Preview

Hacker and Dreifus

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1537 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Hacker and Dreifus
Bob Herbert and Cal Thomas Write Articles

Bob Herbert, a New York Times columnist writes on the subject of the american dream in an article titled hiding from reality. He writes of the dreary state of our country filled with ignored public school systems, dangerously underfunded local and state governments, and a failing job economy. Herbert boldly claims “Wherever you choose to look-at the economy and jobs, the public schools, the budget deficits, the nonstop war overseas- you’ll see a country in sad shape. Standards of living are declining, and american parents increasingly believe that their children are going to inherit a very bad deal” (564). This is one of the first points Herbert makes in his essay. What it appears Herbert is doing is trying to make the situation look as important as possible, that things are heading downhill. Herbert does not specifically assess blame for his claims. Cal Thomas the author of the next article capitalizes on that aspect, which he views as a weakness in Herbert’s essay.

Cal Thomas a panelist on Fox News Watch and author of several books writes an article on the same subject titled Is the American Dream Over? Cal Thomas writes a more complex article. Thomas’ main point seems to be balance between arguing some of Herbert's main points, and discussing some of the problems in our country that herbert also covered in his essays. Such as the school system and a seemingly dysfunctional government. Thomas goes on to better define the american dream in order to show it as something besides, as herbert implies in his last paragraph, dead (567). thomas suggests “The rules for achieving the american dream may no longer be taught in and supported by culture but that doesn't mean they don’t work” (570). Thomas leads his readers to infer that the american dream is as effective as it always has been, it has simply just gone out of style. Initially looking at these two articles it is easy to tell that they are full of contradictions and

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    In the article, "The American Dream Still Exists," by Matthew Warshauer, it is clearly displayed that the American Dream is still present today because it is stated in the article that the American Dream still exists but its traditional ethics and aspects have changed to fit our modern requirements. Keeping original ethics of a notion can be hard and it is especially clear in our modern culture today, so to counter that we must modify the original ideals so that it is befitting of our modern society. The American Dream is no exception to this, but it doesn't mean it no longer exists, its ideals just changed so that it can fit with our current requirements today. In fact, in the " Rags to Riches Through Thrift and Hard Work" section of the…

    • 239 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The idea of the American Dream has always been a questionable topic. In a journal written by…

    • 1021 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The modern American dream was inspired by a growing middle-class that was the triumph of democracy after World War II. It's the promise was and is opportunity: that hard work and earn a good life: A good job with decent pay and security, a home and a safe neighborhood, affordable healthcare, a secure retirement, a good education for the kids. The promise always exceeded the performance…. every element of the dream is imperiled. Wages for the 70% of Americans without a college education have declined dramatically over the past 40 years... ("THE AMERICAN DREAM: Can A Movement Save It?", Borosage,…

    • 1263 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The idea of the American dream began when immigrants migrated to America in hope to become successful, have financial stability, and receive rights they could not in their country. The American dream however was not only fancied by immigrants. Americans also had faith and wanted to pursue the American dream. The confidence in the American dream has diminished over time due to several economic developments and government policies that has widened the gap between the rich and the poor. The American dream is basically dead due to serveral factors. In chapter 18, I came upon several essays that support my argument that the American dream has ended. I have realized that there are ample obstacles one has to endeavor to achieve…

    • 1045 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    In discussion of American dreams, one controversial issue is that Cal Thomas, the panelist on Fox News, claims that it is the dysfunctional government and unstrained liberalism that cause the end of American dreams, but the principle of American culture and the awareness of what got us here will help us to get back on the right track. On the other hand, Brandon King, a student of university of Cincinnati, argues that the American dreams are still alive. What is more, it is the inequality that ruin the American dreams. As long as people have the faith that the life will be better off than today and enact policy to sustain economic growth, the American dreams will keep alive. I totally agree with King’s view and I believe that government do play…

    • 761 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    At first, Brandon King uses examples of the Great Depression, the Great Recession, and other economic standpoints to support his allegation of proving the American Dream is still alive. King contradicts his economic claim with, “Instead of trying to interfere with the enterprise that creates jobs and growth, we should rely on the values of the American Dream: that anybody can climb out of hardship and achieve success” (King, para 8). King is saying it does not matter where someone begins as long as they aspire to be successful. This counters the previously mentioned comment by Paul Krugman: not everyone can achieve success no matter how hard they try. Brandon King adds another source from a newspaper editor in Atlanta to affirm this claim, “’the Great Recession didn’t kill the American Dream. But the promise of a good life in exchange for hard, honest work has been bruised and frayed for millions of middle class Americans’” (Chapman in King, para 8). The American Dream is attainable for those who have to resources, but most people fail because they have to start at the…

    • 1148 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Brian Wang AP Lang & Comp period 5 Thesis: No matter the person nor source or origin, one can search and work for the “American Dream” if one puts in hard work and respectful ethics. Narrative My grandfather emigrated from China in the 50’s.…

    • 3931 Words
    • 16 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Bernie Sanders, a politician, once said, ¨for many, the American Dream has become a nightmare¨. The American Dream was coming true for many in the 1920s, shortly after World War I, and was caused mainly by the country being in an economic boom. The “Jazz Age” was a time when practically everyone believed if they worked hard enough, they would become successful, which at the time meant rich and of high status. Although, this was very flawed and the truth was that being happy was unachievable because they were constantly unsatisfied with their achievements, no matter how successful they truly were. Francis Scott Fitzgerald criticizes the reality of the American Dream in his novel The Great Gatsby. This story is follows the rich Nick Carraway…

    • 1250 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    American Regression

    • 627 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In Cal Thomas ' article, “Is the American Dream Over?” he expresses a strong, anti-liberal opinion that explains why “the American dream” is lost. The article points out that the American society has become too dependent on a dysfunctional government while the key to a successful life in America used to lie in individual initiative. Certain traits, that had lead past generations to success, have been lost, buried underneath laziness, dependance, and indulgence. Most Americans refuse to acknowledge their own flaws, that keep them from achieving their goals, and look for any kind of scapegoat that they can fine: rather it be the government, the media, or their situation. Thomas provides the realistic evidence that proves that “the American dream,” is long gone as a result of the American society itself.…

    • 627 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Goff is correct when she says the American Dream is dead. Well, at least the classic, ideal picture of what has been called the american dream. Across generations, Americans shared the belief that hard work would bring opportunity and a better life. America wasn't perfect, but we invested in our kids and put in place policies to build a strong middle class. We don't do that anymore, and the result is clear (Warren, de Balsio). Although, in the past, people have valued, or have been taught to value, materialistic things like houses and cars, that has began to change. Like many modern people, the American Dream is less attainable than in the past generations, based on the six figure salary we must make in order to live that dream. If something…

    • 803 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The unemployment rate has climbed ten percent in the last five years, that means there are currently 9,237,000 people unemployed in the United States. Which raises the question, is the American Dream real? The American Dream is the ideal that every US citizen should have an equal opportunity to achieve success and prosperity through hard work, determination, and initiative. Some may argue that out of the 318.9 million people residing in the US, only a small fraction of people are unemployed, homeless, or starving. Therefore, many believe that this ideal is possible and within grasp, but the truth is, the great dream is dead. The American dream is, indeed, an illusion, with unfortunate circumstances, with…

    • 1134 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The american dream

    • 328 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In the writing “The American Dream: Dead, Alive, or on Hold?” by Brandon King, a college student at University of Cincinnati; expresses he’s thoughts on the American dream. King’s piece explains how the American Dream still plays a huge part in today’s American society. Regardless that the American Dream was coined during 1931 and was a time where immigrants were coming to America seeking opportunity to own land and be free.King says the American Dream “is more alive and important than ever- and that it is the key to climbing out of the Great Recession, overcoming inequality, and achieving true prosperity” (573). Even though Kings words seem like the right directions to go in but the fact in the matter is; today America is doing the complete opposite.…

    • 328 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Unfortunately, the American Dream has slowly faded due to many factors. According to the Pew Research Center, in 1971, 61% of Americans were considered to be a part of the middle class. Today, the percentage has dropped rapidly to 51%, and within that, 35% are living off of $35,000 or less (Hartmann). With this in mind, the middle class is slowly shrinking while the gap between social classes widen. Because the middle class makes up the majority of the population, it is obviously not good news when a lot of Americans are slowly slipping closer to the poverty line. if the majority of the population is not doing well, the country itself as a whole is not going to be stable either. In other words, it is not the American Dream. In addition to the middle class shrinkage, pessimism in America has risen, and the hope for the American Dream has fallen. In the late 1990s and the early 2000s, Americans were optimistic about the dream because…

    • 801 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    People have developed the mindset that bigger is better searching for fortune not realizing that their dreams are not realistic and structured enough to survive (Source F).When people develop the idea that the end goal of the “American Dream” is fame and fortune, they lose sight of the idea that these dreams are contributors to the nation (Source A). This, in the end, leads to the economic failure, such as that of 2009, with hundreds of thousands of jobs lost (Source A). During this time, doubt developed for the capabilities of the “American Dream” and overall questioned its role in our nation. As recognized by many though, when people prosper, the nation prospers. Without a personal goal in mind, the nation consequently…

    • 564 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The American Dream is core to the American worldview. Though people from schoolteachers to presidential candidates have spoken on this topic, there seems to be no consensus as to whether it is dead or alive. One of the many articles written on the Dream is “The American Dream is Dead—Here’s Where It Went” by Adelle Peters, and as the title suggests, Peters argues that the American Dream is dead. According to her, low upward mobility, caused by unequal education and a gaping income inequality, has made the American Dream obsolete. In quoting economist Paul Krugman, Peters says, “[D]umb rich kids are more likely to graduate than poor smart kids” (Peters 2). Schools in the United States are often paid for by local property taxes, so usually, the…

    • 701 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays