Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Earthquakes are more newsworthy but we ignore other geological hazards at our peril. Discuss

Powerful Essays
1623 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Earthquakes are more newsworthy but we ignore other geological hazards at our peril. Discuss
Earthquakes are more newsworthy but we ignore other geological hazards at our peril. Discuss. (40marks)
Geological hazards are events that are perceived as a threat to people, poverty and nature, which originate in, or transmitted by the physical, built or human environment. These can include volcanoes, hurricanes and earthquakes, which all have various effects ranging from affecting people to the natural and physical environment. Looking at earthquakes in particular, which are vibrations of the earth caused by rupture and sudden movement of rocks that have been strained beyond their elastic limits, their effects can affect various factors and can trigger secondary hazards heightening, and even adding to, the already present effects.
To a certain extent I disagree with that statement as other geological hazards can triggered by the occurrence of an earthquake therefore these hazards aren’t ignored but in fact able to managed with responses such as aid and search and rescue able to come help in the response effort. This is demonstrated in various situations. The first being the geological hazard of a tsunami. A tsunami is a giant sea wave caused by a large scale and sudden disturbance of sea water caused by large rapid movement of the sea floor initiated, nine times out of ten, by an earthquake – 90% of tsunamis occur in the Pacific basin. Detection of tsunami relies heavily on earthquake (seismic) monitoring out in the ocean. Taking the Japan Earthquake of 2011 for example, the earthquake (measuring 9.0 on the Ritcher scale) occurred 78km off the Sendai coast as a result of the North American plate being subducted by the Pacific plate. This caused the plate to slip upwards by 5-10km, triggering a tsunami. The tsunami travelled at hundreds of kilometres per second generating a wave height of 15m. It is because of the earthquake being newsworthy and monitored that this tsunami was known and warnings were given to the people in Japan – within 90 seconds of the earthquake the people of Japan knew a tsunami was going to hit allowing them to evacuate the area to higher ground as the tsunami took 30 minutes to reach the coast from off land. This warning system involves text messages being sent to everyone in areas that were likely to be hit and it being displayed on TVs and radio. Due to this evacuation it saved many lives as in Minami-Sanrikill half the population were able to escape to safety.
However, just because we know that tsunami’s can be triggered by earthquakes it doesn’t mean that these other geological hazards have stopped being ignored, as advances in seismology have continued yet not much has been done to prevent/reduce the effects of tsunami. Keeping with the Japanese Earthquake of 2011, the vast majority of buildings with Tokyo are life safe. This means that the buildings can absorb or resist the shock/ground waves the earthquake releases. As the buildings are able to do this it can saves lives and stop the buildings from collapsing. Whereas, not many preventative measures have been put in place to help against tsunamis and not many are well known and have been heavily researched. Japan did have in place a coastal forest which was meant to intercept and reduce the strength and size of the water but that didn’t happen. Instead, the largest breakwaters in the world were broken and the sea water inundated 500km2 of land with whole cities ruined. This then affected growth of crop as the sediment which was carried by suspension in the sea water, remained on the surface of the land for two months which stopped the crops from growing. This had disastrous effect on the economy of not just the local people who for them agriculture was their source of income but for the local government as well who relied on the port and the surrounding area for the export of fish and other agricultural goods.
This isn’t the case for everywhere because in some locations, advances in science related to other geological hazards is on the increase and these geological hazards aren’t being ignored and if an event was to occur then people living in that area would be prepared and the effects would hopefully be minimal. For example, in the area surrounding Mt. Etna and in Iceland, there is constant research being carried out into volcanicity, which has led to advances in how to reduce and protect you against the effects of a volcanic eruption. In Iceland, the Icelandic MET office monitors various changes and provides data to issue warnings to the locals if there is a good chance that a volcano in the surrounding area may erupt. They have also found out that they can use sea water to cool the lava (as demonstrated in Haeimay) which cools and solidifies lava flow reducing that danger. The Icelandic Government have also scheduled hazard education and emergency response training to everyone in order for whole communities to be prepared and act sensibly in an eruption and have created FUTUREVOLC. This is an organisation which aims to carry out long term monitoring to enable us to understand more about volcanoes & their associated hazards and to be able to respond to them effectively and efficiently to limit damage and the effects caused. On the other hand, Mt. Etna has used different techniques to prevent/reduce the volcanic hazard effects. In previous eruptions they have used explosives to direct lava from its course to prevent the lava destroying whole towns and villages in its path. They have also enforced that no roads or constructions can take place in the area surrounding the area, the only building work that can take place is only necessary maintenance which is usually to the observation building monitoring the volcano. The scientists have also produced a detailed computer stimulated hazards map showing where the biggest impact will occur. This will allow the rescue efforts to be concentrated there. This demonstrates how other geological hazards aren’t ignored to out peril and research is constantly being carried out into volcanoes and their associated hazards.
Nevertheless, it is true that we ignore other geological hazards in favour of reporting about earthquakes. The main of reason of this is because of the LEDC and MEDC divide. MEDC countries can afford to research and implement laws and rules which help reduce the effects and hopefully help prevent people from experiencing dyer effects as a result of a geological hazard. This is shown in the fact that Japan and the United State of America are at the forefront of research into earthquakes and its associated hazards with Iceland and Italy at the forefront of research into volcanicity and its associated hazards. This is because countries like these can afford to spend part of their budget on constructing life-safe buildings, using earthquake resistant materials such as reinforced concrete and designing evacuation plans and education so that people know how to react effectively, efficiently and safely if a geological hazard occurs e.g. the regular earthquake drills in San Francisco. Whereas, in a LEDC they don’t have the finance to do this hence why even though earthquakes are known about those geological hazards along with others destroy cities and affect the whole country. For example, Haiti is part of a multi-hazardous zone. It experiences earthquakes, tsunamis, hurricanes and the rainy season on regular occasions. On one occasion it has suffered extremely badly. In January 2012, a 7.0 magnitude earthquake with 59 aftershocks hit the country of Haiti and with it affected 3.5 million out of a population of 10.17million (80% of these were living under the poverty line). As it is a LEDC, it’s the lowest country on the Human Development Index of the Americas and Western Hemisphere; they can’t afford to help reduce the effects of a geological hazard. They use poor quality material to build their homes. The material consisted of used brittle steel, weak cement with dirty sand and steel reinforcement roads terminated at joints which could only collapse at the slightest bit of ground movement. Over 293,000 homes were destroyed making many families homeless and having to live in temporary shelters set up by International Aid. As everyone was focused on the earthquake, people forgot about the rainy season which hit the country in March every year. Because of this major effects were added to the already growing problems in Haiti and only set back the relief and response efforts already established in the country. The rainy season caused mud slides and with many still living in camps the spread of disease increased as they were drinking the same contaminated water. Then in September just as the country was beginning to recover a tornado hit the city destroying 6000 tents which was shortly followed by Hurricane Tomas which killed 4000 and set off another cholera outbreak in the area. This then made international aid and relief increase their presence and finance donation to the country in order to get people healthy and out of tents into a better living environment. This demonstrates that in LEDCs that other geological hazards, including earthquakes to some extent, are ignored to our peril causing disastrous effects not just socially but environmentally and economically too.
In conclusion, to a certain extent other geological hazard are ignored at our peril in favour of publicising earthquakes, especially in LEDC countries where they do not have the finance to research and help prevent/reduce the effects of geological hazards other than the main geological hazard of earthquakes, even still relying on information and research carried out by MEDC countries. Yet other geological hazards are ignored to our peril because they are being researched into with plans in place but they aren’t as well documented as efforts into earthquakes are.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    Earthquakes are an example of seismic activity caused by the build-up of tension at the three types of plate boundaries: destructive, constructive and conservative. The pressure is suddenly released as the plates jerk past each other, sending out seismic waves from the focus that travel through different parts of the earth. The movement of convection currents within the Earth’s mantle causing the crust to become mobile which creates the different types plate margins, makes the cause due to physical factors. However human activity is suggested to be the cause of some minor earthquakes, for instance the building of large reservoirs where the water stresses the surface rocks or the subsidence of deep mine workings.…

    • 2230 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    This report will focus on examples of different earthquakes happening around the world and explain why some countries cope better than others. To cope well, the country should have low death tolls, good communication with rescue services and other countries willing to help, evacuation and other emergency plans are planned well, and minimizing the amount of damage done to the country.…

    • 1370 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    A hazard is a physical or man-made event which adversely affects human life, business, and events. Volcanic hazards may include lava, pyroclastic flows and volcanic bombs whereas seismic hazards may include earthquakes, tsunamis and liquefaction. Humans attempt to mitigate the effects of volcanic and seismic events via predictive methods but the extent to this may be reliant on the country’s financial status.…

    • 1487 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Discuss the view that the impact of earthquake hazards depends primarily on human factors (40)…

    • 958 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    A ‘hazard’ can be defined as a geophysical process operating within the lithosphere, atmosphere, hydrosphere or biosphere which could potentially lead to the loss of human life or property. However, an earthquake only becomes hazardous and therefore needs management if it occurs within close proximity to a vulnerable population. To some extent, any human settlement around the world situated close to or on top of an area of seismic activity is vulnerable. However, not all nations suffer equal devastation.…

    • 1778 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    It is impossible for anybody to argue that human factors do not have an effect on the impact caused by earthquake hazards; however the extent of the effect is debatable depending on the situation. This can depend on many different aspects, for instance the level of development in the relevant country, the standard of infrastructure, the magnitude and location of the quake and lastly what time the quake occurs. In order to properly assess whether the impact of earthquake hazards depends primarily on human factors, it is necessary to look at a range of case studies which will provide a balanced overview. For instance – looking at the LEDW – examples such as the Haiti earthquake in January 2010 as well as the earthquake in the Indian Ocean in December 2004 could suggest that the impact depends primarily on human factors as these countries are not fully developed and thus might have underdeveloped infrastructure and building regulations. Contrary to this, the MEDW with examples such as the Northridge earthquake in 1994 could provide a contrasting argument in terms of how human factors affect the impact. However, there are always multiple factors which the impact depends on, regardless of the development of the relevant country.…

    • 877 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Sc300 Unit 4 Assignment

    • 1655 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Of all the naturally occurring events on Earth, earthquakes are among the most devastating and bring a lot of truth to the statement, “Just because something is natural does not mean it is not dangerous.” Earthquakes are one of the most natural things I can think of that can cause massive damage and loss of human live in many instances, and the effects are sometimes long term. “Nothing happens without a force. Many geophysicists accept the theory that continents move as a result of the forces generated by mantel convection deep within Earth – motions driven by our planet’s internal heat energy” (Trefil & Hazen, 2010). According to National Geographic (1996-2012), constant movement in the tectonic plates that make up the Earth’s crust causes an earthquake. The constant nature of this movement causes a buildup of energy, which is stored in rocks at fault lines. The stored energy is eventually released and a sudden, rapid shaking of the Earth is the result. “An Earthquake is what happens when two blocks of the earth suddenly slip past one another” (Wald, 2009). An event cannot be more natural than the Earth itself actually causing it.…

    • 1655 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Although prevention of either an earthquake or a volcanic eruption isn’t possible, it is possible to manage them and reduce the overall impact. This should, in theory, be easier for MEDCs due having more money available to spend on management policies. However in some situations it isn’t the primary effects of the earthquake or eruption that have the greater impact. For example in the 2010 Eyjafjallajokull eruption in Iceland it wasn’t the lava or pyroclastic flow that caused problems, it was the ash cloud which was produced. The cloud caused most of northern European airspace to be closed between 15th April and the 23rd with disruptions continuing until late May. In total this cost the airline industry around US$1.7 billion. The impacts can also be viewed from a global perspective as although it was only European air travel which was restricted, it will have caused a lot of problems for travellers all around the world. On a local scale the eruption increased the rate of melting of nearby glaciers which meant that the Krossa glacial river increased by 6oC over a two hour period. Farmland was affected by the thick layer of ash which had fell and then become wet and compact making it difficult to continue farming. This shows…

    • 1182 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A hazard can best be defined as a 'situation that poses a level of threat to life, health, property or the environment.' The overall impact of earthquakes as a natural hazard varies greatly from one place and timeframe to another. As do the types of hazards, which are categorised into primary and secondary. Primary hazards are created by the direct seismic energy of an earthquake; this could include liquefaction, slope failure and tsunamis. These primary hazards can in turn trigger secondary hazards such as floods, fires, disease and destabilisation of infrastructure. A number of factors play a part in determining the severity of these hazards.…

    • 922 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    A hazard is a situation that poses a level of threat to life, health, property, or the environment. Therefore, in this case a volcanic hazard is the threat posed from natural volcanic processes towards the populations and the environment. The extent of volcanic hazards can vary due to two factors; physical factors such as the type of volcano and human factors such as the population density in the area. Volcanic hazards can also be placed into two phases: primary hazards such as lava flows and gas emissions; there are also secondary hazards such as lahars and landslides. The management of volcanic hazards are done through preparedness and planning where through prior risk assessments with monitoring the effects are mitigated. There are three stages of managing eruptions; before the event, during the event, and the evacuation; the effective transitions between these stages creates a situation where there is minimal damages from a volcanic event. Mitigation, in this question refers to elimination or reduction of the risk posed by a natural hazard (volcanic hazard), usually through human intervention. The scale of preparedness and planning varies from less developed countries (LDC’s) to more developed countries (MDC’s) either from financial backing or through technological advances. The lack of preparedness and planning in the volcanic event of Chaiten in Chile saw widespread environmental and infrastructure damage. While, the 2010 eruption in Iceland gave an insight of the wider hazards to other countries in the world; but through high levels preparedness and planning there has been minimal damages to infrastructure and the population.…

    • 2188 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    An earthquake is an emergency because it is unexpected and cause severe damage to environment and properties or lands. It can also severely harm human beings who happen to be in the designated area. In order to be prepared for unexpected situations like this there are some procedures people can follow to ensure safety around them. These are before the earthquake happens…

    • 685 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    In May 2008, a major earthquake hit Sichuan in the south west of China, it was estimated that around 69 000 to 80 000 people were killed and buildings collapsed with people in them information from an OCR science booklet, a news sheet. In my case study, I will be writing about Should we spend more money on predicting for an earthquake than on preparing a town for an earthquake I will do this by discussing different point of views of people if they agree or disagree with the statement above and use their opinion as evidence. In the end of the case study, I will have made my point clear. What is an earthquake, and what causes it An earthquake is a sudden shockwave called a seismic shock (a fast movement of energy that spreads quicker than sound) which is caused by rocks being under stress by the movement of the tectonic plates at plate boundaries and eventually the stress from the rocks build up and reach breaking point. At that point, the stored up energy is released in the form of shockwaves.1 Arguments that supports the statement David Petley, who is an executive director of the Institute of Hazard, Risk and Resilience in the University of Durham, wrote an article in The Guardian. Petley (2012) points out an intriguing argument stating that a successful prediction would greatly reduce the loss of life, if not necessarily the economic damage, by permitting dangerous buildings to be evacuated, tsunami-prone areas to be cleared, and hospitals and rescue teams to be prepared and on standby.2 From this statement it appears that The Guardian believes a successful prediction prevents millions of lives dying or injured by an earthquake, countries wont be economically damaged as houses can get ruined by earthquakes, if people do get injured hospitals and rescue teams will be ready on standby. However, whether David Petley, from The Guardian, is in favour of prediction will be discussed later on. Dr Michael Blanpied, who serves as an Associate Coordinator of the USGS…

    • 2164 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    One method of reducing the impact is by managing the vulnerability. One of the main uses of technology is the prediction of when and where an earthquake will occur. In terms of earthquakes it is very hard to predict when an earthquake will occur. However, there are tell-tale signs that give a nonetheless small idea. Technology here plays an important part; seismographs probably being the more common use. Little movements/ tremors under crusts are measured by seismographs and tilt metre; this information is looked at and then used to predict when. Radon gas is released which is measured by spectrometers. Water levels are also tend to rise before an earthquake giving a big hint.…

    • 1000 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Hazards are anything that could cause damage to humans or buildings. Many volcanic and seismic events happen that cause hazards to humans. Often the world’s poorest people are hit the worst, however wealthier countries can also be adversely affected.…

    • 1016 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Natural disasters are often not natural disasters, but are in fact human disasters. Discuss this statement in relation to seismic events.…

    • 800 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics