Preview

Critique Of John Dennett's Argument

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
624 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Critique Of John Dennett's Argument
AGUREMENT
Dennett also gives an argument that belief paradigm based on the intentional system, attribution in the cases he brought up leave as a great deal of the reasoning inexplicit. By using hypothetical scenario that he used for came up where a man is swerved because he wanted to avoid a detached hubcap. For argument Dennett, he asserts that is unlikely an explicit representation of the relevant propositional attitudes occurred in the man’s consciousness. Something was situations his not belief that means he is in danger and taking action he did. He would not have avoided a piece of paper anymore would he have swerved into an incoming bus. For Dennett, by using test should be employed to distinguish the literal from the metaphorical as the modelling belief as sentence may be an artefact of attending extreme cases because this difficult to articulate a list of beliefs attributed to an agent for action is a normal practice.
…show more content…
For example, artefact like thermostat can sustain a rudimentary intentional stance interpretation. Therefore, insensate entity does real believing and desire and when as if believing and desiring taker over that he want argues against that to delineate. No principle way to distinguish the original from derived intentionality and existence of cases legitimate attributes, with not theoretically motivated threshold the literal from the metaphorical or merely as if cases based on the argument from Dennett. The basic feature of any rational agent regardless if seeking either way, it's one entity for predictable into how the intentional system works whether or not the attributed goals, really appreciated or

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    According to Clifford (1879), there is an ethics to belief that makes it always wrong for anyone to believe anything on insufficient evidence. Clifford (1879) begins his paper by providing an illustrative analogy – one where a ship-owner is preparing to send to sea a ship filled with innocent men, women, and children. Prior to its departure, doubts had been brought to his attention regarding its condition and the possibility of a failure to complete the voyage. The ship-owner, now in a dilemma, successfully convinces himself that because the ship had weathered so many storms and successfully completed so many voyages, it was fit to believe that the ship was fit to sail. He acquired a sincere belief that the ship would successfully complete the voyage despite its apparent faults. Eventually, the ship sank.…

    • 2507 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Clifford argues that actions cannot be separated from belief, therefore any belief held without adequate evidence caries the potential for morally blameworthy consequences.…

    • 566 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In the paper, John Greco accepts the concept of the sensitivity theory. The sensitivity theory is about the intuitive sense in which it requires not only being correct, but also tracking the truth in other possible circumstances. The sensitivity theory refers that S’s belief that P is sensitive and only if P were false, S wouldn’t believe P. The sensitivity theory responds to the skeptical argument. The skeptical argument states that “1.…

    • 1454 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Winston’s argument is that the Party would fail with the power the possess. He states that the older generations would use the previous Newspeak than the new generation and they might be influenced to use the previous language. People can rebel against the Party like how he and Julia did. Even if the proles become cautious of what’s happening then they can overthrow the Party. As long as people remember, you can’t control them at all. A civilization based on hate and fear would never endure. For example, the German Nazi’s had so much power and influence during World War II. Eventually, their power fell and the Allies won the War. No matter what happens, so much power would fall…

    • 121 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Common Sense Religion by Daniel Dennett is an argumentative essay. Dennett talks about different people belonging to different religion believe that life is meaningless without a religion. The poor, who can hardly feed themselves, put money in collection plate for the sake of religion and think that they have beautified their life after death. But there is no guarantee if there money is really being used for good (for needy), what if it is not? If this money collection is done through a preacher, does this still remain a filthy work? Every religion thinks that the other one is stumpy. It is equally believed in every religion that the non-believers are totally out of the question and there is no escape for them.…

    • 467 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    If the question of right or wrong has to do with the origin of belief and whether or not one has the right to believe in the first place, then would the ship owner have been culpable had the doubts about the ship’s condition not been introduced? Is a person required to investigate EVERY doubt or question that is raised by another, which directly or indirectly impacts their belief? What if the source of doubt is unreliable? Without properly addressing these questions it is difficult to determine what the ship owner’s (or anyone else’s) responsibility was in the first place. This, I assert, is the fundamental problem with Clifford’s argument. To implicitly assume that one is guilty for simply believing without “sufficient” evidence can not be easily determined because the standards and thus the determination for “right” and “wrong” are too…

    • 779 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Armstrong claims that P1: Mental states are the inner causes of behavior, is a conceptual truth while Cartesian dualists would label it as trivial and empirical. P1 is supported by Armstrong’s discussion of behaviorism. The crude version of behaviorism said that “the mind is not an inner arena, it is an outward act”. This was challenged by the notion of stoics and people who are do not always express their mental processes. It was then refined by introducing “dispositions to behave”. Glass is fragile and “fragility” is a dispositional concept. Behaviorists say that fragility is not describing some inner state or condition of the glass, but instead what would happen if it were dropped. Armstrong says that fragility is an inner state; it is the qualities of the glass that makes it break. Fragility is a causal inner…

    • 751 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Gilbert Gladwell Essay

    • 864 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Are we aware of our actions or do we react unconsciously? In the article “Immune to…

    • 864 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    To achieve this, this chapter will have 3 sections; the first section will be devoted to explaining the mechanisms of how phenomenal content determines intentional content base on the adverbalist view . This view accommodates intentionality in terms of the non-relational intrinsic properties of experience; hence in the framework of the “phenomenal intentionality” program. This will pave the way for the conclusion that “the phenomenal character of intentionality” is the only source of intentionality, this is, original intentionality. This argument will be contrasted in the second section with Kriegel’s views of intentionality. Kriegel praises a ‘tracking account’, a theory of ‘experiential intentionality’, as the only way to naturalize intentionality (Kriegel, 2011, p. 6). This section will establish that this view is a non-starter: and here I will debate that there is no such thing as non-experiential intentionality or derived intentionality in the terms proposed by Kriegel. The third section will set up all objections and replies to the views defended, and conclude with a discussion about whether the phenomenal character of intentionality can be naturalized. This debate will at the same time provide an introduction to the discussion of the next chapter, about how the hard problem of consciousness can be explored from the base of intentionality view developed in this…

    • 717 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    One potential worry that one might have upon reading Daniel Dennett's "Where Am I?," is about the complications that might arise from Dennett categorizing his brain, who he calls Yorick, and his body, who he calls Hamlet, as two distinct entities. One may contend that the brain and the body are in fact only one entity, connected much in the same way that other people's brains and bodies seem to be connected—however that may be—with the exception of an unusually large temporal gap between Dennett's brain and Dennett's body in this case. Unfortunately, however, this worry is ultimately unclear and incoherent, but if expressed in different terms, it is possible to make sense of the underlying idea . In this paper, I will describe this worry, explain why it falls short, and then re-formulate it in clearer terms in the hope of capturing and clarifying what the underlying intuitions actually are. Furthermore, I will present and respond to a worry that may be brought against this reformulated position.…

    • 1103 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    “The Ethics of Belief” written by W.K. Clifford. Explains the idea of belief and moral righteousness by coming up with the conclusion that it is morally incorrect to believe in a claim with insufficient evidence or to create a claim without sufficient evidence. Clifford brings about various analogies that prove his claim to be true such as the ship-owner and the religious group on the island. Although these ideas helped set out the theory efficiently, William James essay “The Will to Believe” believes in the opposite by stating that anyone can believe in anything without the sufficient evidence provided for a specific claim. James’s, the essay provides counterexamples to Clifford’s work as well as provides strong examples and positions to help…

    • 1480 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The intentional stance is a term used by philosopher Daniel Dennett for the “various levels of abstraction in which we view the behavior of a thing in terms of its mental properties”. It belongs to the mental content theory initially proposed by Dennett, which provides the baseline structure of his later works on free will, consciousness, folk psychology, and evolution. The international stance is described as initially treating an objects behavior as a predictable rational agent; then one determines said objects beliefs in accordance to its place and purpose in the world; Then one evaluates the desires it is believed to have, on the same considerations, and finally to claim that the rational agent will act only to further its goals in light…

    • 1007 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    What does this demonstrate about our brains and the information that they give us about the world?…

    • 626 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Decline of Public Life, Commercializing Leisure and Recreation; Formalizing Recreation: Organization over spontaneity are the three developments that have brought about the change in leisure time.…

    • 279 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “In 1950, Japanese businessmen turned to an obscure American from Wyoming to help them rebuild an economy shattered in World War II. The industrial expert, W. Edwards Deming, taught Japan’s manufacturers how to produce top quality products economically. The Japanese used this knowledge to turn the global economy on its head and beat U.S. industry at its own game” (McInnis D. 2011). Edwards Deming was born in Iowa in 1900 and seven years later the family moved to Wyoming. He received his formal education at the University of Wyoming and also attended school at University of Colorado and Yale University. It was in this period he developed an interest in using statistics to improve manufacturing processes. He was introduced to Walter Shewhart at Bell Telephone Laboratories and Shewhart influenced his ideas on how statistical methods could be applied to other area besides manufacturing (Tortorella M. 1995).…

    • 665 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays