Dream Act Research Paper
Dream Act Should Not Be Approved
The Dream Act would offer amnesty to undocumented immigrants who enter the country before the age of 15. The bill would grant permanent residency (and then citizenship) to an undocumented immigrant if the person completes two years of college or service in the military. Under this bill, millions of people would make their dream come true. However, the Dream Act is a threat to the nation's security, economy, and is unfair to the other people who are seeking US permanent residency.
The Dream Act will contribute to our military’s recruitment effort and readiness (Miranda). However, the truth is this might be a serious threat to our nation. Because these beneficiaries were not born in the United States, they might not have loyalty to our nation and might join the military for US citizenship. When our country needs them, they might not be willing to sacrifice themselves or may easily turn against the United States. …show more content…
Some of them might become spies, working for other countries. The DREAM Act will have important economic benefits (Miranda).
In fact, this bill will deeply hurt our fragile economy. Under the Dream Act, these illegal immigrants now can legally take our jobs. This would tremendously increase the unemployment rate and will result in more people claiming unemployment benefits. At the same time, these illegal students can acquire government financial aid that will increase government expenses. Once they obtain legal residency, they definitely would petition their parents to become permanent residents, and their parents would share our social security benefits without making any contribution. The Dream Act would encourage more people to sneak into the United States and tourists and foreign students would illegally stay because they might think American law is negotiable, and they might think there could be another form of The Dream Act in the future, which could benefit them. That is the reason why Border Control and Department of Immigration need to increase their budgets over
time.
The Dream Act is not fair to the people currently on the waiting list and the other illegal immigrants who are not covered by the Dream Act. US citizen’s spouses need to wait 1-2 years to immigrate to United States. US permanent resident’s spouses need to wait 3-4 years to immigrate to United States and their brothers and sisters need to wait 10-15 years. Dream Act would only benefit a small group of illegal immigrant. The rest of them would remain illegal residents even though most of them have lived in the United States more than 10 years. This bill obviously violates the primary principle of equal opportunity.
Imagine one day a guy breaks into your house and tries to steal your property. He gets caught by the policemen, and after the intruder negotiates with the policemen, the policemen says he is going to release him because he find out the guy is an illegal immigrant, and doesn’t have a job to feed his family. The policeman also suggests that you give some money and food to help this intruder. Think deeply. This is the meaning behind the Dream Act. It would intensely impact our fragile economy and set a dangerous precedent for the future as well. The supporters of the Dream Act (most of them are illegal immigrants’ family or close friends) sacrifices the most of American people’s benefits to achieve their goal. The people of American should stand up to defend our rights and send those illegal immigrants to where they came from because they were not invited here.
The Dream Act would offer amnesty to undocumented immigrants who enter the country before the age of 15. The bill would grant permanent residency (and then citizenship) to an undocumented immigrant if the person completes two years of college or service in the military. Under this bill, millions of people would make their dream come true. However, the Dream Act is a threat to the nation's security, economy, and is unfair to the other people who are seeking US permanent residency.
The Dream Act will contribute to our military’s recruitment effort and readiness (Miranda). However, the truth is this might be a serious threat to our nation. Because these beneficiaries were not born in the United States, they might not have loyalty to our nation and might join the military for US citizenship. When our country needs them, they might not be willing to sacrifice themselves or may easily turn against the United States. …show more content…
Some of them might become spies, working for other countries. The DREAM Act will have important economic benefits (Miranda).
In fact, this bill will deeply hurt our fragile economy. Under the Dream Act, these illegal immigrants now can legally take our jobs. This would tremendously increase the unemployment rate and will result in more people claiming unemployment benefits. At the same time, these illegal students can acquire government financial aid that will increase government expenses. Once they obtain legal residency, they definitely would petition their parents to become permanent residents, and their parents would share our social security benefits without making any contribution. The Dream Act would encourage more people to sneak into the United States and tourists and foreign students would illegally stay because they might think American law is negotiable, and they might think there could be another form of The Dream Act in the future, which could benefit them. That is the reason why Border Control and Department of Immigration need to increase their budgets over
time.
The Dream Act is not fair to the people currently on the waiting list and the other illegal immigrants who are not covered by the Dream Act. US citizen’s spouses need to wait 1-2 years to immigrate to United States. US permanent resident’s spouses need to wait 3-4 years to immigrate to United States and their brothers and sisters need to wait 10-15 years. Dream Act would only benefit a small group of illegal immigrant. The rest of them would remain illegal residents even though most of them have lived in the United States more than 10 years. This bill obviously violates the primary principle of equal opportunity.
Imagine one day a guy breaks into your house and tries to steal your property. He gets caught by the policemen, and after the intruder negotiates with the policemen, the policemen says he is going to release him because he find out the guy is an illegal immigrant, and doesn’t have a job to feed his family. The policeman also suggests that you give some money and food to help this intruder. Think deeply. This is the meaning behind the Dream Act. It would intensely impact our fragile economy and set a dangerous precedent for the future as well. The supporters of the Dream Act (most of them are illegal immigrants’ family or close friends) sacrifices the most of American people’s benefits to achieve their goal. The people of American should stand up to defend our rights and send those illegal immigrants to where they came from because they were not invited here.