Preview

Dbq- Female Workers in England and Japan: How Similar Were Their Experiences?

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1922 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Dbq- Female Workers in England and Japan: How Similar Were Their Experiences?
DBQ- Female Workers in England and Japan: How Similar Were Their Experiences?

The experiences of female mill workers in Japan had different experiences from female mill workers in England. The industrial revolution happened in England around the 1800’s while in Japan, the industrial revolution happened around the 1900’s. There are multiple examples of difference between the different female mill workers. These can be categorized into four different groupings. These groups are Background, Salary/Wage, Gender/Age, and Working Conditions. The groups Salary/Wage, Gender/Age, and Working Conditions all show their differences. While the group of Background shows the resemblance of the two groups. When looking at the difference at the backgrounds from female workers from Japan and England the show few similitarities between these two areas. In Document #1 England of Japan (Maps), the point of view of this document is that it shows a current map to compare the similar size of the two countries; they both are small island nations. Document #2 Mill Workers: Two Visuals, point of view from this document shows that the two pictures show that life in a factory or mill may seem all nice and clean, but as proof from the other documents shows this is not so. They give the deception of the mills and factories being too good to be true. These pictures also show the majority of female workers, with minimal male interaction. One can infer from the deception that these are advertisements for factories in different areas. A few additional documents that would help better explain the background of the experiences of female workers; One would be a bigger map that shows the entire world, and one that shows real photos of the factories that are not staged or propaganda. Through these two documents we can see that even though there are numerous differences between the female workers in the island nations of Japan and England, there are still a few similarities. Even though there are

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    According to the chart in Japan 1892 “Average daily wage of a female silk factory worker is only 13 Sen.” (Doc C) female workers get paid only 13 sen a day. this amount of paid was not enough for a living because at that time a pair of ladies indoor sandals already costs 7 Sen. It is just not right to pay the workers with so little money, especially when the workers spend all their day in the horrible factory conditions working . A survey of the Japanese Silk Worker “70% said the pay was good and 0% said it was poor, overall experience 90% said it was positive.” (Doc F) . Almost everyone said the pay was decent and none of the workers were complaining about the wages. This document is not reliable because as a young female worker , no one would want to work in a harsh condition with low wages especially when you have no choice but agree to work.With all these conditions, it benefits more for the factories rather than outweigh the cost of the female workers because the factories hiring female workers would be better for them because female’s wages are lower than men but they still able to provide the same amount of work as men…

    • 1160 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Female Mill Workers in England and Japan were indeed quite different. Workers in Japan had lower incomes and there were more young female workers. England had higher wages and the ages varied. Through the eleven documents, one can see that they can be broken into four categories, showing the differences between the two countries. The four categories being background information, gender and age, wages and hours, and working conditions. Through these eleven documents one can see that Female Mill Workers in Japan and England were different.…

    • 917 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Cotton Industry Dbq Essay

    • 668 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Poor conditions and low pay developed for workers in both countries, especially in japan. Girls were forced to work late in confined space and pay was sparse, on top of that sickness was common and some died from diseases spread in the factories (doc.3). However despite low pay, factory jobs were important for many lower class or farmer families. Many would send their children to work in the factories to provide extra income to their family (doc.4). Also factory jobs provided an escape from those same lower class strata’s for the girls who went to work as they became responsible for themselves and weren’t held back forced to provide for an entire family (doc. 5). This same effect was true in India where the vast majority of workers were recruited from small rural farming villages (doc.9). These similarities are clearly defined as inherent aspects of industrialization in a non-industrialized…

    • 668 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Unit 4 Study Questions

    • 386 Words
    • 2 Pages

    3. Analyze the social, economic and political changes and continuities facing women between 1750 and 1914 in the industrialized world.…

    • 386 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Workers were more satisfied with how they were treated in Japan while Russia dealt with strikes because of poor working conditions. In document 4, S. I. Somov, a Russian socialist, recalls his participation in a strike. Being a socialist, it is easy to comprehend why Somov would sympathize with the workers and strike and even join them. He describes how the workers stated various phrases over and over again. The workers were on strike because they ran out of patience, and that their suffering was worse than death. These factory workers must have been treated extremely poorly for them to go on strike. In document 5, Yamamoto Shigemi, a historian, interviews elderly Japanese women who worked in silk factories. In Shigemi's survey, most workers voted favorably when asked about their food or pay and not a single one regretted going to work in a silk factory. A survey pool of 580 is enough to justify the notion that these conditions were similar throughout multiple factories in Japan, and that most factory workers were conent in how they were treated at the time. In document 7, M. I. Pokzocskaya, a Russian physicion, published an article about the treatment of womem in Russian factories. Women were required to work extremely long hours, up to 18 on some days. Actual physical force was also used to make children continue working. Women factory workers were treated as if they…

    • 701 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Cotton Industry Dbq

    • 853 Words
    • 4 Pages

    There is a chart (Doc 7) that compares the amount of female cotton textile workers in Japan and India. It shows that over three-fourths were women in Japan, and less than one-fourth of Indian laborers were women. Another way this document helps show the difference of workers between Japanese and Indian textile factories is that in Japan the percent of women workers slightly increases over the years 1920-1930. In India, the percent of female workers from 1909-1934 decreases, meaning women didn’t work as much in factories. Because India was so patriarchal the women’s job was to stay home and take care of the house. Document 4 is a written concern about how there are many women working in Japanese textile mills. Documents 8 and 10 both consist of a picture from a Japanese cotton mill (Doc 8), and an Indian textile mill (Doc 10). The Japanese mill (Doc 8) illustrates a couple of women working and two or three men just sitting there (most likely supervising.) However in difference to Japan, the Indian mill (Doc 10) shows only male workers, this helps prove that more men worked than women in Indian textile mills. One should approach document 8 with caution because the source seems to be unreliable. The photo is from and official company history, meaning the picture was most likely staged to make it look like a superior place to…

    • 853 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    As the revolution was in motion, a number of people had benefited from its growth in the manufacturing industry. Women had started working in factories, producing cloth. This material was able to be made much more efficiently and cheaper, due to new inventions like the “Spinning Jenny” and the “Crompton’s Mule”.(DOC #1) This allowed far more materials being produced to supply the increasing demand. As demand increased, so did employment opportunities.…

    • 509 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Cotton Industry Dbq

    • 886 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In Japan, they had a higher percentage of workers who were women than in India. During the 1920 the percentage of Female cotton workers was eighty percent which increased to eighty point sixty percent in the year 1930. In India their percentage in the year 1909 was a twenty-two point one percent which decrease to eighteen point nine in the year 1934 (Doc.7). While Japans use of female cotton workers increased in India their female cotton workers decreased. Furthermore, the female workers in the cotton industries of Japan often were young girls who were sent from families to help them survive. They would always work from morning till dark; however their first year working they did not get payed till their second year and so forth. Unlike India, in Japan, the cotton workers would get an increase in their pay each year starting off with 35 yen (Doc.3). Last, mostly in India their workers had to work standing up and weaving using the machines. In Japan, they were capable of sitting down and weave using machines or…

    • 886 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Most working women and children were no longer able to keep up with the speed and efficiency of the competing textile machines. In order to provide a needed extra income to help support their families they were forced to work in cottage industries, making pins or buttons, or even finding work in the mines, dragging the mined coal from the men all the way to the storage units. The women did all of this while looking after their children and even using opium to keep their babies quiet during work hours. Yet after all of the struggles that women and children faced, there was still an undeniable discrimination of gender and age in the workplace and the salaries of men compared to women is a prime example of…

    • 1524 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Japan and England although separated by almost a century worth of time had a similar experience in the Industrial Revolution in female factory worker wages, working conditions, and the percentage of female workers. Female workers in both Japan and England were not paid as well as they would most likely want. There pay isn’t enough to get all the resources they would like to support their family. On the other hand males would receive much more. Working condition of both nations weren’t better either. The female workers would work about thirteen to fourteen hour days and would get barely any break time. Finally there was about an eighty five percent difference in female workers to males because the women were the ones that were targeted because of their smaller body. The struggles women went through were definitely tough to go through but opened up a whole new opportunity for women to strive in the modern time. In present day women are getting treated much better in areas that the Industrial Revolution went through as there is work going on to close the wage gap, make sure there is diversity is in a workplace and make sure the pay workers are receiving match the work they put…

    • 1427 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The culture of New England in the 1830’s and 1840’s expected young girls and women to be submissive, moral, and domestic. The factory girls families weren’t too happy with their daughters working outside the home. The industrialists had to convince the public that textile mills were appropriate places for young girls to work. Working at the textile mills provided young women with financial independence that they wouldn’t get staying at home and working on the farm. This idea of financial independence really challenged the role of women in society prior to this time. The girls no longer had to rely on their father’s income for support and this didn’t sit well with the daddies. Working in the mills also provided the girls with more opportunities to extend their education and learning. Often, these working girls would become more educated than their mothers and grandmothers.…

    • 560 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The industrial revolution brought many positive and negative effects to the factory workers, but a majority of negative effects, along with health problems and children working however, a positive effect jobs for women.…

    • 265 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Sparked by first the growth of the planters which then led to manufacturing and factories, all this new growth lead to strains and changes in relationships in both the work place and in the home as women strived to become more independent. In the early days, factory girls were not popular,…

    • 1909 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    In a world view, a worker benefited from the industrial revolution as comparably American workers enjoyed 40 percent higher wages than their counterparts in England (Schaller et al. Pg.353). Their wages were higher than others but there were still negative effects. Working conditions were poor and dangerous to the workers and the people hired were not only adults but also children who were expected to work just the same as an adult worker. While workers were affected both positively and negatively, industries grew and increased the need for industrial labor. For example, the cotton industry grew and the creation of mill girls appeared, who worked in mills weaving cotton (Schaller et al.…

    • 2596 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The work day for both these nationalities consisted of the same unreasonableness and unfairness. In England (In Document E), women had horrendous working hours. On weekdays work in a factory work begin at 5:30 am and finish at 8 pm which is a total of 14 hours and 30 minutes. Then in Japan, a work day would start at 4:05 am until 7:30 pm, for a total of 14 hours and 20 minutes. Also to add on to the burden of being exhausted, women were treated unequally when it came to wages. For example (In Document F), a female worker in England questions her wage when she notices that her youngest child makes more than her. She makes a total of 2 shillings a week while her child makes 2 shillings and 6 pence. This inequality also affects the working women of Japan. Japanese males and females work identical jobs, but (In Document H) there is a difference…

    • 796 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics