Preview

For Cause and Comrades Essay

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
741 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
For Cause and Comrades Essay
For Cause and Comrades

For Cause and Comrades by James M. McPherson consists of mostly of soldiers’ diaries and letters home as to why the men were fighting the Civil War. The initial motivation the union and confederacy sustain throughout the story proves that personal honor is valued more than their lives.

The opening chapter of the book is mostly a plot overview of the events that had yet to come. Fratricide, Meaning one that murders or kills an individual (as a countryman) having a relationship like that of a brother or sister, and Rage Military were the main themes of the opening chapters. The fact intrigued me that the Civil War so divided this country that family members would choose opposite sides of this most deadly of conflicts. “This breakup sometimes forced members of the same biological family to choose opposite sided” (McPherson 14) was a powerful point as to how divided the country really was. I agreed upon a second theme throughout the first two chapters called Rage Military, this French term used in the second chapter demonstrated to me as to why individuals may willingly go into battle.

The idea that unseasoned soldiers were ready jump into the midst of battle to face their conflicting personal beliefs proves the importance of serving with honor. “The belief in duty, honor, and country that had caused them to enlist in the first place held them to the firing line” (McPherson 36) was a point made as to why soldiers would continually move toward the battle. The title “combat narcosis” (McPherson 41) were terms used to describe the extreme effects overpowering rush combat soldiers experienced in battle and to why they would fight with such veracity.

Commanding officers needed to portray strong leadership skills by acting as examples to gain the trust and respect of these volunteer soldiers. Throughout the story the author explains some of the difficulties in adapting to a nearly all-volunteer, non-professional

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    First thing’s first, anyone who encounters this wonderfully constructed book, What They Fought For, by James M. McPherson, must acknowledge his great work. McPherson is one of the few historians worth reading; this is coming from a Kinesiology major who wants little to nothing to do with historians. I strongly believe that this marvelous piece of art work has no flaws or weaknesses, yet has many strong points.…

    • 497 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The book begins by showing Lincoln in the final days of the Civil war waiting anxiously to hear results of the battles that took place. This was perhaps my favorite part of the book. Military history has always fascinated me. This book details the amazing battle of two of the greatest generals in United States history. Ulysses S. Grant vs. Robert E. Lee. It shows that they both were very bold men and wanted to win. In my opinion this book shows that no man other than Lincoln did more to win the war than Grant. This gave Grant the edge of being the better general between the two.…

    • 773 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Jim Frederick’s book “Black Hearts” explores the harrowing account of soldiers from 1st Platoon, Bravo Company, 502nd Infantry Regiment during their deployment in 2005-2006 through Iraq’s “Triangle of Death”. The story is one of failed leadership at all levels, resulting in broken bonds between brothers, drug abuse, and ultimately the rape and murder of an Iraqi family. The soldiers’ descent into complete isolation was brought on by not only dire combat situations, but also a complete disregard for their mental health by higher. This essay will compare and contrast the roles of SSG Eric Lauzier and SFC Jeff Fenlason, and how their leadership had a positive or negative effect on their subordinates.…

    • 498 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    During the course of Civil War people faced many different hardships and challenges. As the war began secessionist hopes were high and they had control over the unionist. However, as the war progressed this began to change. The men that fought for the Rebels were beginning to come home and the same was true for the men who fought with the Yankees. Since many of all these men lived in the same towns and fought for different sides during the war hostility broke out. Even though there was an enormous amount of hostility between the two sides they still had one thing in common, family. Through the lives of Louis Hughes, Cornelia McDonald, John Robertson, Samuel Agnew, one can see the importance of family through hard times and good times.…

    • 3240 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    As long as man has had the ability to think for himself, there has been conflict and war. Wars are waged by the rich and powerful, but fought by the poor masses who march, inexorably into the meat grinder. The question of “why do soldiers fight?” arises when looking at the study of warfare. What compelled the hoplite from Sparta, the foot soldier in Napoleon’s Grand Army, the American Infantryman on Omaha Beach, or the Army Ranger in Baghdad to willingly enlist and fight for their cause? The most devastating war in American history was by far the Civil War, claiming more American lives in four years than all other American wars (except World War I and II) combined. What is it that made these hundreds of thousands of men and women abandon their homes and fight against the nation that their forefathers had fought to gain the independence of not a century before. Many scholars believe that slavery, “states rights”, and freedom were the driving factor in these soldier’s minds. However, there was far more than simple ideology that drove these soldiers to Bull Run, Shiloh, Gettysburg, and Appomattox. Other factors that drove these soldiers into service were a sense of patriotism, their comrades in arms, the need to prove themselves, religion, and the defense of freedom and property to name a few. In For Cause and Comrades by James M. McPherson, McPherson argues that ideology plays a major role in why soldiers choose to fight, but in the heat of battle, ideology is forgotten and the aforementioned reasons become a significant reason as to why they choose to stay.…

    • 1551 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Some historians argue that conscientious objectors were nothing but cowards. How valid is this interpretation of conscientious objectors during World War I?…

    • 872 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    This book follows differing social structures within The Confederate States of America and how those clashing cultures led to multiple changes of strategy in the mountain regions of the Confederacy. All of these combined factors led to multiple tragic events within the Confederacy. The main social groups that are discussed in the book are Rural and Urban Confederates, Confederate Mountaineers, and Unionist. It is important to understand each of the different social groups before a full social analysis can be conducted. Once the social aspect of the mountain regions is understood, the specific strategies used by both the Union and the Confederacy can be discussed.…

    • 1897 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    James McPherson’s writings have been geared towards advancing the arguments that the North was justified in crushing the rebellion in the South. He sees the civil war in the lens of not a war against the North and the South, but a war against slavery and against their emancipation; a war between progressive forces against conservative ideologies in the south. In his writings, he is quick to indicate that the North’s win was inevitable, because of the relatively more polished military organizational capabilities and a vindication by history. McPherson downplays the factual successes that the Confederate forces had on the different war fronts throughout his book as either mere short term lapses in the organization of the Union forces rather than the actual inabilities to withstand the South’s firepower (McPherson, 2009).…

    • 1876 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Crane accurately depicts the Civil War for what it is: the bloodiest war in American history. Unlike common Romanticist writers, he employed Naturalism in his work, earning him notice and praise. This novel has proven to be an important piece of literature, as it speaks of serious issues pertinent during the life of Stephen Crane and in the modern world. His writing helped achieve a strong, lasting position for Naturalism in literature. The success of Crane’s writing has since secured him a lasting standing as one of America’s greatest authors. The life Stephen Crane lead influenced the path his novel took, and the American people are all the more grateful for…

    • 1103 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Combat High

    • 455 Words
    • 2 Pages

    This essay is based on Combat High written by Sebastian Junger first published in Newsweek Magazine in 2010. The article was adapted from the author 's book War which describes life in a platoon in the Korengal Valley of Afghanistan. He spent fourteen months during 2007 and 2008 embedded in the platoon. Junger points out the costs of the war in terms of the soldiers psychological aspects, explaining how being in combat can be damaging. Another cost of war is caused by lack of proper medical and psychological care to returning soldiers to help in the re-insertion to society.…

    • 455 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Why I Should Not Reenlist

    • 936 Words
    • 4 Pages

    War will never determine who is right - only who is left, therefore, we as soldiers during our darkest moments, must focus to see the light. The date was 1777, and the soldiers at Valley Forge were struggling largely. As winter rapidly approached, the camp 18 miles outside of Philadelphia faced numerous challenges. Men were deserting, dying, and the Americans’ fate only seems to grow worse. Women developed “scarlet fever” or a fascination of the British soldiers and their bright red coats.…

    • 936 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The romanticized version of the Civil War creates a picture of the North versus the South with the North imposing on the South. However, after reading “The Making of a Confederate” by William L. Barney, one can see that subdivisions existed before the war was declared. The documents analyzed by Barney primarily focus on the experiences of Walter Lenoir, a southern confederate and a member of the planter elite. His experiences tell a vivid story of a passionate and strongly opinioned participant of the Civil War as well as demonstrate a noticeably different view involving his reasoning when choosing a side. Between analyzing this fantastic piece of literature and other resourceful documents from “Voices of Freedom” by Eric Foner, one can get a better idea of what the conflict was about, where the Confederacy originated from, the cause for the secession, and how Americans experienced the war and understood its meaning.…

    • 1719 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Essay On Lost Cause

    • 639 Words
    • 3 Pages

    After the Civil War and Reconstruction ceased, the South's Lost Cause was introduced to the southern United States by ex-confederates. A very politically influenced movement, the Lost Cause, while building a legacy for the controversial Redemption, was subject to backlash for it's false interpretations of what slavery was like as well as how the Civil War went down. Even with all of its misinterpretations and falsities, however, the Lost Cause influenced the memories of many on the Civil War, Redemption, and slavery for generations to come.…

    • 639 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A social movement is defined by Henslin (2006) as “large numbers of people who organize to promote or resist social change”. These two reasons for movements are reactive, trying to resist some kind of change, and proactive, or trying to promote some kind of change. There are six types of social movements; alterative, redemptive, reformative, transformative, transnational, and metaformative.…

    • 438 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In my today’s article, I am going to explain what this phenomenon is called and how we can avoid a good soldiers becoming a bad captain.…

    • 839 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays