“The Film Gattaca Presents a World Destroyed by the pursuit of our perfection. Discuss.” Andrew Niccol’s film Gattaca does present a world where the world has been destroyed by human’s pursuit of perfection. It is the characters in the movie which show this, Vincent, Jerome & Irene. These three characters illustrate a world to the viewer, a world were perfection means everything. It is this I intend to illustrate for you on how Andrew Niccol’s film shows us a world that has been destroyed by the human pursuit of perfection. Vincent is considered an invalid in the world of Gattaca, because he wasn’t created the valid way. The valid way is done through altering the genetic code of a person, a person engineered to be perfect. Vincent however is anything but perfect; he has a 99% of Heart Failure and is presumed to die at the age of 30. The world of Gattaca is one based solely on perfection, this is shown by the selection criteria of the Gattaca program, in which only the perfect enter, valids. This shows the audience on how intent the world of Gattaca is on being perfect, with the creation of a ‘perfect’ civilization. The world is destroyed; there is a new underclass that is discriminated upon and not given a chance to succeed in the world. One scene in particular which shows this is when the Investigator has all the Invalids lined up for testing, we see darkness which shows the audience that these invalid’s live a dark life. It is this new underclass which shows us the destruction of the world in Gattaca all for the pursuit of our own perfection. On the other Hand we have Jerome Morrow who is an valid. Jerome has the perfect helix so to speak, with an off the scale IQ and a heart of an ox. Jerome is an example of how the world’s people are with their pursuit to perfection. Jerome lives under the burden of perfection which is a burden which many in the Gattaca world would be under, the burden to be the very b...
Essay on Gattaca
In an age where technology is advancing rapidly, there are those who argue for slowing it down so it can be critically and ethically examined. However, there are many who believe there should be as few restrictions as possible, if any.
Gattaca presents a society in which genetic engineering and perfection is worshipped, with anything less unacceptable and discriminated against. The increased focus on technology has decreased the human element, and values have changed. Yet even those genetically superior suffer, as Vincent so aptly puts it, they suffer from “the burden of perfection”. Gattaca is so totalitarian in nature, that even human rights are subjugated and individuality is suppressed. Surely this is not a perfect world.
Our Service Can Write a Custom Essay on Gattaca for You!
Certainly Vincent bemoans the way in which society has changed due to the ongoing attempt to create perfection. Old values no longer contain the same message and relevance, “They used to say a child conceived in love has a greater chance of happiness. They don’t say that anymore”. Furthermore, Vincent adds, “Ten fingers, ten toes, that’s all that used to matter. Not now.” The belief of what it means to be human has changed and diminished, with human life not valued in the same way that it used to be. That term, human life, takes on a new meaning. Human life is simply a commodity to be bought and sold. This is displayed by German, who makes a handsome living trading in genetic material. Gattaca’s society now sees life as expendable. The director has no qualms in murdering a colleague who opposes his vision. He shows no compassion, remorse or conscience in this, simply pride in that he has successfully achieved his goal of launching the mission to Titan. This is indicative of the declining morality of civilisation.
The destruction of “man’s perfect world” is also evident, when the suffering of both “invalids” and “valids” is recognized. Vincent, a faith birth in what is no longer “the natural way”, is discriminated against by schools, organisation’s such as Gattaca and even his own family. This is apparent when Vincent is refused his father’s name, the removal of his name from the measuring pole and the symbolic exclusion of the gates shutting him out from school. In a society where perfection and faultless DNA credentials are idolised, morality has little place.
Due to this pressure placed on individuals to be “the best”, even valids such as Jerome and Anton suffer. They both have a neurotic sense of failure which gnaws away at their insides. Despite these two being given the best possible start to their lives by their local genecists, they are unable to fulfill their own and society’s expectations, and the pressure becomes too great a burden. Irene, also a valid, has a heart defect. She waits for her death. All three lack inner strength and spirit, that only Vincent possesses. Gattaca, through its characters, displays constant suffering, certainly not a credential of a perfect world.
The lack of individuality and distinctiveness in the occupants of Gattaca is alarming at best. With the constant pressure to succeed in life, manufactured or “valid” human beings are sapped of their spirit, ultimately leading to a discontented and empty life. The culture and image of Gattaca influences this, with strongly similar and sometimes identical designs of suits, workstations, and employees in general. Add to this the lack of communication and constant competitiveness between staff and the result is a chilling, depressing workplace, which is a valuable indicator of life itself.
Not only is the value of the individual debased, human life itself is denigrated. The use of genetic engineering to achieve a physically superior human being reduces humans to machines, simply required to perform particular functions.
Ironically, Gattaca, through its obsession with perfection, has created a world more imperfect than the one it preceded. The value of human life, individuality, relationships and morals appear corrupted and dejected, as the inevitable search of perfecting one’s self proliferates.
Discrimination and suffering of humans beings is frequent yet ignored in Gattaca, where the one predominant norm in society-do whatever is necessary to be the best, conquers all.
Together, the opening epigraphs, “I not only think that we will tamper with Mother Nature, I think Mother Nature wants us to (William Gaylin)”, and “Consider God’s handiwork; who can straighten what he hath made crooked (Ecclesiastes 7:13)” offer insightful philosophies on “the not too distant future’ demonstrated in Gattaca. Gaylin shows the obvious temptation in tampering with technology, yet Ecclesiastes emphasizes the impossible task of creating perfection.
Inevitably, the content of Gattaca ultimately demonstrates that the search for perfection can only lead to an imperfect world.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Gattaca (1997) is a film directed by Andrew Niccol that is based on the Science of Genetic discrimination. A world in which scientific proof becomes the complete basis for discrimination. While society holds it as a truth, genes are a primary factor that determine the success of an individual. The film revolves around the Protagonist Vincent Freeman (Ethan Hawke), and his struggle to achieve what he has worked his entire life to get to, but is unable, due to his “In-Valid” status. He is ignored and excluded from most aspects of society. His life is limited to the ‘second best’ option.…
- 765 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Over a period of time sci-fi authors and composers have presented their texts and films using cautionary tales of our soon to be dystopic society. They use informing techniques to instil the fear of a futuristic dystopic society into the minds of readers and viewers. These authors and composers also bring forth the concepts of conformity, mind-control and censorship. The novel, Fahrenheit 451, written by Ray Bradbury, and the film Gattaca, composed by Andrew Niccol, were not only stimulated to act as cautionary tales but were also influenced by events occurring at the time such as McCarthyism, the post WW2 duration, and the start of eugenics.…
- 955 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
From the day Vincent was born, he had always been concidered as highly flawed, and as an 'invalid'. His parents were planning on carrying on the family name with their first born child by calling Vincent, Anton, after his father, Antonio. However, once finding out that Vincent was prone to illness' such as neurological disorder, manic depression, attention deficit disorder, heart failure, and was expected to live for only 30.2 years, Vincent's father felt that he wasn't worthy of the family name, and decided to call him Vincent Anton instead. Mother and Father, Maria and Antonio had a second child, who Antonio felt was worthy of the family name, because unlike Vincent who was conceived the natural way, Anton was born through genetic engineering. As the two boys grew up, Anton was always considered superior to Vincent as he was always upstaging him at everything they did. Until one day, when the two boys played a game of chicken. Like usual, Anton was expecting Vincent to turn around and swim back to shore. However, no matter how much effort he put into trying to beat his brother, Anton and Vincent were neck and neck the whole swim. Anton was confused at how Vincent still had the energy to swim, and finally Anton wasn't able to go on any longer and he gave up. Passing out and starting to drown, Vincent saved his brother's life. For the first time in their lives, Vincent was better than Anton at something. Even though everybody believed that he wasn't good enough to acheive his goals, Vincent now believed that he could achieve anything that he set his mind to. Vincent decided to run away from home and he got a job as a janitor at Gattaca. This was his first glimpse of Gattaca, and he liked what he saw.…
- 777 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
In the 1997 movie, Gattaca, Vincent Freeman is an invalid born into a valid world. This means his parents decided not to pick and choose the ideal genes in the process of conceiving him, causing Vincent to be born with heart problems, asthma, and myopia. He then makes the decision to become Jerome Eugene Morrow and pass himself off as valid in order to achieve his dream of traveling into space. In the movie, there is a clear divide between the valids and invalids, revealing many connections to sociology. Through the poor treatment of invalids, the worshipping of valids, and the lengths Vincent goes through as Gerome all connect to symbolic interaction, Durkheim’s labeling theory, deviance, and the structural-functional paradigm.…
- 1330 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
Gattaca, directed by Andrew Niccol, shows a story of a society where life is controlled by genetics, rather than education or experiences. Based on your DNA, society determines where you belong, and your future. This allows no room for people to gain experiences and to grow, as they are confined to a specific lifestyle. It is evident however in the film that Vincent tries to violate societies’ structure, by playing the role of a navigator, using his blood samples and urine. George Orwell, the author of 1984, shows a similar concept, where life is controlled by the Party and where the main character, Winston, tries to defy the Party. Although it is obvious that both works have a dystopian society, the societies within it struggle to achieve a utopian society instead. Through its intense depiction of struggles to fit in and altering way of life to be accepted in society, Gattaca has enhanced the understanding of the impact that surveillance has in 1984 and how it has limited the people to prosper in life within society.…
- 536 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
The text makes a clear distinction between ‘human’ and genetic traits. So clear is the distinction that Niccol uses separate vehicles to display each set of traits. As the traits and the vehicles clash, Niccol creates a sense of sympathy for Vincent as he is portrayed as the disadvantaged and weak in society in the sense that he does not possess the physical and mental assets that make him a valued member of society. A key example of this is the recurring games of ‘chicken’ between Vincent and his genetically superior brother Anton. Anton beats Vincent time and time again as is expected of Anton by society. However, when Vincent bests his brother one day an emphasis is placed on the manner in which he beat his brother. “You wanna know how I did it? I never saved anything for the swim back!” This creates the impression to the viewer that Vincent did not win with superior stamina, skill or physical strength, rather he won as he possessed traits like courage, determination and grit, traits that are lost in the geno-centric society in which he loves but traits that are valued and admired in todays society.…
- 844 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
The birth scene has a gloomy tone and color scheme, suggesting that this method of living is something humans should avoid. Since this film is a futuristic film about the use of the findings from the Human Genome Project, this film is warning us about the possible misuse of the new genetic information. Geneticists are an important job in the film because after one second, the blood is being tested and geneticists can determine your life and future. This determines how long your life will be and what diseases you may face, but not how happy or what you will face in life. It is different from a fortune teller. A fortune teller tells the outside danger that you may face, however, this warns you about…
- 1211 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
It would appear in the film, that genetically enhanced beings are preferred over naturally developed humans. Genetic engineering is believed to create a superior being; a human free from supposed "genetic dispositions" including anything from premature baldness to behavior disorders. This notion creates a division of superiority starting from birth. For example, Vincent, the protagonist of the film, was a God-child; his younger brother Anton, one the other hand, was genetically crafted. During the designing phase of Anton's genes, his parents have second thoughts about whether or not to "leave some things to chance," but after his mother gazes toward Vincent, seeming to acknowledge his imperfections, nods in agreement to alter the embryo. It's from this moment forth that Vincent, even from his parents perspective, is seen as defective and inferior. His unborn sibling is "worthy of his father's name" and quickly becomes to the family's preference. Discrimination is not only used in personal matters such as these, but also in the workforce. Biologically engineered individuals are given the most prestigious positions, whilst those naturally born are deemed subordinate and reserved for menial work. Vincent falls victim to this bias and describes how he "belonged to a new underclass, no longer determined by social status or the color of your…
- 857 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
By opening the movie Gattaca with quotations from Willard Gaylin and Ecclesiastes, director Andrew Niccol invites us to ponder the tension between science and religion with regard to the ethics of genetic engineering. This tension is further sustained through the complex relationship of the main protagonists Vincent and Eugene, who must ultimately conquer their own physical limitations in order to find ``God''.…
- 1123 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
He suggests that although man may reach ‘the point where we can direct our own evolution’, man is still incapable of evolving past the primal human instincts such as the need to compare and rate, the desire for power, the inability to be satisfied, the ability to kill. The society of Gattaca is based upon a very strict class system; Valids and In-Valids. The aristocratic Valid characters are made obvious by their dark, classy clothes and superior attitudes. This is shown through the general disbelief that an In-Valid could ever sneak into Gattaca. The lower caste In-Valids are garbed in shabby browns and appear less attractive and intelligent then Valids. The ensemble between Valids and In-Valids can be compared to the way nobles have treated commoners throughout history, Jerome illustrates this when a detective dares to question him and he shouts him out of his house. This society places Vailds in an elite, almost royal, position. The Valids world is similar to that of Victorian England, how much royal blood equates to how one ranks genetically. ‘He’s a 9.3’ can parallel to ‘He’s a…
- 945 Words
- 4 Pages
Better Essays -
Gattaca, the “not too distant” future world of Andrew Niccol, is a world that is destroyed by the pursuit of perfection due to the science of genetic selection. This is often resembled by the fact that there are no individuals, the beings in this movie are almost sexless, have a limited personality and behave in a uniform manner. It also leaves people believing that their genetic makeup is what allows them to achieve their ambitions, or in the case of Irene and Vincent, prevent them from achieving their life goals. Genetic selection also segregates the valids, people who have had their genetics chosen, and the in-valids, children from ‘faith births’ where their genetic selection was left up to fate.…
- 884 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
The Brave New World by Aldous Huxley discusses a utopian society in which everything is "perfect". Huxley believes that a society like this will emerge in the future due to rapid development of science. Members of the society are genetically engineered and assigned a class by their intelligence. The society is truly flawless in the sense that everyone is happy with the freedoms they have. On the other hand, people in this society are far from perfect because of their freedoms and the way that they were raised. As a society they are lacking the ability to be compassionate with others, simply because they never had to be compassionate. It seems as if they are not even human beings anymore because humans generally care about thing and do what…
- 716 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
“All men are created equal” these are the words of Thomas Jefferson. Jefferson believed we should live in a world like this, but are we meant to live in a society where everyone is equal and normal? The ideas of egalitarianism can be dangerous if they are interpreted too literally. The agonizing and frustrating normal world in which “Harrison Bergeron” by Kurt Vonnegut Jr. shows a civilization in which being normal is the only life style that people can live. Beauty is not beauty in this story; in fact it is the complete opposite. Can someone reach their full potential without feeling good about themselves? Is it possible to live life in a world like this? Potential, freedom, and beauty are all abominations in the society of “Harrison Bergeron” by Kurt Vonnegut Jr., but they are all but abolished in this generation of “normal people” where being unique is deemed as illegal. No one is better, everyone is worse. But in a world where the extraordinary is outlawed, only the outlaws are extraordinary.…
- 884 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
There is no denying that it is man’s innate desire to want more, to be better, and to strive for perfection. In Aldous Huxley’s Brave New World, that same desire is what drives the World State to construct a “civilized” society where happiness determines “Community, identity, stability (Huxley, 3).” Juxtaposed to a Savage Reservation, this “Brave New World” eventually reveals itself as being anything but a Utopia, because nothing is perfect.…
- 655 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The ethical issues presented in Gattaca are ethical egoism, psychological egoism, sacrifice and the possibilities of radical perfection. It challenged the worthiness of the consequences of extreme self serving efforts; to take risks; to do the impossible despite public opinion. These ethical issues are based on the main character, Vincent. He uses these ideologies to achieve his goal of perfection, defying the constant disapproval of his parents which alienated him as a child.…
- 594 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays