To me as a speaker of the English language, both descriptive and prescriptive grammars are useful.
Descriptive grammar generally advises us not to be overly concerned with matters of correctness; language they say, is not good or bad; it simply is. As the English language is a living system of communication, within a generation or two, words and phrases come into fashion and fall out again. Over centuries, word endings and entire sentence structures can change or disappear.
Descriptive grammar is different from prescriptive grammar in that descriptive rules are never taught to native speakers of a language and often do not correspond to the prescriptive rules taught at schools. Hence, there may be differences from style to style and dialect to dialect.
Descriptive rules allow for different varieties of a language; and accept the patterns a speaker actually uses and tries to account for them as long as consistency is maintained and accepted by his community. As such, in descriptive grammar, the rules are less organised and informal. As such, a native speaker can just speak his mind without worrying about whether the language used is bad or good, so long as the message intended for the receiver is achieved.
Prescriptive grammar on the other hand deals with what the grammarian believes to be right and wrong; good or bad language use. Prescriptive rules of grammar prescribe a standard of usage and this standard English, a sociolinguist would term as high language.
Prescriptive grammar has specific rules which serve to mould spoken and written English to some standard form. Thus, prescriptive rules are taught in schools by teachers to students in the standard form of English. This form is also known as formal English which is used in academic writing, and when a speaker gives a speech to an audience, or a lecturer lectures his class. When a speaker of the English language wants to speak politely or very carefully to another, he also needs to use this standard form.
Prescriptive grammar have rules that strict grammarians have laid out for English speakers to follow and without a doubt, there are many. Prescriptive rules emphasise correctness in sentence structures, past and present tenses etc.
Some examples of prescriptive rules are: a) ‘’Shall” to be used for first person (“I” or “we”). We use “will” with second or third persons (“you”, “he”, “she”, “it” and “they”).
RIGHT: I shall be home tomorrow
WRONG: I will be home tomorrow b) Never use “not” with “hardly, scarcely, neither, never, none, no one, nobody or nothing” as these words when combined, will form a double negative, which is incorrect in English.
RIGHT: I can hardly learn to sew
WRONG: I can’t hardly learn to sew c) Never end a sentence with a preposition.
RIGHT: From where did Miss Lim come?
WRONG: Where did Miss Lim come from?
Prescriptive and descriptive grammars are often seen as opposites, in the sense that one declares how language should be while the other declares how language is. But they can also be complementary, and usually exist in dynamic tension. Many commentators on language show elements of both prescriptive and descriptive in their thinking, and popular debate on language issues frequently revolves around the question of how to balance these.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
**What is the difference between grammar and style? In addition to detailing that difference between grammar and style, please use at least four examples (2 of style, 2 for style) to illustrate your response.…
- 546 Words
- 3 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
The passage I have chosen is from Chapter 5, book 1, which takes place at a wine shop. Dickens is using this passage to explain the recent event that has taken place; crowds of people gather in front of the wine shop, and actually scoop up the wine for themselves from the broken cask. That shows the readers that these peasants are in physical hunger and are that desperate for food, showing that France isn’t in good shape. Once all the wine is gone all that is left over is the stains of the red wine on the street, the peoples hands, faces and feet. Dickens is foreshadowing the blood that will be left there in later years during the revolution. Like I stated before Dickens is showing the peasants hunger, but I think he is showing the physical hunger and the hunger the peasants have for justice and that they want freedom from the misery they’re in, therefore I feel he is also foreshadowing that the peasants are going to revolt and that they’re will be some kind of revolution. When Dickens says “the wine was red wine”, it is symbolic in a way of showing the sense of revolution, because the peasants dressed themselves in the color red while revolting, but also the fact that red is symbolic by symbolizing the blood of all the peasants and people of France that will die in the fight for what they believe in. I also believe when Dickens closes this passage with the words wine-lees blood he is trying to say that although at that moment its just wine, eventually lives are taken and it turns into real blood, and that the blood will stain the streets of France, leaving a reminder of this terrible…
- 307 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Kimberly Tan, the Author of “Why Do We Care About Grammar?” explains the usage and value of grammar. Tan states in her opinion about grammar that “people need to realize that grammar is there for the sole purpose of clarity and that it has no value outside of what it attempts to convey” (Tan). Tan argues that grammar should not have a set of concrete rules and that grammar is not the important part in the end, it is the content that is being expressed that truly matters. I personally agree with what Tan has said about grammar. Grammar should be used more so for clarification when writing an essay, we should be focusing more on the meaning of the essay than grammar.…
- 560 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Someone can go from having everything to nothing, in a blink of an eye. Having everything that was needed and desired to having nothing can really change the way people act and function. In this world there are two types of people, people that have to work for their necessities and people that just get handed what they want. But what happens when it all gets taken away from one mistake? A tragic hero is a great or virtuous character in a dramatic tragedy that is destined for downfall. In the play Oedipus the King, written by Sophacles, the main character is a tragic hero by displaying error in judgement, excessive pride, and reversal of fortune.…
- 610 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The use of appropriate spoken and written grammar is essential for a teacher so as we don’t offend some parents by making them appear or feel inferior or as if they are incapable or “beneath” us. Spoken and written grammar also allows the teacher to expand a student’s written and spoken vocabulary. Allowing parents and students to feel comfortable to question when they might misunderstand also allows them a greater understanding of individual expectations, educational expectations, and allows a “comfort zone” to understand everything more clearly. When teachers understand behavior and emotional constraints tensions ease, communication becomes clearer and everyone is more satisfied.…
- 294 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Last but not least, tremendous details are included in the grammar. People need pay close attention to clauses, phrases, words, and punctuations in order to be free from grammar mistakes. Therefore, good grammar does demonstrate the personality of detail-orientation. In…
- 357 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Prescriptivism argues the bias opinion on how some people think the English language should be used. It would make sense for people to use completely proper grammar, but that’s not how language has ever worked, right? These unwavering hard heads are the grammar Nazis, the annoying boys or girls in your classes that seem to always have the politically correct answer (class kiss-asses), or as Davis Foster…
- 1259 Words
- 6 Pages
Good Essays -
The authors of “Analyzing English Grammar “ are Tomas P. Klammer, Muriel R. Schulz and Angela Della Volpe. The main purpose of this book is to help users from various backgrounds to learn the grammatical rules of English using different teaching methods. This book consists of twelve chapters and an appendix as well as preface, glossary and an index. In the preface, authors discuss the materials included in this book, organization of the topics and the purpose of contents. The next two chapters touch to the points such as the meaning and types of grammar; moreover, they address…
- 1148 Words
- 4 Pages
Better Essays -
When you are unable to express yourself in an articulate way, you hurt your future. When you get to around middle school, teachers start cracking down on grammar. If you were never taught proper grammar before that time, then you are in trouble. When you get into high school, proper grammar allows you to set yourself apart from those who don’t use articulate speech. According to Chron, “grammar makes an impression”. Past high school when you apply for a job, grammar will set you apart as a better candidate. Correctly applying syntax will make you more likely to succeed at a job.…
- 456 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
This paper reviews some of the theories and research which fuel ‘the great grammar debate’ regarding first language acquisition and second language teaching and learning . It will analyse how these theories have influenced governement policies, school curricula and teaching approaches in the past decades and what is the place of grammar within the current teaching of the modern foreign language (MFL), to finally explain how these researches have been informing my own teaching practice.…
- 6976 Words
- 24 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Contrary to my preference for application, I was intrigued by Constance Weaver’s discussion of the arguments for and against the formal teaching of grammar, citing the contradictory research conclusions reached by Margaret Kolln and George Hillocks. While Hillocks seems to totally abandon the idea that grammar instruction can improve student writing, while Kolln questions the validity of some of the research prior…
- 656 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Change is inevitable. For example, take a newborn baby. A baby can wiggle, cry, eat, and excrete. Over time, the baby will grow to develop the powers to think, feel, do, and be. From the moment of birth, the child’s ability to live, act, and experience the world will rapidly increase. The parents of this child will watch him or her grow and evolve through every step. Raising a child is scary due to all the opportunities for mistakes, but one must let go of fear and accept the prospect of creating a unique life. What is correct and what is not correct is ultimately only a matter of what is accepted by society, for language is a matter of conventions within society. The key to change is to let go of all fear, because just like life, nothing in language is set in stone. In the world of grammarians there are two competing camps: descriptivists (naturalists) and prescriptivists (traditionalists). The difference between the two is well explained in a quote from Edward Finegan of the University of Southern California. Finegan says, “Descriptive grammarians ask the question, ‘What is English (or another language) like- what are its forms and how to they function in various situations?’ By contrast, prescriptive grammarians ask, ‘What should English be like- what forms should people use and what functions should they serve?’” (pbs.org) THESIS/ FOCUS…
- 830 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Being able to communicate effectively in the workplace is a key time management skill which can help ensure messages are delivered and received promptly with proper understanding of the content. Good grammar affects how others feel about and respond to each other, which carries great importance in the business world. Making an impression on clients and colleagues through the use of proper grammar can help maintain professionalism. Grammatically incorrect documents could spell disaster for a company where the information is false or misleading. Individuals who use good grammar are more likely to succeed at their jobs, showing a level of professional competency.…
- 202 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
The role of grammar in linguistics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ... . . . . . .…
- 14427 Words
- 58 Pages
Best Essays -
Syntax looks at the rules of a language, particularly how the various parts of sentences go together. While similar to morphology, which looks at how the smallest meaningful linguistic units, called morphemes, are formed into complete words, syntax examines how fully formed words fit together to create…
- 1298 Words
- 6 Pages
Powerful Essays