Safe Area Gorazde” one is left seething. “Safe area”, as Sacco’s title suggests, was a new entry in the Orwellian lexicon during the Bosnian conflict. As Hitchens states in the introduction to the book, “the contempt is reserved for the temporizing, buck passing, butt covering “peacekeepers” who strove to find that swamp of low and “middle” ground into which the innocent are being shoveled by the aggressive” (Hitchens, Introduction). This is a great, if brief, explanation of the evolution of the word “safe”.
The extreme nature of the situation in Gorazde immediately involves the reader’s emotions. Sacco’s brilliance is

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    -Refuges or diasporic communites are often part of nation states. Violence is often at the heart of those types of communities.…

    • 758 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The Bosnians, Croats, and the Serbs eventually come to an agreement after acknowledging the disastrous effects of engaging in war (Sacco 212). Both sides demobilize the troops, and Gorazde rejoice. The Bosnians evicted from their homes return to their homes. The peacemaking makes residents realize the time wasted in battlefields and get used to the new situations as they resume their normal activities. Sometimes, wars bring peace, but they do so if one group decides to give up or both sides reach a compromise where they decide to start a peacemaking settlement. However, the peacemaking settlement must include some form of forgiveness and considers the causes of the war, which then help people to start a new life, as well as, live peacefully with one…

    • 2117 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    As I read Dispatches by Michael Herr, there is an overwhelming sense of fear and horror. His dispatches are populated by soldiers called 'grunts', whose enemy was everywhere and nowhere. Their maps were blank; their names for the enemy, 'Charlie' or 'VC', told them nothing. How do you recognize them? They all wear black pajamas; they are all alien to us. They are everywhere. That's where the paranoia began. Herr's dispatches are disturbing because he writes from inside the nightmare, with all the tension and terror that turned these young men into killing machines. It is all the more frightening because, emptied of any concerns for justice, or ethics, or solidarity, they opened fire anywhere, everywhere. After all, who could know where or who the enemy was?…

    • 998 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    These malicious acts were used as a way to change the ethnic makeup of the area, by impregnating women with Serbian babies so as to create a larger Serbian population in the future and drive out the Bosniaks and Croats. Rape was simply another strategy used in their overall goal of ethnically cleansing Bosnia and overtaking the land as Serbian territory. It is believed that up to 60,000 women were raped in Bosnia from 1992 to 1995(*), but the number may be much higher as many rape victims do not come forward due to the shame and humiliation they feel. Many witnesses recount events of the systematic rape, and often murder, of women and girls during the time by the Serbian military (*). There is also mention of specific ‘rape camps’ through the country that held women and girls of all ages who were repeatedly raped by soldiers. Unfortunately, tactical rape is a common occurence in war zones but it was not until 1992 that the UN Security Council declared widespread rape to be an international crime, specifically noting the Muslim women in Bosnia (*). Later, the International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia cited rape as a crime against humanity, equal with such acts as torture and murder, and added sexual slavery under the definition of slavery (*). The act of rape as a military tactic is in direct interference with article 5 of the UDHR, which states that no one shall be subjected to cruel or degrading treatment. In Behind Enemy Lines, there is no direct mention made to the widespread rape committed by the Serbians which is a shame because it was such a large issue during this time. Given the fact that this movie takes place towards the end of the war and focuses on the involvement of US soldiers, it misses out on some very key and important aspects of the Bosnian…

    • 1298 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Told from his perspective, Joe discusses his experience and his life in Gorazde, a U.N. designated Safe Area in Bosnia. This graphic narrative also features personal anecdotes of many Bosnians themselves as they talk about their role in the war or how the war affected them. I will use this book to argue that National Memory can be used to compare how the memory of a nation differs from individual memories of survivors. Safe Area Gorazde demonstrates how the Bosnian War differs from others recollection of it.…

    • 1398 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Mass Killing Summary

    • 2299 Words
    • 10 Pages

    Shaw argues that studies on genocide have concentrated too heavily on the specific perpetrators and victims with regard to intentions and identities respectively. Instead, he wants to propose that the crime of genocide should be understood within the structure of conflict situations. The most important aspect of genocide studies from the point of view of politics is that the concept of genocide must be clarified, Shaw believes that scholarship should provide this elucidation. By returning to the original definition proposed by Lemkin, the focus is more generally on attacks by the armed against the unarmed. Shaw states that “Lemkin invented ‘genocide’ because he wanted to describe – and highlight for countervailing action – a general class of violent actions.” Taking lessons from one of the most influential studies on war by Carl von Clausewitz, Shaw sees genocide as a form of war directed against civilians. Debates about genocide have certainly advanced since the introduction of the term, yet, Shaw feels these debates from the 1940s onwards have lost two very key aspects of the original concept. In agreement with Lemkin the omission of cultural genocide or social destruction meaning not just physically but a way of life and how genocide relates to war are vital in understanding the nature of the crime. He argues that “Genocide always involves physical violence but it involves many other things as well. Defining genocide by killing misses the social aims that lie behind it. Genocide involves mass killing but it is much more than mass killing.” Similar to some of the arguments made by Claudia Card in relation to the inclusion of cultural genocide, Shaw’s assertion that genocide must be viewed in the context of war provides a valuable framework for understanding the particular violence against civilians. The use of word civilians here is important for Shaw, rather than the UN Genocide…

    • 2299 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    A Long Way Gone Themes

    • 686 Words
    • 3 Pages

    First-world children spend summer days playing with friends or vacationing with their families. But only an ocean away, children as young as ten are forced to kill each other as brainwashed soldiers in morally reprehensible political conflicts. “A Long Way Gone” is Ishmael Beah’s account of his life as a child soldier in the ongoing Somali Civil War. In it, he uses simple language and graphic details to provoke strong emotions in the reader, and hopefully move them to action. His story is one fraught with pain, trauma, death and, eventually, hope for a world without child combatants. It is best to make the last sentence of the intro the THESIS…

    • 686 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Bosnian Genocide

    • 1041 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The Bosnian Genocide is one of the most horrific events of our modern history. Under the former Yugoslavia, different ethnicities were all compressed under the regime of Josip Broz “Tito”, who managed to keep them united for 35 years, however after the death of Tito, violence escalated. Under General Ratko Mladić’s leadership, neighbors started killing neighbors, and changed the way Serbs, Bosnians and Croats treat each other up until now. Forgiveness for the killings is still hard to find, though more people are beginning to see the benefit in forgiving, and slowly the ethnic groups affected by the Bosnian Genocide are started to move toward each other.…

    • 1041 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Bosnian Genocide

    • 1216 Words
    • 5 Pages

    According to congresswomen Allyson Schwartz, "The 20th century taught us how far unbridled evil can and will go when the world fails to confront it. It is time that we heed the lessons of the 20th century and stand up to these murderers. It is time that we end genocide in the 21st century." The world was confronted with a disastrous destruction when six million Jews were shamefully persecuted under the cruel leadership of Adolf Hitler and his inhumane decisions. The cry for help from various targeted groups was ignored, and resulted in a tragedy never before seen by the world. Thousands of regrets were made, and millions of questions were asked by those who had committed almost as big as a crime as the Germans during this genocide; disregard and negligence; all eventually promised to never let such disasters occur again. Just half a century later, the citizens of Bosnia, still able to reflect on the previous European catastrophe, had a similar occurrence resulting in the deaths of many innocent people; and once again showing the world yet another devastation that must never occur again. The Bosnian Genocide is a historical landmark dealing with multiple causes and effects, which are still consequential to many lives today.…

    • 1216 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Maass refers to the dark moments in humanity as “the wild beast,’ where inhumanity runs amok and all morality is lost. After reading this story it can be figured that Maass went as a reporter to the Balkans at the height of the salvage war there, but this story is not traditional war reportage. It can be seen that Maass’ brilliantly observed a moving memoir of the worst event of violence in Europe during the Bosnian War, since World War II. In his story of “The Wild Beast” he writes about what he saw during the two years of war in Bosnia for the Washington Post. Maass offers “one of the definitive accounts of Bosnia’s fin de siècle descent into madness” writing in the tradition of Ryszard Kapuscinski and Michael Herr’s Dispacthes (Random House). Mass captures the national, personal, and universal implications of a civil war.…

    • 1294 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The lost of life is always a tragedy in our history and even worse is the lost of life during a genocide. Many know about the Holocaust and the six million Jews that were killed because the Nazis’ thought that they were a superior race to the Jews, but another genocide is the Bosnian Genocide. The Bosnian Genocide was a tragic time period where the attackers the Bosnian Serbs killed thousands of Bosnian Muslims that lived in Siberia. The Serbs thought that they were a superior race and that the Bosnian Muslims should be killed. The phrase “ethnic cleansing” was mainly used during this genocide, where the Serbs believed that the Bosnian Muslims should be cleansed from the world starting with Siberia.…

    • 1059 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Genocide is the deliberate and systematic destruction, in whole or in part, of an ethnic, racial, Caste, religious, or national group. Generally speaking, genocide does not necessarily mean the immediate destruction of a nation, except when accomplished by mass killings of all members of a nation. It is intended rather to signify…

    • 2472 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Jihad vs Mcworld

    • 310 Words
    • 1 Page

    Political scientist Barber (Rutgers; An Aristocracy of Everyone, 1992, etc.) grandly divides the planet into no more and no less than two camps to explain the present universal, sorry mess. The only hope, he says, is democracy, and between the equally malign forces of Jihad and McWorld, the odds for it aren't too good. According to the professor's realpolitik, McWorld means not merely worldwide fast food but all capitalist buccaneering, global marketeering, cyberspace, megamergers, and international corporate incest aimed at nothing but profit. The Japanese motor in your Swiss camera might be made in China and sold by a British ad agency. Borders mean nothing in McWorld; the sun never sets on its flag. Movies, TV, and theme parks like EuroDisney and the local mall are all. Fighting for hegemony, probably without ultimate success according to Barber, is international Jihad. By Jihad he means not merely Hamas or Sheik Omar Abdel-Rahman. Add neo-Nazis, Vladimir Zhirinovsky, unregulated militia members, and the balkanization of the Balkans. Fundamentalism and nationalism, often drawing sustenanance from imaginary history, are in impassioned battle with infotainment and merchandising. The struggle is not impeded by any government or international agreement. Earth looks like a political Rubik's cube. Jihad receives bomb-making instructions on the Internet. McWorld sells designer jeans to Palestinian and Israeli alike. The paradox hardly enhances the freedom of the individual, and democracy suffers under either banner. And yet, declares Barber, democracy is our only viable choice. The bifurcation of the global village may seem simplistic, but assuredly the dialectic is not. The author's range is, perforce, universal. Certainly he is no optimistic Toffler, Fukuyama, or Pangloss. His concern for the public weal is patent; his impassioned argument is provocative and portentous. This is a generally erudite, copiously detailed synthesis, a polemic long on problems and short on…

    • 310 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Not only were women trafficked into the region, but night clubs and discotheques were customized for their clientele based on their nationality. German soldiers were catered-to with clubs named “Arche” and Americans found comfort visiting bars named “Chicago.” While German and Bosnian military personnel denied any inappropriate behavior on the part of their soldiers, in October of 2000 an American female UN officer discovered information quite to the contrary. She interviewed women who came to her office seeking help and uncovered an underground sex trafficking operation in the area which was frequented by male UN officers. After informing her UN superiors of this devastating issue, she was fired.…

    • 506 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Throughout history and still today there have been many conflicts, wars and broken promises all over the world. These conflicts and wars include civil wars, small wars, world wars and human rights movements. One of the main problems with these are that there are innocent lives being tortured and killed. A perfect example of this takes place in the Turkish-Kurdish dilemma in a region of the world that connects Eastern Europe, the Middle East, and Asia. In this report I will bring awareness to a conflict that needs to be resolved for the best interest of both parties as well as the world. I will examine the Human Rights Watch article that was published in March of 1993 by Helsinki Watch. I will look into details of killings, disappearances and torture of the Kurdish population by the Turkish government.…

    • 2019 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays