Preview

Decisive Moment Robert Frank Analysis

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1381 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Decisive Moment Robert Frank Analysis
Introduction
Robert Frank, who has been called as one of the most important photographer in twentieth century for more than forty years (A. Powell, 2009), it is a special performance of photography history in twentieth century. His book caused the new trend of photography after World War II: more sincere and more individual. Also, Robert Frank present a new way of photography that is "The non decisive moment", this theory is against "The decisive moment" of Henri Cartier-Bresson, which gave a brand new approach for other photographers (S. Greenough, 2009). When just published, there are query and vituperation everywhere. Some people who believe technique is decisive element think that Robert Frank’s picture not qualified yet in technically;
…show more content…
In , Robert Frank takes “everyone” in the book as a whole object in his subject. Therefore, Robert Frank put himself in the opposite of the whole object in order to accept the judgment of his object, or in other words, “the Americans”. At the time of the United States, this behavior is absolutely dangerous and arrogant especially he is a Switzerland and he just arrived to America eleven years. However, this sudden sense is necessary. If Robert Frank changes the name from to , it might look narrower, people may see the book as a personal view not reflection of all people. Some might do not know or Robert Frank. This is an indispensible dramatic conflict in an important event that is the conflict of individual point of view and social consensus. For example, in present China, some documentary photographer such as Guang Lu (Figure1), his work won the third prize in long-term object of World Press Photo 2015. However, Guang Lu is bringing the strong personal view when he taking photos of some events that he thought wrong or something people feel angry. These strong points of view are easily brought into his photos; therefore viewers would consider that these images are too strongly oriented. For this reason, works of Guang Lu has strong controversy in China. On the other hand, another Chinese documentary photographer Dengke Hou, he took over 43,000 films in his life. His …show more content…
The whole society seems thriving however if people cannot discover these problems in time, this society could turn to the negative side. Although China is still constantly developing, economy remains one of the most dynamic on Earth, the businesses the most innovative and the infrastructure construction is also popular; the solicitude for civil realm of spirit seems to have been no attention. The dissatisfaction from citizen to the government is increasingly aggravated. On the one hand, the vested interest in social or in the circle are enjoying benefits of various policies, they have a glamorous life. On the other hand, some that cannot enjoy these benefits are distribute their grievances. However, they seem to be very yearning to enter a circle like that. The value of the whole society seems to have some deviation. To contrast with , if some photographer would like to launch a similar photography project, they could choose some particularly elements as the Chinese characteristics, for example, traditional Chinese street, Asian face, Chinese food, national flag and others. Thus, in this respect one can see that Robert Frank has various experiences for his choice of source material. The reason is that these elements all have similarity, but it is different in every country. The viewers can separate different country by

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    Jan Wong starts out as a naïve, nineteen year old, Canadian student who is displeased with the capitalistic nature of her surroundings. It was the early seventies and to the author, she was experiencing a cultural revolution all her own. Opposition to the Vietnam War was strongly prevalent, the notion of feminism was beginning to arise, and there was a strong desire against conformity of any nature. The author grew up middle class to second generation Chinese citizens and was fueled by bourgeois guilt, and by a feeling of separation from her roots. “Curiosity about my ancestry made me feel ashamed that I couldn’t speak Chinese and knew so little about China” (14). After devouring every morsel of information that she could, she firmly believed Mao and his “comrades” were the only people who had a legit shot at establishing a utopic society. It was official. Jan Wong was going to Beijing.…

    • 1587 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The respondents came from various walks of life and different places in China, and the result is a book that goes into the lives and experiences of Chinese people ranging from artists to businesspeople, former Red Guards to rural migrants, prostitutes to Olympic athletes. However, for this assignment, it was asked to only read the interviews of a wealthy business man, a worker, and a Red Guard. I have heard about China Candid before and that’s why I know a lot about it. Sang Ye shows great interest in the personal experiences of his informants and they were presented not as representative of their occupation or class, but as interesting individuals with rich stories to tell. But with the context being modern China, political considerations affected the lives of all three people with whom he had conversations with. How the political expression was managed differed with every person. Some went along with the party line such as the Red Guard, while others distanced themselves from the authorities or make local officials a part of their schemes. Together, the personal stories told in this collection open a window onto what life is really like for both the Mao and post-Mao generations of…

    • 350 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In both the stories “Balzac and the little Chinese Seamstress” by Dai Sijie and the “Colors of the Mountain” by Da Chen reveal, that the china’s cultural revolution had a great impact on a lot of people especially young students education. This happened in early 1971, it was Mao’s and his communist government who created this Cultural Revolution so that they could control over people. They stopped young student’s education, most of them were students who had educated family or owned lands were treated bad, humiliated and made them suffer because of their status and also Mao thought that they might be a threat to the communism. These students had inner conflicts as well as physical pain.…

    • 354 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Henri Cartier-Bresson

    • 1062 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Henri Cartier-Bresson is among some of the most influential photographers of the 20th century. His photographs appear in most popular magazines such as, Life, Harper's Bazaar, Vogue and also co founding Magnum Photo Agency. Cartier-Bresson pursued photography with an impulsive passion that he refined into a photojournalistic art form. He is also well know for coining the phrase “The Decisive Moment” in photography, which is capturing the moment something is happening creating a photograph that leaves the viewer waiting. In better terms the decisive moment is “the one that fixes forever the precise and transitory instant.” It is important to keep in mind each picture was exposed on film and could only be viewed after the film was developed;…

    • 1062 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Son of the Revolution

    • 1721 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Liang Heng and Judith Shapiro's "Son of the Revolution" is a comprehensive story of Liang Heng's life on growing up during the chaotic times of the Chinese revolution. The purpose of this novel was to depict the horrors and hardships of life during the revolution period in china during Mao Zedong's reign. In the beginning of the book, the author portrays that news and ideologies always stated that the government was working for the good of the people of the country. However, as the book unfolds the author reveals that the government is actually exploiting the people through misuse of people's trust. The book also provides insights into the Chinese life during the period of 1954-1978. This 24 year period saw major political movement and aspects of Mao Zedong's thoughts and its influence on people. The personal effects of these historical movements coincide directly with the Liang family providing stirring details through the eyes of a person that went through the actual horrific events. This essay will focus on some historical central issues of the book from the period when the first campaign against rightist occurred in 1957 to the "Great Proletarian Cultural Revolution" in 1966. The role of family, influence of relationships in marriage and divorce, the power of Mao Thought, and the major political reforms that took place in the period depicted in the novel will be discussed.…

    • 1721 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Mirror with a Memory

    • 682 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In Chapter 8 of After the Fact in the article, “The Mirror with a Memory” by James West Davidson and Mark Lytle, the authors tell the story of photography and of a man names Jacob Riis. Riis came from Scandinavia as a young man and moved to the United States. Riis firsthand experienced the bad conditions in the heart of the slums of New York. He worked from place to place, doing odd jobs until he found a job as a police reporter for the New York Tribune. Riis lived in a slum called “The Bend.” When he became a reporter, Riis aspired to make people see the awful conditions of “The Bend.” Riis was continuously disappointed because his articles did not receive much attention or sympathy he was looking for. He then vowed to write a book called How the Other Half Lives. In his book, he would detail all the troubling settings that people were living in. To stir interest, Riis learned that photography was very powerful and made readers reflect and think.…

    • 682 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    Chicago's Chinatown

    • 3929 Words
    • 16 Pages

    This research paper encompasses parts of Chinatown 's culture, history, demographics and landscape. We will attempt to explain some of their beliefs and customs, as well as, link the present Chinese Americans to their past in Communist China. It 's hard to remain objective, particularly while taking this class (COMS540), but in an effort to remain somewhat neutral, we will limit our comments to just slightly closer to being opinionated. We will first cover our visits; when we went and what we saw, move into some not-so-pleasant material concerning practices and communism. Speak on President Sun Yat-Sen. And finish with some proposed construction for the Chinatown area. We found the people to most accommodating and very friendly. We experienced some food, well for Richard (barbecued pork buns) a lot of food, and enjoyed our experience immensely.…

    • 3929 Words
    • 16 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    Back when I was in Kweilin, people did not think about the fancy cars that make the putt-putt-putt sound or the mortgage on their house. Their worst troubles were their children’s moans of hunger. Most people only dreamed of their next meal. Everybody had humility, all these Chinese people bound under the same problems, all of them having to work hard. Even though they were so different, they learned to cooperate and work together.…

    • 1448 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Saboteur

    • 832 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The setting of a story has a ponderous influence on our perception as it often justifies a character's behavior. The story takes place in Muji city, China. This place maybe is a beautiful place, because Mr. Chiu and his bride select this place for spending their honeymoon. Time seems around 1980s, "the Cultural Revolution was over already and recently the party had been propagating the idea that all citizens are equal before the law."(P635). The concrete statue of Chairman Mao is located in the middle of a square before Muji train station. Experienced the Culture Revolution, people’s opinion of morality has a great changed. Mr. Chiu eager to get justice, but he suffered unjustified treatment. Let we see how Mr. Chiu’s character changed. Finally he became a “saboteur”.…

    • 832 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Art History 21

    • 1744 Words
    • 7 Pages

    The impact of the camera, invented shortly before the mid-19th century, was revolutionary. The camera was a revolution of visible objects and, among other uses, became a very useful tool for recording. People became intrigued with the ease of capturing the moment and the accuracy these images could provide. The middle class especially welcomed the modern form of art because it cost less. Photography was a significant accomplishment that changed the public’s perceptions of ‘reality’.…

    • 1744 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Robert Frank, a Jewish photographer, was born in Switzerland. He plays an important role in the photography field because of his most famous work The Americans, which was published in 1958. His unique and fresh outsider’s view of American society received criticism in the U.S when the book first came out. The reason is that the Frank’s photographs are unlike other photographic essays, which portray Americans in a positive way instead it demonstrates the idea of Americans by taking the violent and desolated photos. Criticism aside, in order to make a fair judgment, we will analyze specifically the photos from the Frank exhibit, at the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York. The exhibition features all 83 photos picked by Frank from the 28,000 shots, which he took during a road trip between 1955 and 1956. The work is divided into four sections. The first section shows different comparisons such as politicians to civilians, White to blacl,and rich to poor. The first photo in the first section titled “Parade—Hoboken, New Jersey” shows two windows: above them is an American flag and two women look out from the window. It is definitely not showing a parade, but rather Frank ironically portrays the idea of sadness and isolation. In the second section, Frank is more focused on the social and economical inequality. For example, the photograph in the second section titled “Trolley— New Orleans” shows the passengers in the…

    • 850 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    According to Understanding Global Issues (UGI), advanced telecommunications and transportation systems have made the planet shrink and weakened the barriers between different nations (UGI, 2008). Meanwhile, Eastern culture has gained opportunities to communicate with Western culture, which has triggered mutual integration and transformation between these cultures. Culture globalization has had a wide influence on many aspects of modern China. One significant effect of this is individualism which has been brought to China by the West. This spread of individualism is a topic of controversy in China. Although a considerable amount of prejudice and fear surrounds the notion, it has made a contribution to the liberation of personality, especially in China’s younger generation. In this essay the plight of individualism in China will be argued in the first part; then, the second part will focus on the negative effect of individualism on Chinese certain groups, such as the older generation; finally, in order to identify the effect of individualism in practice, this essay will critically evaluate the dramatic changes of China’s younger generation.…

    • 1616 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In The Contemporary Chinese Dictionary(1997), People who just care about themselves put individual interests above collective interests and that is a wrong thought, which means some people only mind his own business instead of other people’s feeling. The pattern of Chinese culture focuses on inner world and embodies in introspection and wisdom. Nevertheless, American culture keeps a watchful eye on outside world. Only in this way, they can express their feeling outwardly. American life also shows the epitome of driving force in these modern societies(Adams, 1938). It advocates each person should have rights to acquire maximum property (Yuan Yan, 2001). Wang Jintang (1997), who ever compiled the famous…

    • 3846 Words
    • 16 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    The concept of creativity differs between the Western and the Asian societies. Study by Niu and Sternberg (2006) compares the development of conceptions of creativity between the East and West. Both ancient Westerners and Chinese conceptualised creativity having the feature of goodness, including moral goodness. However, the Chinese further extend such goodness to the contribution to the whole society. Such extension is largely influenced by Confucianism, whereby filial piety and family is the fundamental building block of a society. In Western society, it is loosely-organised and the focus is on the development of personal self where the emphasis is on democratic and open exchange of ideas. In Asian society, it is tightly organised and the focus is on social face where the emphasis is on social order and harmony. Therefore, Western society tends to be individualistic and Asian society tends to be collectivistic.…

    • 1050 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    China Reflections

    • 1674 Words
    • 7 Pages

    In this paper I try to capture not only the planned itinerary of industry visits, but also all that I absorbed in the two cities, Shanghai, and Hangzhou – the people and my walks in the evening, the smells and food, billboards and the weather, and my adventures into back alleys haggling with Chinese people over the calculator while I buy faux designer brands. Before delving deeper, I would like to state that my humble observations in this paper are merely reflective of a visitor trying to soak in an entire country and its various cultures in a short period of one week, and so some portions may be biased, naïve or even totally oblivious to the actualities of a country as historic, vast, vigorous, beautiful, and ambitious as China.…

    • 1674 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays