Preview

Ethical Issues: The Removal Of Headgear In Boxing

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1370 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Ethical Issues: The Removal Of Headgear In Boxing
I. INTRODUCTION

In 2012, The International Boxing Association (AIBA) announced the removal of head gear. Boxing is a contact sport and contact sports have recently been the topic in the media when they talk about sports. (19) Resulting in many recent studies done based on the fears of brain injury. The movie starring Will Smith, "Concussion" in 2015 dealt with the brain damage and concussions in football. You expect a sport in which the objective is to strike the head and body of your opponent would not safer than football and soccer. But professional boxing is rated 4th in highest recorded brain injuries and concussions when ranked against other contact sports. I say "contact sports" but third on the list is race car drivers. The list from most to least recorded brain injuries goes; American football, soccer, auto racing, boxing, rugby, wrestling and then amateur boxing. (21)

The safety of the sport of boxing without head protection has not
…show more content…
It does so from the insider’s view of rule changes and conflict of interest by reviewing both research based information and financial issues that may have influences the controversial removal in that the author’s experience in amateur boxing provides insight into the mindset of possible ethic decisions by AIBA. I have worked as a professional boxers and amateur boxers and currently train amateur boxers and I am an active member of USA Boxing and an official and coach. In making the reader of aware that these experiences could be viewed to have the potential to cloud my judgment. I argue that these experiences provide a unique insight into the mindset of AIBA, which in turn helps me address the ethical question on whether the removal was safety based or financial based and that the study the stating that it is safer has not been released and only referenced in a Wall Street Journal

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Although Joan's point is loud and clear about boxing only being about knocking somebody out and “unlike cars or planes or bathtubs, boxing has no purpose except to inflict enough brain damage to make an opponent unconscious”. However The Globe and Mail published an article earlier this year stating that “most sports-related brain injuries occur in hockey” and studies found that “hockey is the biggest contributor to sports-related brain injuries in children and teens”. Another article published on the Canadian MMA Law blog states that “overall risk of injury in amateur boxing [is] lower than football, hockey, wrestling and soccer”. It is as though Joan only considered injuries realted to boxing instead of other injury prone sports.…

    • 497 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Throughout the history of football there has been concussions because poor helmets have bad padding. Many people have in it taken a major part in it. How many people have died from head injuries. So people are should upgrade the helmets to protect anymore bad injuries, people have upgraded helmets but we need to do more from causing a lot more concussions. The head and brain are one of the most important parts of the body which they need to be protected and that is a very good way to protect it from injuries…

    • 391 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Many sports can cause concussions, which can be changed by getting better equipment and adding other sports that won’t be as dangerous. Even though the sports are dangerous getting better equipment can help make the sports less dangerous. If the better equipment would too…

    • 284 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Concussions cause the dangerous disease CTE that has already claimed the lives of many athletes in the NFL and in other sports. We are doing research on CTE but a lot more needs to be done. If the NFL is going to be safer they need to relinquish all of their information and research on player brain injuries. Some good things are being done to rule changes to make the game safer, but it is still not enough. There is a fine line however between changing rules and changing the game, which the NFL will have to navigate carefully. One of the better answers to these brain injuries is to improve the helmet protecting the head. Many developers have made ingenious new ideas to combat the concussion epidemic in football. It is up to the NFL to adopt the new innovations to the football helmet to drastically improve player safety. A person’s brain is the most important part of the body. It just makes sense to want to protect it as much as possible. As the public becomes more aware of the dangers football has on a player’s brain people may reconsider playing football. If the NFL is going to have a future, they must make their game safer. If people see less players effected by concussions on TV public perception of football will improve. Something clearly needs to be done to combat these serious health problems facing current and past NFL…

    • 3109 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Football plays a great part in the United States. It is a part of our culture and is a part of the atmosphere in the fall when school is about to start. It is an amusing experience for a lot of people and their families. This is what make football a part of our culture. One thing to actually think about though is what is essentially happening to the children, the young adults, and athletes involved in this sport; they are growing older then, attending college or even playing professional football with head injuries. Understanding that in football there are many collisions of the head to somebody else’s head or other body parts. Although, the brain sits inside of a cranial vault, also known as the skull. Even wearing the best equipment…

    • 428 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Football Helmet Safety

    • 503 Words
    • 3 Pages

    There has been a ton of research done on head injuries and helmets. Basically, researchers have found that the problem is getting the helmet to absorb the impact given to the helmet. There needs to be material that can do this while not having very much of it at all. The concussions are cause when the helmet is hit, and the head is smacked to the other side of the helmet. The momentum and transferring of the momentum of the hitting player to the receiving player’s brain is what needs to be reduced. Either before the momentum hits the head/brain, or the head/brain needs to have a…

    • 503 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Anno

    • 2217 Words
    • 9 Pages

    Even though modern helmets protect the skull in football, the helmets do not protect the brain from concussions and others injuries such as spinal injuries because the hard shell of the helmet creates a harder impact and allows people to feel comfortable leading with their head to make contact with another player, a softer shelled helmet, a helmet with extra padding or no helmet at all would lower such impacts and chances of concussions as well as lowering chances of players leading with their head on a tackle.…

    • 2217 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The seriousness of sports-related concussions will have harsh repercussions where the impact of being hit forcibly repeatedly can lead to severe bodily harm where quality of life is affected. Although the topic of concussions related to sport injuries has garnered much attention in today’s era where safety is promoted to protect the athlete’s health. However; this was not the case in the early 20th Century for athletes who suffered brain damage from the result of playing football. (Harrision, 2014) stated “years before the first medical study of football injury was published, it was obvious that this new American game was dangerous. Even though the players and public knew of the dangers of football, unfortunately; some athletes did not report…

    • 225 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Those in favor of preventing concussions in sports say that sports leagues need to up there rules on limiting hits to the head so all players are safer. To begin with, most officials do not have the medical background to determine a concussion, which means they’ll miss most signs of a concussion. Without a doubt, officials need to know what they’re dealing with to protect our players from developing worse outcomes. According to Jon McClement, “They should have this covered” (1). Officials should be able to determine a concussion, but most officials don’t which puts players in a place that exposes them to more injuries including concussions. Next, a concussion can be very major and it can eventually turn into life-threatening diseases and more.…

    • 328 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    NFL Concussions

    • 1305 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The alarming effects of Concussions in the NFL has become a major topic of discussion with a wide variety of opinions from medical professionals, NFL representatives, academic institutions and Anti-NFL advocates. While there has been action taken on behalf of the NFL, some believe that these actions still aren’t enough and that the complete mitigation of concussions has yet to be addressed. There has been many new outlets and sports forums that have called out Roger Goodell and the NFL on their continuous practice of masking the true dangers of head trauma. The New York Times published an expose that revealed that the “NFL omitted 100 diagnosed concussions from its supposedly all-encompassing study from 1996-2001, which understated the risks…

    • 1305 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Brain Injuries In Football

    • 1303 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The awareness of brain injuries and the effects it has on a person during and after their football careers has to rise on all levels. All the untold facts has to be told to the world in order to prevent brain injuries. Every head collision effects the brain, it is very important that every person who participates in the game know that. Many concussions occur on every level of the game. Those concussions causes players brains to function differently forever. Repetitive head collisions can lead to the development of chronic traumatic encephalopathy. That disease can possibly lead to death. It is essential that the players of the game have a great reason to believe that they will not develop that disease. The people of America love football it is a great sport, but too many lives have been lost and too many lives have been altered negatively forever to allow the game to stay this way. Everyone affiliated with the game of football must help to create a safe game. It is imperative to the safety of the game and those who play the game for fun and for a living. The United States is a country of safety and freedom. Football is one of America’s most popular sports, it is essential that the sport is altered to ensure safety for all the players…

    • 1303 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Head injuries are quite common and occur regularly in all contact sports. Concussions, from brain injuries can cause long term effects and can lead to dementia. Too many concussions occur in high school athletes that participate in contact sports. One may suggest that contact sports should be banned from all high schools. Non contact sports should become a part of the physical education curriculum so that young adults should not have to suffer the consequences from head injuries in contact sports.…

    • 3849 Words
    • 16 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Concussions are very serious injuries in sports now a day. They seem to be occurring more and more as players start trying to become faster and stronger. NFL.com did an article in 2010 that showed in the 2010 season that the concussion rate had gone up 21% from 2009 (Press). A concussion is a traumatic brain injury that is caused by a blow to head or body, a fall, or another injury that jars or shakes the brain inside the skull (Healthwise 1). The concussion can either be minor or it can be severe to where there could be bleeding of the brain. The NFL, NHL, and NCAAF deal with these kinds of injuries all the time, and have tried to make the sports safer for the players. What is also hard for the players is dealing…

    • 902 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Boxing is a game loaded with hard hitting, quick developments and a lot of blood; however, being a boxer is not excessively fierce for the general public, but rather it has its goods and bads. Boxing is a sport that is watched all around the world and has considerable amounts of income and views on television. There is a rising argument-causing event over the sport, because of the number of people who have gotten hurt and the deaths of people in the ring. There is a lot written on the serious injuries in boxing: for example, blackout, mind wounds, and break of the skull and facial bones. These individuals who are focused and encounter outrageous anger ought to take part in boxing to avert physical conflicts which will promote deflation of anger.…

    • 1715 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Boxing is a sport in which two opponents who each wear padded gloves punch each other for a set period of time. Boxing is done at all levels, from amateur to professional. According to many studies and professionals on the subject boxing is indeed a dangerous sport. The short term and long term health of the boxer is put at risk. For over 50 years there has been at an average of 10 boxers die in the ring each year. Boxers put their health and even their lives at stake every time they choose to compete in a boxing match ("Common Boxing Injuries & Prevention | iSport.com").…

    • 911 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays