Ethical Perspectives The Mysterious Roses and Cold Feet
The Mysterious Roses and Cold Feet
ETH/316
March 17, 2013
The Mysterious Roses and Cold Feet For week five I chose option 2, Ethics Game Dilemmas as my final assignment. I was not sure what to expect of the simulation and what kind of decisions I would face. It was a challenging experience and I learned about myself and my decisions through this process. The first ethical issue that was presented to me in the simulation was answering Gayle’s request for confidentiality. Gayle Dornier was a lead sales representative who came to me, her marketing director with a request to meet to discuss a problem she was facing with confidentiality. It was brought to my attention from my administrative assistant who thought it was important that I know Bill Witherspoon a Research Scientist was going out of his way to show Gayle attention through various actions. I also received an e-mail from Bill indicating that Gayle was going through a hard time and that her sales were suffering. He believed he was trying to be supportive during this difficult time. During this exercise I was given two ethical lenses to work with on this issue, Rights/Responsibilities Lens and the Results lens. When using the Rights/Responsibility Lens I thought that I leaned toward rationality and allowed Gayle to maintain responsibility for her actions and I provided my ethical duty by following standard of action. When using the Results Lens, I took an ethical action and encouraged Gayle to talk to me about the problem so that I can provide her assistance. Both choices I made were reported ethical in this situation. I realized that by telling Gayle that I can keep a personal matter confidential, I also had to let her know that if it were work related I would be forced to report any wrongdoing, and I would do my best to address her concern with confidentiality. The second issue presented was investigating the possibility of falsified and
ETH/316
March 17, 2013
The Mysterious Roses and Cold Feet For week five I chose option 2, Ethics Game Dilemmas as my final assignment. I was not sure what to expect of the simulation and what kind of decisions I would face. It was a challenging experience and I learned about myself and my decisions through this process. The first ethical issue that was presented to me in the simulation was answering Gayle’s request for confidentiality. Gayle Dornier was a lead sales representative who came to me, her marketing director with a request to meet to discuss a problem she was facing with confidentiality. It was brought to my attention from my administrative assistant who thought it was important that I know Bill Witherspoon a Research Scientist was going out of his way to show Gayle attention through various actions. I also received an e-mail from Bill indicating that Gayle was going through a hard time and that her sales were suffering. He believed he was trying to be supportive during this difficult time. During this exercise I was given two ethical lenses to work with on this issue, Rights/Responsibilities Lens and the Results lens. When using the Rights/Responsibility Lens I thought that I leaned toward rationality and allowed Gayle to maintain responsibility for her actions and I provided my ethical duty by following standard of action. When using the Results Lens, I took an ethical action and encouraged Gayle to talk to me about the problem so that I can provide her assistance. Both choices I made were reported ethical in this situation. I realized that by telling Gayle that I can keep a personal matter confidential, I also had to let her know that if it were work related I would be forced to report any wrongdoing, and I would do my best to address her concern with confidentiality. The second issue presented was investigating the possibility of falsified and