Four Ethical Frames Related To The Ethic Of Justice

Justification Essay Decision-making is part of daily life, and understanding biases, perspectives, and values assists leaders and those in power to make more informed decisions. The ethical dilemma presented requires deep reflection and analysis of my ability to honor my mother’s dying wishes while navigating through family disputes and grief. As the “chosen” decision maker of the family, am I equipped to select the most appropriate course of action? Should I have convinced my mother to undergo treatment in hopes of living longer? Application of four ethical frames related to the ethical dilemma is provided.
Ethical Frames Approaching ethical decisions through the frames of justice, critique, care, and the profession allows leaders to reflect on their decisions from various
Ethic of Justice focuses on rules, laws, and more “abstract concepts of fairness, equity, and justice” (Shapiro & Stepkovich, 2005, p.13). Application of the Ethic of Justice “serves as the foundation for legal principles and ideals” (Shapiro & Stepkovich, p.13). On the other hand, the Ethic of Critique challenges the status quo and uses a critical lens to analyze and reframe concepts, including power, privilege, and inequities (Shapiro & Stepkovich, 2015). In contrast to the Ethic of Justice, the Ethic of Care considers consequences and values input and collaboration from multiple voices in the decision-making process. With the Ethic of Care, hierarchical, top-down formats are challenged with a more inclusive approach taking precedence. As Staratt (1991) noted, the Ethic of Care, “postulates a level of caring that honors the dignity of each person and desires to see that