Commom Pleas Court
Q. 1Probibility of Cases
Being Appealed and
Q. 2 Probability of
Q.3 Probability of
Judge
Reversed
Appeal
Rank Reversal
Rank
Fred Cartolano
0.04511
14
0.00395
Thomas Crush
0.03529
4
0.00297
Patrick Dinkelacker
0.03498
3
0.00636
Timothy Hogan
0.03071
2
0.00358
Robert Kraft
0.04047
10
0.00223
William Matthews
0.04019
7
0.00795
William Morrissey
0.03991
6
0.00726
Norbert Nadel
0.04427
13
0.00676
Arthur Ney Jr.
0.03883
5
0.00435
Richard Niehaus
0.04086
11
0.00477
Thomas Nurre
0.04033
8
0.002
John O'Connor
0.04345
12
0.00404
Robert Ruehlman
0.04524
15
0.00562
J. Howard Sundermann Jr.
0.06283
16
0.01047
Ann Marie Tracey
0.04043
9
0.00414
Ralph Winkler
0.02849
1
0.00194
Total
0.0446
0.65139
0.07839
6
4
12
5
3
15
14
13
9
10
2
7
11
16
8
1
Q. 4 Conditional
Probability of Reversal
Given Appeal
Rank
0.08759
0.08403
0.18182
0.11667
0.05512
0.19780
0.18182
0.15267
0.11200
0.11679
0.04959
0.09302
0.12414
0.16667
0.10236
0.06818
1.89027
Data Analysis Regarding Municipal Court
Judge
Mike Allen
Nadine Allen
Timothy Black
David Davis
Leslie Isaiah Gaines
Karla Grady
Deidra Hair
Dennis Helmick
Timothy Hogan
James Patrick Kenney
Joseph Luebbers
William Mallory
Melba Marsh
Beth Mattingly
Albert Mestemaker
Mark Painter
Jack Rosen
Mark Schweikert
David Stockdale
John A. West
Total
Q. 1Probibility of Cases
Being Appealed and
Reversed
Q. 2 Probability of
Q.3 Probability of
Appeal
Rank Reversal
Rank
0.00699
20
0.00065
0.00435
9
0.00077
0.00515
12
0.00075
0.00556
15
0.00065
0.00663
19
0.00246
0.00114
1
0
0.00197
3
0
0.00367
6
0.00063
0.00563
17
0.00087
0.00214
4
0.00036
0.00532
14
0.00170
0.00459
11
0.00109
0.00414
8
0.00085
0.00438
10
0.00034
0.00563
16
0.00181
0.00313
5
0.00134
0.00526
13
0.00167
0.00611
18
0.00111
0.00410
7
0.00074
0.00143
2
0.00072
108.464
0.08732
0.01851
6
10
9
5
19
1
1
4
12
3
17
13
11
2
18
15
16
14
8
7
Q. 4 Conditional
Probability of Reversal
Given Appeal
Rank
0.09302
0.17647
0.14634
0.11628