Preview

Generalization In Malcolm Gladwell's Essay Troublemakers

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
Malcolm Gladwell’s 2006 essay Troublemakers provides an interesting discussion about how we use generalizations in organizing and regulating our society. He frames his discussion with a consideration of the 2005 law banning pit bulls in Ontario, but in between he refers to generalizations in insurance (young male drivers pay higher premiums), medicine (overweight males will be counseled to have their cholesterol checked), law enforcement (what markers are used to identify terrorists) and our perceptions about crime rates in New York City. The pit bull ban is the only law that he considers, the rest are practices or perceptions. Gladwell concludes that the ban on pit bulls is overbroad, because not all pit bulls are dangerous, and that it …show more content…

Gladwell states that laws are often based on generalizations, and in this article he makes a point about how the pit bull law is a “generalization of a generalization of a trait”. Second it is important to use evidence to try and choose an appropriate generalization, because being too vague or too specific can have negative influences on the enforcement of said law. And lastly in an ideal world, lawmakers would periodically review the generalizations that they have based laws upon to ensure the generalization was or remains …show more content…

He suggests that in the case of the pit bull ban, the Ontario Legislature chose the wrong generalization because the real behaviour to be targeted is bad breeding, bad training, and abusive ownership. He refers to evidence that many pit bulls are gentle, which means the law is too broad, and that many other breeds have caused serious injury to people, which suggests a ban on pit bulls only is too narrow. I disagree with Gladwell on this point. I think that the generalization is a good one, and that Gladwell’s conclusion ignores some of the evidence that the Ontario courts looked at. For

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    In Gladwell’s opening chapter of Outliers, he begins to tell us about where success comes from. Right away he makes clear that people do not come from nothing, to be successful, all on their own. He does this because you often here sports broadcasters say, “John Doe, came from absolutely nothing, to become this sports All-Start.” Gladwell uses the analogy of the tallest tree in the forest. He says that that tree does not get to be the tallest on its own. Gladwell reminds us that the sun was not blocked from that tree. That tree had no root damage from rabbits. That the tree was spared from a lumber jack. That tallest tree had help from many aspects of nature.…

    • 505 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The simplest way to describe the “Matthew Effect” is to say that the good will only get better and average will remain average. Gladwell supports this claim using sports examples and asserts that success is not based purely on talent, but rather a combination of talent and other uncontrollable factors, such as opportunities and rules determined by society. He supports this claim by describing the process of how hockey’s All-Stars are chosen. Gladwell explains that because of how the age cutoff dates (a rule set by society) in the hockey leagues are set up, the bigger players are cultivated and receive more attention than the smaller players and therefore, become more skilled. Whereas the smaller players, because of the age cutoff date, will…

    • 243 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    "…the meanest, ‘baddest' dogs in North American Pop Culture have been, without a doubt, pit bulls." Even though this stereotype exists, she challenges it by giving her own relation to pit bulls. "To me, Ahab, is a regular family dog: a joker and a couch potato, hungry for affection and table scraps, gentle and patient with ear-yanking children." She is able to state the real trouble and give information on what is being done to help the subject. "Currently, Canadian animal experts and organizations are lobbying for more comprehensive dangerous dog legislation – something that holds owners of all breeds accountable and doesn't penalize responsible owners of maligned breeds." I feel George is rhetorically effective over all with it comes to her essay, "Pit Bull, Bum Rap?" She gets her position across and leaves you thinking about what can be done to solve the…

    • 667 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Lastly, in Outliers Gladwell has an additional explanation for how outliers came to be, they had motivation. Gladwell provides evidence of how most, if not all, outliers spend at least 10,000 hours of work or practice. There is a study on many outliers that says, “Greatness requires enormous time,” and that amount of time has shown to be around 10,000 hours (Gladwell 47). The Beatles had the motivation to play eight hours each night, seven days a week, for a few years which forced them to turn good into greatness (Gladwell 48). Bill Gates, one of wealthiest guy in the world, got his 10,000 hours in when he found a glitch in a computer system that allowed him to be on a computer for as long as he wanted, instead of being restricted to 1 hour…

    • 186 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the second chapter of his book, Outliers, Malcom Gladwell writes to his readers about the importance of repetitions. In this chapter, Gladwell expresses and gives examples of the importance of repetitions. In order for one to become an expert or excel in something, one must repeat this action for at least 10,000 hours.…

    • 668 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The topic I choose to write about is “Pit Bulls – should this breed be banned?” Pit Bulls should not be banned. Over the past years in the United States, Pit Bulls have been portrayed as a breed who is extremely dangerous and untrustworthy that some States are banning ownership of this breed. This breed should not be banned simply because of unfortunate events. It is not until recently that the negative images these dogs are facing by the media started. One may hear or read headlines in the news stating “Child mauled by a Pit Bull,” or “Owner killed by a Pit Bull,” yet the media does not disclose that certain dog’s upbringing…

    • 374 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Outliers: A Story of Success, Malcolm Gladwell argues that success is achieved not only from hard work, but also from the circumstances and opportunities you meet with. His argument is backed by a multitde examples throughout the book. it is hard to read this and not agree with him.…

    • 504 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    On page 40 of Outliers, a novel written by pop-psych author Malcolm Gladwell, neurologist Daniel Levitin explains, “The emerging picture from such studies is that ten thousand hours of practice is required to achieve the level of mastery associated with being a world class-expert--- in anything.” Gladwell takes this quote and heavily relies on it with his thesis for the next chapter, which basically says that anyone can become a master in anything with excessive amounts of practice. He claims that the greats were not necessarily incredibly gifted at the start of their lives, but with lots of practice and effort, they were able to become experts and masters in their fields. But just how true is this…

    • 1160 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Throughout “Small Change,” Malcolm Gladwell describes how the civil rights movement have changed. He introduces the traditional activism at the beginning of the essay. Then, he briefly introduces one example of reinvented social activism. The author shows social changes by using social media, such as Twitter, Facebook, and YouTube. The author points out that unlike traditional activism, recent social activism is empowered by social media and leads to unexpected results because they can easily unite people together for a cause. However, the author also argues that there are several drawbacks and contradiction. Unlike traditional activism, which is based on strong-tie relationship between ‘friends,’ recent social activism is based on weak-tie…

    • 252 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Pitbull Behavior

    • 925 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Natalie Lima, an animals rights advocate created a whole novel about how the Breed- specific legislation ban creates more issues including the state losing money, the shelters being packed, bite rate not going down, and people would move on to a different “fighting breed”. The other main issue of banning Pit bulls is that dog fighting is presently illegal yet it still happens, therefore, it would pull Pit breeds away from loving family homes and put them in dangerous homes that will abuse their…

    • 925 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Banning Pitbulls

    • 243 Words
    • 1 Page

    People label Pit Bulls as "Killer Machines.” Breed Specific Legislation, or BSL, are a set of laws that restricts or completely bans the breeds of a dog from an area. Pit bulls have been given a bad reputation because of all the publicity pit bulls have received. Many states of the U.S. are stuck between whether or not to ban the breed of pit bulls. People who agree with the BSL may have had a bad experience with dogs, or may fear that they’ll encounter an aggressive dog. Everyone needs to come to the realization that dogs behave a certain way due to treatment from their owners. People need to understand that the BSL is a form of breed profiling, in this case it discriminates against pit bulls. They also need to see that the label of, “Killer…

    • 243 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    breed is responsible for its behavior. These laws are commonly referred to as breed bans,…

    • 1599 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In the animal world Pit bulls are victims of discrimination. The second someone hears the word pit bull they become frightened. A lot of times you will hear on the news that someone had been bit by a dog. Know matter what kind of dog had bit someone, the news shows a picture of a Pit Bull. This is not fair. These animals are no different then any other large breed of dogs. Yet because of some foolish people who take a pit bull puppy, isolate it, starve it, antagonize it, and simply raise it for the sole purpose to fight it for money, there is now the concern to ban this breed. It is not the breed of dog that should be ban. It is the group of people that organize these dog fights. If you are a dog or even an animal lover, please hear…

    • 158 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Annotated Bibliography

    • 986 Words
    • 2 Pages

    "Why Breed-Specific Legislation Doesn't Work." The Humane Society. 9 Jan. 2013. Web. 11 Oct. 2014. <http://www.humanesociety.org/issues/breed-specific-legislation/fact_sheets/breed-specific-legislation-flaws.html>.…

    • 986 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Pitbull Animal Abuse

    • 817 Words
    • 4 Pages

    One of the more specific contributors are definitely morality and how it is the reason some humans are able to bring a dog down and some can’t. Each person has their own individual beliefs and personality contribute as so confiscating the dog in the first place. They are ripped apart from their own family before being thrown into the tight-spaced, cold kennel known as home. Why some may cringe at this idea, some just merely shrug it off as if it was nothing and that is a basis on a person’s morality. Everyday, society is becoming more and more insensitive to inheriting good morals. Many people believe that if it doesn’t affect oneself then why even bother in the first place. If society’s morals were open minded and full-hearted, BSL wouldn’t even have a person to turn to. Yes, they believe it is for the good of humans but why would it be acceptable for criminals to have a chance to live if given the choice but dogs don’t. Canines can’t speak and often humans take advantage of that. Everyday dogs are dying for innocent acts that they didn’t even do but more importantly, only specific breeds are being known to be vicious and ‘deserve’ to be put down. There is no greater threat to society than a person’s own well being and how they treat animals and even wildlife itself because at the end of the day dogs especially are not humans who know exactly how to act and when…

    • 817 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics