Centrally planned economies assume that the market does not work in the best interest of the people, and that in order for social and national objectives to be met a central authority needs to make decisions. The state can set prices for goods and determine how much is produced, and can focus labor and resources on industries and projects without having to wait for private investment capital.
Most modern economies are a mixture of centrally planned economies and market economies, with governments controlling some aspects of the economy and the private sector controlling others. www.investopedia.com/terms/c/centrally-planned-economy.asp Introduction of Planned economy
A market economy is the opposite of a command or centrally planned economy. In a command system, the government determines what goods are sold, how much of them, and what they will cost. This single actor is replaced by many in a market system, where the price of a good is determined by both the supply and demand for it (wikinvest.com 2012). And in the following we will talk about the advantages and disadvantages of planned economy.
1.2.2 Advantages of Planned economy
1.2.2.1 Elimination of inflation and price fluctuations
In command economies, the central government stipulates what and how much of most products will be produced. By setting prices and wages the central government can also dictate how much of the production is allotted to each household. In short, the central government controls production and income in command economies (Musgrave, Harding, Kacapyr & Harding 2001, p. 37). And because of this functional feature of command economies, the price could not be determined depending on how much would be produced and how much people’s demand is, as a result, price would be stable and as a matter of fact in most planned economies, prices are set by the policy makers. Hence, one major advantage of adopting the planned economy is that it largely eliminate the appearance of inflation and price fluctuations which are usually challenges to the capitalist free market economies.
1.2.2.2 A powerful central government
1.2.3 Disadvantages of Planned economy
1.2.3.1 Lack of employee motivation and responsibility
According to Max Weber (1978, p. 110), a planned economy oriented to want satisfaction must, in proportion as it is radically carried through, weaken the incentive to labour so far as the risk of lack of support is involved. Because it would, at least so far as there is a rational system of provision for wants, be impossible to allow a worker’s dependents to suffer the full consequences of his lack of efficiency in production. This lack of labor or employee motivation and responsibility could be found in China before its famous economy reform in the 1980s. At that time, distribution of goods are depending on the labor hours and individuals were not responsible for the consequences of their works. Therefore, the labor efficiency was much lower in China. And also, as a result, technology innovations were rare because they were not motivated to do so as there would be no obvious rewards for such good performance. http://www.chinaabout.net/advantages-and-disadvantages-of-market-economy-command-or-planned-economy-and-mixed-economy/ An economic system that includes a mixture of capitalism and socialism. This type of economic system includes a combination of private economic freedom and centralized economic planning and government regulation.
There are many countries around the world that are either capitalist or socialist, with countries ranging from the United States to Cuba being referred to as mixed economies. A capitalist system is based on private ownership, labor, personal profit and investments. In contrast, a socialist economy is controlled and regulated publicly, usually through mechanisms like government bodies and planning councils. www.investopedia.com/terms/m/mixed-economic-system.as Advantages of Mixed Economy
Since mixed economy involves both government and private enterprises it has the advantage of taking the benefits of capitalist nature of private companies and socialist nature of government.
There is less inequality of income because intent of government is to have a balanced economic growth of an economy.
Mixed economy allows individuals to run their business and make profits but at the same time it places some responsibility on these companies by inducing them to contribute towards the welfare of society.
Disadvantages of Mixed Economy
Since welfare of society is important in a mixed economy it leads to lower than optimum use of the resources because government mobilize the resources towards the production of those goods and services which are beneficial for the society as a whole rather than producing those goods and services which in economic terms are more beneficial for an economy.
Under mixed economy private enterprises have to face lot of difficulty because of various government loopholes like favouritism and bureaucratic nature which is prevalent in mixed economy.
As one can see that mixed economy like socialist and capitalist economies has both advantages and disadvantages and therefore it will be always debatable whether a country should follow mixed economy structure or not. http://www.letslearnfinance.com/advantages-and-disadvantages-of-mixed-economy.html http://www.chinaabout.net/features-advantages-and-disadvantages-of-command-economy/ http://english.caijing.com.cn/2009-09-30/110269580.html http://econc10.bu.edu/economic_systems/Economics/Command_Econ/planning/comec_plan_czechosl.htm
Grant, S G, 2012. Igcse And O Level Economics India Edition. 4th ed. India: Cambridge University Press http://books.google.com.my/books?id=LiX_-SX3E3gC&pg=PP2&lpg=PP2&dq=centrally+planned+economy+inflation&source=bl&ots=8YXswHoSH5&sig=oHYswhvjqAgM67rwt3Bvpu4qXOI&hl=en&sa=X&ei=PYOHUoqrE4iRrQf2soC4DA&ved=0CGoQ6AEwCTgK#v=onepage&q=centrally%20planned%20economy%20inflation&f=false http://21stcenturylearning.sharepoint.com/Pages/2EconomicSystems.aspx http://www.harpercollege.edu/mhealy/eco212i/lectures/command/command.htm Microeconomics, 16/e
Campbell R McConnell, University of Nebraska, Emeritus
Stanley L Brue, Pacific Lutheran University
ISBN: 0072875615
Copyright year: 2005
This textbook and accompanying Website are "Out of Print." Please check with your instructor or McGraw-Hill Sales Representative on the availability of current editions. http://econc10.bu.edu/economic_systems/Economics/Command_Econ/planning/comec_plan_czechosl.htm https://www.boundless.com/business/economics-and-business/businesses-under-mixed-economic-systems/the-benefits-of-mixed-economies/
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
A centrally planned economy most often refers to an economic system that is under comprehensive control and regulation by a government in accordance with the plan of economic development.…
- 1033 Words
- 12 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Command Economy: an economy in which production, investment, prices, and incomes are determined centrally by a government.…
- 329 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Command Economy - an economic in which government leaders give the answers to the three economic questions…
- 2993 Words
- 12 Pages
Good Essays -
This allows the people to choose: what they want to buy, how much they want to charge for an item, and how much of an item they want to produce. Friedrich Hayek, a nobel winning economists, called this system a “spontaneous order.” His point was that this type of economy is not regulated nor unplanned, instead the planning and regulation come from the arrangement of decentralized knowledge among countless specialists, not the government. There are communist countries where the government controls: what to produce, how much of a good they want to produce, and the price of an item. These countries proclaim that controlling the economy has its advantages.…
- 960 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
In a command economy, there is safety and security. The government makes most of the decisions as to who is employed and what gets produced. And they strive to make sure their decisions works for all involved. One of the drawbacks is that there are limits as to who, what, where, when and why when it comes to the product produced.…
- 328 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
The argument still persists of which economy is better. These economies both try to look after their people in different ways. The command economy is more of a direct supervision of its people. It is similar to how a parent watches over a child. The government tries the best to ensure safety in the economic world for their civilians just like a parent protects their child. On the other hand, a market economy is similar to the moments of a bird. When the bird reaches a certain point, they must take a leap. This leap will either kill them, or let them prosper. The market economy is similar since individuals must take the risk to be successful. The risk though, even if possible, may not end as badly we’d like to think. Thousands of businesses flourish in these markets, all because of the risks people have taken to get there, and only some didn’t “flap their wings” like the bird should. This risk pushes people to do their best, so they can prosper like they want. Both economies try to help the very people of the nation, but because of the markets economies risk, there is also great prosperity. This is the very thing that command economies do not…
- 662 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The major difference between a command economy and a market economy is that a command economy is told what to do by the government. A market economy does things for the people, the people decide what they want. The command economy is told what to produce, who to produce to, and how to produce by the government. The market economy is told is told what to produce, who to produce to, and how to produce by the people.…
- 481 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
1. Command Economy: The government will determine countries economic needs. The government tells people when they work and how much they get paid.…
- 277 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
An economic system comprised mainly of privately-owned enterprise (businesses), low levels of regulation and relies heavily on the free-price system to allocate resources. This is distinguished with a planned economy based on private enterprise.…
- 1256 Words
- 6 Pages
Powerful Essays -
mixed economy - an economic system where the economy is directed by both the public and private sectors…
- 673 Words
- 3 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Numerous and diverse economic systems have been established throughout the course of global history, impacting society in various ways. Many of these systems include manorialism, capitalism, communism, market economy, and many more. An economic system that has greatly influenced a specific region and its society is communism, established in Russia during the Russian Revolution. During and after World War I, Russia was in chaos due to the opposition of czarist rule, economic hardships, and other dissatisfactions of many. Due to these complications, Russians were pleading for economic and political changes. Communism in Russia immensely affected Russian society as some oppressed this regimen, while others benefited from it.…
- 404 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
One reason command economy is more efficient than a market economy is because the command economy focuses on providing survival for its people. All residents are provided with the basic needs for survival such as housing, jobs, education, clothing, food etc. The government provides all the needs. There is no worry about bills, losing jobs, food shortage. In a market economy, you are not guaranteed all this, sure you are given well fare– but you are not guaranteed a job. What happens to those in need of a job? They aren’t given a job. In a market economy you are on your own. Karl Marx, a German philosopher, formed the command economy. In a market economy, you are constantly competing for survival. Whereas the command economy- you are guaranteed survival. The government provides all your basic needs. According to Marx, “Disadvantage of a pure market economy cannot provide security to those who, because of sickness or age, cannot be economically productive.” The bottom line is that the government of a market economy does not imply support to its residents. An older couple is not living under the government’s wing, but the insurance and money they have saved over the ages.…
- 953 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
There were many outlines for this new system called capitalism, which would make it different from any other economic system we have ever seen. What made capitalism different from all other economic systems was that production facilities, land, and capital were all privately owned. What made capitalism different was the government did not control the economy entirely. Capital is based on the idea of free economic decisions for the people; basically the people were free to spend their money how they like. Companies on the other hand were able to decide what they wanted to produce and how much to charge. In a capitalistic society, the prices of…
- 969 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
I believe the best option would be the Mixed-Market economic system. It not only has economic institutions but also a mix of private as well, which in turn exercises economic control. Production is owned by private and public firms along with the government to help monitor the economy. The same principle applies to resources since both have a share with the land/natural resources, capital and labor/entrepreneurship. One advantage of this system is the preeminent authority that consumer and producer holds because of their ability to choose what to consume/produce as long as it lies within the consent of the federal government. It is a positive factor since nothing dangerous or threatening services or goods will be on the market, providing a safe and healthy economic society. The social cost of business activities have the possibility of a reduction by completing a cost-benefit analysis by the government. There is a freedom of enterprise ownership, profit earning, social welfare and politics for people to take advantage of. Altogether, these private/public sectors work together in order to bring more production, a positive quality with the Mixed-Market system.…
- 661 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Page 284 – 292 Economic Systems An economic system is what allows a country to decide what to produce, how to produce, and for whom to produce. These systems include natural resources, labor, capital, management and standards for creating products. Market Economies In market economies, i) ownership of private property is encouraged, ii) businesses are encouraged to produce better products, iii) competition is encouraged because it can create better quality and lower prices, iv) the Government has little direct involvement with the business itself, and v) selfsufficiency is not seen as an economic goal. Supply and demand control market economies. The “law” of supply states that as the price of a product increases, producers will be willing to make more of that product. The “law” of demand states that as the price of a product increases consumers will demand less of that product. Producers must find the equilibrium point which is the point at which the consumers are willing to pay the asking price and the company still makes a profit. Centrally Planned Economies In centrally planned economies the government controls the ownership of private property. By having more government control the profit motive is not the main goal of the business. There are fewer pure centrally planned economies following the collapse of communism in the former Soviet Union. Mixed Economies A mixed economy includes government involvement and private ownership of businesses. In some countries, the government owns the transportation and communication businesses. In socialist mixed economies, most of the main industries are government controlled, but citizens are free to work in other industries. Canada has a mixed economy. Because Canada has a large, land mass and a relatively small population, the Canadian government has to play a major role in our important…
- 979 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays