In recent decades many Australians have probably gained their strongest impressions of Gallipoli from Peter Weir's famous film of the same name. Weir's audience could be forgiven for believing that most of the fighting on Gallipoli was done by Australians under British leadership. Even the New Zealanders fail to rate a mention in the film. The truth, however, is very different and there are several general histories of the campaign that more accurately reflect the relative roles of the various combatant nations.
General histories
Two of the best known general histories of the campaign are Alan Moorehead's 1956 book Gallipoli and Robert Rhodes James's 1965 book of the same name. In the introduction to his 1999 edition, Rhodes James wrote that although he was at first very impressed with Moorehead's study, a second reading led him to a different conclusion. Moorehead's Gallipoli, he wrote, was the work of "'a brilliant journalist, not an historian". It is true that Moorehead wrote with the flair of an experienced journalist and, for the