Gerald 4MAT Book Review Grading Rubric The Great Commission to Worship
4MAT Book Review Rubric—The Great Commission to Worship
Student: Joyce Gerald
Elements
Criteria
Excellent:
Satisfies criteria w/ excellent work
Good:
Satisfies criteria
Average:
Satisfies most criteria
Poor:
Does not satisfy criteria
Points
Earned
Instructor’s Comments
Abstract
The abstract is an objective summary of about 1 page that proves comprehension of the readings. It includes a minimum of 2 footnotes.
10 pts.
9 pts.
8 pts.
0–7 pts.
10
Your abstract shows that you have have digested the material.
Concrete Response
A personal experience triggered by the book is included and meets the word count requirement of about - page.
10 pts.
9 pts.
8 pts.
0–7 pts.
10
You provide a a good contextual example from your life that shows you have internalized what you have read.
Reflection
A critique of the book is included. The critique includes questions that the author should have addressed/considered. It should be about 1 page.
10 pts.
9 pts.
8 pts.
0–7 pts.
7
Your critique addresses some important issues, although the discussion of discipleship and worship was confusing. Did you mean to use the word evangelism? Later , however, you discuss evangelism and discipleship. The overall discussion is incomplete. Supporting your comments with references to this book would have been helpful. Including references to outside sources would have been beneficial.
Action
There are 3 measurable action steps included to change life, ministry, and/or work habits as a result of the reading. Specific steps and time-frames are included and the 2–3-page requirement is met.
19–20 pts.
17–18 pts.
15–16 pts.
0–14 pts.
19
Your action steps are both attainable and measurable. The first two plans are very similar.
Title Page, Format, and Bibliography
The title page and bibliography are included, and proper formatting is followed throughout.
10 pts.
9 pts.
8 pts.
0–7 pts.
9
Spelling errors.
Total
55
Out of 60 points
Student: Joyce Gerald
Elements
Criteria
Excellent:
Satisfies criteria w/ excellent work
Good:
Satisfies criteria
Average:
Satisfies most criteria
Poor:
Does not satisfy criteria
Points
Earned
Instructor’s Comments
Abstract
The abstract is an objective summary of about 1 page that proves comprehension of the readings. It includes a minimum of 2 footnotes.
10 pts.
9 pts.
8 pts.
0–7 pts.
10
Your abstract shows that you have have digested the material.
Concrete Response
A personal experience triggered by the book is included and meets the word count requirement of about - page.
10 pts.
9 pts.
8 pts.
0–7 pts.
10
You provide a a good contextual example from your life that shows you have internalized what you have read.
Reflection
A critique of the book is included. The critique includes questions that the author should have addressed/considered. It should be about 1 page.
10 pts.
9 pts.
8 pts.
0–7 pts.
7
Your critique addresses some important issues, although the discussion of discipleship and worship was confusing. Did you mean to use the word evangelism? Later , however, you discuss evangelism and discipleship. The overall discussion is incomplete. Supporting your comments with references to this book would have been helpful. Including references to outside sources would have been beneficial.
Action
There are 3 measurable action steps included to change life, ministry, and/or work habits as a result of the reading. Specific steps and time-frames are included and the 2–3-page requirement is met.
19–20 pts.
17–18 pts.
15–16 pts.
0–14 pts.
19
Your action steps are both attainable and measurable. The first two plans are very similar.
Title Page, Format, and Bibliography
The title page and bibliography are included, and proper formatting is followed throughout.
10 pts.
9 pts.
8 pts.
0–7 pts.
9
Spelling errors.
Total
55
Out of 60 points
Bibliography: The title page and bibliography are included, and proper formatting is followed throughout. 10 pts. 9 pts. 8 pts. 0–7 pts. 9 Spelling errors. Total 55 Out of 60 points