Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Effect of Washington Consensus Upon Emerging Market

Better Essays
1398 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Effect of Washington Consensus Upon Emerging Market
Washington Consensus implemented by emerging markets refers to economic policies created by John Williamson (Hooper, 2002; Rodrik, 2006). It is based on financial liberalization theory of McKinnon and Shaw, which emphasis on freeing financial markets from government intervention. Financial liberalization theory assumed perfect financial markets with perfect information, perfect competition and depends on institution-free analysis (Demetriades, 1999). These assumptions are irrelevant in the sense that market, as a whole is imperfect. Despite these deficiencies, emerging countries agree to implement Washington Consensus requested by International Monetary Policy (IMF) and World Bank as part of their loan contracts. According to Washington Consensus, emerging economies facing similar problems with developed markets should be treated with the same tools. Washington Consensus aims to encourage privatization with high level of economic openness. There are many criticisms regarding the policies content of Washington Consensus. Some critics argue that the policies are not being devised in a sequentially correct manner and did not consider emerging markets’ development stage (Hooper, 2002). There are several impacts of the implementation of Washington Consensus upon the emerging capital markets namely worsen economic growth and increase stock market’s volatility. Implementation of the Washington Consensus through financial liberalization has affected economic growth of emerging capital markets. Financial liberalization is developed in the objective of improving economic growth by encouraging saving, investment and capital productivity. Before financial liberalization is introduced, many developing countries encounter financial repression, which is the process where government intervenes in the economy (Demetriades, 1999). In 1960s and 1970s, government intervention was needed to control pegged exchange rates under Bretton-Wood regime. Government controlled the markets by allocating high reserve requirement, interest rates ceiling, and controlling capital, credit as well as exchange rate. These interventions led to disequilibrium in interest rate, for example, interest rates were below equilibrium level (Hooper, 2002). In order to curb the problem, financial liberalization is introduced, for instance, by setting higher interest rates. High interest rates were aimed to encourage savings, which will attract investment through borrowing and thus improved economic growth. Unfortunately, financial liberalization did not result in greater savings instead high interest rate can destroy reformation in real sector (Hooper, 2002). In addition, financial liberalization exacerbates economic growth in the sense that ratio of reserves to foreign denominated short-term indebtedness had declined substantially (Stiglitz, 2000). Washington Consensus suggests emerging capital markets to deregulate their economies in order to achieve economic growth. However, lack of comprehensive regulation has led to Asian Financial Crisis in 1997. Moreover, dampen economic growth during Asian Financial Crisis came from maturity and currency mismatch. For example, long-term investment in local currency financed short-term liabilities in dollars. Besides, Washington Consensus did not emphasis on capital flow structure in liberalizing capital flows. Many emerging capital markets destabilized due to high level of capital flows. In Latin America (1980), economic crisis was a result of cash flow structuring problem with the increase in portfolio equity to replace portfolio debt. Asian Financial Crisis 1997 has been deteriorated due to regular flows of money between financial markets. This term hot money will flow from countries with low return to countries with the highest interest rates as banks attempt to get highest return as possible. These flows can affect balance of payments if exchange rates in the total is high (Hooper, 2002). Thus, Washington Consensus worsens economic growth of emerging capital markets. Volatility of stock markets is also affected by the implementation of Washington Consensus. Financial liberalization lead emerging capital markets to more volatility. This is because financial liberalization encourages deregulation, and liquidity, which are the components enhancing volatility. It also goes for taxation as lower taxes lead to volatility. Since liberalize markets usually have lower market concentration, volatility will also increase (Hooper, 1998). Moreover, increasing portfolio equity flows increasing volatility of stock markets (Hooper, 2002). These situations reduce the attractiveness of investing in emerging stock markets (Stiglitz, 2000). Besides, stock markets’ volatility will be exasperated when there is no sufficient accounting disclosure since investors are not able to make informed judgment about the firm. However, financial liberalization did not improve accounting disclosure and structure of governance (Hooper, 2002). There is negative relationship between quality of accounting system and volatility of stock market. Poor accounting system lead to higher market volatility. Moreover, Washington Consensus policy of deregulation has also intensified volatility of stock market (Hooper, 1998; Hooper, 1998). In addition, financial liberalization increased volatility of stock markets with changes in outside country. Since, emerging markets seemed risky, investors are discouraged to invest in the markets. Thus, results in large capital outflows (Stiqlitz, 2000). However, in the long run, volatility of emerging stock markets is improving as they liberalize. International investors find investing in emerging markets are profitable since their risk-return of overall portfolio improved. Investing in emerging stock market lead to diversification of risk, as there is low correlation with other markets (Hooper, 1998). Despite that, implementation of Washington Consensus in emerging capital markets lead to volatile stock market especially in the short-term cycle. There are several ways for IMF and World Bank to conduct policy in developing countries. One of the ways is IMF and World Bank have to make sure that Washington Consensus policies are implemented in correct sequencing manner (Hooper, 2002). For example, financial sector should be reformed after regulatory and bank supervision are restructured and after real sector has been reformed. IMF and World Bank should also encourage developing countries to review and comprehend their regulation system since deregulation can harm economic growth (Hopper, 2002). Furthermore, fortifying securities and accounting regulation help reduce volatility (Hooper, 1998) by implementing framework and policies like fiscal policy, which represent the countries stock markets’ volatility. Besides, IMF and World Bank should bequest emerging countries to be more transparent in accounting disclosure and adopt good governance structure. For example, companies with poor governance are required to pay high return to investors. To reduce the premium, corporation should lessen information asymmetry by increasing accounting disclosure. Thus, cost of equity is lowered since investors are more aware about the firms’ cash flow. Moreover, accounting disclosure overcomes capital flows problem while clear securities framework helps lower volatility. Accounting disclosure should improve so that firms are abled to be monitored and controlled by government (Hooper, 2002). In addition, higher interest rates in emerging capital markets leads to adverse selection and moral hazard problem. Adverse selection normally occurs when interest rates are high as borrowers invest in extremely risky investment without lenders’ knowledge. While moral hazard arises when borrowers invest in projects they had not agreed to. This can lead to increase in cost of borrowing for other borrowers. Thus, encouraging accounting disclosure helps to reduce adverse selection and moral hazard. For example, Thailand and South-East Asian faced moral hazard due to deficient accounting disclosure and comprehensive regulation (Hooper, 2002). Besides, transparent information helps heal economic growth through effective resource allocation (Stiglitz, 2000). IMF and World Bank should also emphasis on binding constraints on economic growth by finding ways to correct the constraints. It is important for an economy to use the appropriate tools in reducing the constraints. For instance, reforming financial intermediaries will not improve investment with poor property rights. Thus, binding constraints have to be evaluated (Stiglitz, 1998). In conclusion, implementing Washington Consensus in emerging capital markets is not efficient. It deteriorated economic growth of many developing countries; for instance, East Asian and Latin America were in bad financial crisis. Moreover, the liberalization process also affects stock market of emerging countries by exacerbating stock markets’ volatility. Thus, International Monetary Fund and World Bank have to play their role by setting up efficient policies in order to curb problems arise from the implementation of Washington Consensus as well as improving the economy of emerging countries.

REFERENCE LISTS * Demetriades, P 1999, ‘Financial liberalization: the experience of developing countries’, Eastern Economic Journal, vol. 25, no. 4, pp. 441-457. * Hooper, V 1998, ‘Volatility and openness of emerging stock markets: some empirical evidence’, Emerging Capital Markets: Financial and Investment Issues, pp. 35-45. * Hooper, V 2002, ‘The Washington Consensus and Emerging Economies’, pp. 1-14. * Rodrik, D 2006, ‘Goodbye Washington Consensus, hello Washington Confusion’, pp. 1-28. * Stiglitz, J 1998, ‘More instruments and broader goals: moving toward the Post–Washington Consensus’, pp.1-46. * Stiglitz, JE 2000, ‘Capital market liberalization, economic growth, and instability’, World Development, vol. 28, no. 6, pp. 1075-1086.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    The International Monetary Fund (IMF) and the World Bank Group are two global institutions created to assist nations in becoming and remaining economically viable. Each plays an imporant role in the environment of international trade by helping maintain stability in the financial markets and by assisting countries that are seeking economic development and restructuring. Inadequate monetary reserves and unstable currencies are particularly vexing problems in global trade. So long as these conditions exist, world markets cannot develop and function as effectively as they should. To overcome these particular market barriers that plagued international trading before World War II, the International Monetary Fund (IMF) was formed. Originally 29 countries signed the agreement; now 184 countries are members. Among the objectives of the IMF are the stabilization of foreign exchange rates and the establishment of freely convertible currencies to facilitate the expansion and balanced growth of international trade. Member countries have voluntarily joined to consult with one another to maintain a stable system of buying and selling their currencies so that payments in oreign money can take place between countries smoothly and without delay. The IMF also lends money to members having trouble meeting financial obligations to other members. Argentina, Turkey, and Greece have recently received such help from the IMF, but the results have been mixed.…

    • 1154 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Best Essays

    Recent events have merely confirmed what economists have known for some time, namely, that the interconnectedness of global economic activity renders macro-management by single governments redundant. Their function is now to regulate markets to ensure economically efficient solutions.…

    • 3025 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    On a macroeconomic level, according to a United Nations’ study, “The recovery of the global economy continues, with strong output growth in developing countries and weaker economic performance in developed countries.” (UN, 2011)Even so higher energy and food cost are contributing to rising inflation rates. These indicators are mitigated by a stronger world trade of goods and services in 2010 compared to the year of 2009, it should be noted that Asian countries account for most of this growth. According to the above cited UN report, some of the risks witch may hamper the growth that is currently taking place may be the problem regarding the sustainability of public finance of developed countries, including the collapse of the dollar due to continued volatility of commodity prices. This doesn’t take in consideration the unpredictable area of policy making which outcomes cannot be accurately predicted.…

    • 749 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Levine, R., Zervos, S., 1998b. Capital control liberalization and stock market development. World Development 26, 1169±1183.…

    • 4310 Words
    • 18 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Best Essays

    [ 36 ]. M. Goldstein, Integrating Reform of Financial Regulation with Reform of the International Monetary System, Peterson Institute for International Economics, Working Paper No.11-5 (February 2011), pp. 5-7.…

    • 4146 Words
    • 17 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Fixed rates provide stability in international prices for the conduct of trade. Stable prices aid in the growth of international trade and lessen risks for all businesses. Fixed exchange rates are inherently anti-inflationary, requiring the country to follow restrictive monetary and fiscal policies. This restrictiveness, however, can often be a burden to a country wishing to pursue policies that alleviate continuing internal economic problems, such as high unemployment or slow economic growth. Fixed exchange rate regimes necessitate that central banks maintain large quantities of…

    • 2218 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The main concept of the article is to explain why the New International Financial Architecture (NIFA) was created and who is being benefited from this approach. The discussion begins with an examination of the power structures of the global political economy by focusing on the continued dominance of the USA. The article presents the contradictory relations between USA and global finance will be explored so as to shed more critical light on the NIFA. This article critically examines the NIFA by linking its institutional components to the larger contradictions of the capitalist inter-state system. A contradiction is the constant promotion of financial liberalization in emerging markets by US-led international financial institutions (IFIs), and the frequency of financial crises in the developing world, on the other. The article suggests that the NIFA is an attempt to stabilize and legitimate the scaffolding of the existing imperative of free capital mobility.…

    • 1391 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Many countries in Latin America fell into debt crisis in 1989 and Washington Consensus was raised to resolve this problem which was advocated by International monetary fund (IMF) and Word Bank (WB). The Washington Consensus, coined by John Williamson in 1990 and informed by neoliberal theory, supplied ten specific economic policies aiming at domestic economic reform in Latin America. The main objectives of those policies were to achieve economic growth and equitable income distribution in the developing world especially in Latin America but the results of the implementation of the policies did not fulfill the requirement as expected. This essay will evaluate the effect of Washington Consensus on emerging financial markets in terms of economic growth and volatility of stock market and suggest some recommendations for IMF and WB to conduct the policy in developing countries in the future. The essay will be demonstrated: the evaluation according to economic growth and stock market volatility and the recommendations suggested to IMF and WB.…

    • 1123 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Globalization is the interaction of world economies to become one big economy, for the sole purpose of enhancing free trade, growth and efficiency and employment. It emphasizes the neo-liberal economic policies – commonly referred to as the ‘Washington Consensus’ – of free trade, financial and capital market liberalization, deregulation and privatization (Juhasz, pg 408). The supporters of globalization argue that it is essential to an individual’s advancement and economic progress, and constantly reiterate that an integrated market economy will bring prosperity worldwide. Whereas, critics of globalization believe that without a proper framework and policies, the consequence of globalization will have a great impact on world politics, income inequality and environment (social services). In this paper, I will highlight the adverse affects and flaws of globalization policies that aim at promoting the notion of one unified economy. The focus will be on the critical analysis of the instruments and areas of globalization; that proponents continue to use to support their argument.…

    • 1731 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Capital control is an action taken by the government, central bank or other regulatory bodies to limit the inflow and outflow of foreign capital in the domestic economy. These controls include outright legislation, tariffs, restrictions on volume, taxes and market-based forces. These actions allow a country to preserve a fixed rate of exchange for its currency without risking its holdings of foreign currency reserves or hard currency. The problem, however, is that this control or preservation comes at a substantial cost, as many investors will not willing to invest the same levels of funds in that country.…

    • 1257 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    A common model used in assessing the relationship between financial development and economic growth is the McKinnon-Shaw model. As AK and Kara (2011) say, “according to McKinnon- Shaw, Levine and King, several restrictions (financial repression) imposed on the banking system by the government can slow down the development of the financial system and therefore, can cause negative results on economic growth.” The authors identify these negative results as things like compulsory high-level reserve applications, higher interest rates.…

    • 1246 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Exchange Rate

    • 7437 Words
    • 30 Pages

    Since the breakdown of the Bretton Woods system of fixed exchange rates, both real and nominal exchange rates have fluctuated widely. Under this system, each country’s central bank was obligated to intervene in the foreign exchange market to keep the exchange rate in a narrow band around the previously agree rate. This Bretton Woods system will encourage more open trade, finance and investment and lead to a period of rapid economic growth after World War 2.…

    • 7437 Words
    • 30 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Cross Border Capital Flows

    • 3621 Words
    • 15 Pages

    As with many public goods, global stability is “undersupplied.” This is partly due to market failures that may warrant policy adjustments, but also because individual countries may not take full account of the effects of their policies on other countries and on the system as a whole. Indeed, a survey conducted by the G20 showed that the vast majority of authorities either were unaware or unable to quantify the impact on capital flows of their own policies, although several pointed to spillovers from the policies of others.…

    • 3621 Words
    • 15 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Developing countries are mainly used to control capital to store the local economy from the free forces flowing into the international capital market. The developing countries find themselves trapped in the globalization of capital flows and the enormous powers of the global market, which increases the financial vulnerability of developing countries. Many developing countries maintain a series of controls over capital flows and foreign exchange flows to buy goods and services.…

    • 1247 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    IPE is about interplay of economics and politics in world affairs. The core question of IPE is: what drives and explains events in the world economy? For some peoplethis comes down to a battle of ‘states versus markets’. The ‘markets’ for world economy are not like local Street bazaars in which all items can be openly and competitively traded and exhanged. Equally, politicians cannot rule the global economy. World markets and countries, local firms and multinational corporations that trade and invest within them are all shaped by layers of rules, norms, laws, organizations an deven habits. Political scientists like to call all these features of the system institutions. The relationship between states and markets was highlighted by the fact that some states failed to restrain their financial markets. Relations between so called North and South were transforment as emerging economies carved out a new position for themselves in international institutions including in the new G20, while other developing countries remained marginalized. Perhaps suprisingly, the international economic institutions used to manage the crisis were those created in the aftermath of the WWII, in spite of widespread agreement that they needed updating.…

    • 794 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics