Can you make people love you more by forming them, the way you want them to be? This is the essential question in For their own survival (2002) the short story by Ursula Hegi. The story is about the two persons Liz and Sam. They are on holiday by the coast in Mexico.
After eleven years of marriage, Liz decides to leave Sam. This is very ironic, because she is the one who promised him, that he would always be with her. They are both active persons, and do everything together. The reason for this is that Sam wants them to. In the place they live, it is the man who is in charge. The woman needs to do what the man wants her to do. That’s also why they have no children, because Sam has no interest in having them. They do have to dogs, probably also Sams decision, instead of having two kids, they get two dogs, easier to look after, and do not crave as much attention. All Liz can do is say that’s a wise decision, and keep her frustration to herself. One of the clearest examples of this being a man dominated world is when they are out fishing, and Liz hooks a marlin. Almost instantly Sam takes the rod away from her, to take the credit and honour for the catch. This could also be because Sam is an old military man and now principal. He is a control freak. He needs everything to go after his head or else everything goes wrong. I think he means well with the things he does. He just wants to make sure it is done right.
Sam being the control freak that he is describes and almost analyses her. He describes her as being a shy woman, with no confidence. Sam doesn’t like her being that way and wants to change her. He goes in and plays god. Only god or themselves can change people. He shapes her like she is a mannequin or a piece of plastic. He hasn’t been perfect and has made some mistakes such as “A few times he misjudged his timing, and she slipped away from him.” (Line 91) The way the sentence is, it is almost like a military diary, a journal or logbook. He gives her almost animal like intelligence. The prey slipped away from the hunter, it is once again him putting himself higher than her. He makes himself seems as god. Being able to change and shape her for his own liking, a violation against god as well as Liz and not to forget nature. There is a reason why god is over us humans, he can do what we can´t or shouldn’t. A little later it says that they have often laughed about the person she was when they first married. This point to that Sam only fell in love with the idea or potential of Liz and not her. It now gets clearer that Sam is manipulating Liz, to be the person he wants her to be, just as when he was drill instructor in the army. Once again he shows his lust for control.
The themes in this story stretch a lot, all from control, sculpturing, love and the understanding of love and self-education. The one going through the biggest change is Sam as he explores his own self, and when he realizes why he is alone it covers up a kind of emptiness. That is what self-education is all about, you might not find the solution, but you learn something and can progress. Then there is the theme of love. The whole thing stops when “ and all at once he wanted to release the fish before the color drained from it completely” (Line 169) In that line Sam finally lets go of Liz. After haven thought about who he is, and learned something, he could finally let go of her. The thing with colours is because he tried to make her in his image, and almost made her go grey, but he realised it before it was too late. Therefor we can forgive him, because he realized his mistake before it was too late. Another thing the fish being Jesus symbol, and him haven played god, so that support my theory of him playing god. Sam has a real hard time of letting go of Liz, because he finds it difficult to see where he went wrong, but as pointed out earlier, he is able to see it in the end. When looking back, he couldn’t see any of the signs of her wanting to leave him.
To conclude on this story no one can shape people the way you want them to be. For Sams own survival he needs this power and control over Liz and everything else. He needs the power until he starts looking in himself. Shaping things is his force and nature, and didn’t do anything to hurt Liz, at least no deliberately. He always did what he thought was the best. When he realizes that he has been manipulating and controlling Liz, he sets her free. This is a very hard realization. He realizes that the one who needs to change is him. It is very hard for him to change, because he is used to changing others to his liking, now he has to change for others liking.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Sam Sing who wore his thick black hair to the side was not exactly a sociable or considerate man. He had the ability to make others feel insignificant and often left people feeling uncomfortable. He rarely spoke, rarely smiled and would regularly be seen glaring at his customers from behind his glasses. Sam was frugal and controlling in all…
- 566 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
George and Lisa have been married for five years and have no children. George works as a salesman for a small local company and gets easily stressed from a demanding day in the sales field. George will often arrive home upset and expects sympathy from his wife Lisa who will always drop what she is doing to ensure that he feels better.…
- 420 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
She’s raising two kids, working, and still participates in family chores at home. But Bartels does the same. Since they had children, he recalls having to give up several things, these including drinking beer and ‘guy’s night out. This came with the territory, but what else came with the territory, he was not expecting. His wife begins to take her anger out on him, letting her frustrations of the children out on her husband. With an accusing “your son” or “your daughter” implying she had nothing to do with their behavior, Bartels found himself at his wits’ end.…
- 556 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The two women in the story are Mrs Johnston and Mrs Lyons. Mrs Johnston is a lower class single mother living in a council house in the centre of Liverpool. Her husband has left her, while she is pregnant, for a younger woman after she had given birth to 7 children. Willy Russell portrays her as a superstitious and lonely woman. ‘Oh God. Never put new shoes on a table Mrs Lyons.’ At the beginning of the play, I feel sorry for Mrs Johnston because she has lots of children and loves them all equally but she simply cannot support them financially as a cleaner. How she has let herself get into this position is extremely sad but is also a social comment by Willy Russell on society today. Russell sets Mrs Johnston up as the extreme example of the benefit living, single parent family who live with and by the hand of the social. ‘The welfare’s already been onto me. They say I’m incapable of controlling the kids I got.’ I do feel a bit angry at Mrs Johnston when she gave Eddie away to Mrs Lyons but when I see how Mrs Lyons manipulated her and made her think that she was doing the right thing, I feel sorry for her. The picture is quite complicated; Russell is testing the moral ethics of the audience.…
- 789 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
love is able to flourish. However, the absence of freedom and responsibility fosters fear, resentment, self-centeredness, and an imbalance of power and control, all of which drives love out of the relationship. They suggest, “when we do these three things-live free, take responsibility for our own freedom, and love God and each other-then life, including…
- 1370 Words
- 6 Pages
Powerful Essays -
4. The fact that women are expected to be laughed at in marriage as the narrator states suggests that women are not taken seriously in marriage and are not considered equal counterparts in the partnership of marriage. The narrator is a stay at home wife who is expected to obey her husbands orders while her husband is a physician and makes all the decisions for her. Their relationship is suggestive of what gender roles were like in the 1800’s.…
- 573 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Eric Bartels explains how he feels himself to ultimately be the more dominant parent and his wife has much built-up anger that she constantly takes out on him. After working many hours, along with helping to take care of the kids, he gets yelled at by his stressed out wife about the things that he did wrong and the things that he could have done right. Bartels provides probable cause as to why his wife is so angry, such as motherhood and professional success, while also admitting that he did make mistakes before the marriage. Bartels ultimately feels that he does not deserve any of her anger because he has not done anything wrong making her the only one with faults and who is being the harsher one in the marriage.…
- 914 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Families are torn apart because of war. Sam and Mr. Meeker, come to a huge disagreement whether Sam should join the war or not. This makes Mr. Meeker so frustrated that he kicks out Sam. ‘Go, Sam. Go. Get out…
- 758 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Any decision that Monica made she was nervous about and needed other people’s thoughts on it. She doesn’t feel comfortable being herself because she believes people will not like her and leave her. Monica tells her friend, “I was up till 2:30 doing my hair poll”. This is showing she would rather exhaust herself with what other people will like on her instead of picking a hairstyle she liked for herself. “You are debating that or state?” Liz asked. She feels once she goes to the college no one knows her at and her friends will leave her and never talk to her. Also, she feels like she will make a mistake and people will think she is not perfect. Before going to prom Liz and Monica look for a dress and Monica states, “I really like it”. She understands that she can like things on her own and it doesn’t matter what other people think about it.…
- 711 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
“To understand your parents' love you must raise children yourself.” Amy Tan illustrates the process of recognizing parent’s love in her short…
- 827 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
This interpretation uses a lot of mentally ill traits to define the character’s behavior about herself. From the movie Benny and Joon; the character Joon is mentally ill and suffers from Asperger syndrome and schizophrenia behaviors. Her obsession to her daily routine is abnormal compared to others around her. Joon’s behavior affects others around her, especially her older brother Benny (her caretaker). In the future, she finds a special person to help her overcomes most of these symptoms and become independent and live alone with the special person; Sam.…
- 316 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Throughout the story, there is a major focus on Sammy's observations of others. Sammy is a young cashier at a grocery store whose personality reflects immaturity and insecurity. When three teenage girls enter the store, it is clear that all men are watching closely as they strut the store in bathing suits. The store is "right in the middle of town, and if you stand at our front doors you can see two banks and the Congregational church and the newspaper store and three real-estate offices" which lets us know that the store is in a conservative area, where bathing suits in public are definitely frowned upon. The girls become objects of desire as Sammy observes their every move. He feels the need to describe the three girls and sort of place himself on a pedestal as he judges them. His focus is solely on the girls and he makes a mistake ringing up a customer but he pawns it off like it was the woman’s fault for being a ‘’witch”. His co-worker, Stokesie plays with Sammy as they joke about how pretty the girls are. All of this playfulness and desire leads Sammy to ponder the thought that Stokesie is beneath him. He is only three years older and is already married with two kids. He starts to talk down…
- 1019 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
As the story starts we see a young couple. At first glance it is a stereotypical gender couple. The man is in charge. He does the ordering for them He makes the decisions as to what and how much they will drink. She allows him to be in charge (letting him be the stronger one the male). She even ask him “What should we drink?” (Hemingway, 2012, p.4) She lets him be in control. Like most women of the time period (1920 's -1930 's) Jig wants to to please her man. She is willing to do this at any cost. Jig would even have an abortion if that 's what it will take to please him. “And if I do it you 'll be happy and things will be like they were and you 'll love me?” (Hemingway ,2012, p.55)…
- 807 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
The conflict of man vs. society is quickly revealed from the beginning of the novel. Through a recalled account of past life events, the reader is allowed to grasp an understanding of the life of Janie Crawford. Her life’s trials and tribulations have compelled her into the woman she is, a woman of self-determination who has abandoned the idea of the need for a male presence, as a result of three unsuccessful marriages. Coming into her own, Janie battles with society’s ignorant definition of gender roles and relations versus her personal views of self progression and independence. From her financially driven first marriage to the death of her last husband, she has taken on the flaws of others, specifically a man, to help her search for personal happiness, which has only hindered her progression. Janie once took on the same views as society but due to her personal experiences that allowed herself growth, she broke free of the biased, realizing that the development of an individual identity amounts way more than simply compromising for the like of others.…
- 581 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
When Elizabeth and Sylvie come back from their trip after 3 days, “In the sink was a mountainous pile of dishes.” and the boys are just sitting at the table playing cards instead of cleaning up their mess. Back then she thinks that only women works and men can do whatever they want but now Elizabeth realizes that she was the reason her sons are like that. “All along I bin blamin’ men fer bein’ men. But now I see that oftentimes it’s the women that make them that way”. After she realizes her mistake, she tries to tell her sons to help out in the family, she hopes to at least change them so that when they have a family, they can help out their wives so that in the future generations, women and men have equal standing in the house.…
- 591 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays