Preview

Discuss The Role Of Groupthink In Civil Disobedience

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1514 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Discuss The Role Of Groupthink In Civil Disobedience
The experiment found that two-thirds of the people continued to the highest level of 450 volts (Mcleod, “Milgram”). The rest of the people still obeyed the orders of the authority, just to a lesser level. Apparent from the Stanley-Milgram Experiment, “People tend to obey orders from other people if they recognize their authority as morally right and/or legally based. This response to legitimate authority is learned in a variety of situations, for example in the family, school, and workplace” (Mcleod, “Milgram”). Hitler’s antics allowed him to be viewed as the higher authority from the legal aspect: Hitler established himself as the Chancellor of Germany, the highest power of Germany; consequently, he was able to implement the policies and …show more content…
The psychological term for this is groupthink, which is a subconscious occurence in the human mind. To propagate this idea, there is also the social pressure that is put on the individuals. Because of this, people would be too afraid to even question the grey area. With the apprehension lying on everyone’s mind, people began to think like each other as a means of survival. Consequently, it became hard for one voice to speak out and counter what the majority is saying, thereby solidifying his control. Hitler advanced this strategy by completely wiping those who disagreed with the Nazis. Those who remained continued to believe that what the Nazis were doing was immoral were convinced that they were alone and isolated (Kayla). Moreover, as many psychological experiments reveal, humans instinctively conform as a result of survival instincts. The urge to survive outweighs any morality in an acute situation, heightening the violent tendencies of each individual. Consequently, the group mentality changes as well due to the effects of mob mentality. As Dr. Sajid Surve wrote, “Le Bon posited that once individuals came together to form a group, the individual’s will was surrendered to what was perceived to be the will of the group. Their faculties of reasoning were impaired or destroyed, and …show more content…
If something is in black and white, and this will always lead to that, it is easier to shape a person’s thoughts and ideas (Brown). The either or statements also added to the sense of urgency that insinuated people to take action (Science). Hitler’s vicarious reinforcement is a form of strategic repetition; it is similar to the rewards and punishment system, but it is enforced through law and officials in order to establish it as a social norm (Brown). As time went on, “They understood, seeing the horrors of the concentration camps and deportations, that them and their families could easily be in that position if they spoke up against the Nazis. Nazi induced fear kept everything in their control for a very long time.” (Kayla). Other than just using laws, Hitler’s speeches also included trigger words with negative connotation to elicit that instant response in the crowd, like shouts and jeering (Science). To further this strategy, Hitler had a fixed schedule of persuasion. This is a psychological term that entails that behaviors are rewarded/punished every single time. The opposite of fixed schedule is an interval schedule: “...an interval schedule, and behaviors aren’t rewarded or punished every single time, then the behavior isn’t going to be conditioned as strongly, as effectively” (Brown). In Hitler’s case, every attempt at rebellion

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Most people would agree with doing something horrific to another person, since it is easier to conform, than to fight, people tend to protect themselves before protecting a stranger. Stanley Milgram put a study together to prove that Germans are more likely to be obedient to authority then American are. The study was called “If Hitler Asked You to Electrocute a Stranger, Would You? Probably.” Milgram explains the character aspects of why people listen to authority and why they afraid not to. Social structure and the organization of society have a powerful affect on people. Milgrams set out to New Haven to start the study ad later on planed to go to Germany to do the study on the society there.…

    • 453 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    All of this happened because people lost their sense of identity when in a group. Zimbardo did an experiment where he tested how people are led to violent behavior about “Four participants were led to believe they were overhearing the research assistant tell the experimenter that the students from another college were present to start the study in which they were to deliver electric shocks of varying intensity to the participants (according to the dictates of a reasonable cover story)”(Zimbardo 32). Zimbardo also has experimented with human behavior in his Stanford Prison Experiment. He set up an experiment where he took volunteers from Stanford University and randomly selected some to be prisoners and others to be guards. They acted as if they were actually in prison, but things got out of hand when the people that acted like guards became way too invested in their roles. They began to act violently and abuse the people who were acting like prisoners. Even though those guards and prisoners were normally good people, suddenly, the experiment changed them and made them behave differently in this powerful situation. Le Bon believes this can happen often. He said,“...having entirely lost his conscious personality, he obeys all the suggestions of the operator who has deprived him of it and commits acts in utter contradiction with his character…

    • 1535 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Milgram Obediance Study

    • 1318 Words
    • 6 Pages

    In May of 1962 Stanley Milgram, a Social Psychologist at Yale University, conducted a study on “Obedience and Human Nature” that was influenced by his curiosity of the WWII German Nazi Holocaust and concentration camps. Milgram asked “How could it be, that ordinary German people could allow the extermination of the Jews” and wanted to know under what circumstances would a person disobey authority?…

    • 1318 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    It is only natural to dismiss the idea of our own personal flaws, for who with a healthy sense of self wanders in thoughts of their own insufficiency? The idea of hypocrisy is one that strikes a sensitive nerve to most, and being labeled a hypocrite is something we all strive to avoid. Philip Meyer takes this emotion to the extreme by examining a study done by a social psychologist, Stanley Milgram, involving the effects of discipline. In the essay, "If Hitler Asked You to Electrocute a Stranger, Would You? Probably", Meyer takes a look at Milgram's study that mimics the execution of the Jews (among others) during World War II by placing a series of subjects under similar conditions of stress, authority, and obedience. The main theme of this experiment is giving subjects the impression that they are shocking an individual for incorrectly answering a list of questions, but perhaps more interesting is the results that occur from both ends of the research. Meyer's skill in this essay is using both the logical appeal of facts and statistics as well as the pathetic appeal to emotion to get inside the reader's mind in order to inform and dissuade us about our own unscrupulous actions.…

    • 1050 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Ap Psychology Unit 1 Summary

    • 2722 Words
    • 11 Pages

    - Group Pressure: how a group has influence over an individual to change their own beliefs and behaviour to fit in with the majority.…

    • 2722 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Because Hitler was good at brainwashing people like this. He could motivate anyone to do almost anything at that time because he promised them money.…

    • 815 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Looking back at the events that occurred during our history, particularly during World War II, many of the people often reflect back and ask the question, ‘Who let a man like Hitler come into power or what made the German people decide to follow him? The seeds of Hitler's rise to power were planted following the outcome of the First World War. Hitler’s rise to power was not inevitable. It depended heavily on a range of factors, events and circumstances.…

    • 1568 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Stanley Milgram is one of the leading researchers into the psychology of obedience. Rice et al (2008) and was interested why thousands of German soldiers blindly obeyed orders that resulted in the death of millions of Jewish people during World War II. However if a soldier is obeying orders from their superiors, then should responsibility for the consequences be held to those superiors? But evidence suggests that there was a mass willingness of tens of thousands of people to cooperate with the Nazi regime, even to the extent of shopping neighbours to the Gestapo. Rice et al (2008). The Allies saw the Germans as an authoritarian, militaristic and obedient nation. Suggesting an explanation for this extreme behaviour. Adorno et al (1950) claimed that it was the authoritarian personality that was responsible for the persecution of the Jews in Nazi Germany. Milgram was sceptical of this, believing that obedience was owed more to the situation than to the national character of a particular nation. So in the early 1960s Milgram conducted a series of experiments to support his theory.…

    • 1743 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    And in fact, many historians have been fairly comfortable to do so. But Christopher Browning’s account of the factors that encouraged regular Germans to take part in Hitler’s hideous plan reveals something of great importance where an event like the Holocaust is concerned. His Ordinary Men seeks to shift perspective away from the notion that those predisposed toward the behavior that perpetrated this greatest of human tragedies were inhuman and accustomed to operating in fashions more sociopathic than militarily appropriate. In doing so, he sets a sizable challenge for himself. Truly, there is no way to address why the German people participated in without elaborating upon some of the most unspeakable acts committed in modern history. To that end, Ordinary Men takes its readers through some difficult narratives that reveal brutal, amoral behaviors that would imply a society impoverished of intellectual, ethical or academic development to that point. Moreover, the base and vile nature of the war crimes committed against a people unprepared to defend themselves and presenting no legitimate antagonism to its aggressor, suggests that the German people themselves were inherently bad people, inclined toward acts of evil and…

    • 1712 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Milgram’s infamous 1963 study into the nature of obedience is often portrayed in the media as strong evidence for an innate human predisposition to obedience, “resistance is futile” (Parker, 2007) when it comes to the human condition to obey – even in a “destructive” (Milgram, 1963) sense. As Milgram (1963) himself states, obedience as a concept is one of the most fundamental aspects of society, and much has frequently been made of drawing parallels with the atrocities carried out by the Third Reich and the data produced by Milgram’s obedience studies [most notably the dramatic results of the baseline study (Haslam, 2012)]. The ideation is frequently asserted that Nazis themselves were displaying blind obedience (Debattista, 2012) to their superiors, and this blind obedience is what is captured in Milgram’s 1963 experiment, although this proposition must be questioned in lieu of a scientific analysis of Milgram’s actual works,…

    • 1215 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Another explanation to why people obey being this idea of Gradual commitment, which has a snowball effect of starting of small and therefore making it easier to progress to something more extreme. If we look back at Milgram’s experiment, all participants were started at the same, relatively harmless, 15 volt shock. The shock levels gradually increased in increments of 15 volts and did not become painful or dangerous until several shocks had been administered. However, had participants been asked to deliver one large shock initially, it is less likely that they would have done so, but the method of gradually increasing bit by bit made the previously unthinkable seem like just another step. The idea of gradual commitment could perhaps be applied to the actions carried out my Nazi soldiers, they began small: name calling, minor violent attacks, more serious attacks, then it grew more serious: murder and mass extermination. However Milgram’s study lacks ecological validity and can therefore not be used definitively as explanations for real life situations.…

    • 629 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    As the impact of World War One took its toll on Europe countries like Russia, Italy and Germany were in dire need of a change. Germany was most impacted by the war and was left in a state where everyday citizens were homeless, jobless, and starving. Looking for someone save Germany, Germans were in a desperate need for change and turned to group of radicals that were rising in power at a rapid rate known as the Nazis. Looking for someone to “save Germany” the Nazi’s unconventional but radical beliefs gave many Germans a strong sense of hope. “One of the reasons the Nazi ideology was so successful in eliciting support for the party and consensus behind its program was that its structure was built central concepts that, in the…

    • 3069 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    While propaganda not only led to discriminatory policies and violence, it also had a substantial psychological effect on its victims. On the side of ethnic Germans, propaganda played a pivotal role in reinforcing certain beliefs. For instance, it strengthened the idea of Aryan superiority, which boosted the perpetrator’s sense of entitlement and superiority over others. This feeling was one that was key in allowing an environment of anti-Semitic ideology to flourish. Propaganda was crucial in fostering psychological distance between perpetrators and their victims, making it easier for acts of violence to be carried out against Jews without empathy or guilt.…

    • 1685 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    This may be another reason Hitler was able to convince the jealous Germans to repel those who were different. Literature also helps us see that the Holocaust affected everyone, even those living after it. Mary Helen Dirkx was teen who grew up when the Nuremberg Trails were happening. As any normal teen she was always looking for an adventure. Mary would explore abandoned buildings then one day she realized something.…

    • 966 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Although they may not have known it, the general public began to conform to the beliefs of Nazis. It could be seen as a feat to get almost a whole country to conform to a single person’s beliefs, but many studies show that it would not be as hard as it seems. For example, in the Stanford Prison Experiment, 24 mentally healthy men were chosen take part as “guinea pigs” in the experiment. Half of the men were chosen to be “prison guards” while the others were “prisoners”. Without direction to…

    • 714 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays