Preview

Essay Comparing Machiavelli And Romeo Dallaire

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
411 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Essay Comparing Machiavelli And Romeo Dallaire
Essay: Machiavelli compared to Romeo Dallaire The Rwandan genocide of 1994 was the largest mass slaughter of human beings since the Holocaust. Canadian Lieutenant-General Romeo Dallaire, commander of the UN Assistance Mission in Rwanda, tasked with overseeing the Arusha Accords and the transition of government. Dallaire soon realized something much more critical was being set in motion. A doomed mission in hindsight after watching the documentary, Shake Hands with The Devil. Stationed without a sufficient number of troops or weaponry to combat such an insurmountable force of people, Romeo Dallaire, as the commanding officer, realized he would have difficult decisions to make over the course of his mission. What do Romeo Dallaire’s actions …show more content…
In connection with Romeo Dallaire and whether or not Machiavelli would either support or oppose Dallaire’s decisions in Rwanda as the highest ranking officer these characteristics must be analyzed. Although it is impossible to personify every desirable trait, one must decide where their priorities lay. It is said that in terms of battle, a commander's concern must be focused on war, its institutions, and its discipline. In connection with the documentary, Dallaire is not only there for the mission “on the ground” but also to follow and convey orders from within the hierarchy of his superiors at UN headquarters in New York. Nothing is possible without support from the international community. The first few paragraphs we read in class paraphrase to - “an unarmed man is unsafe and despised in the eyes of armed men”. In regard to Dallaire's decisions, it was better to protect his men against a well-armed militia who outnumbered them and to not engage ill-equipped and underfunded. Lieutenant-General Romeo Dallaire represented his own compassion for the native people but also understood his mission prior to the plane crash which triggered the 100-day massacre and to save the lives of those under his command. Before the triggered events to follow Dallaire executed all mission mandates successfully through many setbacks, he was known for his

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Romeo Dallaire Analysis

    • 551 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Senator Romeo Dallaire was a Lieutenant-General in the Canadian army in 1946. He was sent to Rwanda in 1993 to enforce peace agreements between the Hutu’s and the Tutsis. He was more or less set up for failure however because he did not have nearly as much soldiers as he needed. The inevitable happened and Senator Dallaire found himself as a witness to one of the greatest tragedies we have seen this century. The result of this “peace agreement” ended up with over 800,000 people dead and about 1.4 million in refuge. The most griping story that Dallaire told was when he was getting out of his army truck and was greeted by an eleven year old boy pointing an AK-47 (rifle) into his nostril. To this day Senator Dallaire swears the only reason this boy did not kill him right then and there was because he was holding a candy bar in his hand.…

    • 551 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    ignoring the problem, but they are actually exacerbating it by telling the government, which is composed of the perpetrators. Furthermore, the United Nations strengthened their restrictions and reminded Romeo not to intervene during the genocide. This proved to be unsuccessful because, as Dallaire perfectly points out, the only way to save them is through communication and negotiation. Romeo’s problems became even worse after the U.N. Security Council also refused to help. Yet Dallaire refused to leave Rwanda during the genocide, despite his lack of support.…

    • 717 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Lao-Tzu’s writings offered a basis for Taoism, a religion officially founded by Chang Tao-ling in about 150 A.D. However, the Tao-te Ching is an ethical document as much as about good government as it is about moral behavior. Niccolo Machiavelli was an aristocrat who had his ups and downs according the shifts in power in Florence. His writings encourage a prince to secure power by almost any means necessary. Lao-Tzu’s Thoughts from the Tao-te Ching and Niccolo Machiavelli’s The Qualities of the Prince both have main goals of how to mold a better prince. Their views on government and the ways they attain their goals each differ in method.…

    • 839 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Essay On Romeo Dallaire

    • 557 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Firstly, Romeo Dallaire has been continuously fighting for human rights and world peace around the world. In 1993, Roméo Dallaire took command in the U.N peacekeeping mission in Rwanda. He desperately tried to prevent the imminent genocide despite orders from the United Nations to fall back. “The genocide occurred swiftly and massively. In the 100 days between 6 April and 16 July 1994, an estimated 800,000 men, women and children were brutally killed” (Bonikowsky, Romeo Dallaire). In spite of this, “Dallaire saved over 200,000 Tutsis and Hutu moderates…

    • 557 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Every case of genocide and mass murder has its own story and anotherness, they also didn’t happen in the blink of an eye. The perpetrators of these events have always had a fundamental reason to what led them to execute such gruesome crimes. Most may know, the German holocaust and the Rwandan genocide are the two most known and most terrible violation of human rights because of the amount of people that were killed and the way in which these murders were performed. This essay is a discussion of key similarities and differences of the roles of perpetrators in the two case studies; Rwandan genocide and the German…

    • 109 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The Rwandan Genocide occurred during the latter part of the Rwandan Civil War after the assassination of former president Juvénal Habyarimana. Close associates of Habyarimana believed the Tutsis to be behind his assassination, thus prompting procession of a planned extermination of the Tutsis (Des Forges, pp.6). Nonetheless, the systematic killing was a result of a multitude of events for which the assassination served as a breaking…

    • 1826 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the play Romeo and Juliet by William Shakespeare, Benvolio is more civilized than Tybalt. To begin, Benvolio is respectful towards his kin. In a conversation with Montague, Benvolio wishes that “[his] noble uncle…so please [himself], step aside” (Shakespeare 1.1.140-153). Benvolio addresses his uncle with the utmost respect and politeness, depicting his civilized nature. Next, Benvolio tries to avoid violence. Upon seeing a fight, Benvolio intervenes to try and “put up [their] swords” (1.1.63). Benvolio’s trying to avoid a conflict demonstrates his civil actions. Unlike Benvolio, Tybalt is uncivilized. First, Tybalt does not respect the wishes of his uncle. Instead of doing as Capulet bids, Tybalt expresses to his “uncle, ’tis a shame” (1.5.82). Rather than politely doing as he is told, Tybalt snaps back rudely to his elder, illustrating his uncivil side. Whereas Benvolio asks his respected uncle to step aside politely, Tybalt disregards Capulet’s wishes and even retorts with a saucy comment, hence displaying his lack of civility in comparison to Benvolio. Moreover, Tybalt welcomes a fight. When given the chance to avoid using violence, Tybalt does not “excuse the injuries/that [Romeo] has done [him]; therefore [turns] and [draws]” (3.1.65-66). Instead of calmly forgiving and forgetting past offences, Tybalt intends to fight with Romeo. Tybalt is being uncivil towards Romeo, as he is trying to start a conflict with him when unnecessary. In contrast to Benvolio, who does his best to avoid fights, Tybalt strives for a conflict, hence proving him the less civil of the two. In conclusion, Benvolio is more respectful and peaceful than Tybalt, proving him to be the more civilized…

    • 269 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Human Rights Dbq Analysis

    • 591 Words
    • 3 Pages

    To elaborate, despite the UN’s clear outline as to what constitutes a genocide, the UN refused to provide help to the Cambodians who were being “...executed in the hundreds of thousands…” due to the fact that they were considered “intellectuals” (Doc 4). This illustrates how the UN disregarded their proclamation of what defines a genocide, and would not react against the apparent human-right violations, as well as the mass killings caused by Pol Pot’s Khmer Rouge. Furthermore, the UN would not intervene with the Rwandan genocide, in which Hutu extremists brutally slaughtered the majority of the Tutsi population; the UN decided to “[not] reinforce the small and lightly armed UN blue helmets already in Rwanda…”(Doc 7). The withdrawal of funds and supportive equipment for the Rwandan UN soldiers goes to show that the UN refused to acknowledge the atrocious genocide that was taking place in Rwanda. It also illustrates that the United Nations acted as more of a peanut gallery by pleading ignorance than a peace group that halts genocidal…

    • 591 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    When Hutu fears that the Rwandan Patriot Front was gaining increased power grew, extremist Hutus formed a group called the Interhamwe to resist the RPF. While Hutu president Habyarimana grew desperate to gain support of Hutus following a series of failed promises, he saw an opportunity in the Interhamwe to balance forces and resist the RPF. In 1992, RPF forces mobilized, revolting against the Hutus. Habyarimana took action, trying to silence the RPF, and, as described in Country Torn Apart, “unleashed a campaign of violence against Tutsi civilians.” (Pg. 57). This is significant because it shows the steps that the Interhamwe took to silence political opposition. These campaigns of violence escalated to a higher level of organized killings, and, as described in Country Torn Apart, “about 8000 Tutsis were jailed, tortured, raped, and beaten” (Pg. 57). This evidence is significant because it shows the escalation of conflict between the Interhamwe and the RPF, ultimately leading to the genocide of the Tutsis by the Interhamwe. While this escalation was momentarily paused by the cease-fire declared by Habyarimana, the mysterious plane crash that led to Habvarimana’s death jump-started tension again, and, as described in Country Torn Apart, “The death of the president immediately sent shock waves across…

    • 1330 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Shakespeare's Macbeth, the main character, Macbeth, can be compared in many was to a Machiavellian prince. Macbeth's ambition to be king and his desire for power are the basis of Machiavelli's ideas, but when examined more closely we find many flaws in Macbeth's character that Machiavelli warns will be destructive. Although Macbeth has many Machiavellian characteristics, Macbeth's rise to power without true "fortune" or "virtue" leads him to his downfall.…

    • 804 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Canada In Rwanda

    • 642 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The fighting and outcry of Rwanda began to grab the attention of world leaders. Peacekeeping missions were a priority to stop the genocide. In October 1994, the United Nations formed the United Nations Assistance Mission in Rwanda. The main objective of this mission was to end the civil war in Rwanda. Canada was asked to take leadership of UNAMIR and 2500 military personnel. Canada was to cooperate with nations including Belgium and the United Kingdom on this assistance mission. Canadian general Romeo Dallaire was put in charge of the mission. The setup seemed to be heading in the right direction. However, Complications occurred for Canada, while UNAMIR was deployed in Rwanda, Proper protocol was for UNAMIR to remain hands off while dealing with genocide. This meant no armed conflict was to be used while in Rwanda. Too further complicate the mission, Romeo Dallare said “Now, in this U.N. stuff, the commander, although he has troops, they don't really belong to him. They're loaned by the country to the U.N. to be used, but each of these countries provide a contingent commander, a senior guy who communicates directly back to his capital.” This meant UNAMIR was not a typical military force, each military personnel were from different countries around the world, so miscommunication occurred because of the different cultures,…

    • 642 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Nazi genocide and the reign of terror Hitler inflicted on the Jews during WWII is not unique. Rwanda suffered an equally brutal reign of terror in 1994. However, not many people are aware of the genocide. It was not until the film “Hotel Rwanda” by Terry George, was released as a direct result of the genocide that the world took cognisance of this atrocity.…

    • 1505 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Raphael Lemkin Trial

    • 2240 Words
    • 9 Pages

    The U.N. Commission’s report on Darfur would set the stage for the “genocide” deliberation. The events found in the report indisputably prove acts of genocide. However, according to Alex de Waal, “ The question of intent is somewhat more ambiguous. There is no demonstrated intent to eliminate physically an entire ethnic group, and—with the exception of the Nuba in 1992-1993—no attempt to wholly eliminate the identity of a group. Both the stated and the real aim has been to subjugate.” Though de Waal clearly did not understand that genocide could be committed against a group in part, his discussion of the confusion over intent is vital. As such, the issue of intent in the convention has allowed the Sudanese governments, as well as numerous others, to evade justice by justifying their actions in the context of military and political threats as counter-insurgency. (de Waal, 28) However, Darfur set an important precedent when the Secretary of State Colin Powell deemed it genocide and sent abundant humanitarian aid, but then noted that U.S. policy would not change. If the duty to intervene was placed on specific countries, such as those of the Security Council, who are able to intervene, this conflict could be avoided altogether. Moreover, even U.N. agencies have been highly effective in providing humanitarian aid, yet absent in action.…

    • 2240 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In The Gay Science, Friedrich Nietzsche talks about how “To grow tired of a possession is to grow tired of ourselves,” and how sexual love is “a craving for a new property.” In The Prince, Niccolo Machiavelli talks about “whether it is better to be loved rather than feared, or feared rather than loved.” In Nietzsche’s text he focuses on how greed and love are similar to each other, while in Machiavelli’s text he contrast the idea of being feared rather than loved. The arrangement of both texts clearly show how their ideas demonstrate their unique style of writing, using different examples two prove their points.…

    • 1410 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Machiavelli Essay

    • 1055 Words
    • 5 Pages

    How commendable in a prince it is to keep his word and live with integrity, not making use of cunning and subtlety, everyone knows well. Yet we see by experience in these our days that those princes have effected great matters who have made small reckoning of keeping their words and have known by their craft to turn and wind men about and in the end have overcome those who have grounded upon the truth.…

    • 1055 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays