Preview

Goodbye Lenin Analysis

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
471 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Goodbye Lenin Analysis
Goodbye, Lenin is a heart-warming film about a son’s attempt to make time stand still in order to keep his sick mother from knowing the truth about the political changes. His mother, Christiana, is a strong political activist in the Socialist party in East Germany. She becomes ill after she sees her son, Alex, protesting in the streets, she falls into a coma after suffering a heart attack. During the eight months she is in a coma, the Berlin Wall comes down and capitalism floods in from the west. When she does finally awaken, the doctors urge Alex and his sister Ariane to leave their mother in the hospital since the huge changes to society could force her into another heart attack, which she would not survive. Alex does not like the idea of …show more content…
As a film audience, we witness the changes to society through different generations as well. In the beginning when the wall came down, people were generally happy with the idea of the new freedoms promised. However, as the film progressed, we get a glimpse into what the citizens of the GDR lost through the beginning of reunification. There was mass job loss and forced retirement to the older generation. This is emphasized in the film with the neighbor and family friend literally digging through trash in order to survive. The people of East Germany were technically now free, but their lives were not necessarily better off. The film also shows the impact of the start of capitalism in the East. Supermarkets were cleared of GDR products to make way for western commodities. There is even a scene in the film were soldiers are preforming the changing of the guards in front of a building while huge Coca-Cola trucks pass by that would usually have been military trucks. Ariane fully embraces the new western culture seeping in by dating a western man, working at Burger King, and redecorating herself and the apartment. Despite adapting to the new culture around them, both Alex and Ariane have a sense of nostalgia for the past East. Their childhood is associated with the East and it wasn’t all terrible. People did make a life for

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    The extent of a balanced interpretation of Trotsky within history varies throughout the differing aspects of his life and personality, however it can be considered that overall, it offers a balanced interpretation to a limited extent. His position as a Marxist offers a more unbalanced interpretation, as perspectives vary from stating that he was a practical Marxist idealist to perceiving him as a bloodthirsty terrorist. Similarly, interpretations of Trotsky appear unbalanced when considering his role as a propagandist through his oratorical skills and writing, which allowed for him to be viewed as a great Bolshevik figurehead, whilst Soviet Realism effectively eliminated his significance within history, and vilified him. Within his role as Commissar for War, however, offers a more balanced opinion as it is widely regarded both during his time and in more contemporary times that he was incredibly fit for the role, however there are still interpretations that vary from the romanticised notion of Trotsky as War Commissar. Therefore it can be considered that when considering different aspects of his life, the extent of a balanced interpretation varies, however that overall history offers a limited balanced interpretation of Trotsky, as within each segment of his life, there is no real mutual consensus, as differing contexts and agendas behind documenting history aim to colour Trotsky in different ways. Historiography allows for these differing opinions to be recognised as due to the different contexts and agendas behind historians for documenting Trotsky’s history, as history is a humanised process and thus flaws can be evident within the differing interpretations of Trotsky’s character.…

    • 484 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “The Wall was an edifice of fear. On the November ninth… it was a place of joy”. (President Horst Köhler). When the Iron Curtain, or Berlin Wall, was built, it divided Berlin into two regions: East Berlin and West Berlin. The West Berlin was allies with the United States while East Berlin was dominated by the totalitarian Soviet Union government. The fall of the wall had divided the city for thirty agonizing years allowed people to rediscover life. The Berlin Wall devastatingly divided families, and in the east kept career opportunities from meritorious contenders. Communication was essentially prohibited between the two regions, for easterners were forbidden to travel to the west. Easterners were only granted permission to visit the west under dire circumstances by the discordant Eastern government, and west Berlin citizens did not want to visit their socialist neighbor. According to the westerners, life was great. The wall had just become a custom for them, but for the east, it was much more. The wall divided them from their freedom. “Voices from the Wall” by Marco Mielcarek captures the enticing point of view of the western Berlin citizen on that fateful November 9th, 1989. “Voices from the Wall” by Marco Mielcarek apprehends the discomfort from the wall’s division…

    • 424 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    During the turbulent years in which Lenin had passed, his significance still continued to dominate Russian politics. One clear example of this was his funeral as party members were afraid to read his testimony as it would make themselves look unpopular. This showed that even in death, Lenin’s words still held weight making him extremely significant. Furthermore, many of Lenin’s early policies such as his feminist policies continued to persist through Stalin’s administration as the USSR was the first country to have female pilots and female snipers. Lastly, we can see similarities in both Lenin and Stalin’s policies. For example, Stalin had copied some of Lenin’s “War Communism” as Stalin’s “Collectivization” advocated requisitioning of grain.…

    • 143 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Lenin's Brutality

    • 1671 Words
    • 7 Pages

    “Every year, thousands of people flock to the cold and dreary Red Square in Moscow, Russia.” Located there is something remarkably peculiar. In a cold, damp, and dark mausoleum lies Vladimir Lenin’s lifeless, preserved body. Frozen in time because of science, the body has been an attraction to many throughout the decades. While traveling thousands of miles to see the body of a man who was long dead may seem strange, the actions of Lenin makes it stranger. Although he was certainly an influential man, changing the political landscape of Russia forever and creating a global superpower, Lenin has a darker side. While the genocide of his successor, Joseph Stalin, live in infamy, Lenin is often overlooked for his evil. Lenin brutally killed thousands…

    • 1671 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Children are born depending on what the society calls for, they are denied true development, but the citizens are made to be happy with their lives, even the character says “We don't want to change. Every change is a menace to stability.” (16.51 Aldous Huxley.) This price is to high. In order to have stability and to be happy one must give up their own individuality, their government drilled into their heads that stability can only be achieved if people think and look the same, their government wants machines, not people.…

    • 1154 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Throughout our chapter on Death, we have seen many characters attempt to escape it. They all equally fail, as some attempt to succeed out of their own selfishness, while others do so for a noble cause. The Grandmother from “A Good Man is Hard to Find,” when faced with death, thinks only of herself and not for the lives of her family. Ivan Ilyich found the finite pleasures of his life slowly being taken away from him as he got sicker and sicker. Fetyukov of “One Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovich” incrementally sacrificed his dignity in order to survive the harsh environment in the gulag. Finally, Guido Orefice from “Life is Beautiful” demonstrated how to selflessly attempt to defy death, not for his own sake, but for the sake of his family.…

    • 1099 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The Communist Manifesto, written by Karl Marx is an economical and philosophical ideology that is centered on communism. Specifically, it is centered on the redistribution of wealth so that everyone in a specified nation or State is completely equal in wealth for the “betterment” of the society. This in theory eliminates the class system and as a result is intended to eliminate the oppression that comes along with the class separation and wage gap. Thankfully, for me this literary piece’s brilliance does not come simply from Marx’s economic ideals but instead it comes from the simple fact that it exists at all. What challenges me and forces me to strive towards betterment is that the Communist Manifesto serves as a reminder to me that it is…

    • 262 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Essay On Berlin Wall

    • 750 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Beside the financial cost and the lost of life, thousands Germans, both East and Western, lost their jobs. Those who had invested into real estate were devastated by the loss, and much like in the crash of the stock market, some resorted to suicide. Trade between East and West Berlin was abruptly halted, and some in east Berlin starved due to the their dependance on the west. Poverty was a familiar sight in Eastern Germany, and a paragraph from an unnamed author depicts…

    • 750 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    With the growth of the Soviet Union after World War II, Communism had spread worldwide mainly in Eastern Europe, which was mostly lands occupied by the Soviets, and in Southeast Asia. During that time, those Asian regions were oppressed by poverty and from the government too because of that. Communism is often a response from these poor lower class or working class people, tired of their life like that. They believed that by adopting Communism system of the society, everything will be fair and equal.…

    • 555 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Karl Marx and Freidrich Engles, The Communist Manifesto is an announcement of the aims of a communist organization. It has also functioned as an explanation of the ideas that form the foundation of communist and socialist philosophy.…

    • 672 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    Berlin Wall Controversy

    • 2911 Words
    • 12 Pages

    On November 9, 1989 when East German citizens poured through border crossings in the Berlin Wall, the event marked a new beginning for East Europeans. Under strict control of the Soviet Union, life in Eastern Europe had been restricted, with little freedom and or luxury (Cernich). The unstoppable flow of East Germans fleeing to West Germany began the Soviet Union’s decline in power, and it floundered until dissolving on December 25 in 1990 (Montgomery). The Berlin Wall had separated countless families and friends on the West and East sides of Germany, and after they traveled through the wall they were finally reunited (Gorman). The fall of the Berlin Wall led to Germany unifying on October 3 in 1990 (Montgomery). When the Berlin Wall fell,…

    • 2911 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    Karl Marx Response Paper

    • 1054 Words
    • 5 Pages

    According to Karl Marx, wages are a representation of one’s potential value of labor, however company owners necessarily get more money from one’s labor than an individual is paid in wages, for wages are based upon what is considered the minimal amount of money needed to sustain a worker’s life. This makes it a structural necessity in capitalism to feel as though we are paid less than the amount of work we put in. Given the author’s arguments, going through a retraining program in order to find a fulfilling career goes with Marx’s claim that we sell our labor for a wage in order to live, but he does not take into consideration the satisfaction received in a fulfilling career such as…

    • 1054 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Re: Marx and whether his theories apply to what is happening in today's modern workplace…

    • 1096 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Lenin’s political role in the success of the 1917 Bolshevik revolution was to a critical extent due to his thirst for power. However, to a reduced extent, the feebleness of the Provisional Government and the support/work of Trotsky guaranteed political accomplishment. Lenin’s strength within the political sphere was most accentuated by his April Theses – 7 April 1917. Lenin was a described by post-revisionist historian Robert Service as a ‘political warrior’ and a ‘power hungry politician’. Lenin aspired to achieve power and superiority over others, thus he founded a faction of the Marxist Russian Social Democratic Labour Party – The Bolsheviks in an attempt to overthrow the Provisional Government and gain rule over Russia “winning was everything for Lenin”– ‘Lenin: a biography’, Robert Service. Lenin postulated that “by offering a democratic peace straight away, by giving land to the peasants straight away, by restoring the democratic institutions and freedoms trampled on and crushed by Kerensky, the Bolsheviks will form a government that no one will overthrow…” – this was the basis of the Bolshevik series of directives the April Theses, of which Lenin was the mastermind. Lenin’s April theses influenced the July Days and October revolution in 1917 and also allowed political amnesty for exiles. The attainment of the April Theses was aided by the growing dislike of the Provisional Government for it could not and was unwilling to offer the directives. Post revisionist McCauley claims that it was a combination of Lenin’s skill as well as conditions in Russia at the time that enabled the Bolshevik to gain power. The momentum of the Bolsheviks was highly influenced by Lenin’s hunger and determination for power, Service asserts “he was a sinuous politician in pursuit of his ideological goals” The Bolsheviks would not have apprehended rule if Lenin did not call for them to seize…

    • 2030 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Stalin Dbq Essay

    • 1789 Words
    • 8 Pages

    |For Example: for and against, positive and negative, social, economic, political. (The categories are determined based on the |…

    • 1789 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays