Preview

Genetically Modified Foods Ethics

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
408 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Genetically Modified Foods Ethics
Comstock gives key questions that we should ask when trying to access the potential harms associated with genetically modified foods. He portrays his many reasons as to why it is ethically justifiable to pursue genetically modified crops and foods through intrinsic and extrinsic objections, theories (Rights, Utilitarian, Virtue) and via technology going deeper in explaining his reasons using experiments and the precautionary response. I agree with Comstock and defend his reasons in concluding that it is ethically justifiable to pursue genetically modified crops and foods.
Potential harms are associated with genetically modified foods and the key questions Comstock (2001) suggest we ask when trying to access such is, what is the trauma that is envisaged? In other words, how significant and who’s benefiting from such situations and is the case fair and just or is one group being harmed more than another. What kind of data do we have? Do we not have enough information and are we missing something important that we should know? Another key question important is our options. When it comes
…show more content…
The intrinsic objection is the, “Process of making GMOs is objectionable in itself” (Comstock, 2001, p. 487). This notion portrays the view of GM crops and foods as not ‘natural.’ The adoption of GMOs may result in potential harm according to the extrinsic objection (Comstock, 2001, p. 487). These two objections bring up the negative within genetically modified foods and in this case, these are considered “bad” and the “risks.” Alternatively, the positive is based on the fact that people have the right to choose to embrace GM technology and the discovery allows for safer and better results. The technology has many benefits that overcome the risks, providing higher quality foods. This brings about the arguments of what is ethically justified, and how in the end, the good overcomes the

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    GMOs, or genetically modified organisms, have been a minor but relevant issue since they became popular. They exist almost everywhere in America, but countless people continue to debate whether they should remain. Andrew Pollack’s article “Genetically Engineered Crops Are Safe, Analysis Finds,” for instance, leans toward GMOs. In contrast, Danny Hakim’s “Doubts About the Promised Bounty of Genetically Modified Crops” gravitates against them. While exploring their perspectives of GMOs, the articles most prominently include an obvious audience, strong but contrasting uses of information, and various rhetorical appeals, all of which help demonstrate their purpose.…

    • 1330 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Miss

    • 8881 Words
    • 29 Pages

    Ensuring that the crops are safe for ingesting is an important portion of the demand aspect of supply and demand laws. Consumers will be more inclined to be purchase a particular item if they are believed to be properly tested and have passed the strenuous scrutiny of the FDA. In addition, in companies where biotechnology is utilized to cross breed genes where that would otherwise not occur naturally, these experiments are completed by experienced scientists. For consumers, this appears to be a double comforting factor. The Environmental Protection Agency also plays a role in the regulation and legislation of genetically modified organisms.…

    • 8881 Words
    • 29 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Best Essays

    Summary: Behind The Veil

    • 2761 Words
    • 12 Pages

    With the amount of genetically modified foods in our supermarkets, the research and development of these products should be extensive. On the contrary, there is a shortage of adequate research on the issue of genetically modified foods being safe for human consumption. In a court proceeding against Monsanto, the reason for a general lack of evidence is that they require agreements between the seed growers and the seed producers concerning certain stipulations against outside scientists doing the necessary research. These agreements allow the research to be done only by the company’s scientists, whose salaries are paid by the company. “As a result of restricted access, no truly independent research can be legally conducted on many critical questions regarding the technology” (Tollefson 55). We have a right to know what we are eating and how our government is making decisions about what kinds of food stores and companies are selling us. This information could only benefit the public health; we are being kept in the…

    • 2761 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    Genetically Modified Organisms, or GMOs, are organisms that have been created through the gene-splicing techniques of biotechnology Although GMOs have been around for many years, it wasn’t until just recently that people have become more concerned with them. However, many companies that produce genetically modified organisms, like Monsanto, try to make believe that the products they produce are healthy and beneficial for the environment; while that may be true first glance, lots of anti gmo activists believe that these companies scam people into believing false information. In this essay, we will uncover the pros and cons of these genetically modified organisms and ultimately, come to the conclusion that GMOs may have downfalls for humans and the environment, but are economically beneficial.…

    • 545 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Many opponents of genetically modified foods doubt the safety of those artificial foods. They are the products of people’s intelligence and creativeness, but compared to the eternal law of the nature, human knowledge is not always right. People make mistakes, and sometimes they do not notice about these mistakes until the problems arise. Though developers and manufacturers make sure that there are various advantages of consuming genetically modified foods, due to the potential genetic defects or problems in these foods, they may still damage humans' bodies and undermine the environment. Regarding their benefits such as variation of food choice and the decrease of the cost of food production, genetically modified foods do bring improvements to our…

    • 1154 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    The first ethical issue I perceive in the case is that both parties, when discussing the subject, base their arguments more on feelings and assumptions than on scientific facts, which I find unethical when discussing something as important as health and alimentation. Also, there is the pro-GM vision, that claims that the “risks should be judged once scientific consensus has been reached.” I think that this argument in not ethical, since the fact that scientific groups haven’t completely agreed on the side effects of GM foods doesn’t mean that these risks are not present. On the other side, I also see that the argument of anti-GM foods to be vague, since deliberately slowing down research and progress “in order that society may digest innovations of past years” means to stop human development without a reason, which I find unethical. Another ethical issue present is the claim of anti-GM foods groups of the studies of GM-crops being biased and reaching conclusions without sufficient evidence. Also, it is very likely that companies producing pesticides and herbicide-resistant seeds exaggerate the benefits of their products while diminishing or hiding the side effects, in order to make more sales. Finally, according to GM proponents, “detractors often exaggerate environmental hazards, do not substantiate their claims with scientific evidence, and are simply reacting out of fear”, which is an unethical reaction to a field that might end world hunger.…

    • 1243 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Jefferson, Valeria. "An Overview of the Genetically Modified Food Debate." 2009. Genetically Engineered Foods. Ed. Nancy Harris. San Diego: Greenhaven Press, 2003. At Issue. Rpt. from "The Ethical Dilemma of Genetically Modified Food."Journal of Environmental Health 69.1 (July-Aug.2006): 33-34. Opposing Viewpoints In Context.…

    • 442 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Druker, S.M. (2004). WHY CONCERNS ABOUT HEALTH RISKS OF GENETICALLY ENGINEERED FOOD ARE SCIENTIFICALLY JUSTIFIED, [internet]. Alliance for Bio-Integrity, Iowa. < http://www.bio-integrity.org/health-risks/health-risks-ge-foods.htm > [accessed 18 JUNE 2008.]…

    • 1189 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Have you ever heard about the term of genetically-modified foods (GM foods)? Or have you ever seen this kind of foods, like GM tomatoes, in the market? GM foods are the foods that contain the genes transferred from other plant or non-plant organisms. It might be the most controversial topic in the world now. In the article “The False Promise of GMOs”, Joe Pedretti wrote about the argument about the GM foods.…

    • 776 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Gmos Research Paper

    • 1221 Words
    • 5 Pages

    “We are what we eat.” Everyone has heard this famous quote or a variation of it, but what do we actually eat? Over the past years a new type of food called Genetically Modified Organism (GMO) has flooded the food market. This new type of food is designed to better resist the climate and to contain more vitamins and minerals for the consumer, yet the debate is still ongoing: are GMOs harmful or helpful? The following text will present both sides of the argument: the GMOs activists and the anti-GMOs activists’ views. Then I will explain why I support the GMOs activists.…

    • 1221 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    It is probably safe to say that modification of anything without education is mostly looked upon as taboo. Backlash of the unknown often occurs on a variety of scales. Transgenic vector mosquitoes are no different because of the many bio ethical factors involved. Health, environmental and chemical are just a few of the well documented concerns surrounding GMO research. While genetically modifying Aedes mosquitoes scientists have been able to reduce dengue disease but are there medical breakthroughs in disease control for outbreaks such as the West Nile or Chikungunya viruses? Decreasing instances of infection would be tremendous but at what cost? In my opinion this shows that the most troubling bio ethical issue is ecological. Imagine a non-human…

    • 322 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Over the past decade, there has been an outcry over the genetically modified (GM) food industry in America. Some believe that farmers are being forced to use only GM seeds instead of conventional ones. Others claim that GM seeds could have unforeseen effects on wildlife. Still most are criticizing our government’s food safety standards and feel there may be health risks on the people who consume GM foods. Concerns like these and many more regarding GM seeds and foods are being asked by many people. I’m going to discuss the truth about GM seeds and foods and open your eyes to the real effect this industry has on our farmers, the environment, and most of all, our health.…

    • 1725 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    “I think the risks and benefits are overstated by both sides of the debate,” states Dr. Lucy Carter. (University of Queensland) By stating this quote, Dr. Carter is critiquing how both sides convey their arguments to each other. Furthermore, it shows that Dr. Carter believes that genetically modified crops are still a benefit to society in the long term. The article further states that there is no evidence to prove that genetically modified foods poses a threat to humans or the environment and that Australian states should not ban production of genetically modified foods. “You can’t easily create a hybrid that is both strong enough to withstand natural environmental conditions,” stated Dr. Carter. (University of Queensland) When Dr. Carter states this, she is saying that risks such as super weeds are not possible and should not be viewed as a significant “GM” threat. Therefore, because Australian states still use genetically modified foods and because studies in Australia show that benefits of genetically modified crops outweigh the risks, there should be an increasing role of genetically modified crops in the global food supply in order to solve society’s…

    • 1428 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    After various testing performed by various scientists and experts it “is clearly evident, GM technology can quadruple its maize output, more than triple sweet potato output and increase banana output by eight times” (Wambugu 84). With this much crop increases multiplied by all farms throughout the world mankind can cause world hunger to disappear and replace it with excess food so that none shall have to worry about starving or going hungry ever again. While there are some people who voice their concerns over the safety of genetically modified foods they can be assured that “rigorous testing takes place to ensure GM foods are safe” (Wambugu 82) and as a result “there is no evidence that genetically engineered foods currently on the market pose any human health concern or that they are any less safe than those foods produced through traditional breeding” (Hammerstrom 122). This means that any potential health risks are discovered and rectified before the food is even close to going on the shelves for consumers to purchase. With these potential benefits mixed with the genuine feasibility of achievement they all hold shows that taking the risks involved will be well worth…

    • 1423 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    GM plants and animals have the potential to be the greatest discovery in the history of farming (Huffman, Rousu, Shogren, & Tegene, 2003). Although there is still much to research, GM technology could reduce the cost of food, the rate of application of pesticides, create higher yields, enhance vitamin and protein content of food, and reduce farm worker poisoning (Rich, 2004). I agree that the safety aspects of GM products should be thoroughly analyzed, but they should not be outlawed until there is substantial evidence of harm to people or the environment. People should also be given a choice whether or not to eat GMO (Rich, 2004). Labeling should be required on all non-GMO products.…

    • 285 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays