Preview

Crystal City Internment Camp Analysis

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1366 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Crystal City Internment Camp Analysis
Earl G. Harrison the commissioner of the INS was on a mission to find the perfect location for the establishment of the very first family camp. In his searching he came across government owned land in rural and isolated Crystal City, Texas. This old migrant camp was geographically the ideal location for the establishment of the family camp. The location was both strategically far enough from both the East and West Coast, and it was close enough to house the transported families from Latin America. On December 12, 1942, thirty-five German families that were being held at Ellis Island and Camp Forest entered the unfinished camp in Crystal City, the camp was officially opened. Harrison placed Joseph O’Rourke who had previously worked at the Seagoville camp, as officer in charge at Crystal City.
Under O’Rourke’s command and the labor of German and Japanese internees he reconstructed the old migrant camp into the largest internment camp in the nation. The Crystal City Enemy Detention Facility was in total 290 acres, and consisted of 500 buildings, with a variety of living units that all had heaters, kerosene ranges,
…show more content…
In a video created by the INS in 1945 that highlights the life inside Crystal City Internment Camp it stated that the camp was equipped with electricity, plumbing, and running water throughout. All housing units were provided with daily milk deliveries, ice boxes, linens, chairs, and some even had their own toilets. Crystal City was seen as the model camp of all camps, however there were underlining reasons as to why internees in Crystal City had it so much better than others, and that reasoning was a part of the whole bigger picture of what really happened within the camp. Officials knew that how they treated the internees here could have a direct effect on how American POW’s and American’s being held in Japan and Germany were being

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    Prisoners of the Andersonville prison camp often found that life in the prison has been much worse than on the battlefield. The prison was often unsanitary and overcrowded, which led to disease. Many prisoners who were once healthy, died because of disease or malnutrition. These prisoners were not in these camps for doing wrong, but for fighting in the war. Furthermore, the Andersonville prisoner was not only in prison for different reasons than people of today, but also had much harder lives to live.…

    • 199 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    SAISE Summary – US internment camps during WWII Analysis – not much taught in our schools about US internment camps, taught about German and Japanese camps, US had many camps/detention centers – some were almost as bad as the German concentration camps, not called concentration camps – had a negative connotation – camps sounded better, number varies in research 24 – 30, Seagoville most unusual camp run by INS, set up like a college campus, had dorms, had many luxuries, had more freedom than those which held only men, had hospital, rec hall, library, allowed gardening, farming and many outside activities, still a prison as evidence by barbed wire fence and guards, was a women’s reformatory prior to WWII, able to cook and grow own food, Crystal City, Texas family internment camp - a prison, more freedom than other camps, largest camp in country, housed whole families, were able to grow & cook own food, whole families traded for “more important” American prisoners in Germany & Japan, had…

    • 1442 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The internment camps during World War 2 was seen as necessary, positive and needed to those who were not interned because of the Pearl Harbor Bombing in 1941, which was the hegemonic narrative. Many euphemisms were used to disguise the truth behind the interment of the Japanese-Americans like the words camp, opportunities and more. The place where Japanese-Americans were interned was anything but a camp, it was where they experienced no happiness or fun. It was simply a place where the Japanese- Americans were segregated from others and treated as prisoners who had to be locked in and constantly watched with machine guns being pointed at them. In When the Emperor was Divine, Otsuka demonstrates how the internment camps had psychologically damaged and traumatized everyone from how the girl starts to become distant with her family, the woman breaking down trying to cope with…

    • 1578 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Andersonville Prison was officially known as Camp Sumter. The prison was originally built to only hold 10,000 men, but the number rapidly started growing. “The largest number held at any one time was more than 33,000 in August 1864” (Andersonville Prison). Not only was it very crowded but there was also little food, no clean water, and lots of diseases.…

    • 550 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The War on Terror and World War II’s parallels arise in George Takei’s op-ed “Internment, America’s Great Mistake”. Actor George Takei shows the reader how he can relate to the prejudice American Muslims face in the United State’s current social climate. Takei was relocated to an internment camp when he was only seven simply because he looked like the enemy. By showing similarities in the historical reality and his own experience in Japanese internment camps, Takei is able to relate to the current prejudice American Muslims face.…

    • 266 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Opening on August 12th, 1942; the Heart Mountain Internment in Wyoming held up to 10,767 evacuees at any point. Unlike the climate that the mostly Southern Californian Japanese-Americans were not used to the cold climate, which resulted in lots of illness and an overcrowding hospital. Dissimilar to the Gila River Relocation Camp with one watchtower, the Heart Mountain Camp had nine watchtowers with military police and searchlights. Within the camp, ran a garment factory, the produced silk would usually be made into posters for the navy and other camps. In early 1945 evacuees were allowed to return back to the West Coast with $25 and…

    • 1628 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The Confederate soldiers kept enemy Union soldiers in prison camps. Andersonville Prison was considered the main camp for the Confederates. Those who were held at Andersonville lived in hostile, dirty, and inhumane environment.…

    • 392 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Japanese Relocation speech covered how the Japanese were treated, what their daily life was inside of an internment camp, and some of the features that came along with living there. The people were served free food, housing, and they even conjured up a community government. The President made it sound like living there was not that bad. On the other hand he explained his reason for why he ended up placing Japanese into internment camps. Later in the speech he states “The Japanese's were within a stone's throw of a Naval air base, shipyards, and oil wells, Japanese fishermen had every opportunity to watch the movement of our ships” (Document A). This statement proves that the Japanese could have been spying on us at any moment so the President took preliminary precautions to ensure that it would not happen. His decision to put them in internment camps was not only justified, it was also warranted and correct.…

    • 475 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    What was the role of the POW camps and what treatment was received by the prisoners and what did the prisoners do in the camps? During World War II over 140,000 prisoners were kept in Japanese’s camps. These camps took away the prisoners clothes, food and anything they have been carrying through-out the war. The prisoners who lived in these camps were contained by guards, the guards were cruel and abusive mentally and physically. These type of camps were often kept as a secret to the rest of the world. Prisoners were given jobs to do during the day to keep the busy and at the end of the day the lack of protein provided in the food is unreal. In the book Unbroken Louie was kept in one of these awful camps under strict rules made by “The Bird.” “The Bird” whose real name is Mustsohio Watanabe was in charge of everything and everyone in the POW camp.…

    • 270 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Andersonville Prisons

    • 1111 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The prison camps of the American Civil War were terrible due to the falling apart of prisoner exchange programs, the decline of paroles available for officers, and poor war strategies by both sides. Camps were scattered across the country in both the North and the South. The best known of the Union camps were; Fortress Monroe, Virginia; Ohio State Penitentiary, Ohio and point Lookout, Maryland. The better known of the Confederate camps were; Danville, Virginia; Libby Prison, Richmond, Virginia and Andersonville, Georgia. Conditions where many inmates died would send chills down the spine of anyone in this day and age. The camps ended up so crowded there wasn't enough space to shelter every inmate, some died of exposure to the elements, and…

    • 1111 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    I’m Connor and I’m going to be talking about the significant civil rights movements carried out by the Native American Indians such as the Occupy Alcatraz movement and the Trail of Broken Treaties movement. The Occupy Alcatraz shown in the first and second image was a land rights movements made by the Native Americans where many students went to the island and protested for Indian land. The students had said that they were not scared of the US government and their laws because Alcatraz was Indian land. Due to the public spot light that the occupation put on Indian issues it accelerated the process of repealing the tribal termination policy. Johnson and Glasser had said “It might have happened anyway, but Alcatraz had the attention of the nation,…

    • 633 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Right after the attacks, some 2,000 men were arrested because they were seen as immediate threats. Despite the fact that no proof was ever given for Japanese espionage, many Americans still insisted it was a “military necessity” (Sunquist). Many people recognized the wrong in isolating the Japanese, but still rested on their prejudiced opinions. Knowing that citizens saw the unconstitutionality of the situation goes on to prove the motivation for internment camps: fear, war hysteria, and prejudice. The Japanese Americans were given one week to pack up their old life before they were transported to the assembly centers. Extra clothes, bedding, and whatever else they could carry were among the little that the Japanese could bring with them. Not only were the Japanese ripped away from their lives and forced to live new ones, but they had a limited amount of time to do so and could only bring whatever was suitable for their captors. Removing Japanese Americans from their homes was unnecessary in itself, but not only that, they couldn’t feel at home where they were going. They lived in assembly centers for six months while the U.S. hastily built ten internment camps that were located at fairground parking lots or horse stalls that had housed horses up to a week before the arrival of the Japanese Americans (Candela). Forcing people to leave their homes is an injustice in itself, but forcing people to leave their homes and move into ramshackles is even worse. However, when the detainees arrived at the assembly centers, everything was confiscated from them including “cameras, baseball bats, and even popguns”…

    • 1577 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Japanese internment camps in the United States were unjust for many reasons. For one, the ten camps that the Japanese Americans were forced to live in had filthy and…

    • 806 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The conditions inside the United States internment camps were extremely overcrowded and provided very poor living conditions. According to the reports published by the War Relocation Authority, the administering agency in 1943, Japanese Americans were housed in tar paper covered barracks with guard towers and barbed wire fences for boundary. Moreover, not only were these boundaries just boundaries. They were guarded by military police with rifles, and numerous Japanese Americans in these internment camps were killed by the military guards for not following the orders or because they resisted the officers.…

    • 791 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    WW2 Internment

    • 556 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Most of those forced into the camps were American born; others were Japanese immigrants. However, all had already made a good themselves in America. Many were professionals such as lawyers, and doctors, and thousands of Japanese Americans even served in the U.S. army during WWII. Many photographs depict the difficulties that many Japanese American’s had adjusting to life in the camps. Entire families were given one room to live in. Showers and toilets were communal and often set in the middle of the camps offering no privacy for the internees. Internees could not bring personal belongings into the camps, so they often only had the clothes they were wearing. some of the internees were separated from their families, adult or child. For children who are the age of seventeen, were given an loyalty test, in which officials were to ask questions. Surprisingly the test only consisted of two questions, 1. Are you willing to serve in the armed forces of the United States on combat duty wherever ordered? (Females were asked if they were willing to volunteer for the Army Nurse Corps or Women's Army Corps.) 2. Will you swear unqualified allegiance to the United…

    • 556 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays