Preview

George Norhoff On Personal Identity

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
978 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
George Norhoff On Personal Identity
Personal identity is the major issue in medical ethics for brain transplantation. The fundamental problem that arise from whole body transplantation is the discomfort and confusion about the personal identity of the patient. The sense of personal identity is essentially one of our own experience – remembering the past that we treasure, taking the present experiences, imagination that we have plan for the future and the continuity of consciousness – in spite of what has just been said we also identify with our body, within which and through which we have express our personalities and those we have experience. The very importantly matter is how we perceive the action and appearance of the body of the other person to think that you are not the person who donate the organ because some people think that if you transfer the one organ to another the recipient will act as …show more content…
He does not assume that the personal identity is an either or matter but there is something that can change (cf Hansson 2005). There are three main views according to Norhoff on the relationship between the brain and personal identity. Some philosophers assume that “personal identity is slightly related to mental states where by themselves can neither be decrease to neurophysiological functions or psychological functions (Norhoff 1996, 179). If we want to learn more in changes in personal identity we should research the changes in mental states. According to Parfit what I have discussed above this paragraph, what matters is psychological continuity. As long as patients have the same psychological features before and after their personal identity in terms of this continuity remains untouched. The third one is based on the view of Thomas Nagel, he said that we are our brain. Inside this school of thought the insertion of brain can change our personal

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    3. Add 10-20 drops of each known solution to respective test tubes, do not mix pipets!…

    • 372 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    It is very difficult to attribute characteristics to a mind when we know it does not actually exist in the physical realm. Though, personal identity has been connected to the mind. However, it is tricky to determine what exactly comprises one’s personal identity. Although it is a difficult concept to grasp, philosophers such as Nagel and Chisholm attempt to construct their own position on the characteristics of the mind. By comparing Nagel and Chisholm’s positions on personal identity, it is evident that identity is a development of both body and mind. Nagel shows that we cannot properly identify a mind, and if this is the case then it is impossible to attribute personal identity to a mind. In turn, he attacks the idea that personal identity can be defined in terms of physical attributes. Chisholm shows that although things are constantly changing, they still remain the same. He argues that it is the mind that holds our identity, regardless of physical alteration. In my view, the physicalist perspective of identity is the most logical when contrasted to the mentalist argument simply due to the fact that we do have a self-identity, and Nagel does not attempt to define what it is. Locke’s argument finds a middle ground between Nagel and Chisholm as he argues for a conscious and bodily continuity of the mind.…

    • 1610 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The accounts for personal identity, thought up by John Locke, were skeptical for several philosophers throughout time. Locke believes that we are the same person as we were yesterday because of our personal identity. He says that our personal identity is founded on consciousness namely, a continuity of conscious memories, but that the substance of the soul or body does not affect our personal identity. First, I will discuss what Locke believes to be a person. Second, I will explain why Locke believes personal identity has to be a continuous consciousness throughout time. Third, I will asses Thomas Reid's objection to Locke's account on personal identity and explain why I believe Reid's account is stronger.…

    • 1152 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Perry's Dialogue

    • 1530 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Personal identity has proven to be a very controversial topic in this dialogue. By the second night, it was argued to be defined neither by the bodily existence nor the existence of an immaterial soul (320). Instead, identity is approached by the concept of person-stages (322). This idea implies that a person lives in consecutive stretches of consciousness connected in a logical manner. In this case, each stretch of consciousness indicates the all thoughts and emotions experienced by a person at a given moment in time (322). This leads to the Memory Theory of personal identity, which Miller suggested according to his readings on Locke. It basically states that all the past events occurring within this stream of consciousness forms memory and our personal identity consists of the accumulation of memory that can be traced linearly through it (322). Weirob was not able to find any flaws in this theory.…

    • 1530 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    He agrees that identity is a bundle of memories or perceptions; meaning that they all interconnect; or that these perceptions “succeed each other with an inconceivable rapidity, and are in a perpetual flux and movement” (2). It is hard to maintain and to say that one is exactly in that personality forever because he is always changing…

    • 1005 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Entrenched in the “simple” view is the idea that personal identity, and the persistence of personal identity, cannot be measured through philosophical discourse or scientific investigation. There are a number of opposing arguments, known as complex theories of personal identity. In each of these arguments, the central claim is that either the body, the brain, or the psychological continuity of an individual determines how they persist as the same person (Garrett, 1998, p 52). To call them complex is a misnomer – for each is far too narrow to properly define and explain personal identity.…

    • 1036 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The mind-brain identity theory holds that mental states and processes are similar to that of the brain; in such that mind or consciousness is a mere physico-chemical process in…

    • 552 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    This hence suggests that perhaps the solution to the question of personal identity lies somewhere between the body and the brain views – A conclusion of which can be better accommodated for by the scattered individual view rather than by the aforementioned…

    • 586 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Psychologist Erik Erikson defines identity as ‘a sense of continuity over time as a being or entity that is different from others’ (Clarke, 2009, Pg252). We all have our own identities that are different than the person stood next to us, but he believed that it doesn’t stay the same identity throughout a person’s lifetime. We all go through different stages during our lifetime; babies, childhood, adolescence, adulthood and then to old age – Each forging a new identity for us not only based on past experiences but on conflicts and experiences that challenge us in everyday life and the future.…

    • 1397 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Thesis: Becoming an organ donor after death is not only an important decision for yourself, but it is also an important decision for the life that you may have the power to save. I. Introduction…

    • 417 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Hume on Personal Identity

    • 1534 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Hume 's view of what constitutes personal identity rests heavily upon his preceding theories concerning the nature of ideas and causation. The most important preceding ideas to take into account are the rejection of causality and necessary connection and his strict empiric stance on the basis of knowledge and the only two types of perception being ideas that are reliant on initial impressions. There will clearly be difficulty in defining and explaining 'the self ' when both the notions of causality and substance have been rejected, this results in Hume restricting himself in what he feels he can define as personal identity. Hume does not want to distinguish between the nature of personal identity and the nature of the identity we hold in single objects or ideas. Both are based in initial single impressions which the mind then assembles into a 'chimera ' of a more complex idea, constituting it 's identity. This for Hume is irrational, as there is no observable or conceivable necessary connection between past, present and future sense data, resulting in the self being strictly and thriftily described by Hume as 'a bundle of perceptions '.…

    • 1534 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    A view obviously related to this case is the same-brain view in which Julia’s continued existence and personal identity is determined by the survival of her living brain. According to such a view, Julia remains alive after the operation because of the continued existence of her brain, albeit within a different physical body. Julia North’s survival was determined by the fact that after the brain transplant operation her original physical brain was preserved and with it all of the memories and thoughts that had previously constituted Julia North. While this view may seem initially reasonable, I find it to be deficient when parameters of the case are modified. For example, consider an alternative situation in which Julia’s brain was preserved and kept alive but her thoughts and memories were completely erased before transplanting her brain into a new body. The resultant person would have no recollection of Julia’s past thoughts or actions or even the slightest idea of who Julia North was. Certainly this new person would not be considered the same as the previous Julia North. Instead of Julia continuing to exist, people would say that Julia had died and with her physical brain a new person had been created, thus discrediting the value of the same-brain account of personal identity.…

    • 1287 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    This is also what is an issue with his view. Parfit does not think identity is needed because we all share some beliefs and memories with others, making our memories and beliefs not unique to us. This is a problem because if someone was born and left alone following birth, to grow up by themselves, this person would have no shared memories or anything…

    • 2083 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Mind Body Debate

    • 614 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In Chapter 7, Personal Identity, Eric Olson approaches identity of a person by asking many questions to find out what makes a person who they are. He takes a different approach from other philosophers but his main point is that a person’s identity is biological not psychological. He asks many questions, one of which is, what makes us human? He states by being a biological organism we escape the psychological approach which makes us human and not animal. Olson argues no psychological relation is sufficient for a person to persist. He discusses personhood and persistence and disagrees with several well known thought experiments dealing…

    • 614 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    TrueLocal.com.au is one of the fastest growing online business directory services website in Australia. It operates as its own functioning business unit under the umbrella of News Digital Media (NDM) organisation, a managing group for a cluster of individual digital companies that is owned by Rupert Murdoch’s News Corporation, one of the world’s largest global media companies. This case study examines the change that occurred in Truelocal when almost the entire senior management staff level was replaced including the CEO two years ago.…

    • 2947 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Powerful Essays