Emma and Clueless, are two movies that illustrate Jane Austen's novel entitled "Emma". The stories illustrate the importance of self-development and personal growth by using the theme of social status and moral worth. The protagonists, Emma and Cher, are bound to transform from callow young adults to mentally and emotionally mature women, given their similar situations.
The major difference between Emma and Clueless is the way situations in the plot of the story are illustrated, and the different time frames used in the context. The setting of Emma is in nineteenth century England, while Clueless sets in Beverly Hills, U.S.A. in the 1990s.
Both Emma and Cher are young ladies of the rich, high-class society and cultural elite. Money is important for both societies, because money is synonymous to power and high social status. Because of their wealth, the protagonists are spoiled, and they encompass a sense of vanity, arrogance, and social superiority. Emma and Cher are supposedly the "epitome of perfection" of their time frame and setting. Emma appears to encompass the beauty, charm, grace, intelligence, and wealth of an ideal woman in nineteenth century England, and Cher has everything a teenage girl could possibly want: a car, a mansion, and an endless line of expensive clothing. And with all their wealth, they have acquired the idea that they are superior to others. Emma's arrogance is first seen when she brags about her skill in matching couples. Likewise, Cher exposes a sense of her pompousness when she and her best friend, Dionne, teach Tai how to be popular.
Emma and Cher's arrogance and self-confidence has challenged them to do things beyond the norm. They have taken two lower-class girls- Harriet and Tai- "under their wing" to assimilate with the upper-class society. Emma thinks that Harriet has been associated with "unworthy" people, and embarks on a mission to introduce her to the upper-class society. In Clueless, Cher takes pity on Tai and embarks on a mission to make Tai popular. In the process, Emma and Cher tried to match Harriet and Tai to men they considered of upper-class status. However, Harriet and Tai seemed to have been interested in men of lower class- Robert and Travis. Emma disregarded Robert Martin because he was a farmer who posed a threat in her mission to improve Harriet. Likewise, Cher disregarded Travis because he was a skater boy, which was considered of lower social status in high school. Emma and Cher forced Harriet and Tai to rethink their initial judgment of the two lower-class men. Harriet and Tai, naïve as they are, were brainwashed by the protagonists, and have eventually developed a certain fondness for the upper-class men who they were being linked to. However, the guys that Emma and Cher tried to match Harriet and Tai with, were actually in love with the two protagonists.
The stories take a new direction with the arrival of the characters Frank Churchill from Emma and Christian from Clueless. Emma and Cher instantly become infatuated with Frank and Christian. But nothing would come of this infatuation because Frank Churchill is found out to be engaged with another woman, and Christian is a homosexual. It is a humbling experience for the two protagonists because they have further realized that they can make wrong judgments about other people.
The characters of Mr. Knightly in Emma and Josh from Clueless, have been seen throughout the movie, but only towards the end, did they come to the foreground of the story. Mr. Knightly and Josh became the object of Harriet and Tai's latest infatuation. Through jealously, Emma and Cher begin to realize their love for Mr. Knightly and Josh, and the two men have also realized their love for Emma and Cher.
In the end, Mr. Knightly and Emma were married, and Josh and Cher became a couple. With Emma and Cher, being a little more open-minded about social issues, Harriet and Robert Martin reestablished their wandered love, and it was likewise for Travis and Tai.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
In observing Jane Austen's Emma and Amy Heckerling's Clueless we are able to compare the symbolical manifestations and realistic products of both Emma and Cher’s social environment. “Clueless” is a coming-of-age romantic comedy that reflects upon the values explored throughout “Emma” such as social class. Each of their social contexts is portrayed by the composers' differences and parallels of values. These values assist in confirming the social contexts within both texts. Emma Woodhouse is part of the rich, upscale society in 19th century England where her family is highly looked upon, while Cher Horowitz lives in the upscale Beverly Hills of California where Cher and her father are also viewed as the cultural elite.…
- 668 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Clueless, an adaptation of Jane Austen 's 1815 novel, Emma, is a 1995 American film by director, Amy Heckerling. The comedy serves as a 20th century update of the original text that shifts into creating a contemporary Emma, one for our own era. Though Clueless seems to set forth on building its reputation on a completely new, distinct ground, it is not an entirely different work of art. Considerable amounts of uniformities between the adaptation and Emma can be pinpointed throughout. As “Clueless is most faithful to Emma in its recreation of the plot involving Mr. Elton, Harriet Smith, and Emma” (Troost, Linda, and Greenfield 124), several parallels between the two distinctive texts, concerning this matter, can be recognized. One outstanding example is the correspondence and connection between the modern photography scene in Clueless and the sketching/painting of Harriet’s portrait in Emma. Hence, along with the novel’s highly persuasive guidance and the two’s so-called loose relation, various similarities as well as differences are inevitably present.…
- 1912 Words
- 8 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Parallels are drawn between the values and attitudes of post-modern and regency society in Emma 's carriage incident and Clueless ' car scene. In Emma, Mr Elton displays complete disgust and outrage at the notion of marrying the socially inferior Harriet, exclaiming 'Good heaven! What can be the meaning of this? ' This segregation and incompatibility of differing social classes is also portrayed in Clueless through Elton 's outburst of 'Don 't you even know who my father is? ' revealing the transcending importance of family background and social connections, and the superficiality within both societies.…
- 406 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
The 1990s have seen Jane Austin novels become more popular than ever. Hollywood, as is its custom, has followed suit, bringing to the screen several Oscar-nominated films faithfully based upon the author's works during that decade. Why would our modern society still be charmed by these novels, written by a woman who never married or even traveled outside England? How can these 200 year-old stories be relevant to our jaded culture? Probably because, despite all the radical social changes that have taken place since Jane Austen's time, people haven't really changed all that much. Heckerling’s film Clueless, an adaptation of Emma, shows that although society’s values have changed, the status quo still exists and is just as rigid nowadays as it was in the nineteenth century. However, because Clueless is set in a different time to Emma and because Heckerling uses a different medium to Austin, there are bound to be changes between the two texts.…
- 1054 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Yes, Amy Heckling’s 1995 movie, Clueless, can be related to the novel Emma, published in 1816. There is no doubt that Clueless substantially derives, and is adapted from Emma. However, apart from similarities, there are differences and adaptations from Emma to Clueless. These are necessary as a result of the disparity in values and attitudes between the early 19th century England of Emma and late 20th century America of Clueless. Adaptations are applied to characters, plot, and settings.…
- 1174 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
Both Emma and Clueless have almost identical values. Life for women during Emma was all about who you married, what family you came from and the amount of wealth you and your family had. Clueless highlights some of the values that Cher and her friends have, including who you go out with, the amount of money you had and could spend on items, and for Cher in particular the importance of family. The context of the novel and the film are completely different. Emma was written in the early 19th century by novelist Jane Austen and through the context the reader can understand what life was like for upper class women. Clueless was directed by Amy Heckerling set in the 1990s shows the “way normal life” for rich American teenagers.…
- 704 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Qualities of relationships have transformed through time along with values, the parallel worlds within postmodern Beverly Hills and Regency England display the contextual shifts brought forth. The bildungsroman novel Emma by Jane Austen exemplifies the strict values within Regency England society whilst Amy Heckerling’s film Clueless illustrates the transformation of these values within Beverly Hills. The values of social status and pride and vanity are explored through the inflexible Regency England society in comparison to the more fluid postmodern society of Beverly Hills. The use of various language and film techniques enhances the observation of the parallel values displayed within both contexts.…
- 1033 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Generally one would assume that our society has changed considerably since Jane Austen's times and I do not want to argue the opposite. In some ways, however, we are still concerned with similar problems. Especially coming of age is a topic which has not lost any of its currency. This can nicely be seen in the 1995 Hollywood remake of Jane Austen's Emma Clueless. Director Amy Heckerling transferred the story originally set in Highbury in Surrey of the early 19th century to Los Angeles of the 1990s. In the following I would like to compare Austen's novel with Heckerling's movie adaptation. Because of the limited length of this essay I shall mainly concentrate on the…
- 1333 Words
- 6 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Amy Heckerling transforms the many values and issues conveyed in Jane Austen’s Emma, set in the 18th century in Highbury to her teen pic film Clueless set in the 20th century, in a high school society. Both texts involve a protagonist, being Emma in Emma and Cher in Clueless who meddle with the relationships of others as their interest, while being “placed in the midst of those who loved her, and who had better sense than herself”. The protagonists are morally transformed towards the end of the film and novel when they slowly realise the error of their ways. The texts explore unchanged values while highlighting society changes through the transformation of values. Heckerling and Austen convey the values marriage, integrity versus wealth and social status through cinematography and writing techniques such as dialogue, characterisation and stereotyping.…
- 884 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Clueless sustains interest in the patriarchal values and social stratum of Emma by manipulating the mediums for relaying information to the audience and allow them to resonate with the messages portrayed by Austen. The teenpic Clueless (1995) directed by Amy Hecklering employs the materialistic world of LA to make a multi-layered social commentary about the patriarchal values and social strata elucidated in Jane Austen’s 19th Century novel, Emma. Hecklering draws parallels to the rigid social hierarchy of the Regency period and the role of women in a patriarchal society with issues pertaining to female power and control, present in Emma. In order to sustain interest Hecklering has transformed aspects of the mediums portraying the themes in the Regency Period novel Emma to allow the values represented to resonate with the modern audience of a materialistic era.…
- 1314 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
Through close analysis of the novel Emma, by Jane Austen and the film Clueless by Amy Heckerling, we discover that both texts are influenced by, and reflect the values of their respective contexts. Emma is set in the isolated, rural town of Highbury, England in the early 1800’s, at a time where society had placed value on social hierarchy. This distinction between classes was largely…
- 847 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Transformations often involve familiar themes but reflect those themes in a different context in order to resonate the values and interests of that society. Thus, context dictates form and meaning as well as the values inherent in the texts. Amy Heckerling’s, 20th century American film, Clueless is a transformation of Jane Austen’s conservative Regency England, Emma. The use of different techniques and medium allow Emma’s themes of personal growth, social structure and the role of women in society to be conveyed in a more appropriate form in Clueless.…
- 1106 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
The actions of Emma lead to the emotional pain that Harriet went though. She gave a poem to her from Mr. Elton, convincing herself and Harriet that it was a marriage proposal.(88) When Emma broke the new of Mr. Eltons true love to her, she was heartbroken. Harriet later got over the pain and found a new love. She confessed to Emma her love for Mr. Knightly.(471) Unfortunately for Harriet, Emma also loves Mr. Knightly. This is a dangerous situation for Emma because she does not want to hurt Harriet anymore than what she already had. Emma took the risk and told Harriet the truth of her heart. Again, Harriet’s emotions were hurt. (480)…
- 685 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Amy Heckerling’s Clueless sustains interest in the values represented in Jane Austen’s Emma by the modernization of the initial text through the medium of novel to film. Additionally, Heckerling transforms the ideas of marriage, social class and gender roles from Austen’s early Nineteenth century context, to a late twentieth century context through an examination of relationships, high school cliques and the changing notion of gender roles.…
- 1414 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Additionally, Emma enters college in Southern California and meets other African Americans she soon discovers that her skin color makes her unpopular. The men on campus identify her as “Hottentot” meaning a young woman who had pronounced African features. Likewise, she is rejected by society because her skin is not light enough. She moved to Harlem after college and there she seeks a new identity as a teacher. Emma Lou tries to make her skin lighter, and it didn’t succeed it made her look worst even when she appeals excessive make up on her face. She gets into a relationship with a guy named Filipino Mulatto. At first, everything was going well then it became an abusive relationship. In the end, she accepts herself as who she is and how she looked…
- 337 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays