The pessimist viewpoint, which he later discredits, theorizes that if determinism is true then any concept of moral obligation or responsibility, and thus punishment for defiance of these expectations, is unjust. This is because the pessimist idea assumes positive freedom which requires not only the capacity to act, but also that the outcome of this action is not pre-ordained. This argument proposes that since we do not have the free will to truly
The pessimist viewpoint, which he later discredits, theorizes that if determinism is true then any concept of moral obligation or responsibility, and thus punishment for defiance of these expectations, is unjust. This is because the pessimist idea assumes positive freedom which requires not only the capacity to act, but also that the outcome of this action is not pre-ordained. This argument proposes that since we do not have the free will to truly