Existence Argument
Many problems exist in our modern society, one of which is the unequal pay rates of men and women. This "gender pay gap" has been cause for many debates over the years but the simple fact of the matter is that a difference between men and women's salary most certainly exists even in the present day. Regardless of this empirical fact many parties still argue that a pay gap does not exist. The major argument used to debate said non existence of a gender specific pay gap is that women don't get paid less than men due to discrimination but rather they get paid less because they are simply not trying hard enough to get paid more. Apparently according this argument, women tend to lean more towards "softer" careers, ones that tend to pay less, in order to spend more time with the family. However if a woman did choose a "hard" career, one that pays more, she apparently would be held back from making more money by her choice to have a child and a family, but both these arguments are forms of discrimination in of themselves. Who is to say that a man could not be the one raising a child or wanting to spend time with his family? This traditional way of thought is the fundamental basis for their argument against the existence of a gender pay gap, one that stems from cultural expectations on who has to cut back on their career to care for a child. It's simply blindly expected that a woman's choice to have a child would have a major impact on her career and the same does not apply for a man, so much so that she deserves to make less income than a man would. Stepping back briefly to look at the data that supports the side that a gender pay gap does in fact exist, data was collected from the Center of American Progress Center stating that women as a whole make around $10,000 less a year on average than a man would. As of 2010 women have been making just 77% of income a man would make when both parties a working full time. The most startling fact is that when taking into account, ethnicity, age and education level, woman make less across the board when compared to their male counterpart. The only left standing would be that woman choose easier careers that offer more time for family life and thus pay less money but this notion is ultimately flawed as well. The problem with this argument is that it groups women of all careers with men all careers but in order to see the full picture one must take a glance at each career field in its own regard. Using data from the bureau of labor statistics, it's apart that the gender pay gap exists in nearly every sector including the areas that usually are controlled by the female population. Simply put, a female joining the same high paying profession as a male, both having equal education, would still make less than said male. With this it becoming readily apparent that there is in fact still an issue with women not receiving equal pay to men in occupations across the entire spectrum of the work force.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
When Congress enacted the Equal Pay Act in 1963, it was in an attempt to remedy the “ancient but outmoded belief that a man, because of his role in society, should be paid more than a woman even though his duties are the same (Bixler, 2005).” Due to the Equal Pay Act, women have seen a 30 percent increase in pay in relation to men’s in the last 30 to 40 years (Bixler, 2005), but it is still far from being the equality that Congress sought. Gender segregation, long-term low wages, and limitation of workable hours are all contributing factors to the current wage discrepancy, which is unacceptable.…
- 660 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Gender pay gaps persist not only in the United States but also around the world. The gender pay inequality is the reason why female in America makes 78 cents per 1 dollar of males’ salary. The gender is still the factor when it comes of determining a salary for an employee. Woman always placed with wage discrepancies and difference compared to what men earn. Unseen and often not acknowledged barriers that stop a woman from rising to upper position regardless of their achievement or qualifications. These patterns shows acceptance and power of social structure in our society.…
- 233 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
The gender based pay gap is an important business, ethical, and legal issue. Due to the relevance of the pay gap issue and its prevalence in the literature, I will be able to provide the necessary and adequate information for the Critical Analysis Template within all eleven categories. The gender pay gap will ultimately effect my career, since it is an ongoing dilemma within society. With the pay gap’s social and personal ramifications, a deeper understanding of this issue will enable me to be a stronger advocate for justice and equality as a Christian businesswoman.…
- 95 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
Today’s society continues to argue about the subject of social inequalities even in cosmopolitan and first world countries like United States. Gender inequality is a subject that have been forgotten eventually since the women civil rights movement developed and they started gaining an equal right for work. Still, in U.S history, gender inequalities remain till today in relation to the workplace to some degree. The Gender Wage gap is considered a gender inequality, but could be also a result of the interaction of many factors such as education, hours of work, career, etc. Indeed, by definition it is a “statistical indicator” of the amount of money women’s earn in relation to men’s work salaries and calculated by dividing the median annual earnings of women with the median annual earnings of men (Brunner and Rowen, 2012; OECD).…
- 1396 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
For instance, they don’t take into account women who only work part time, or women who work less hours. Some may argue that even when a man and woman work the same job for the same amount of hours, the man will still be payed 21 cents more. This is simply a lie, there is no proof to backup this statement. When a person, no matter their…
- 751 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
