Although the topic of abortion is very controversial, there are many ethical arguments in favour of it. These include viability, consciousness, and the view that the mother has the choice about whether or not to terminate the life of the foetus.
Viability is the point at which the foetus is able to survive independent from the mother. This is around the 20 week mark of pregnancy and the foetus then has the status of personhood. Prior to this point, the foetus is not a person, therefore should not have the same rights as a person would. This means that it is justified if the foetus is aborted, as the rights of a person do not apply. Consequently, abortion is not murder in this circumstance. People holding this view are pro-choice, meaning they would accept the plan for abortion under most circumstances up to the point of viability (birth). Someone who supported this view was a philosopher called Mary Anne Warren. She claimed that, ‘Birth rather than some earlier point marks the beginning of the moral status’. Therefore supporting that it is not until birth that the child has moral status or a level of personhood, therefore it is acceptable to have an abortion before this point.
Secondly, another ethical argument in favour of abortion is consciousness. Many people would agree that abortion is completely acceptable under most circumstances as long as the human has no signs of consciousness or presence of rationality. Examples of this are the ability to develop complex language and make tools. Similarly to viability, this point of consciousness is later on in the foetus’ development and growth, as even though all the DNA is there, the fact that there's no higher brain activity strongly suggests that there's no consciousness. Even the later presence of a heartbeat and of primitive streak do not imply consciousness or preciousness, as there is no higher brain activity or self-awareness. Therefore, this argument supports that before this point of brain activity, it is not wrong for the child to be aborted.
Finally, the woman’s rights argument states that it is the mother’s choice of whether or not to terminate her pregnancy. They would argue that if the mother’s life was in danger it is acceptable to have an abortion. An example of this is an ectopic pregnancy, this is when a fertilised egg implants itself outside of the womb, usually in one of the fallopian tubes. This means the egg will not develop into a baby, which can not only be devastating emotionally to the pregnant woman, but also if not treated, can lead to death. This argument supports that the mother has a right to do what she wants with her own body, as she is the person who will experience severe changes in her body, diet and emotions. Not only this, but it is argued that in the long term, the mother will be caring for the child until it is completely independent, taking up most of her life. This is also supported with a quote from Sarah Weddington who stated that a pregnancy to a woman is possibly, ‘the most determinative aspects of her life. It disrupts her body. It disrupts her education. It disrupts her employment. And it often disrupts her entire family life.’
In conclusion, there are many strong ethical arguments that are in favour of abortion. Viability being an important argument, stating that abortion is acceptable under most circumstances before personhood is recognised, usually at the point of birth. The second argument is consciousness, arguing that abortion is allowable until there is a presence of rationality. Finally, possibly the strongest argument, the choice of the mother, stating that it is the mother who must devote the majority of her life to the child, therefore has deserves the choice to abort it.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Most arguments concerning the abortion issue hinge on the moral status or standing of the fetus with respect to the rights it possesses and the obligations that are directly owed to it. These arguments typically fall into two commonly termed categories: pro-life and pro-choice. Pro-life advocates tend to place the status of the fetus first. They argue human beings including a fetus, have an intrinsic value that confers them the right not to be unjustly killed. Conversely, some pro-choice advocates argue the fetus lacks a virtuous characteristic that affords it any rights or significant morals, this is usually termed the 'personhood' argument.…
- 2254 Words
- 10 Pages
Better Essays -
There is a massive moral debate over abortion in America and many other countries. Murdering human beings has been called severely immoral for a very long time. The arguments for abortion are not only if the fetus applies to this rule, but also our basic rights as humans. Some of the strongest arguments to date on either side are A Defense of Abortion by Judith Jarvis Thomson and Why Abortion is Immoral by Don Marquis. I will argue in defense of abortion using these arguments.…
- 1676 Words
- 7 Pages
Better Essays -
The ethical argument that applies to pro-choice abortion is the violinist analogy. If I were hooked to the violinist, I would unhook the tubes the minute I realized I could not take it anymore. I am the one who is hooked to the violinist and I know what I am capable of handling, and someone else cannot tell me that they know when I have enough than myself. The same thing applies to those who are pro-choice and they know their body better than anymore…
- 567 Words
- 3 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Nearly all abortions take place within the first trimester of the pregnancy. Within that time, the fetus cannot exist outside of the mother’s tummy. It is attached by the umbilical cord, and therefore depends on the mother’s health for survival. If it cannot survive on its own, the fetus is technically not a person yet, and being a living person is very different from the concept of human life…
- 460 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
To start, pro-life advocates base their arguments off many factors, one being that babies are viable lives and have rights from the time of conception. As discussed earlier, the embryo, which is an organism in the earliest development stage, contains DNA in its chromosomes when it is concepted. By the fifth week of pregnancy, the embryo is rapidly growing and has now started to develop major organs, such as the heart and brain (Mayo Clinic Staff, par. 11). According to Baby Med, viability of pregnancy is based on the presence of a fetal heart beat, normally rising hCG levels, and the fact that the fetus is alive inside the womb. Baby Med also states that, typically, a hospital considers the 24th week of pregnancy to be the age of viability outside of the womb, though it is known for babies born younger than that to survive (“What Does …”, pars. 2-3). Despite the time mark that a baby can survive outside the womb, all unborn lives should be considered “viable” because as they age, the better chance they have at surviving outside the womb. Most unborn babies develop normally and will eventually develop into a healthy, viable child. Another key argument for the side of pro-life is the availability of alternative options for mothers pregnant with children they do not wish to raise. Adoption is a leading alternative for abortion. Adoption is a great option for mothers who do not want to raise their…
- 1819 Words
- 8 Pages
Better Essays -
Is Abortion really murder. Give about 266 days after conception and see what emerges from the womb. It will be a human baby, not a horse, a fish or an honey badger. When a human egg and sperm unite, the result is a fetus. Within 3 week you can hear a heartbeat. At 4 weeks you are able to pick out facial features, arms and legs. Nerves and brain waves are in place by eight weeks after conception. At 12 weeks breathing of fluid for oxygen. So is this a fetus or a human? That is still up to interpretation. Legal rights have stepped in but, yet they are broken all the time.…
- 783 Words
- 4 Pages
Better Essays -
The similarities between the three are that they determine good and bad traits about a person, and with the determination of their actions, it also determines the characteristic of the person which is virtue ethics. Utilitarianism is similar that finds the good in a person. One issue is that it avoids finding the bad in a person. With the deontological ethics the product of the action is good not bad. It holds acts that are morally obligatory for consequences made by human actions. The differences between the three ethics are, utilitarianism is an act that focuses on consequences. Virtue ethics is the character of a person not the actions of a person. Deontological ethics is a reflection of a person’s morality, which is ultimately a combination of that person’s attitude.…
- 369 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Abortion is the killing of an unborn child, or in other words, murder. The unborn child is in fact a living human being. Although some may disagree that the baby is living while in the womb, it can be proven scientifically otherwise. Erick Eckholm in the New York Times online quoted Dr. Eric Webb, an obstetrician, who said, “With the union of the egg and sperm, that is life, and genetically human.” It is human at the moment of egg and sperm coming together. Rob Schwarzwalder similarly explained in his online article on Family Research Council, “The zygote is composed of human DNA and other human molecules, so its nature is undeniably human and not some other species. . . It is also quite clear to us that the earliest human embryo is biologically alive. It fulfills the four criteria needed to establish biological life: metabolism, growth, reaction to stimuli, and reproduction.” He makes the argument very clear that when the sperm and egg fuse together, a new entity that is distinctly human becomes alive and an individual. He also discusses that the new human zygote has a genetic composition that is different from any other human, including the mother (Schwarzwalder). All of these facts contribute to the fact that this baby is not just an extension of the mother’s body alone, but it is a new and unique human being. Mary Balch bluntly states in her article online for USA Today, “The fetus, in many cases, dies just as a human adult or child would: It bleeds to death as it is torn limb from limb.” When you decide to abort, you are technically killing an irreplaceable living person.…
- 975 Words
- 4 Pages
Better Essays -
Abortion has been an ongoing controversial topic of many discussions. Women that go through with abortion tend to take for granted the life that a fetus could have lived. A woman should not have the right to choose abortion and take away an innocent life.…
- 978 Words
- 4 Pages
Better Essays -
A lot of people who are for abortion, say that it is not a viable life until it could survive outside the body. With today's technology, babies are surviving outside the womb as early as 20 some weeks. Another disturbing fact, is when a pregnant woman is murdered or dies, it is considered a double homicide. If the abortion of an unborn child is not “murder” or killing of a life, it wouldn't be considered a homicide. Many abortions now are given not by the mutilation and suction out of the woman's body, but by a pill that disintegrates the child, organs, and developed tissues and…
- 511 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Far too much focus on is put on the premise that a fetus is a human being. Carol Gilligan conducted a study on the language of the public abortion debate, finding that “The connection between the fetus and the pregnant woman becomes the focus of attention and the question becomes whether it is responsible or irresponsible, caring or careless, to extend or end this connection.” (Gilligan, 281) The dilemma is that the people tend to sidetrack off the actual abortion topic and the argument shifts to become more care ethics oriented. Thomson avoids this issue by seeing no obligation whatsoever to pay regards to the state of the fetus as it is irrelevant in proving that an abortion is not impermissible. Yes, the fetus is a person, and yes, both the mother and the unborn fetus have equal rights to live. But, keep in mind that a fetus is merely a tenant in a small house that the mother owns called her body. We can now establish without impartiality that the mother is more deserving of her body than the fetus because she is the rightful owner of it. This extra right she has is called autonomy, which means she is entitled to have complete control over her own body. The principle of autonomy goes to prove that the determinant of the choice to abort should be the choice of none other than the woman who is pregnant herself. Even if a fetus is entitled to life, it is not entitled to force a mother to use her body in a way that she does not want to. We can very well argue this principle for the legality of abortion as well. See, the government does not have control over a woman’s body and cannot force her to proceed with the pregnancy if she does not wish to. Therefore, it is she, the owner of her own body, who is allowed to make the autonomous choice to undergo an abortion.May it be noted that Thomson only argues that abortion should not be impermissible, not that it is always permissible, as there are…
- 2182 Words
- 9 Pages
Better Essays -
The moral issue of abortion is that it is wrong morally based on the simple fact that a life is a life (2006). When we find we are so great and mighty that it is…
- 1095 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Someone that believes in the pro-choice theory would say that the decision is up to the woman, but the person with the pro-life theory would say that it is murder no matter what the situation. Would you consider it murder to kill a baby the day after it is born? Then why would it not be murder to kill it before it is born? "If it is impossible to abort a baby in the ninth month, then what makes it ok to do in the fifth or sixth month." (Carl Sagan & Ann Druyan).…
- 751 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Abortion is a very cruel act. “...abortion is murder, the cruelest possible violation of the rights of an unborn child, a crime they can not in good conscience overlook or condone.” (Dworkin, Ronald m. Life’s domination; An argument about abortion, euthanasia, and individual freedom. Vintage, 1933.) Some people don’t believe that it is murder because the baby isn’t alive. There is proof that the baby is alive. “Science could not be more clear. Unborn human beings are living, separate and unique. From the moment of fertilization-better known as conception- a new human life is in existence. Ending this life is not ending potential. It is ending a life.” (Abortionno. 10 reasons why abortion is wrong. 2015.) If someone is ending a life it is murder if the baby is alive then murder is taking place. If there is life then abortion is clearly murder. “... they advance in opposition to laws restricting access to abortion fail or refute even weaken the traditional anti abortion argument, i.e. , that a fetus is a human being, and therefore abortion is murder.” (Warren, Mary Anne “On The Moral And Legal Status of Abortion” The Monist vol. 57 no.1 1973, p. 43-61 www.jstor.org/stable/27902294.) Abortion is not only murder but also just plain…
- 955 Words
- 4 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Many women in the entire world face abortions. In Sri Lanka the rate of doing abortions illegally is high. Women believe there are many reasons to abort such as fear of having or raising a child, being raped with a child, or not having enough money to live. But whatever the situation I believe there is no acceptable reason to get an abortion. Abortion has been a controversial topic for as long as the idea has existed. People argue that it is the mother's body, the mother's choice. Some says that a life is a life, no matter how small. No one in the world has the right to even think of murdering an innocent child. Just because a fetus may not have a complete eye or leg formed doesn't mean he or she isn't a human. Many people who are against death penalty are in favor of abortion. Abortion is one of the worst types of murder because it is the killing of a person who has not committed any sin. Those who practice abortion should receive the same penalty that they give the baby. According to my point of view there are some important reasons why women should not abort have to do with human values, religious values, and doing an abortion is unsafe for the mother.…
- 833 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays