Preview

Detective Fiction Conventions

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1590 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Detective Fiction Conventions
The genre of detective fiction is one that has changed significantly since its beginning during the Victorian era, with the scale of the crimes being committed on a larger scale nowadays and also the methods of solving crimes used by detectives. I will argue today that:
“Fictional detectives that star in films and stories in the genre of detective fiction have changed dramatically in terms of their appearance and their role. Nowadays detectives can be anything from an investigative journalist to an FBI agent. But when analyzed in detail, it can be proven that the traits of fictional detectives have not changed much at all.”

1. Overview of plot
Today I will be investigating the film Prisoners through context and techniques, and also drawing
…show more content…
This film is a detective fiction story as it focuses on the individuals involved in the crime, rather than the action. The gathering of evidence and red herrings are present in the film, allowing it to fall under the clue puzzler sub-genre. Human endurance and courage are repeatedly tested in tight/frightening places, allowing it to fall under the psycho thriller sub-genre, making it tense and apprehensive experience for the audience. The story is as formulaic as an Agatha Christie ‘Who dunnit’, this is fulfilled by the constant question being asked toward the audience “who did it”. Throughout the film, you are never sure if Alex is the correct suspect, asking yourself if justice is being served by Keller holding him hostage. The genre of detective fiction is very popular these days, as they appeal to most people due to their ability to excite and puzzle audiences. The film prisoners is ranked amongst some of the top detective fiction movies of the modern era, with its ability to connect with the audience through its plot and …show more content…
But when it comes to core values and traits, the two are very similar. I have put together a Venn diagram displaying differences and similarities in traits between the two. As you can see, both detectives share more traits than they do differ. Observance is one that is very evident when analyzing the two detectives. Sherlock shows this by always being able to quickly read a situation and come up with a theory that explains, for example, he notices little things in characters such as twitches, stains on clothing and small scars or pigments. On the other hand, detective Loki shows observance through his analyzation of evidence. SHOW CLIP. In this clip, you will notice Loki’s methods of Interrogation and his ability to notice small things that lead to huge clues in solving the case. You would of all hopefully noticed how he interrogated the man, using laughter to implant a false sense of security into the suspect. Also, Loki noticed days prior to the interrogation that the suspect was buying children’s clothes, which also goes to show that he is an observant

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    the puzzle game

    • 500 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The puzzle game is a short story written by Patricia D. Maida and Nicholas B Spornick. This short story explains the reasoning behind almost all detective stories. The puzzle game demonstrates how all detective stories follow a “puzzle tradition” that produce the reader with intrigue and intellectual stimulation. The puzzle games found in detective stories operate on multiple levels with varying complexities derived by an ingenious author. These games follow many variations and rules, but will never allow you to fully comprehend who the victim, the murder, and sometimes even who the sleuth is in the story. Two fascinating detective stories that follow the format of the puzzle game are “Silver Blaze” by Conan Doyle, and “The mysterious Affair” bye Christies.…

    • 500 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Humans crave a mystery. We are curious beings and gravitate toward the unknown. Patterson uses this psychological fact to his advantage. The criminals that star in his New York Time’s Bestsellers are often vaguely portrayed, to the point where their identities remain unknown to the reader. This caricature description keeps the reader thinking. It is like being given a wrapped gift: One can see the shape of the present but not the physical contents. This…

    • 804 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The structure, the order parts of the documentary are presented determine how prisoners are constructed by the viewer. In Music and Murder Vernon, Geoffrey and Daniel are all constructed in the same way and overall the documentary works to…

    • 875 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Christy Hong – Is The Life and Crimes of Harry Lavender a typical detective genre?…

    • 2849 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    [Introduction] Television crime and courtroom dramas have advanced in many aspects from the 1960’s through present day; visually and verbally. According to The Fifties Web, “Top ratings in the 1960’s,” Raymond Burr’s Perry Mason was one of the top ranked crime dramas in 1961 and 62. In today’s era Law and Order SVU is among the favorites. Law and Order SVU and Perry Mason are both hour long crime dramas that investigate crimes in one segment of the program and shed light on the courtroom drama in the remaining part of the show. The major difference in each is how the suspects are apprehended. Perry Mason exercises high dialogue and Law and Order SVU is more visual and action packed. As noted in “Excessive Style,” “American mass-market television underwent an uneven shift in the conceptual and ideological paradigms that governed its look and presentational demeanor in the 1980s.” “By the 1990’s television in the later years, became more ideological than just a form of escapism.” (Caldwell, p. 651) The way in which criminals are apprehended in these crime dramas depicts a closer relation to the evolution of real life. From the video tape of Rodney King to the fall of the Rampart Division, police officers over time have advanced more toward violence and major manipulation, i.e. corruption. [Thesis] The evolution of change within the structure of crime-courtroom dramas with the comparison of Perry Mason in the 60’s and Law and Order SVU in the present day can be a result of the real life changes in society. Perry Mason is a crime drama with high dialogue, less violence and minor manipulation, while Law and Order entangles a web of violence and police coercion that sometimes crosses the line to apprehend their suspects.…

    • 1682 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Who does not enjoy a good mystery story? Popular literature abounds with examples, raging from the controversial work of Dan Brown to the horrific work of Stephen King. This genre, rooted in the Victorian tradition of Edgar Allan Poe, Wilkie Collins and Arthur Conan Doyle, certainly has a wide following. On the beach, on the subway, people escape into the worlds of these authors. Although many female writers claim to be the “Queen of Crime Fiction”, it is really Agatha Christie against whom all others are measured. Even many years after her death, readers appreciate Agatha Christie’s novels because of her strong characters, her interesting setting and her strong morality.…

    • 669 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A: The organizational structure of the Pinkerton National Detective Agency, found in 1850 by Allan Pinkerton and the first of its kind in the US, was later adopted by the FBI. As with the Pinkerton Agency, the FBI began to take on cases that local law enforcement were too limited in resources to handle on their own. In addition, Pinkerton created what was called “the rogues’ gallery” which detailed the names and operations of known criminals and their associates. During the European Industrial Revolution, thief catchers (now known as informants, snitches, and a variety of other names) were hired to help law enforcement catch criminals, a practice which is obviously still in use today. In addition, thief catchers were also criminals in their own right, which made it easier to infiltrate the targeted criminals. In eighteenth century Paris, a personal identification system, known as the Bertillon System, became the first system based on the idea that human characteristics such skeleton size and eye color were the same throughout a person’s life. In the mid eighteenth century, the study of fingerprints became a popular way to identify crime suspects. They did not learn until the turn of the century that each person’s fingerprints were unique and could not be changed. Scotland yard, founded in the early eighteenth century, was the model that the FBI modeled itself after initially. All of these are examples in which criminal investigations of today have been influenced, directly and indirectly, by the past and the progress that has been made in the time that has gone by since then.…

    • 1581 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Harry Lavender Essay

    • 683 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The protagonist, detective, Claudia Valentine’s voice is largely in first person narrative ‘I woke up feeling like death’ metaphorically alluding to her hangover from a night’s drinking. Dey’s unique style of crime writing lies in her deception of her audience into believing that the distinctive…

    • 683 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    for the good of humanity or just the good of one's loved ones every hero has a cause. Sherlock Holmes seems like an obvious hero but he doesn't really care about saving or protecting people. It seems the only thing Sherlock cares about is working and solving the cases because it is fun for him to have a challenge. But Sherlock does seem to have an internal struggle whether to fight for good or to prove his intelligence according to the author of (sherlock character confessions by Raven Simmons). “Sherlock seems to be divided by the urge to defeat Moriarty because he is a criminal and it would simply be the right thing to do r to defeat Moriarty simply to win a challenge made against his intelligence; basically, as a battle of wits”. So it seems that there may be some kind of good conscience inside of this man. Even though he is a kind of strange man that keeps to himself he does try to help others though it may seem he has selfish reasons for helping. I believe that he is a true hero when you hear someone talk about the great Sherlock Holmes you think of a mysterious british man with quick wits that fights crime for good. He is an iconic hero in british literature that everyone…

    • 886 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Psychic Passion

    • 962 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Detective Stephens is a small town cop trying to make it in the big city of Birmingham, Alabama. He is haunted by his past and suffering accordingly. His wife left him, his kids hate him, and he struggles with a crippling urge to drink. To help cope with these urges, he phones Andrew Morris, who soothes him and feeds him generic psychic dribble: “…I see a change in professions… your soul is afflicted with variant emotions of the past… keep life simple and take a chance on love” (22), and initially doesn’t want to give him any information pertaining to the gruesome murder case he is feverishly working on with his hated partner, Adams. Morris reluctantly admits that it is the work of a serial killer, affirming Stephens growing suspicion. Little does Stephens know, Morris’s reluctance to discuss the case is just a ruse, the beginning of his conniving plan to manipulate Detective Stephens.…

    • 962 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Successful crime writer's know how to realise their intentions of keeping the responder's mind constantly busy trying to work out ‘who dunnit', often feeling as though they are working side by side with the detective to solve the crime and find the murderer. As well as effective characterisation, character motivation, and settings, crime writers must know the conventions of their chosen sub genre and more importantly how to use and subvert these conventions to achieve their intended purpose. To emphasis the timeless nature of crime fiction we can take a look at two film texts that exemplify how older texts can still entertain modern audiences as much as today's fast-paced modern texts do. Alfred Hitchcock's film…

    • 1469 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Conventions shape a text and are adopted to suit a specific audience or contextual purpose. The genre of crime writing covers a wide diversity of texts that through the composer’s contextual influences and intentions conform to or subvert the archetypal crime writing conventions and themes such as the investigation of a crime and the associated social and moral issues involved. ‘Rear Window’ a highly cinematically geared 1954 film by Alfred Hitchcock, ‘Anil’s…

    • 1460 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Due to the fact that true crime involves real people who have suffered horrible tragedies, writing about it is a delicate undertaking--even more so when the crime is unsolved; a situation which prevents the victims or their families from obtaining closure and propagates fear throughout the local community. At the same time, however; the very mystery which causes so much harm to those close to the tragedy in question, is what draws outsiders to it. People immerse themselves in the puzzle of it all, becoming both fascinated and frustrated by the case. It is no wonder then, that personal narratives of people immersing themselves in unsolved cases are so popular. The shared experience between the author and reader, makes for a story which is doubly captivating. A captivated audience is one easily influenced however, and the author’s persona and own attitude toward the case, influencing so many, may have far reaching…

    • 1180 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Crime fiction writing is a response to specific social and cultural conditions within its writer’s context. The lasting popularity and relevance of Crime writing can be credited to the ‘flexibility’ of the genre as it is able to change and explore aspects of crime and individuals therefore can communicate the messages of the contexts and values of many societies and cultures to readers. Through the analysis of P.D.…

    • 1363 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The two malevolent murderers share a time period, and as an effect, their social climate. As Jack the Ripper’s crimes were introduced to the public by the media, the general public became obsessed with his gruesome tales. Mystery authors such as Sir Conan Doyle preyed on this new interest and…

    • 671 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics