Preview

Eisenstein's Use of Montage and Shot

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
580 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Eisenstein's Use of Montage and Shot
How does Eisenstein use montage and shot composition to create a dramatic effect on film?

Eisenstein’s strong use of montage editing and shot composition effectively builds drama and conflict in Battleship Potemkin and its “Odessa Steps” scene. His choice of framed image conveys emotion and, along with camera position, engages and appeals to the viewer. The montage editing technique that Eisenstein uses creates a sense of conflict that supports the conflict and tension of the narrative.

The marching boots create a rhythm that Eisenstein juxtaposes with the chaotic crowd scenes. The editing of the marching scene is out of sync with the marching itself. This montage editing generates a feeling of conflict. Similarly Eisenstein cuts between the rhythmic rolling of the pram and close-up horrified reactions of the people around the pram. He builds suspense and creates a connection between the film and the audience, reflecting the sheer insanity of the scene. As the massacre plays out, Eisenstein increases the pace of the editing, adding further to the tension and excitement. This style of editing allows the brain to believe the edits are created by real events, rather than a director’s deliberate intent.

The framed images in the film are carefully chosen. Close-up shots of characters’ faces convey raw emotion by showing their expressions in graphic detail. For example, the full frame shot of the mother’s horrified face at seeing her boy lying shot creates empathy in the viewer who feels just as horrified. The shots of lines of boots marching down the steps creates a tense rhythm, building a sense of inevitability and making the soldiers seem inhumane. The intensity builds dramatic effect. The soldiers’ faces are not shown, unlike the faces of the fleeing crowd. The medium shot of the mother cradling her fallen son is a powerful one; one woman defying an army. The soldiers’ shadows falling across her and the line of rifles themselves create a sense of her being

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    In the movie, I really learned about war and warfare. You really can’t understand just how heart wrenching and scary it can be while ducking bullets and watching your comrades die, unless you are there. Imagine this: you are sending off screaming bullets while dodging them. All of a sudden, you hear a thump as one of your fellow soldiers fall to the ground beside you, you’ve heard the words “retreat” many times…

    • 431 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The film transported you to an atmosphere in 19th century United Staes that felt realistic. The costumes and the weaponry felt very authentic. It was especially powerful to see the tattered soldiers, wounded and bandaged up. The dead soldiers lying lifeless were very realistic. The viewer is…

    • 508 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The use of distinctively visual images allows an audience to perceive and distinguish the composer’s specific representation. From these distinctive visuals, the audience’s perceptions force them to respond in a particular way. In ‘Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon’, Ang Lee utilises a range of film techniques to position his audience through a combination of quiet, dramatic scenes and choreographed action sequences. In his painting, ‘Third of May, 1808’ Fransisco Goya conveys meaning exclusively with distinctively visual techniques. Both the composers are able to effectively convey their message and immerse the responder in the different aspects of the texts.…

    • 923 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Similar shots are used throughout the movie as the sisters share a bed, and these shots also seem to be intentional to enforce Sally’s motherly role. The concept of motherhood is extended upon in the film when a mother in the settlement losses her baby after the Natives attack. During her panic, the mother is given a close-up in the centre of the frame so that the audience can see her dishevelled appearance with her widened eyes and messy hair. Therefore, the film is implying that a mother without her baby becomes savage like the wild Native people because it’s a woman’s civilized duty to protect her infant. In a later shot, the mother aimlessly stumbles around in the frame as the loss of her baby has driven her almost mad. She is framed with a medium-long shot that cuts off the top of her head to enforce her mindlessness. Smoke surrounds the pro-filmic space to illustrate how out of place she is in a war-setting. She is powerless in this sort of situation in comparison to the white men, who are currently fighting, as enforced by the numerous long-shots of the battle. In contrast, Native women are portrayed like Native…

    • 624 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    For example, In Edward Scissorhands, Peg invites Edward into her house and is showing him pictures of her family. When a picture of Peg’s daughter, Kim catches his eye, close up shot is used to show Edward is romantically attracted to her. Edward’s feelings for her is expressed by the use of close-up shot. Another use of Shots and Framing is when Edward escapes from the town and goes back to mansion on the hill. Kim and Edward are both in love with each other at this point in the movie. Two shot is used to show expression the strong feelings and interactions the two have for each…

    • 537 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Soviet Montage cinema developed their own style of editing in which a series of unrelated images were pieced together to connect the message and story. An example of a well-known Montage film is The Man with the Movie Camera (1929) directed by Dziga Vertov. This film featured a startling amount of different shots of nearly anything that is to be found in the city, accompanied by a rather modern-sounding soundtrack. As it is experimental, there is no clear storyline, and Vertov’s intention seemed to be showing rather than telling. Classical Hollywood editing uses continuity editing, a technique…

    • 599 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    Eisenstein Montage Lists

    • 3942 Words
    • 16 Pages

    The montage lists are technique prepared prior to shooting and entailed a careful concentration of pieces chosen for their capacity to express a developing line of thought, or emotion. The shaping of an image evolved through associational logic, whereby one sense image chased after another; but the development of inner rhythm of the work became an increasingly complex system of unity in diversity. Eisenstein’s montage lists provided a methodological model for Kracauer’s History: The Last Things Before the Last. The montage lists composed by the Soviet filmmaker for the creation of interior monologue of protagonist Clyde Griffiths in An American Tragedy, the product of Eisenstein’s 1930s American visit led Kracauer to the insight that the multiplicity of factors and computations within any historical situation meant that any historical explanation must, by its very nature, be provisional. Eisenstein’s distinction between the depiction reality and creation of a global image is in way similar to that made by the Marxist…

    • 3942 Words
    • 16 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    montage is constructed specifically with the intention to provoke a response from the audiences or to also feature as a shock tactic in the documentary. The visuals begin in the hallways of…

    • 147 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The Sopranos Camera

    • 3085 Words
    • 13 Pages

    In the film they used 45 and 90-degree shutters to sustain actors movements and expressions and a certain crispiness in the explosions to make them look more realistic. The shots used in this film were mainly mid shots and close ups to show the expression of the soldiers being scared and when they are shell-shocked which adds to the realism. The location also looks so real where they filmed it because it looks really rundown and it does look like a real wasteland/battlefield type location. I think that the film became desaturated with the dulled effect was to bring out the tragedy and emotions in the film. By adding this desaturation, it made the film look more explicit, violent and disturbing. Sound is key to add to the realism in Spielberg’s film because music plays a big role in films and the audience judge whether they like the film or not, purely because of the sound used. In the opening battle scene, you can immediately hear gunfire fulfil the air as they are charging towards the beach. The sound mainly includes gunfire, and bomb explosions. This is a good technique that they have used because it makes the dialogue barely audible and the reason why the director has done this is to demonstrate and emphasise to the audience the reality of difficulties in the war. Spielberg applies imaginative ways of sound placement and sound deprivation to help the audience connect to…

    • 3085 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    American Sniper Theme

    • 666 Words
    • 3 Pages

    With contrast to high angle shots, the close up of the tank treads symbolises the destructive power and the sense of war which shows the established rivalry between the Americans and the Iraqi. This contrasts to the second significant scene in the middle of the film which is used to position the audience to be on the American’s side who are shown to be the light in a dark and dangerous place. In this scene we see an Iraqi soldier hiding in a dark doorway with bright white colours symbolising heaven, helping to emphasize the fact that death and war is near as the American’s stroll through the building to not be scared by violence. This then introduces us near the end of the film to the last significant scene of the film where the primary villain, the Iraqi sniper is portrayed. In this scene, Kyle and his team are ambushed by the sniper who is hiding away on a rooftop of an old building. Because the sniper is higher than Kyle, it is leaving Kyle exposed, vulnerable and weak which forces the Americans to abort and run from the…

    • 666 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The film uses graphic images to portray what the battle scene was really like. It shows how the American troops were outnumbered and how they were fighting literally within feet of the enemy. The images in the movie that we seen are as close to as what it was really like, because there was a photographer there taking pictures during combat. The pictures that the photographer shot during battle helped us visualize what the battle scenes were really like and the pain and anguish that soldiers went through when fighting. The images of soldiers dying during combat and the reality of the battle helps to portray the bloodiness of the battle. Hollywood used good images to try to portray the movie to make it look exactly as it was at the actual battle in 1965. Some black and white photographs of the actual battle scene in 1965 were in the film so that the viewer could see real images of the battle and what soldiers had to go through to survive the…

    • 1733 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    She uses a slide presentation of the photographs she took to emphasize the physical trauma cluster bombs have caused. In addition, her photographs seem to focus the survivors’ faces for added effect.…

    • 663 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Another way the author shows this appalling theme is through the use of characters. As the soldiers talk, you can see their mood and personalities; ironically this reflects how war has affected their minds and personal lifes. As the story develops you can see how the characters' life changes and how their thought of fear develops inside them. The soldiers manage to get use to the war environment, but they became more cold and less emotional. This ironic aspect expresses violence and death because after a solder has been to war, their whole aspect of life changes.…

    • 392 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Even the Native American, who should stick out like a sore thumb, is hidden from our view. I believe the artist was successfully able to do this through the usage of gaze through other peoples’ eyes. As you can see, everyone in the crowd is looking at General Wolfe. Further analysis of this crowd shows that they all have different uniforms on, signaling their different ranks among the army. Despite this difference they all have on thing in common, and that is the expression of concern for General Wolfe. By including all of these elements, West continues to dramatize the death of General Wolfe. By doing so, it furthermore emphasizes the importance of General Wolfe’s death. Their sadden deposition again puts much more notion on the worthy motive in which Wolfe died for. In a way, it makes the viewers sympathetic towards the General and that he should be commemorate for his…

    • 557 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    This photograph is for Simone Segouin who is considered a symbol of the French resistance fighters, 1944. I can say that this photography is really eye catching. Seeing a woman in unusual situation can attract a large number of viewers. The first thing I can see as binary opposites is woman and man, this is physically clear. short and long trousers can be mentioned too; Simone is wearing short while the two men are wearing long trousers. Seeing a gun refers to death and life, also Indoor and outdoor as I can see clearly that Simon and the two soldiers are standing outdoors. Black and white is another binary opposite, which is symbolizes the old period taken this picture. I can also say peace and war because it shows soldiers who are trying…

    • 217 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays