Preview

Does Meursault Deserve Punishment

Satisfactory Essays
Open Document
Open Document
211 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Does Meursault Deserve Punishment
An individual does not murder someone without reasoning. There is always meaning behind action. Meursault was guilty of crime, however, he did not deserve the punishment he received, due to an unfair trial and his mental state. Meursault’s trial was unfair. The prosecutor focused mainly on Meursault’s detachment toward Maman’s death. The trial was supposed to be focused on the murder of the Arab. Throughout the novel, Meursault appears to be depressed, and even mentally unstable at some points. He appears to have little to no emotion, even as a narrator of the story, which is unlike most people. Meursault was not in the right mindset during the time of the murder. At the end of the novel, he even mentioned that he was not ready to die,

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    The book starts off with Monsieur Meursault’s mothers’ death and he received a telegram from the home he put her in saying, “Mother deceased. Funeral tomorrow. Faithfully yours.” (3) He responds to the telegram saying, “That doesn’t mean anything.” (3) This makes the reader think that he doesn’t really care for his mother and maybe he didn’t like her especially since when he asked his boss for a couple days off and his boss looked angry he said “it wasn’t my fault” (3) and “I didn’t have anything to apologize for.” (3) Even when he was offered to see his mother’s corpse for the very last time he refused simply because he didn’t want to.…

    • 1947 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    3. What factors led to the individual's wrongful conviction? (ie. Why do you think the person was convicted of a crime he did not commit?)…

    • 1244 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    He becomes more depressed than ever before and the reader can sense his wanting to give up. At first it seems as if his depression shows a lack of emotion, but I disagree. I believe that these moments of depression highlight his emotion; showing just how much he wants to quit. This is a major step considering that earlier he wanted nothing for himself, but only for others. The depression takes over a large section of the book, but towards the very end one can see the joy that Meursault is overcome with. As he realizes that he was correct all along, he feels content. This really is the first and only time Meursault feels and fully shows his emotions without any distractions. He states “...I too felt ready to start life all over again...To feel it so like myself, indeed, so brotherly, made me realize that I’d been happy and that I was happy still” (154). This quote, from the very last paragraph of the book, is the only incite into the full, unguarded emotion of Meursault. His sentencing first led to many more feelings of distress than ever; then concluded in him accepting himself and showing his true…

    • 783 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Meursault is sentenced to death by guillotine. He awaits everyday waiting for the footsteps of the men to come and execute him. During this time Meursault has done much thinking and begins to think to himself that death is inevitable. This realization of death’s inevitability constitutes Meursault’s triumph over society. Expressing remorse over his crime would implicitly acknowledge the murder as wrong, and Meursault’s punishment as justified. The chaplain tries to come to him and speak to him about God, but he still is unwillingly to accept that there is a God.…

    • 248 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    consummated, for me to feel less alone, I had only to wish that there be a large crowd of spectators the day of my execution and that they greet me with cries of hate." (Camus 122-3). He felt as if he was ready to live again just like Maman before she had passed away. Meursault is an absurd hero at the end because he accepted death, passing the Absurd Walls and into the absurd freedom, where one can experience life to the fullest.…

    • 1522 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Both Keating and Meursault distinguish themselves from the masses that seek to chain their spirit. Meursault is an outsider who feels very removed from his surroundings. His reactions are very different from the conventional norms and society judges him negatively. The prosecutor describes him as a man “whose heart is so empty that it forms a chasm which threatens to engulf society” (The Outsider, 98). Meursault shows no emotion at his mother’s funeral. He is indifferent to the idea of marriage to Marie, to the possibility of a job position in Paris, as well as to his verdict of the death penalty. Meursault is judged to be an anti-Christ because he chooses not to believe in God. He refuses to lie or pretend to be something that he is not, simply to please others and to conform.…

    • 1336 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    While readers hope for Meursault to act, when he finally does, it is in a gruesome juxtaposition to the death Meursault would not face to the one he inflicts. In the beginning of the novel when asked if he wants to observe Maman's body, he refuses. But now, as his “eyes [are] blinded behind the curtain of tears and salt… he fired four more times at the motionless body…”(59). Readers hope this act, one of his only acts, might shake him. But once again the indifference and even the selfishness of him “knowing that [he] had shattered the harmony of the day, the exceptional silence of a beach where he’d been happy” (59), causes a sense of uncomfortable regret for Meursault that he is not able to feel himself. It could be said in some way that Camus wanted to make the reader a mirror for what society expected Meursault to feel, but…

    • 425 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Chapter four begins with the opposing side’s lawyer saying that Meursault showed absolutely no sympathy for committing this murder and that he is a very smart man. Both of these reasons are good enough to charge him with premeditated murder. However, from what we know of Meursault, showing emotion towards this death would not be him. Meursault is incapable of feeling human emotions or even processing what is happening. He goes from one moment to the next and never looks back.…

    • 601 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    When Meursault is talking to his lawyer, he is ridiculed for saying that he was ‘tired and sleepy’ on the day of Maman’s funeral, “He thought for a minute. He asked me if he could say that that day I held back my natural feelings. I said, ‘No, because that’s not true.’ He gave me a look, as if he found me slightly disgusting” (Camus 63). A man vs. man conflict is created by Meursault’s honesty and his lawyer;s aversion to his answer. Meursault’s own lawyer expresses his hostility towards Meursault, and therefore can no longer objectively and fairly defend Meursault. In addition to his lawyer’s hostility, Meursault experiences condemnation from the Magistrate after revealing he is an atheist, “… the judge would lead me to the door on his office, slap me on the shoulder and, and say to me cordially, ‘That’s all for today, Monsieur Antichrist.’ I would then be handed over to the police” (Camus 68). By using a critical tone to an ideal that all people should have faith, and those who don’t are wrong, the magistrate created an unjust prejudice against Meursault. Similiarly, during Meursault’s trial, the funeral director is testifying about the events at Maman’s funeral. “… and said that I hadn’t wanted to see Maman, that I hadn’t cried once and that I had left right after the funeral without paying respect to her grave…the prosecutor exclaimed, ‘Oh no, that is quite sufficient!’… I had this stupid urge to cry, because I could feel how much these people all hated me” (Camus 86). By using a harsh tone towards Meursault, a despairing mood is created regarding Meursault’s fate. The prosecutor knows that because man is subjective, a jury…

    • 1287 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Meursault is always emotionally detached from his situation. This begins with the death of his mother. Meursault understands that everyone will die eventually and does not show much emotion.…

    • 584 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Meursault doesn’t show any sign of emotion to his mothers death, he doesn’t feel any love or sorrow for her. A normal man would feel pain and regret for not being there when she died. He does not even know his mother’s exact age, he says “about sixty” when his boss asks him what her age was. The first example of Meursault not feeling anything was…

    • 294 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Camus Good Vs Evil

    • 442 Words
    • 2 Pages

    With all of this I can prove that Meursault is a evil man that constructs fear. “All we have to fear is fear itself” -FDR but to me we also have to fear the men that create fear and use it as a tool. Meursault deserved the death in the public…

    • 442 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Meursault is condemned not for the murder of the Arab but for not meeting society’s expectations…

    • 326 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    He is unfairly judged by society because he exhibits no emotions of any kind at his mother's funeral. In a community where the principle belief that emotional displays are the necessary and correct response to traumatic events such as in Meursault's case (his mother's death) means that there is a standard that is applied to all people. But because the protagonist is shown to be a rebel he does not obey the expected behavior of mourning that society wants him to show. Society asks “has [Meursault] uttered a word of regret for his most odious crimes? Not one word, gentlemen. Not once in the course of these proceedings did this man show the least contrition (Camus 126).” Meursault finally understands that he is in a paradoxical situation where he is judged for showing the lack of feelings rather than his murdering of the Arab man. In the courtroom, the jury represents society’s ethics in which Meursault is being judge while the spectators in the courtroom represent society who are there to pass views on him. He eventually is put on the death penalty because of his nonconformist attitude. Another example that shows the protagonist to be a social misfit is that Meursault believes all men are equal in a sense that no one can ever escape death even if they were a Christian or not. He explains that “every man alive was privileged; there [are] only one class of men, the privileged class. All alike would be condemn to die one day; his turn, too, would come like the others (Camus 152).” He even goes on to say that Old Salamano’s dog was worth just as much as Old Salamano's wife in view of the fact that like all humans, dogs will eventually die as well. So the life of a human can’t be more special than that of a dog since both organisms are made equal by death. The protagonist is an absolute rebel because he is passive, detached, and emotionless…

    • 1583 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    This story further adds to the theme of absurdism throughout the novel because there was no reason for the son to die such as there was no reason for the Arab to die. During Meursault’s trial, there is an attempt to create a reason for his crime despite there not being one. Unlike the philosophy of absurdism, the court believes in reason and order which leads to the establishment of a cause for Meursault’s crime even if it is false. Once Meursault is sentenced to death, he realizes that he no longer has the choice between life and death that all humans are given in life. He instead has death as his only “choice”. Through this, he sees that there is no difference between dying from execution and dying in the future from a different cause. Meursault then accepts that the world is as indifferent as he is to people and finds peace in this realization.…

    • 540 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays