Preview

Ethical Dilemmas In The Crucible '

Satisfactory Essays
Open Document
Open Document
671 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Ethical Dilemmas In The Crucible '
Alexandra Rodriguez, Sydnie Sephton
Mrs. Philipose
Humanities 1 - 1st
20 February 2018
Prompt #2
Ethan seemed moral in the beginning, but slowly got out of it by cheating on his wife with her cousin, Mattie. He seemed to spend as much time with her as possible, and got close to her whenever he had the opportunity to do so.
Zenobia showed to be sickly more frequently throughout the years she spent married to Ethan. She went out for days at times, just to go to various doctors. He gave her enough by providing the money she needed (among other human necessities), yet never more than that. A lack of connection (whether it be love, friendship, or otherwise) nearly presented a reason for avoidance, but having each other as a spouse bound them together
…show more content…
Women are classified as girls, because they were meant for all around housework (cooking, cleaning, washing, etc). Without her husband, she can not make any profit to afford a house for herself. This is where his morals came in to prevent abandonment. Another problem arose with both Ethan’s parents dying early on.
Ethan proved a morally inadequate man, though never a constant in his life. It all started with the death of his parents. After the incident, he moved back to Starkfield and had later on met Zeena. The death of Ethan’s parents affected him in a way where he couldn’t bare the thought of loneliness Ethan’s mood would have differed if his mother had not died in winter. After marrying Zeena, he couldn’t move back to the big city to become an engineer because he had to take care of her. She had also became silent and began complaining a lot; this had started affecting their relationship and their feelings for each
…show more content…
For all of his life, he had lived in the sight and sound of Mattie Silver, and he could no longer conceive of its being otherwise” (1.32). Zenobia had oppressed Ethan, which caused him to develop a disliking towards her, and to stop seeing her as a person. Ethan disfavors hurting people but instead he hurt Zeena anyway. Him expressing dishonesty and cheating on her with Mattie had downgraded his role as a man, husband, and as a person. Little mistakes and actions had then started to develop, spreading the problem to become even worse.
“You wanted to make the supper-table pretty; and you waited till my back was turned, and took the thing I set the most store by of anything I’ve got-” (7.126). Here, in a way, Zanobia called Ethan out on his actions. It originally started as Mattie’s fault for leaving out the plate (lead to the cat to hit against it), having the couple to argue about how things have changed since she’s arrived. Ethan at first, meekly defends Mattie and thinks about going off on Zeena, but decides against it. Ethan has the right to defend Mattie, but what he wanted to do or say is not appropriate, especially in front of his

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    The tragic novel turned movie, Ethan Frome, has two main female roles: Zeena and Mattie. These two women have very diverse personalities. Zeena can be best described a controlling, over-bearing, self absorbed person who thrives for attention. On the opposite, Mattie can be looked at as lively and free spirited. But as we continued watching the movie we saw some major changes in both of these characters, some physical and some psychological.…

    • 659 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In this chapter, Zeena voiced her health problems and told Ethan that she was going to leave for Bettsbridge to visit a doctor for her pains. As she explained the plan and who she would travel with, Ethan showed no feeling of worry or concern. He automatically agreed to everything, and did not offer to go with her or ask if she needed anything. Notably, he lied about his plans so he would not have to ‘bear the encumbrance’ of dropping her off. Additionally, this was because he has extreme feelings for Mattie, whom he does not wish to leave. Zeena must have felt hurt by the fact that her own husband did not feel anything for her. For this reason, it almost seems as if before Zeena left, she had to ‘establish her dominance’ with Mattie. Perhaps this sprouted a feeling of self consciousness. For example, the tone in which she specifically pushed the empty bottle and told her a job she has to do is much more commanding. It gives a feeling of superiority to Zeena so Mattie feels threatened to not go after Ethan. To further explain, the quote is ‘if you can get the taste out’ which makes the statement sound even more demeaning as it is asking if she has the capability to do such a simple task of properly cleaning a…

    • 2257 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Edith Wharton’s Ethan Frome, juxtaposes the treatment and attention Ethan directs to Zeena and Mattie. The different treatment between the two further reveals Ethan’s internal selfish thoughts to be with Mattie. As Ethan and Mattie have more interactions and time to themselves, “The grow of passion he had felt for her had melted into an aching tenderness” (Wharton 85). Ethan’s selfishness is the antagonist of Ethan and Zeena’s marriage, and it acts as a barrier to the struggle between his affection for Mattie and his existing relationship. Although Ethan’s selfish desires to be with Mattie are shameful, he stoops to beyond a level of inconceivable selfishness, and schemes to flee Starkfield in order to escape Zeena to forever…

    • 283 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Before Naomi reads Aunt Emily’s letters, she is surrounded by “a silence that will not speak” (preface). Naomi always asks questions about her past while “expecting no response” (31). Naomi, filled with dullness, stops asking questions. She bottles her curiosity instead of looking for answers. Naomi, after finding the answers, starts to feel emotions other than dullness. For example, when Naomi realized that places like the “Pool” and “Sick Bay” were prisons, she felt disgusted that people could be “kept there like animals” (92). After Naomi reads of what happened to her mother, she is “not thinking of forgiveness”(288) towards the government like she thought. Naomi, after unleashing her emotions, suddenly sees that her mother “remains in the voicelessness”(289). Finding that her mother represents the silence, Naomi listens to hear her…

    • 678 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    around the house so she takes Mattie in. Ethan begins to develop an attraction to Mattie that he didn’t have with Zeena. Zeena begins to have “complications” that deteriorate the little bit of health that she still had (61). Ethan is responsible for Zeena’s complications becoming worse because of the lack of love and affection he gives to her; as a result of his neglect Zeena thinks herself worse. Ethan’s desires for Mattie triumph against his obligations to his…

    • 557 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    yelled at him for not giving Beth the camera, instead of talking to him and seeing where…

    • 589 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Ethan realizes his own impulsiveness and flawed character, becomes aware of his flaws, proving that he fits the archetype of a tragic hero yet again. Ethan was going to deceive kindly Mrs. Hale into giving him money. However, he took a step back and saw his situation in a different light, saying “With the sudden perception of the point to which his madness had carried him, the madness fell and [Ethan] saw his life before him as it was.” (113). Ethan is so desperate to escape from his situation at home that he feels the need to take advantage of others. Ethan's impulsiveness persists, and he commits suicide when he is no longer able to face his dark…

    • 691 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Wharton depicts Zeena as old, cold, and insensitive while Mattie is warm, loving, kind, and most importantly, a much more fitting wife for Ethan. Symbolism is used in the form of Mattie’s red scarf to give Mattie a sense of life and loving warmth, while at the same time giving Zeena a colder appearance. Therefore, Wharton makes Ethan’s desire to leave his ghastly wife for another woman considerate in the eyes of the reader. Yet, just like in the case of his engineering career, Ethan cannot bear to leave Zeena, on the account that society would severely frown upon a husband that abandons his sickly wife. He is torn between following what he knows is the “right” thing to do, and following what he knows will make him happy. It is important to note that his love for Mattie never falters—The conflict is external, not internal. He is afraid of what people would think, and not whether or not he loves Mattie. Although he has one night alone with Mattie, he cannot stop thinking about all of the responsibilities placed on him. His strong desire for Mattie eventually leads to the shattering of his marriage, which is symbolized by the shattering of Zeena’s prized wedding red pickle…

    • 965 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Although Frome’s actions seem to contain merit, his vacuity is what causes him to live in constant moral isolation. The author foreshadows Ethan’s fate with an allusion to a grave: “SACRED TO THE MEMORY OF ETHAN FROME AND ENDURANCE HIS WIFE…” (Wharton 70). This depicts Frome’s tragic end to a great extent, because he does not die a physical death, but rather a mental demise. Frome’s poor judgement of allowing Mattie to convince him to commit suicide resulted in him being trapped in moral isolation. Furthermore, it resulted in Mattie becoming paralyzed, while Zeena was left to tend to both individuals for the rest of their lives. Frome was left to endure the consequences of his plight. He was also left with a resentful Mattie, who realized that Frome had truly destroyed her. Frome was a “prisoner for life” (Wharton 117) and would continue to be tormented by the constant reminder of his failure and lack of…

    • 852 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Ethan Frome Theme Essay

    • 555 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Picture yourself, trapped in a lackluster world, where everything seems to have a shade of gray. Everyone around you seems to be moving in an excessively slow pace. Yet you’re not able to leave that place, not being able to find a hint of love or joy anywhere you look. That place is called Starkfield, a place where Ethan Frome lives in the novel by Edith Wharton. Ethan is constantly held back by his wife Zeena, not being able to experience much emotion because of her, acting like a leash to a dog. Merely waking up everyday seems like an excruciating task, draining all of the energy out of him. Zeena Frome is like the world, placed on Atlas’s shoulders. Zeena is the greatest hindrance to Ethan Frome and his ability to be free and live a joyful life, bringing negativity to Ethan’s life.…

    • 555 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Although Zeena is Ethan's wife, Ethan is repelled by Zeena's constant illnesses and what is portrayed as a miserable marriage. The author used extensive characterization to describe Zeena as a gruesome, aging, flat-chested, angry, and fun-sucking person. This characterization is what turned the reader away from Zeena and edged them towards Ethan's side. Ethan often contemplated moving away to live and pursue a relationship with Mattie, but his conscience destroyed that dream. Even though Zeena was old and grotesque, she was still Ethan's wife, and it would have been morally wrong for Ethan to divorce Zeena to marry a younger and prettier, Mattie Silver. Ethan knew this and he understood it well. Sometimes when he thought of Mattie his conscience would leave him, but it would always come back before he made a…

    • 768 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    To take personal responsibility means that you are recognizing that you made a mistake and must do your best to fix it. When people say to take responsibility, they mean they want you to acknowledge the fact that a mistake was made on your part. However, to take personal responsibility is to not only acknowledge the problem, but also finding viable solutions to the problem at hand. This ties in with The Crucible very well because many people in the story are willing to acknowledge the problem but not too many are willing to do something about it, some are even willing to make the problem worse as long as it guarantees their safety. This is a vital problem with the way we as humans behave, we mostly only act in our best interests. For example,…

    • 277 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    All the witches' judgments are fundamental to the action of cricible and accusations and dramatic accusations as well as confessions fill the room with confines, doubts and more questions or that can be seen in some acts such as in Act 1.…

    • 230 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Arthur Miller is a great author that uses many forms of syntax, figurative language, and diction to enhance his writing throughout The Crucible. Miller uses figurative language throughout The Crucible, to put emphasis on certain ideas and things. Miller also uses diction in The Crucible to show that the story is taking place in the past and to give the story a more biblical feel to it. One other thing that Arthur Miller does really well is his use of syntax. He uses syntax throughout The Crucible to show the intelligence levels of different characters. Miller uses these three different things in combination throughout The Crucible to enhance the story and to tell the story of the witch craft trials in an insightful way.…

    • 846 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Heavy Rain

    • 1144 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Self-mutilation, putting people in danger and murdering is all viewed on as something wrong in society; Ethan obviously is aware of it too but his devote love to his son causes his determination. When completely the tasks self mutilation, mentally and morally these tasks were the “easiest”. Ethan thinks “I would never do anything to harm or hurt myself, but I can lose a finger for my son”. He has two choices, don’t harm himself and let his son die or harm himself and save his son. Then comes driving at high speeds through a busy city without obeying the laws of traffic; not only does Ethan put himself in danger, but many others as…

    • 1144 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics