Oct 17th
Gentlemen, Your verdict
In this story Gentlemen your verdict, the captain of a submarine, L-C Oram, is put in a difficult situation which results in him sacrificing 14 of his men including himself, to save 5 men with families waiting for them back home. Of course killing people is wrong, but if I, or anyone else, was put into a situation like L-C Oram was, then I think it would be okay to…..as bad as that sounds. In situations like these, I think there are some exceptions to killing people. He wasn’t trying to murder his crew for fun, he had good intentions! He did it so that 5 men could go home to their families. He even sacrificed himself! He was being generous and thinking about the wives and children on those 5 men. L-C Oram had no choice! He was the captain, it was his duty to do the right thing….whatever that may be. He had no time to think, and there was no way he could save all the men in the submarine. He was even kind enough to make sure the crew died somewhat peacefully with the poison. But, this short story doesn’t make any sense at the end when the jury is asked “So gentlemen, guilty or not guilty?” Obviously he is guilty since he killed 14 other men and himself on top of that. I don’t see why he is on trial in the first place, he is dead! You can’t send a dead body to jail. Oram acted in the moment, anyone else would do the same thing. At least he saved the men that he did. In my opinion, he was a true captain. Everyone makes mistakes, even if this was a big one. I’m sure many others would agree with me that the only thing he is guilty of is being a true captain. A hero.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Judge Lawrence Wargrave on the stand for the mass murder on Soldier Island. How shall you plea “ Guilty of the murder of ten people”. Now to say the people on the island were guilty themselves. He knew he had done wrong and therefore killed himself as well. Knowing all those people died for no other reason but someone else's enjoyment is wrong and Wargrave is guilty.…
- 576 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
In Gentlemen Your Verdict (GYV) and Always A Motive (AAM) the main character takes on te role of a hero. Joe from (AAM) returns the little miller boy to his family and Commander Oram (GYV) saves 5 family men from an underwater submarine disaster.…
- 279 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Although some believe that Captain Vere should have sentenced Billy to death. Although Billy was his friend, he needed to establish justice. Following the code, Captain Vere had to sentence Billy to death for what he had done. By deciding this, it discouraged the chance of mutiny among the sailors. The jury’s verdict was guilty.…
- 513 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
In the "case of the shipwrecked sailors", three men were marooned after the sinking of an oil tanker. Subject to extreme conditions and starvation, the men drew lots after about twenty five days and decided that the loser would be killed and eaten as food. When one of the men lost the draw, he pulled out his consent, and the other two men killed him anyway, eating him. Five days later, the remaining two men were rescued and ensuing actions incurred their murder charges. This seems to be a simple case over the battle of life and death, and it truly is. The two men, Dudley and Stephens, made a conscious decision to commit not only the crime of murder, but the atrocity of cannibalism. Crime is crime and law is law- when breaks a law and commits a crime, a punishment must ensue.…
- 398 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Ladies and Gentlemen of the jury, I would appreciate your assistance in convicting this young boy named Ralph, the chief of the island. He along with a few other boys became stranded on an island hoping for rescue when many brutal deaths occurred. Since the children made most decisions within a group, it’s difficult to convict one person. However, Ralph is caught speaking about the night of Simon’s death, “I wasn’t scared, said Ralph slowly, I was--I don’t know what I was” (Golding 156). Ralph may say he wasn’t himself that night, However he still executed an act of involuntary manslaughter.…
- 272 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
My client pleads guilty, but for a lesser charge than death. He was only trying to do what was right for England. The people of England were going through a hard time and the country needed money. When my client and the Parliament could not agree on terms of taxation and plans to raise money, his only choice was to dissolve Parliament. As king, he was ling power and the only way to gain that power back was to wage war on Parliament. We both agree that this war was wrong and foolish and many great lives were lost. We plead that his punishment should be removal as king of England and Exile from this great country.…
- 763 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
This prompt poses many moral questions. My immediate, intuitive response was that the four defendants were guilty of the crime of Roger Whetmore’s murderer. If you look at the question as simply and literally, “Did they willfully take the life of another?,” the only possible answer is yes. However, the circumstances surrounding this problem were extreme, and that forces one to consider other factors in the problem.…
- 1733 Words
- 7 Pages
Powerful Essays -
The first thing I noticed that was important and having to do with the law and jury concept, was that there were 12 people. In the book all 13 of the passengers had something to do with the murder of Daisy Armstrong, her maid who committed suicide, Daisies’ mother who died giving birth to a premature baby, or her father who shot himself because he was so broken-hearted. In a jury there are 12 people that decide the fate of the convict, and on the Orient Express the passenger appointed themselves as a jury ; to decide the fate of despicable Samuel Ratchett aka Cassetti. So all of the passengers, with the exception of one, Countess Andrenyi who was innocent, helped with the murder of Ratchett, it “Made it more in order” as Colonel Arbuthnot put it. I think that all of the passengers agreed because they all believed that the Armstrong case deserved justice.…
- 687 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
On April 14th, 1951, Reginald Rose, a thirty-one-year-old army veteran published his second, and most prominent dramatic work entitled Twelve Angry Men. This play is now admired as a momentous, eloquent and critical examination of the United States jury system. Twelve Angry Men examines key courtroom themes including civil duty and reasonable doubt. Through the voice of these twelve men, the audience must ask themselves imperative questions regarding the American court system, moral responsibility and the role of emotions in a verdict.…
- 1296 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
Gentlemen of the jury, considering the evidence given before you, it would be immoral to let this murderer walk free. Mr bromden; a six foot eight, concrete build of a man, trained to kill, with a history of violence was a modern day con-man . A manipulative liar who faked his own deafness and dumbess to the authorities that swore to protect him for eight years. It is beyond reasonable doubt gentlemen of the jury, that this man had the capabilities and the disregard for the law to carry out such a premeditated, cold-blooded murder.…
- 273 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
For this case the main question here is was this murder case justified by necessity. The verdict I have come up with is that that both men are found guilty of murder but face a lesser charge of five years of jail time. I decides on this verdict because they needed to do it or everyone would die. Also Parker looked very sick and according to them he was on the verge of dying. The crew members were also starving and if they didn't act they would have all died. They deserve they five years for murder but should not be executed because they had to do it in order to survive. It's also important to take in consideration that Parker did bro want to be killed and was being held down by Stephens and was killed by Dudley. When someone is trapped on a…
- 189 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
What is seen as the right thing to do is not always the lawful thing to do. This concept as a whole is explored deeply in the conclusion to Herman Melville’s novel Billy Budd, Sailor, as Captain Vere executes foretopman Billy Budd for what seems like a justifiable crime to the reader, under an undiscriminating law. The idea of capital punishment for laws that do not take into account anything but pure facts has long been debated on moral and ethical grounds, and Melville explores both sides; the side of justice, which would have let Billy live, and the side of the law, which condemned Billy to death. Through the character of Captain Vere, “Billy Budd, Sailor” reveals the conflict between law and justice, and how Billy’s execution by Captain…
- 695 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
“No, sir. All I truly know is that I killed them, which makes me the murderer. I have nothing to hide. I’m ashamed of what I did but I have no reason why.”…
- 770 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
As stated above to build the desired classification models you will use Weka. Weka is a data-mining environment that contains a collection of machine-learning algorithms for solving real-world data-mining problems. The algorithms can either be applied directly or called from your own Java code. Weka contains tools for data pre-processing, classification, regression, clustering, association rules, and visualization. It is also well-suited for developing new machine learning schemes. Weka is open source software issued under the GNU General Public License.…
- 647 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Decision-making is an essential aspect of modern management. It is a primary function of management. A manager's major job is sound/rational decision-making. He takes hundreds of decisions consciously and subconsciously. Decision-making is the key part of manager's activities. Decisions are important as they determine both managerial and organizational actions. A decision may be defined as "a course of action which is consciously chosen from among a set of alternatives to achieve a desired result." It represents a well-balanced judgment and a commitment to action…
- 1183 Words
- 5 Pages
Powerful Essays