Preview

Flora

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
939 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Flora
In the fictional memoir,Maestro, Peter Goldworthy illustrates the impossibility of reaching perfection. The protagonist, Paul Crabbe, uses ten years to fulfill his dream of becoming a concert pianist, but ultimately only to become an academic in Melbourne. His failure is caused by his flawed personality and his inherent human limitation. Paul’s teacher, Eduard Keller, the ‘maestro’, is a damaged individual. His high status in music does not give him a perfect life, as his wife and son are killed due to his insensitivity and false confidence in his own excellence in music. Peter Goldworthy shows that perfection in an ambition farfrom reaching through the characters’ struggle for it.

Paul’s arrogance and smugness indirectly hinder him from attaining perfection. He is an adolescent who is ‘spoilt’ and given ‘too much praise’. Thus causing him developing the egotism and self-centre which driving him refuse to accept Keller’s advice that ‘we must know when to move on. To search too long for perfection can also paralyze’. Paul redoubles his efforts to strive for success but finally‘ out of reach’ in the Dry. His arrogance pushes him to overestimate his musical ability and then ignores the fact that the ideal level is non-existent. Besides Paul’s arrogance, he also dares not recognize himself subjectively. When his mother Nancy wants to read Keller’s letter which ‘tore’ his performance‘apart phrase by phrase’, he lies he ‘ left it around here somewhere’. Paul’s lack of self-awareness and fear of making mistakes both prevent him from achieving perfection because ‘only the second-rate never make mistakes’. Peter Goldsworthy here demonstrates that Paul’s imperfect personality could make the perfection is tougher to achieve.

However, the major factor that renders perfection impossible to be achieved is the natural human limitation all the people should accept without choosing. Keller prods Paul more than once, drawing a negative image and telling him that he will never

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Discovering friends and finding things hard in the beginning are all part of Paul's future life, When he joins a rock band with a bunch of students, he suddenly feels in control as if he had finally found control and authority. As time goes by after he finds himself looking for a way, finding direction; thinking about what he should do with his life. What he was lacking was that little bit, which had been keeping him from winning. In the first few lessons, we learn that Paul has yet to touch a single key on the…

    • 461 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Paul, the main character in ‘Maestro’ is taught by a musical maestro named Keller who not only teaches him about his music, but also life skills. Keller becomes instrumental to Paul’s life and Goldsworthy presents this clearly in his novel. As Paul matures, he slowly comes to the…

    • 1028 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Early on in Maestro we are given contradicting distinctively visual images of Edward Keller, an example of this contrast is “the pitted sun-coarsened skin- a cheap, ruined leather…but then the suit: white linen, freshly pressed”, this conflicting images Goldsworthy gives us are there to create the enigma known as Edward Keller. Though we are given these conflicting images of Keller, this is merely to help the reader to paint a clearer picture of him in their minds and because of these clearer images the ideas Goldsworthy is using Keller to convey become more obvious. Keller is a guide and a teacher for Paul…

    • 1013 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In the novel Paul’s parents both share a deep passion for music. They both have different thoughts on music which is shaped by their life experiences and contrasting personalities. This is highlighted when Paul is describing his parents relationships towards music,…

    • 366 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The novel begins in Darwin in 1967 and traces Paul's life through his childhood to 1977. During this time he travels to Adelaide, through Europe and ends up settling in Melbourne. The central concern of the novel "Maestro" is definitely the growth to maturity of Paul. The issues which arise in the novel, such as music, relationships, love, and betrayal, all contribute to lead to his developement to understanding. These issues portrayed in the commencement of the novel is what entices and sustains the reader to continue.…

    • 801 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Shine Human Condition

    • 1046 Words
    • 5 Pages

    This part of the human condition has greatly affected David, as he, much like his father, can't let go of the past. We are presented with two extremes of David's reflections on his childhood, his success and mentors and his father. Ben, later David's piano teacher, is first introduced to us as a judge at a local competition. David's piano career begins from that point, as his reflections started from there. Although Ben was always arguing with Peter, he could not overpower or influence him in any way and this was shown by the physical height difference between the two men and Peter's large over powering voice. Many shots were also taken from relatively high angles, to minimalise Peter so the audience can clearly tell who is the dominating of the two. In the reflections, David is always repeating, echoing his father's words in a trusting way where he believed every word he said was true and sacred. We hear the same lines again " David, you are a lucky boy" and " no one can love you like me" but the older wiser David reluctantly repeats them in an untruthful tone. From this we can tell David, who has been stuck in his childhood reflections for so long has finally let go and moved on with his life. The music played in the reflections also indicates to the audience David's acknowledgement and ability to differentiate between the good and bad. When he spent time with Katherine, the music was light and peaceful yet when he was at home, the music was dark and suspenseful. From David's reflections, we learn not to dwell in the past, but rather learn from the mistakes as he has and move on. This component of the human condition enables us to self-correct and rediscover ourselves and people affecting our…

    • 1046 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Maestro

    • 3744 Words
    • 15 Pages

    Characters: Paul Crabbe. Paul is the protagonist of Maestro and the narrator. He narrates the novel retrospectively (see Techniques) as an adult. On a basic level, Paul is a fifteen year old boy with a gift for playing the piano. He is very talented, and never tires of hearing other people, particularly his parents, shower him with praise. However, this state of mind whereby he is a flawless piano player is changed when he meets Herr Eduard Keller (Herr is the German word for “mister”, see Explanations). For the first time in his musical career, Paul has met his match. Keller is critical of him, almost painfully so, and is the only person, aside from the future Paul, who can recognise the sheer arrogance that is at the base of Paul’s character. The story follows Paul’s development as a piano player, but also his development as a human being. His schoolyard escapades as well as his relationships with the other characters in his life are also explored; however, some things remain common to all of the aspects of Paul’s life, namely, Paul’s naivety. Throughout his adolescent life, Paul is plagued by a lack of understanding of many abstract concepts. One such concept is beauty. Paul has augmented ideas about beauty, and fails to realise that beauty is an infinitely complex concept which cannot be harboured in the way that he wants to hold onto it forever. An example of this is when he goes out…

    • 3744 Words
    • 15 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    My own life’s dream is to have a career in which I can surround myself in music. I will not let anything stand between my dream and I; however, I will never allow my dream to come between myself and my loved ones, or my reality. Many have already fallen victim to the pursuit of the American Dream – a fantastic projection of life that varies based upon its dreamer. However, the road to the American Dream, if followed blindly, can lead to nothing more than a dead end. In The Great Gatsby, by F. Scott Fitzgerald, and in Arthur Miller’s Death of a Salesman, respective protagonists Jay Gatsby and Willy Loman are blinded by the pursuit of the American Dream, and both meet their downfalls at the hands of their own ignorance. These two authors both criticize the human tendency for self-delusion through the flawed moral characters of Gatsby and Loman.…

    • 729 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Maestro is written in the first person with an adult Paul, the main character, reflecting back over his life. It begins with Paul and Keller’s first meeting and they are both presented to us as rather arrogant and insensitive. However, when the adult Paul then interjects into his story about how he can understand that it might be incredible to believe that he came to ‘love this man’, his gruff music teacher the reader is brought to the realisation that there is a lot more depth to those characters and to their emotions than we might have previously thought.…

    • 597 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Blooms

    • 274 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Add, apply, shop, calculate, change, modify, classify, complete, sketch, compute, demonstrate, manipulate, discover, divide, construct, examine, graph, record, interpret, multiply, illustrate, operate, prepare, choose, produce, show, predict, solve, subtract, translate, use, dramatize, and schedule.…

    • 274 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Paul was trapped in Misery’s life; he needed to release himself from having one topic to write about. He knew that it was going to get old one day, and he was feeling as if he could not write about anything else unless he got rid of Misery for good. He was trapped into Misery’s life because the obsessive women that followed Misery’s life provided him with fame and money. He wanted to start a new novel in order to free himself from Misery Chastain’s grasp.…

    • 714 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    “He had fair hair, blue-grey eyes and irregular but distinguished features, his nose being markedly aquiline. His whole person was characterized by refinement and high distinction….In him we have the unusual spectacle of a proud, reserved and passionate spirit housed in a frail and ailing body….he surrendered himself to the torrent of passionate music which flowed from the piano when he abandoned himself to his inspiration.” (Hedley 72-73).…

    • 863 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Christians strive to emulate the ‘perfect' life of Jesus, though they know that they will never truly achieve their goals. The idea of God is almost always boiled down to the "aspiration to participate in or be in harmony with perfection.1" But how does this perfection shape our conception of God? The nature of perfection is defined in theistic circles as love. There are two schools of thought addressed in the selection; traditional theism & process theism. Cobb & Griffin discuss the conflict between traditional theism and process theism's definition of divine love, the possibility of divine dependence, and the idea that God's love is more than a creative-impassive love.…

    • 993 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    American Musical History

    • 1390 Words
    • 6 Pages

    John Hill Hewitt was born in 1805 within a wealthy family. His family was full of musical atmosphere. His father James Hewitt was a music publisher, composer, and musician; his sister was a pianist; his brothers took over his father’s music publisher company. However, Hewitt’s father didn’t want him to follow the same path as he do. He pushed Hewitt away from music, and tried to let him become an artist. He wanted him apprentice a sign painter in Boston. Hewitt rejected to become a sign painter, and run away. His farther also tried apprentice him to a number of other field, but neither of them had accept by Hewitt. Finally, Hewitt entered West Point, the United States Military Academy under his families’ assurance. Even he entered the academy; he still didn’t pay attention on his study. His grade was pretty bad at all. At the end of the program, he didn’t have the grades to graduate. But he received his instruction in music, from the leader of the Army bandmaster Richard Willis.…

    • 1390 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Religion

    • 1969 Words
    • 8 Pages

    • saying that God created humankind in his own image doesn't mean that people actually look like God, but that people have a unique capacity for rational existence that enables them to see what is good and to want what is good…

    • 1969 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics