Today we see many of the Jeffersonian principles in action. We have attempted to expand the right to a free primary education to include all races and religions, so as to offer the opportunities of social mobility equally. One of Jefferson 's fundamental concerns was that education serve the democratic system. His belief that all members of society be able to make competent political judgments through general education is an analogue to the modern no child left behind ' policy our nation is attempting to adopt. Jefferson proposed more state and federal control over education, so that the population could be equally and properly educated. Our current system of accountability and standardized testing is an attempt to ensure a general knowledge base for the entire population. There are many positive aspects of this kind of system, but it ignores many important aspects of education in general. If students are constantly studying for standardized tests based on a general knowledge base, they are not able to focus on differentiation. This is not a practical system, as it does not take individual goals and interests into consideration, reserving that ability for college. Any nation as diverse as ours cannot hope to effectively teach a common curriculum with a common method. Loyola University holds its common curriculum as a cornerstone of college education, but it also encourages students to criticize, analyze, and question both the material and the system in concurrence with the Jesuit ideals it holds. This is much closer to a true Jeffersonian system, although its very nature as a private institution places it outside of Jefferson 's realm of concern.
Horace Mann would be the next great influence on modern education. He was the most outspoken proponent of a practical education, one which related the concepts being taught to the future careers and vocations the students might choose to pursue. His philosophy of education included the theory that education provided the power of social mobility and the ability to live outside the status quo. Much like Franklin, Mann believed that the principle purpose of education was to allow the individual to better themselves and their position in life. Equally important was an exposure to the ideas and doctrines that form moral guides and spiritual beliefs. Although he was a proponent of non-sectarian religious education, he was not a proponent of religious indoctrination. In his development of the common school movement, he says, When the teacher, in the course of his lessons or lectures on the fundamental law arrives at a controverted text, he is either to read it without comment or remar; or at most, he is only to say that the passage is the subject of disputation, and that the schoolroom is neither the tribunal to adjudicate, nor the forum to discuss it.
This comment reflects the development of the American ideal for the School System. Fundamentally, we are still struggling to come to terms with this type of education. Throughout the history of American education, the greatest struggle has been the degree to which political and religious beliefs should affect education. While in Mann 's time an abundance of religious indoctrination was the issue, we are currently facing a right-wing backlash against the separation of church and state as it relates to the school system. Mann proposed that students be shown Christian values, not inflicted with them, so that that they may make their own choices. In today 's public schools, a religious or moral education is absolutely maligned in favor of an intellectual elitist attitude that neglects spiritual development altogether.
Finally, the developments of John Dewey and Johann Pestolazzi would set the stage for the state of modern education. As the United States developed a more rigid system of education, it became apparent that more systematic practices were necessary, as well as changes to the methods in which subjects were taught. Pestolazzi continued the practical nature of the Herbartian movement to an even greater extent by extending the practicality to the home and the maternal method of instruction. While it economic benefits may have influenced his championing of women as natural teachers (they were paid a third as much at the time), it brought the educational system to a level of equality unseen in other careers. John Dewey 's developments of teacher education combine with Jefferson 's to form the modern requirements for teaching certification.
While all of these figures were tremendously influential, the state of the American educational system is far from stable. The reason these figures stand alone as the most influential is that their concerns and actions are at the basis of all the current issues in the educational system today. The role of education is still something we struggle to define, as is the nature of education. Is it the role of a state to control the opinions and ideologies through education, or are we truly a free nation? With the growth of the internet and other forms of free information, we are approaching a time when we must truly decide what is knowledge, what is necessary education, and what is the role of the school in modern culture.
Works Cited
Spring, Joel. "The American School." New York, McGraw Hill (2001).
Cited: Spring, Joel. "The American School." New York, McGraw Hill (2001).
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
The Common School Movement was a crucial aspect of the 1830s and 1840s, and it has paved the way for education today. Horace Mann, the father of Common Schools, diligently earned the title, whereas he advocated for free public education, and caused much controversy doing so. In his efforts to implement the common school, Horace Mann wrote appealing, persuasive, and controversial reports, with the twelfth report being the most popular. In Horace Mann’s twelfth report, he frames the goals of education into five categories; physical education, intellectual education, political education, moral education, and religious education. In his report Mann states many of his concerns with past education schooling, he says, “Our schools, far more than they…
- 317 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
It is clear that changes in society, whether they are political or economical, always make a difference in the way education is viewed and taught. Chapter 6 talks about how the goals of education are linked to the questions of who controls American education and who decides what knowledge is of most value to teach to students. The first sections talks about should knowledge being taught be left up to federal government, state government, local school boards or parents. It all comes down to control. We exercise control over public schools in many ways like voting representatives to the local school boards and the parents having the power to select the school their children go to.…
- 340 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Benjamin Franklin and Booker T. Washington were both American personalities that assumed great importance in the history of the United States. Franklin was born in 1706, in Boston, to an English father and an American mother. Washington, on the other hand, having a family history of slaves, did not know his origins or anything about his ancestries. As the author himself says in his autobiography, “My life had its beginning in the midst of the most miserable, desolate, and discouraging surroundings.” (Washington, p.15). He only knew his mother, a brother and a sister and he did not even know the time or the place of his birth. In spite of some significant differences in their early lives and, after, along their trajectories, Benjamin Franklin and…
- 1475 Words
- 6 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Throughout the development of education in the United States, individuals have extolled the need for protection from political forces seeking conformity in the realm of ideas. This protection has been of particular importance during those times when the educational goals may have been more a reflection of the political policies of those in power, rather than the advancement of new theories or ideas (American Association of University Professors, 1970).…
- 1492 Words
- 6 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Benjamin Franklin is a major figure in early American history. He accomplished many great things for his country as a politician, political theorist, writer, and a diplomat. Ironically, in his “Autobiography” he shows himself as more of a scientist than a political thinker. A reader gets a full picture of Franklin who is interested in learning and fascinated by doing whatever he can to make life a little bit better for American citizens. He truly believed that the only way to please God and be a good person, was by doing good deeds for other people, without wanting anything in return.…
- 670 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Thomas Jefferson, had many ideas about the distinctive version of America. He believed in education throughout the states. Women’s education opportunities, Native American, and Higher education. He wanted to establish an American public school system to boost the [electorate] (Brinkly, 2012). Most of the facilities for education were private schools which most people were not wealthy enough to attend. The majority of the women were not educated with small [illiteracy rates at the time of the revolution] (Brinkly, 2012). Many had beliefs that the [“revolutionary mother”] (Brinkly, 2012) could make great contributions to the education of the children giving them a great sense of meaning bringing up the next generation of leaders.…
- 482 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Franklin exemplifies America as a new civilization taking its first baby steps or saying its first words. Colonists are brave and ambitious for the new world. Franklin, having such high hopes, is able to help shape the new civilization with elements such as education. For instance, Franklin states “These libraries have improv'd the general conversation of the Americans, made the common tradesmen and farmers as intelligent as most gentlemen from other countries, and perhaps have contributed in some degree to the stand so generally made throughout the colonies in defense of their privileges.” Franklin is able to show high American standards by the quality of its libraries.…
- 772 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Benjamin Franklin 's Autobiography catalogues his poor background and the way that he learned to educate himself. Because of his background, Franklin was most concerned with introducing a work ethic among the younger generation that stresses not only hard work in one 's job, but also a dedication to improve oneself by reading and applying the learned knowledge to oneself. To this end, Franklin provides a thorough account of the society he created for him and his peers called Junto. This group was dedicated to the studying and understanding of all the arts, philosophy, and science. This interaction, coupled with his own reading time, becomes the best model of education that Benjamin Franklin can provide. Thomas Jefferson, however, is more interested in a formal education which is certainly what he received as a member of an aristocratic family. Jefferson details a multi-tiered plan for education in the new United States that involves free primary public education to all, with the best and the brightest students moving up through college education. This rigorously structured plan does share one thing in common with Franklin 's ideas; it allows for a hardworking son of a poor farmer to achieve at the same level as a child of a rich family. Jefferson understands that great students and…
- 1107 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
At the birth of our democratic republic prominent political leaders, Thomas Jefferson, Benjamin Franklin, Benjamin Rush, Noah Webster, and others, recognized that educating the youth of our nation was critical for the future prosperity and security of America. These men, in their writings and oratories, strongly advocated for a publicly supported, non-secularized system of education that would be available to all American children free of charge. However, the newly ratified U.S. Constitution contained no provisions for education and, consequently, the responsibility for providing public education was given unto the individual states. Indeed, of the original thirteen states, seven states included provisions for public education in their constitutions, as would each future state, only in the South was the concept of public education resisted until after the Civil War. Over the next two centuries, public education in America would change and evolve, responding to changes both from within our own society and, increasingly in modern times, from forces that are reshaping the world. This essay shall briefly examine four distinct phases in the development of American public education and some of the individuals who made significant contributions that helped shape our modern system of public education.…
- 1187 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
The cornerstone of the United States of America is its Founding Fathers. This group of highly educated, wealthy aristocrats instigated the revolution against Britain, built the American system of government from scratch, and introduced American ideals that would resonate with the rest of the world. Some of the most acclaimed Founding Fathers include George Washington, John Adams, and Thomas Jefferson. However, although all of the Founding Fathers influenced the country in one way or another, none of them had as large of an impact as Benjamin Franklin. In addition to being a Founding Father, this Massachusetts-born Patriot was a renowned author, printer, scientist, politician, diplomat, and much more. Because of his exemplary work in these different…
- 1504 Words
- 7 Pages
Better Essays -
Back then, education wasn’t very important as it is today. There was no learning standards, grade levels, or even a base to rely on. However, that all began to change. American citizens demanded tax supported schools so that it could eventually improve in an efficient way. On the other hand, this idea resulted in a spark of disagreement with those who sent their children to private schools, which weren’t tax supported. One of the most important leaders of the movement was Horace Mann. He added different teaching and learning programs. In addition, he had also doubled the amount that the state spent on schools to enhance the learning experience like it is today. In document 3, he states, “I believe in the existence of a great, immortal immutable principle of natural law”. This excerpt from his speech demonstrates that people should be the ones who decide whether or not they want to learn--not the…
- 589 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
During the 1980 President Regan decided to abolish the Federal Department of Education and to turn education back into the hands of the localities and the state. During these years there were also dramatic changes in ideas about the purposes and content of schooling. By the end of Regan terms school researchers came to the conclusion that basic skills was no longer sufficient enough to be competitive globally. They contended that teaching should be more deeply rooted in the disciplines and much more demanding. Teachers should be able to help students understand mathematical concepts, interpret serious concepts, write creatively and converse thoughtfully about science and history. Reformer proposed changes in politics and policy’s to achieve these goals (Ladd, nd)…
- 1360 Words
- 6 Pages
Powerful Essays -
An innovator and pioneer in the fields of education, science, and politics, Benjamin Franklin’s contributions to society were great and long-lasting. Climbing the social ladder, he worked his way from the lower-middle class and eventually became an affluent leader who played a crucial role in America’s quest for independence. The epitome of the American Dream, Franklin was the first true example of how someone could achieve success and prosperity through their own hard…
- 452 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
The study of education is very multifaceted with topics ranging from teaching methods to history. The two are inextricably linked, however. To understand the origins of the practices of modern teachers and the ways that schools function, one must look to the past to see the development of those practices. Education in American society has been a changing mechanism since even before the United States became a nation. The role of education has changed as society changed to adjust for the new needs of society. School structure has also shift tremendously since the nation began. By looking at people and events that were shaping American society throughout history, one can see how schools evolve over time.…
- 1585 Words
- 7 Pages
Better Essays -
Menger, K., "New approach to teaching intermediate mathematics," Science, 127, 1320 (1958). Pressey, S. L., School and Society, 23, 586 (1926). ,ibid.,36,934 (1932). Skinner, B. F., "The experimental analysis of behavior," Am. Scientist, 45, 4 (1957) . Verbal Behavior (Appleton-Ceutury-Crofts, New York, 1957). "The science of learning and the art of teaching," Harvard Educational Rev., 24,2(1954). Science and Ilunian Behavior (Macmillan, New York, 1953). Dr. Homme prepared sets of frames for teaching part of college physics (kinematics), and Mrs. Meyer has prepared and informally tested material in remedial reading and vocabulary building at the junior high school level. Others who have contributed to the development of teaching machines should be mentioned. Nathan H. Azrin cooperated with me in testing a version of a machine to teach arithmetic. C. B. Ferster and Stanley M. Sapon used a simple "machine" to teach German [see "An application of recent developments in psychology to the teaching of German," Harvard Educational Rev., 28, 1 (1958)]. Douglas Porter, of the Graduate School of Education at Harvard, has made an independent schoolroom test of machine instruction in spelling [see "Teaching machines," Harvard Graduate School of Ethic. Assoc. Bull., 3, 1 (1958) ]. Devra…
- 7775 Words
- 32 Pages
Good Essays