This essay, published by The New York Times and written by the journalist Claire Cain Miller, establishes a counter argument for the position that many people have taken on the issue of the gender pay gap. Miller and Harvard labor economist, Claudia Goldin, established the view that the pay gap is because of gender and not because of comparisons between the different jobs that males and females take. Being informed is essential to finding solutions for an issue and in this essay Miller informs her audience and shows how information can lead to meaningful solutions. “Occupations that most value long hours, face time at the office and being on call-like business, law and surgery – tend to have the widest pay gap.” Miller establishes in what occupations…
- 708 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Throughout the years men have been superior to women in labor and in gender. It’s no surprise that even to this day men are still at a higher level than women. It is a fact that women are paid less than men by a vast amount. During the American Revolution women were mostly at home serving as house maids while men did work labor and brought home the money. In the year 1970, white men were paid 100 percent of their earnings while white women got paid 58.7 percent, there is no denying the difference in the wage gap between genders. In addition, the wage gap didn't affect gender only it affected race and ethnicity. In that same year 1970, black men got paid 69.0 percent of their earnings while black women got paid 48.2 percent, it was always men that got paid more and women left behind with barely enough money to feed a household. These percentages didn't change in any way…
- 1713 Words
- 7 Pages
Good Essays -
Some people believe that the gender wage gap simply doesn’t exist and that the earnings…
- 666 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The impact of discrimination against women and their pay entitlements has been, without debate, proven by many polls and research efforts. According to an article published in The Wall Street Journal that conducted a poll discussing gender in workplace bias, “84% of women say men are paid more for similar work, a view borne out by government data but which draws agreement from only two-thirds of men. More than four in 10 women say they have faced gender discrimination personally, most often in the workplace” (Nelson). The article further expounds to address very specific data. Some of that data was collected by the Bureau of Labor Statistics. “The Bureau of Labor Statistics data shows that women who work full-time earn 79% of the weekly pay that men bring home. The Institute for Women's Policy Research, which tracks the gender wage gap, finds that women's median earnings lag men's in almost every occupation. While the gap narrowed during the 1980s and 1990s, there has been little movement since 2000” (Nelson). While there are minute differences in statistical findings from different reports, they have all provided the same general concept that differences in pay do exist based on…
- 1849 Words
- 8 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Two landmark court cases served to strengthen and further define the Equal Pay Act: Schultz v. Wheaton Glass Co. (1970), U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit; Ruled that jobs need to be “substantially equal” nut not “identical” to fall under the protection of the Equal Pay Act. An employer cannot, for example, change the job titles of women workers in order to pay them less than men.; Corning Glass Works v. Brennan (1974) U.S. Supreme Court; Ruled that employers cannot justify paying women lower wages, because that is what they traditionally received under the “going market rate.” A wage differential occurring “simply because men would not work at the low rates paid women” was unacceptable. (“The Equal Pay Act”) While these things have caused the gap to narrow there is still s noticeable difference in the pay of…
- 756 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
The gender wage gap is a constant debate in society today. It is a fact that men are paid a…
- 1704 Words
- 7 Pages
Better Essays -
The wage gap is made a huge deal, but lots of speculation has surfaced about whether it’s real or not. If the wage gap is really the big deal that it’s made out to be, it would being affecting thousands of women all over the US. With all these women it’s affecting, why hasn’t the government put a stop to it? If the wage gap isn’t real, why is it known as the biggest reason for gender inequality in America? This speculation leads me to only one question, is the gender wage gap even real?…
- 619 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
This article is about an issue that has been around for years to decades and is still in debate as I type. This issue is called the Gender Pay Gap it dances or is attached with the federal Equal Pay Act which was signed on 1963 by John F. Kennedy which was part of his New Frontier Program. This year it marks fifty years since the signing of the Equal Pay Act. The purpose for the Equal Pay Act was to prevent discrimination of pay between males and females who are equally educated and skilled providing the same work output at the work site. The article states that on April 9th 2013, which is Equal Pay Day, states that a woman must work into 2013 to equal the pay amount of a man's earnings in 2012.…
- 474 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Over the past hundred years, women’s participation in the workforce has grown significantly. Today’s women are getting college degrees which was not common before the mid-twentieth century. More of them than ever are taking jobs that were originally run by men. Many women are going into medicine, engineering, and law which was nearly impossible fifty years ago. Their ability to get into these fields allows them to pursue careers they could never before. However, there is a major gender pay gap. Men are still to this day paid way more than women. Although men have a large impact on our nation’s workforce, women perform job tasks just as effectively, therefore they are completely worthy…
- 1615 Words
- 7 Pages
Better Essays -
How exhausting is it for a woman to walk in the same place of business as a man with the same job position, and still receive less pay? What a very exhausting feeling! The difference between the amounts of money paid to women and men, often for doing the same work is titled, the “Gender Wage Gap.” I chose this topic because I am a woman, and the thought of a man receiving higher pay than me for the same job is a very difficult thought to have. I believe that understanding the gender wage gap is very important to society as a whole. Equality for women is a perquisite for society as a whole.…
- 1574 Words
- 7 Pages
Better Essays