Preview

David Brian and Winthrop D. Jordan: Varying Opinions on Racialized Slavery toward Africans

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
866 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
David Brian and Winthrop D. Jordan: Varying Opinions on Racialized Slavery toward Africans
There is no denying that slavery has existed since the beginning of time. References and drawings describing slavery have been traced all the way back to the biblical era. While many people associate the word slavery with the African race, history shows that multiple races and cultures have undergone such captivity. In “The Origins of Antiblack Racism in the New World” by David Brian Davis and “Unthinking Decision: Enslavement of Africans in America to 1700” by Winthrop D. Jordan, two historians express varying opinions on racialized slavery towards Africans. Their argument differs not only in time and location but also the underlining factor in which slavery became racialized. The time period in which the authors believe racialized slavery began isn’t that far apart. Davis argues that this took place during the 1400s, while Jordan claims this took place between the 1640s and 1660s. Religion played a part in how the authors choose this timeframe. Due to biblical associations and the negative connotation with the word black, it wasn’t long before this ideology reached the head of the church. Davis believes it wasn’t until the 1400s when a succession of popes begin giving their blessing towards the enslavement of Africans. “It thus seems probable that most Europeans received their first subliminal impressions of so-called Negroes in a local church or cathedral” (Davis 59). Backing up their beliefs with biblical stories such as the “Curse of Haam”, it wasn’t long before the European nation was on board. (Davis 56)
On the other side of the argument, Jordan believes it wasn’t until after the establishment of New World colonies that slavery became racialized. He states that the new settlers felt an overwhelming since of disorientation and isolation. Losing many passengers on the voyage to the New World, and then being thrust into a rugged uncivilized territory prompted quick and immediate solutions. Tudor statesmen began to harp on the importance of a labor system.



References: and drawings describing slavery have been traced all the way back to the biblical era. While many people associate the word slavery with the African race, history shows that multiple races and cultures have undergone such captivity. In “The Origins of Antiblack Racism in the New World” by David Brian Davis and “Unthinking Decision: Enslavement of Africans in America to 1700” by Winthrop D. Jordan, two historians express varying opinions on racialized slavery towards Africans. Their argument differs not only in time and location but also the underlining factor in which slavery became racialized. The time period in which the authors believe racialized slavery began isn’t that far apart. Davis argues that this took place during the 1400s, while Jordan claims this took place between the 1640s and 1660s. Religion played a part in how the authors choose this timeframe. Due to biblical associations and the negative connotation with the word black, it wasn’t long before this ideology reached the head of the church. Davis believes it wasn’t until the 1400s when a succession of popes begin giving their blessing towards the enslavement of Africans. “It thus seems probable that most Europeans received their first subliminal impressions of so-called Negroes in a local church or cathedral” (Davis 59). Backing up their beliefs with biblical stories such as the “Curse of Haam”, it wasn’t long before the European nation was on board. (Davis 56) On the other side of the argument, Jordan believes it wasn’t until after the establishment of New World colonies that slavery became racialized. He states that the new settlers felt an overwhelming since of disorientation and isolation. Losing many passengers on the voyage to the New World, and then being thrust into a rugged uncivilized territory prompted quick and immediate solutions. Tudor statesmen began to harp on the importance of a labor system. A system which would constitute the social norms for the New World. The answer seemed simple, find cheap labor. This labor would provide the work force behind the growth of colonies and more importantly the cash crop. Its no secret to historians that New World colonies flourished from agriculture. Jordan claims that by the year “1660 slavery crystallized on the statue books of Maryland, Virginia, and other colonies” (Jordan 26). The developing of a new community also created the subconscious need to distinguish the outsiders from the insiders. With the increasing number of Scottish and Irish servants the need to distinguish a “true Englishman” became inevitable. Not only do the authors differentiate on when slavery became racialized, but also from whom this notion was adopted. The majority of Davis’ argument focuses on the Islamic world and its influence on the rest of the world. For a long time Europeans associated any person from the African region with their Islamic enemies. Africans were seen as barbaric foreigners, ones who needed to be taught and civilized. Davis states that Islam basically “invented Africa as a continent” (Davis 60). Muslim conquest extended geographical boundaries and produced the need for a massive flow of slaves from one area to the next. Davis accredits the Islamic World to developing the first slave trade by both caravan and sea. Medieval Arabs and Persians, while enslaving various different outside races, associated the most horrendous forms of labor with black slaves. This ideology, combined with the races highly distinct features slowly paved way to the black association with the term slavery. Over time the Arabic word for slave ‘abd’ came only to mean black enslavement. The constant interchange between the Muslim and European world slowly but surely merged together the racialized ideology that Africans were ‘natural born’ slaves. “By the fifteenth century, many Iberian Christians had internalized the racist attitudes of the Muslims and were applying them to the increasing flow of African slaves to their part of the world” (Davis 64). Jordan on the other hand believes the primary group involved in racializing slavery was the Spanish and Portuguese. He claims that slavery has existed in Spain and Portugal since the beginning of time as a primary “function of the religious wars against the Moors.” It wasn’t until the mid 1500s that Englishmen developed the idea that profit could possibly arise from supplying the Spanish with Negroes. Explorer John Hawkins was the first, in 1560, to make the voyage. Hawkins made three voyages, two of which were successful, and proved to Europeans that Africans could indeed be treated as beneficial merchandise. The Spain and Portugal use of African slaves acted as an example towards the New World. While Davis argues that the Islamic World influenced and racialized slavery, conversely Jordan argues that it was the Spanish and Portuguese. (Jordan 34). Differentiations in time and ethnic origin don’t overshadow that fact that both authors key point the fact that slavery took place on a national scale. Both historians agree that over time society needed a way to differentiate between those who were free, and those who were slaves. On top of that, religious references, negative symbolism, and the social outlook that Africans were child-like and inferior all contributed to the racialization.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    These legacies of the slave trade are prominent through the idea of race, as “Atlantic slavery came to be identified wholly with Africa and with blackness” (689) Racism was used in this time period to justify actions, as through racism, “Europeans were better able to tolerate their brutal exploitations of Africans” (690). This racial discrimination became a reoccurring theme that has lasted well into the twenty-first…

    • 278 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Slavery is as old as the world 's first civilizations. Two important slave movements were the one across the Sahara Desert and another along the East African coasts of the Indian Ocean, both of which terminated in slave markets in the Muslim world. The subject of slavery is viewed in contrast by different parts of the world. Narrowing to the topic of slavery in the Americas and the Muslim states, it is apparent that the two regions contain mostly different opinions as to whether slaves exist for sheer labor or that slaves are humans just like you and me. What is similar between the facts that Muslims view their slaves religiously with more compassion than that of the Americas, who view their slaves as crudely as "horses"? From a total of nine documents, they can be categorized into three groups. Documents 5, 6, and 8 contain statements that support slavery. Documents 2, 3, and 7 sway towards the idea against slavery, and the idea of treating slaves more humanely. Lastly, Documents 1, 4, and 9 are observations, or data concerning slavery.…

    • 1151 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Gary Nash discusses the impact of black people in a white peoples colony. The first negro people to come to America in Virginia were probably indentured servants who would receive some type of reward after their time of service was over, until 1660. After 1660 though many of the “Negros” that came to America were slaves, purchased as property. By the 1800’s every colony in America had “slave codes” which stripped black people of every right they had and made them property. His biggest claim was his stating of, “More than anything else it was sugar that transformed the African slave trade.” The slave trade became an extremely profitable enterprise for European nations once the sugar plantations reached the New World. Many of the New World colonies sought to buy slaves to work on the sugar plantations. It wasn't until the last third of the seventeenth century were the English involved with the slave trade and since it was their royal colonies that were buying most of the slaves they saw a new opportunity to get more money from their colonies. Once the English started to get involved it caused most European nations to war over who dominated the slave trade since it was such a profitable enterprise. pg 38-39.…

    • 1041 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    After this slavery began appear in Jamestown. In the 1700 slavery increased once the need for labor in growing tobacco was need. That ultimately started and grew the slave trade. Wait hasn’t slavery been around for a long time? Well that’s correct African kings would go into battle with each other. These kings would send their strongest warriors to capture the other tribe and bring back the other tribes people. What the king would do with those people is basically turn them into slaves and either let them work for him or sell them Europeans in trade of guns, gold and other goods. Johnson states, “The white man did not introduce slavery to Africa . . . . And by the fifteenth century, men with dark skin had become quite comfortable with the…

    • 297 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    To say that slavery existed solely because of racism is far beyond the real reasoning. Through my readings, The Peculiar Institution and The African American Odyssey, I have come to the…

    • 400 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Myne Own Ground

    • 987 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The 17th century was an important time period as the New World continued to develop into a society run by English settlers. The book, Myne Owne Ground, by Timothy Breen, focuses on the colonial history of the 1600’s. However, what is discussed in the book does not detail what was accomplished in this time period. Rather, Breen pinpoints the classes of people such as slaves, indentured servants, and free blacks; how they came to become part of those groups and when racism first started. For decades, not all blacks were slaves and servants. Some blacks were free men in the New World. That would only become a short memory, though, as the idea of being non-white turned into the biggest embarrassment in American history; slavery.…

    • 987 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Defending Slavery

    • 1983 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Defending slavery demonstrate the opinions and knowledge that the Southerners held concerning blacks and slavery. Paul Finkelman talks about slave legitimacy in colonial America. He argues that the first defense of slavery became visible after the end of American Revolution; it attempted to justify continuous forced labor with the Declaration of Independence. This essay aims at critically analyzing ideologies and racial theories that Southerners promoted to defend slavery, which included racial, political, legal, economic, and religious ideologies. Most specifically, this essay will discuss the legitimacy of slavery, in the earlier days, and justify this idea by using the religion and racial defenses of slavery.…

    • 1983 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Slaves Outline

    • 780 Words
    • 4 Pages

    A. During 1607-1775 the beginning stages of the economy for the southern colonies was a time of desperately needed labor, known as the “starving time” as the Indian laborers were no longer passive to the strict demands being given, but became rather troublesome and aggressive to overtake. This obstacle led the colonists to seek a more manageable alternative. The availability of these black slaves were in greater numbers by dealers seeking profitable gains. White men saw slavery as a means to better their own egos in society, as manual labor done by anyone other than a slave was noted as degrading. Since the slaves were taken from regions that were already accustomed to the extreme climates of the southern colonies, the African slaves were ideal workers in such conditions.…

    • 780 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    This book not only goes into details about the labor that the slaves partook in on a daily basis that kept America up and running, but also about the cultural aspect of bring slaves into the country. Bringing African’s over to America brought a whole new culture to America. Although white men enslaved African’s they continued to embrace their culture. They brought a new religion, language, music, and several skills that have uniquely blended the American culture that it is today.…

    • 1403 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Slavery has plagued nearly every part of the world, from ancient Greece to modern Mauritania in 2007; countless government bodies have sanctioned the ‘civil relationship in which one person has absolute power over the life, fortune, and liberty of another’. North American slavery began in the early seventeenth century; however the stage was set as early as the fourteenth century, when the wealthy nations of Spain and Portugal began importing captive slaves from Africa to Europe. When these practices extended into the newly conquered Caribbean and West Indies in the mid-1600s, Virginia colonists began to take note of the phenomenal agricultural production…

    • 1962 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Kunta Kinte

    • 2397 Words
    • 10 Pages

    States in Europe have begun to invade the American Continent in 16. century. Especially, Spanish invaders enslave and run indigenous people who live in America in sugar cane farm and mines in very poor conditions. Indigenous people have disappeared in a short time because of Europa people's infectious diseases and poor working conditions. Upon this the Spaniards and the Portuguese turned to Africa to find a source of cheap labor. Slave trade was legitimized in the Kingdom of Spain in 1502.[1] In 1509, the catholic bishop of the chiapas city of the Spain, Bartolome de Las Casas said that; ''Spanish settlers who goes to America should take a certain amount slaves''. This advice is considered the beginning of the slave trade from Africa to America. To save American indigenous people and to improve relationship between the settlers of America and American indigenous people, The Laws of Burgos inserted into force by spanish Kingdom, in 27 December 1511 and this law has allowed black slavery.[2] In 1518, Lorens de Gominot took the first official permission to dispatch 4000 African slaves to America continent. In 1519 the first slave ship from Africa to Puerto Rico in American continent is thought to be moving. The beginning of the slave trade there were not a link between the slave trade and racism. However, with the increase of African slaves, slavery and the negro were used in the same sense in the West. European Christians, did not accept other Europeans (whites) to be slaves. However, they did not have any objections for the slavery of black Africans, so the new target was Africa continent.[3]…

    • 2397 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Slavery has been around since the birth of civilization. From Mesopotamian times, up until Europeans started colonizing in America. Servitude became such a strong belief that even between the same race it was ideal, England would separate inferiorities based on religion. Acknowledging this the colonist used the same perspective by justifying the color of skin and cultural to be secondary in order to debar the natives and blacks from whites. It wasn't until colonial leaders, perceived religious faith, stating that no longer mistreatment would be allowed. These justifications would continue slavery in other parts of the world shaping the modern meaning of racism.…

    • 296 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    African Diaspora Analysis

    • 510 Words
    • 3 Pages

    What I'm referring to is the Atlantic Slave Trade which popularized slavery world wide, portraying "blacks" as the primary target. Before then Africans traveled all over the world. There are historic accounts of African presence all over Europe in the middle ages, from art form to sports. Africans were residents of countries from there to the Middle East where Africans were also missionaries to spread there religious views to the different parts of "their world as they knew it," at the time. Our text talks about India having the largest number of enslaved Africans recorded. The slaves there however were not treated unjustly, and it was not race based slavery. The slaves there were worker form the fields to administration. Africans were sailors to soldiers, who traveled the trade ways. Queen Elizabeth I in 1556 recognized too many "blackamoores" and thought they should be sent back to Africa (The African Diaspora Experience, pg. 6). In these days Africans freely traveled to these different countries among the world, just like explores, they participated in the development of the Americas and…

    • 510 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The N Word

    • 1905 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Black, D. P. (1997). Dismantling Black Manhood: An Historical and Literary Analysis of the Legacy of slavery. New York: Routledge.…

    • 1905 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    racial Discrimination

    • 1805 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The period of the Renaissance and Reformation was also the time when Europeans were coming into increasing contact with people of darker skin colors in Africa, Asia, and the Americas were making judgments about them. The owners and traders of slave’s official conclusion for enslaving African Americans came from a passage from the Bible in Genesis. It was thought that the “dark people” had committed a sin against his father Noah that condemned his supposedly black descendants to be "servants unto servants." “ Race Discrimination” Shellist Lazarz Slobin, pg 1 As a result, in 1667, Virginia decreed that converted slaves could be kept in bondage, not because they were of different origins, but because they had heathen ancestry. The thinking behind black servitude was forever changed from religious status to something approaching race. Beginning in the late seventeenth century, laws were also passed in North America forbidding marriage between whites and blacks and discriminating…

    • 1805 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays