Preview

Did the Catholic Church Hinder Italian Unity

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
405 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Did the Catholic Church Hinder Italian Unity
How far do you agree that the Catholic Church significantly hindered Italian unity in the years to 1870?
To a very far extent the Catholic Church did hinder Italian unity as the church was generally a reactionary body as it opposed to new ideas especially, Italian unification. Such as when Pope Pius IX asked the French army to defeat the Roman Republic in 1848. Also the Catholic Church made it forbidden in science to say the Earth travelled around the sun. However the Catholic Church does show little evidence of not hindering unification. Such as in 1846-7, Pope Pius IX appeared to be Liberal and freed 2000 political prisoners who were mostly revolutionaries.
To some extent there is evidence that Pope Pius IX did not hinder the unification but actually showed evidence of liberalism. In 1846 with the election of a new pop, Pius IX was believed to have liberal sympathies. E.g. he freed 2000 political prisoners, mostly revolutionaries. He reformed education, the law and papal administration and he gave laymen a greater share in public affairs. He also ended press censorship, allowed Jews out of the ghetto, granted Rome a constitution to replace absolute papal rule and created the Consulta, an elected body to advise the Pope. His strong evidence of liberalism encouraged nationalist and liberals, such as Piedmont and Tuscany in 1848 both reduced censorship and gave more liberal constitutions. Also the pope had seemed to be anti-Austrian as in 1848 when the Pope forbade Austrian troops from entering the Papal states.
The Catholic Church shows to a great extent of evidence of hindering unification. In 1848 revolutions, attitudes of Pope Pius IX had changed from liberal to reactionary. E.g. the 1848 Papal Allocution. This condemned Italian nationalists, rejected the Risorgimento and refused to use Papal troops to fight against Austria. This ended dreams of neo-Guelph’s such as Gioberti who had envisaged a Confederation of states with the Pope as leader. In 1849, the

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    The extent to which the papacy asserted dominance over the Western Church has been greatly disputed amongst historians. Certain historians would argue that there is little to suggest that the pope had control from inside other than papal reform to prevent unrest and, would argue that in fact the real conflict was between him and individual states and that he had to deal with multiple reforms and claims that failed. However, there are Historians who would suggest that, in fact, the papacy was successful in asserting its authority over the Western Church due to the religious significance of the Pope’s position which on occasions caused individual kings to submit to his power. Furthermore, it can be argued that although the Pope was the figure head of the Church and had power, he had to rely on the support and co-operation of Kings if he was to be able to keep control over the Western Church and therefore it could be said that he was not as dominant as one would think.…

    • 2243 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Ap Euro Dbq Essay

    • 1105 Words
    • 5 Pages

    o Around 1858, Cavour unites Italy under the Piedmontese king, lessening the power of the Catholic pope…

    • 1105 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Assessments chapter 9

    • 529 Words
    • 2 Pages

    As the Italian states grew wealthier, the power of the Church began to decline slightly.…

    • 529 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The northern and Italian renaissance profoundly affected the reformation because of the several key factors that influenced and prompted it, the powerful nonconforming people whose ideas opposed the Church’s practice, the Catholic Church abuse that caused speculation and criticism amongst the people, and Gutenberg’s printing press.…

    • 239 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    i.The Concordat of Bologna established a papal monarchy, establishing Catholicism as the state religion. This led to numerous conflicts between the Catholic population and the Huguenot population of Protestant Calvinists.…

    • 950 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Susan Muthan1

    • 427 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Though some wanted to stick to tradition, there were some important and influential people who encouraged the unification. Giuseppe Mazzini, attorney, believed that Italy deserved to be a nation and it was about time all the parts of the monarchy to be part of one big republic in unification. Along with Mazzini, Carlo Cattaneo, philosopher and political activist, also believed in the unification of this monarchy would be a right step for Italy. He said that even though it would mix them, it won’t take their culture and traditions off the grid like they believed, but instead, they would all be appreciated and remembered. Vincenzo Gioberti, a priest of Piedmont stated that the unification would actually make the kings stronger without damaging their own independence.…

    • 427 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    In the textbook, The Western Experience, Mortimer Chambers states, “Although the culmination of these disruptions did not come until the Reformation in the 1500s, the history of the previous two centuries made it clear that the institution was profoundly troubled” (Chambers 347). The Avignon Exile, in which the center of power of the Papacy moved from its historic home in Rome to the French city of Avignon undermined the institution’s legitimacy. Several successive Popes stated that, at the time, the Papacy could not be effectively controlled in Rome, even though they expressed desire to return, showcasing administrative weakness (Chambers 347). Seven months after the return of the Pope to Rome, a second Pope was named, prompting the Great Schism. Although the Council of Pisa succeeded in ending this conflict, there were still long-term consequences. Chambers argues that the Papacy’s close association with Italian politics degraded its universal appeal, particularly in Northern nations, “undermining the centrality of the papacy to the life of Europe” (Chambers 349). The political and cultural influence that the Papacy previously experienced all across Europe had eroded away. Most telling is that nations such as England, France, and Spain issued decrees limiting the Church’s authority in their territory. Chambers notes that these acts clearly, “document the decline of papal control over the international Christian community” (Chambers…

    • 1498 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    3. Charles V attempted to unify Europe but it was such a difficult task for him that he eventually quit. His attempt at unification was unsuccessful because of reasons including an increase in royal authority and limiting the power of the Church. Countries such as England and France were also beginning to develop politically centralized states and religious unity. Interfering with their states especially if they were growing so fast would be unsuccessful because his attempt to unify them would be ignored.…

    • 885 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The unification of both Germany and Italy brought great change in these countries. This process resulted in these countries to focus on for their independence, economic growth, and a strong nationalism. Also, there is another role of the unification and it is an occurrence of war, separation and controlling politics. War is a natural force which leads to unite some nations as wells as divide others. In the unification process, it is essential to have a confident and courageous leader. Bismarck was a leader in Germany while Cavour was a leader in Italy. Bismarck’s ideas were based on the pure survival. He insisted to work hard in a forceful way thought it might be brutal, to unify the Germany and therefore he was recognized as “Bloddy Iron”. The leadership of Italy was primarily based on the political issues.…

    • 632 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Nationalism Dbq

    • 700 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Nationalism was a key factor in building nations. Throughout the years Italians were growing impatient and dissatisfied under foreign rule. Count Cavour was responsible for the brains behind the unification of Italy. He believed that releasing the Italians from foreign rule would not only leave the country authoritative and superb but also supply the people with intelligence and knowledge (Doc. 3). Italian Nationalists looked up to the Kingdom of Piedmont-Sardinia because of their power over the Italian states. In 1848, the kingdom had adopted a liberal constitution. So to the middle class liberals, unification under Piedmont Sardinia was appealing. Giuseppe Garibaldi, the leader of army of nationalists, captured Sicily. After marching across the Italian mainland their was an agreement to let the Sardinian king rule. Like Italy, Germany achieved national unity around the same time. The Austrian Empire took over the German confederation; however, Prussia was prepared to unify them. Prussia had a mainly German empire. Therefore, nationalism truly unified Prussia. When Bismarck took control, he was a master of realpolitik. Bismarck’s method for uniting Germany was through blood and iron (Doc 5). He believed that the power of Germany should be allocated over all German People. In his eyes, war was the only option to achieving success.…

    • 700 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Thirty Year's War

    • 2163 Words
    • 9 Pages

    The Holy Roman Empire had been a strong national entity since the latest 900’s where the First emperor, Ottoman 1 took power. Through marriages, treaties and alliances the empire grew to encompass Germany, Italy, Austria, Hungary, and many other European nations. At the height of the empire a tragedy for its well being occurred. Martin Luther and other religious thinkers insinuated the Protestant Reformation. This tore the Empire apart and forced it to break it’s Spanish ties with King Phillip with its Austrian and Habsburg ties with Ferdinand II. The peace of Augsburg concluded this stage of the religious wars, it destroyed the hopes of a fully Catholic Europe from ever returning. The Peace of Augsburg of 1555 had brought a temporary truce…

    • 2163 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    It was a significant development in the Catholic Church as it ended the religious unity between Europe and formed the many…

    • 1536 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Religion was a vital part of Italian society in the earlier 20th Century, Mussolini himself said that the Pope “represented 400 million people scattered (throughout) the world”. This meant that the pope and religion posed a massive influence on Mussolini’s rule and exercised a lot of power on all classes. Mussolini himself was atheist like his father and believed that science was made to prove religion wrong and that Jesus was a madman who had been mistakenly taken for a prophet, however publicly he relied on his image as a deeply religious man who prayed several times a day and who had a Catholic marriage and sent three of his children to communion. Over all Mussolini used religion as a political tool to ensure that he remained in power by appeasing to the population while also using it to appease to Italy’s allies by its racial policy.…

    • 1124 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    This event changed papal monarchy by regulating the Pope's power by use of a general council. Once these heresies were accepted by followers, Europe was then divided for years due to the various issues between the two churches.3…

    • 593 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The Great Schism Essay

    • 1305 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The Reformation was brought about during the sixteenth century mainly because of the strength of these forces. Effective complaints of the clergy had stemmed from a wide variety of sources, and the supreme power of the papacy was strongly challenged by the Conciliar Movement. The disapprovals increased significantly, and the spiritual leadership of the church continued to decline rapidly. The concerns of the popes during the fourteenth and fifteenth centuries were nothing but worldly, which included their profound association in the political life of Italians, further pushing the church away from all the religious concerns that needed attention. Alongside these external pressures which facilitated in the decline of the church, the increasing thought of exploration saw the emergence of a new outlook toward the division of the church. Furthermore, the invention of the printing press, provided a means for ideas to spread more quickly. From a socioeconomic point of view, the medieval church, in its adaptation to the new environment of the towns, was less effective. The church did not put the problems of the people at the forefront. Too many questions were left unanswered, which led to a failure in providing enough parish priests to keep up with the rapid growth of the urban population. This played a major part in several towns becoming centers of heresy. In conclusion, the encounters between the French ruler Phillip IV, and Boniface VIII resulted in the growth of nationalism and the increasing averseness of kings to obey any conflicting establishment, including the…

    • 1305 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays