1. Thoreau opens his essay with a radical paradox: “That government is best which governs not at all.” What does Thoreau mean?
What Thoreau means when he begins his essay with “That government is best which governs not at all” is Thoreau doesn’t want a government that doesn’t govern at all or a tyranny but a limited government, where the people have more say.
2. Thoreau uses logic in providing an example of the problems with government. What is the example?
The example Thoreau uses is the Mexican War (“Witness the present Mexican war, the work of comparatively a few individuals using the standing government as a tool…”)
3. Thoreau uses an emotional appeal in citing what the government does not do. What does government not do?
The government does not further any enterprise, “It does not keep the country free. It does not settle the west. It does not educate.”
4. What conflict does Thoreau see between majority rule and individual conscience? The conflict Thoreau sees between majority rule and individual conscience is the majority has the risk of overthrowing and removing the need and role of individual conscience. 5. What ethical appeals does Thoreau make in this paragraph?
The Ethical appeals that Thoreau makes in this paragraph are that people should not support crime or wrongdoing, and they should not contradict themselves by saying or doing one thing out in public and allow contrary things to occur without doing anything.
6. What emotional appeal does Thoreau make in this paragraph? Do you think he is correct about one person being able to change the system?
The emotional appeal that Thoreau makes in this paragraph is his personal experience with his civic neighbor- the tax collector and asks for respect, which is something people are able to relate to. I believe that he is correct about one person being able to change the system due to any individual being able to spark a change in the peoples hearts for support to change how the system works.
7. Why might Thoreau include this anecdote about the boys and the dog? What is the purpose of the comparison of the state to a woman with her silver spoons? Thoreau includes this anecdote about the boys and the dog in order to compare it to the malice of the government. The purpose of the comparison of the state to a woman with her silver spoons is the state is afraid of crimes that may never happen just as the woman is timid to thieves due to only having silver spoons.
8. To what does Thoreau compare his night in jail? How does he explain his unusual comparison?
Thoreau compares his night in jail to that of traveling into a far country. He explains this unusual comparison by speaking of Concord and how it was medievil like that of the United States, so it was medievil of them to put him in jail.
9. Why does Thoreau criticize his neighbors so harshly?
Thoreau criticizes his neighbors so harshly due to them not standing up or “they run no risk” to what they believe in.
10. Thoreau sums up his political ideas about ideal government.
What does he envision as a truly just government?
Thoreau envisions a truly just government as one that respects the individual as a
“higher and independent power” and is fair to all people.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Constitutional Governments- where most of the power is given to the people, and the gov’t little…
- 1199 Words
- 5 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
The essay Civil Disobedience, written by Henry David Thoreau has much to do with Thoreau’s own experiences than a general perception of people as a whole. Thoreau, a stellar student from Harvard believed one key idea: change begins with the individual. With this belief Thoreau in 1846 spoke out against the Mexican American War and slavery. His response resulted in the deliberate obliviousness to his taxes. In July of 1846 Thoreau was arrested for not paying his taxes and spent a night in Jail. During this time Thoreau wrote about the laws enforced by the government must be based on conscience rather than majority appeal.…
- 647 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
In "Civil Disobediance", by Thoreau, Thoreau claims that there should be improvement from the government, and that people should fight for it. Thoreau uses paradox, and similes to convince his readers that they should take the initiative to speak up.…
- 237 Words
- 1 Page
Good Essays -
"Rather than love, than money, than fame, give me truth. I sat at a table where were rich food and wine in abundance, an obsequious attendance, but sincerity and truth were not; and I went away from the inhospitable board. The hospitality was as cold as the ices." - Henry David Thoreau, Walden, or Life In The Woods…
- 956 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Thoreau begins his essay by arguing that the government intervenes too much and it would be better if they were not involved at all. He believes men are too absent minded and do whatever the government says without thinking about their morals. Those who listen and follow the government are not wise and do not trust their conscience.…
- 351 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
I think that Thoreau makes some good points about civil disobedience in his writing. And I think that if more countries would go by these points, then a lot of the world’s most major and disturbing problems would be solved. Here are his main points:…
- 272 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
King was influenced by the works of Transcendentalist Henry David Thoreau. He studied his work while at Morehouse, and was impressed with his concept of civil disobedience (McElrath & Andrews, 2007). King was intrigued by the possibilities of Thoreau’s method. Thoreau stated that it was better to “break the law than to participate in the injustice toward another person” (McElrath & Andrews, 2007).…
- 517 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
with an illuminating promise (Thoreau, “Economy,” 4) . The promise to have property (terra nullius), and in that property, is the tabula rasa of man’s new beginnings. Yet that liberty came at the further expense of aboriginal, black, and enviromental freedom. The flame from liberty’s chalice casts its lawful protection of those considered citizens, and in that, disavows certain men from that sense of having security: “[a] slave and prisoner of his own [private] opinion of himself” (4). The material consciousnesses of men sublates and alienates man from his/her self-development. The alienating practices of patriotism as a form of hegemonic social control estranged man from his neighbours. S/he must balance between the necessity of “commerce…
- 1240 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
In 1968, close to 50 years ago, Martin Luther King, Jr. was killed by an assassin's bullet. He had given us a decade of nonviolent protest and civil disobedience during the civil rights movement of the 1950’s. While the idea of nonviolent protest was still relatively new, MLK hadn’t invented it; he had been one of a few who pioneered the idea and made it popular. The theory of civil disobedience can be traced back to an essay by Henry David Thoreau by the same name. This theory was adopted and popularized by Leo Tolstoy, Mahatma Gandhi, and eventually, Martin Luther King, Jr.. In “Civil Disobedience,” Thoreau said that if a law “requires you to be the agent of injustice to another,” you should break that law, rather than be unjust to another person.…
- 485 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
2. Thoreau considers civil disobedience as a duty rather than a right because he believes that the individual should “make known what kind of government would command his respect,” which “will be one step toward obtaining it” (941). When a civil law, or a law established by the government contradicts with the divine law, it becomes a duty for an individual to disobey the civil law. In his essay, Thoreau describes majority of the men as “machines,” serving the state “not as merely as men mainly” (941). Thoreau believes that in order to preserve the moral sense of the individual, civil disobedience is necessary and it is the duty of the people to go against the civil law.…
- 723 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Civil Government and Higher Law. In Civil Disobedience, Thoreau's basic premise is that a higher law than civil law demands the obedience of the individual. Human law and government are subordinate. In cases where the two are at odds with one another, the individual must follow his conscience and, if necessary, disregard human law.…
- 1727 Words
- 7 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Whether it is dependency on someone else for money, food, or clothing, it all creates a feeling of resentment in a person. Upon taking this into consideration, the ideals of individualism and self-sufficiency begin to appeal to someone. Self-sufficiency takes the weight of dependency completely off one’s shoulders and the idea of individualism takes the guilt of their shoulders as well. No longer would you need to depend on others, and you wouldn’t feel obliged to help other’s either. Instead you can focus on your own aspirations, both political and social. However having a community of people based on the virtues of individualism and self-sufficiency would cause some problems. The first issue is if it could even be considered a community. Dictionary.com defines a community as “a group sharing common interests.” However, if that common interest is the pursuit of an individual interest, rather than common or collective interests, then is it still a community? Either way having virtues of individualism and self-sufficiency would jeopardize the community as history has proven during times when communities experienced a bad economy, came under attack from an enemy, or had conflicting aspirations. In America’s history, the basic ideas of individualism were applied in other ways: states’ rights. Less than 30 years into our country’s history, issues with states’ rights had already appeared. Having just gained independence from a nation that controlled almost all aspects of life, America was eager to pick up the idea of individualism. Even upon writing the constitution, each man who arrived had ideas that would benefit the state he was representing.…
- 771 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Henry Thoreau developed many ideas throughout his lifetime that have been highly influential for many years. Perhaps the most famous of these ideas were those presented in Civil Disobedience. Within this text, Thoreau presents highly unconventional ideas for his time. These ideas, however, lead to many of the ideals held by Americans today. In Civil Disobedience, Thoreau presents the ideals and attitudes embodied by so many American citizens today.…
- 542 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The great author Henry David Thoreau once wrote, "Many men go fishing all of their lives without knowing that it is not fish they are after." Thoreau's quote is trying to express that in life we sometimes try so hard to accomplish things and gain status that we tend to forget what we are really after is happiness. People often believe that certain things will bring them happiness such as money, jobs, and material possessions. However, after they acquire these things instead of feeling contentment they feel a sense of emptiness.…
- 595 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Henry David Thoreau uses many examples of the logos, ethos and pathos appeals in his…
- 373 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays