Preview

Hamilton Jefferson disagreements

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
336 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Hamilton Jefferson disagreements
Alexander Hamilton sought to shape the fiscal policies of the administration, so that it would favor the wealthier groups, who would in return lend the government monetary and political support. He urged Congress to assume the entire national debt, justifying it as a proper national obligation since the debt was incurred in the war for independence. As the capstone of his financial system, Hamilton proposed the idea of a bank of the U.S; more specifically, he proposed a powerful private institution of which the government was the major stockholder. Jefferson, on the other hand, felt that the establishment of a bank by the government was unconstitutional. He felt that the power to charter banks rested in the hands of the states, not Congress. He refers to the Bill of Rights by saying that all powers not specifically granted to the central government were reserved to the states. Jefferson and his followers believed that the Constitution should be interpreted “literally” or “strictly”, what is known as the theory of “strict construction.” Hamilton argued that what the Constitution didn’t forbid, it permitted. He invokes the clause of the Constitution that Congress may pass any laws “necessary and proper” to carry out the powers vested in the various government agencies. He argues that the government was explicitly empowered to collect taxes and regulate trade and in carrying out these basic functions, a national bank was both “proper” and “necessary.” Hamilton and his followers believed in a “loose” or “broad” interpretation of the Constitution, which evolved the theory of “loose construction” by invoking the “elastic clause” of the Constitution. Jefferson and his followers felt that Hamilton’s financial schemes, including the suppression of the Whiskey Rebellion, were problematic for states’ rights. They felt that the states were being overshadowed by a federal colossus and so Jefferson and Madison organized their opposition to the Hamiltonian program, which

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    AP U.S. History Goal 1: DQs

    • 2550 Words
    • 11 Pages

    - George Washington chose the talented Alexander Hamilton, who had served with him throughout the Revolutionary War, to take on the challenge of directing federal economic policy as the Secretary of Treasury. The first issue that Hamilton tackled as Washington's Secretary of Treasury concerned the problem of public credit. Governments at all levels had taken on so much debt during the Revolution. The commitment to pay them back was not taken very seriously. By the late 1780s, the value of such public securities had decreased to a small fraction of their face value. In other words, state IOU's — the money borrowed to finance the Revolution — was viewed as nearly worthless. Hamilton's vision for reshaping the American economy included a federal charter for a national financial institution. He proposed a Bank of the United States. Modeled along the lines of the Bank of England, a central bank would help make the new nation's economy dynamic through a more stable paper currency. The central bank faced significant opposition. Many feared it would fall under the influence of wealthy, urban northeasterners and speculators from overseas. In the end, with the support of George Washington, the bank was chartered with its first headquarters in Philadelphia. The third major area of Hamilton's economic plan aimed to make American manufacturers self-sufficient. The American economy had traditionally rested upon large-scale agricultural exports to pay for the import of British manufactured goods. Hamilton thought that this dependence on expensive foreign goods kept the American economy at a limited level, especially when compared to the rapid growth of early industrialization in Great Britain. Rather than accept this condition, Hamilton wanted the United States to adopt a mercantilist…

    • 2550 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Why did Jefferson advocate a “strict” interpretation of the Constitution? Jefferson advocated a “strict” government in order…

    • 323 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Hamilton's vision was the most appropriate for America in 1790 because of his argument about the ways of funding debts, the creation of the banks, and the protective tariff. For funding debts, he believed that national government should pay any debts such as foreign debts, state debts, etc. so that they can build up credit with new national government. In addition, he believed that if this properly worked, the nation's economy will be balanced and stable. When it becomes stable, that benefit could also increase the supply of money.…

    • 255 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Chapter 10 Concepts

    • 2586 Words
    • 11 Pages

    Thomas Jefferson- was the Secretary of State. When Alexander Hamilton wanted to create a new national bank, Jefferson adamantly spoke against it. He felt it would violate states rights by causing a huge competitor for the state banks, then causing a federal monopoly. Jefferson's argument was that since the Constitution did not say Congress could create a bank they should not be given that power. This is the philosophy of strict construction. Thomas Jefferson's beliefs led to the creation of the political party, Democratic Republicans. They believed in an extremely weak central government, no special privileges for special classes, especially manufacturers, and did not believe in letting every white male the ability to vote, only those intelligent enough to make wise decisions.…

    • 2586 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Not all agreed with Washington's actions. Secretary of State and Republican Thomas Jefferson strongly opposed the opinions and views of the Secretary of Treasury and Federalist Alexander Hamilton. Jefferson firmly disagreed with Hamilton's self-absorbed point of views. Washington more often than not favored the opinions' of Hamilton. Jefferson distrusted the ideas of having a national bank. He viewed them as unconstitutional and an abuse of congressional power. Jefferson also opposed the handling of the Whisky Rebellion, arguing that the…

    • 692 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Hamilton was a federalist who wrote more than half of the essays in the federalist papers. Hamilton had many ideas in the new colonies that would help with debt, one way he came up with was the fiscal policies, he wanted to combine all of the state’s debt and government debt.…

    • 356 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    George Washington and Alexander Hamilton the secretary of treasury, and one of the federalist paper writers, knew that the economy could not prosper in the present chaotic atmosphere. Congress told Hamilton to write a report on the economy of the states. Hamilton analyzed in his report, the financial standing of the United States of America, and made a recommendation for the retirement of the national debt. During the American Revolution, the country under the article of confederation acquired a very large debt. America borrowed a lot of money from other European countries, mostly the French and the dutch. Hamilton’s financial plan in 1791, organized the debt in three categories, debt owed to foreign nations, debt owed by the national government to private citizens and debt owed by states to private citizens. Some states were also in debt. Hamilton calls for assumption which means that he wants to assume all the state debt into the national debt. This financial plan made the southerners angry, especially who believed in states rights. Hamilton comes to a compromise with Thomas Jefferson, the secretary of state, in order to get assumption which is what Hamilton’s wants,but Jefferson wants something for the south. The assumption is very controversial because the southern states are starting to become a state right and they are afraid that if you allow the federal government…

    • 596 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Since raising revenue in the United States was one of the first economic issues the Federalists were up against, a solution to national debt had to be found and agreed upon. During the Federalist’s struggle, James Madison was a federalist who was also known for being Hamilton’s close ally. He imposed taxes to control the government and to simultaneously raise revenues. At first, the taxing started off rather small, but then quickly grew into more expensive taxes. Madison believed that raising revenues would be better for the economy. The amount of taxes developed depended on the basis of a ship. If the Americans built the ship then they would pay a small amount; if foreign companies built the ship, then they would pay a greater tax than the Americans. The federalists also believed that the idea of a national bank could be plausible because of a line in the Constitution stating that anything that would benefit the country could be formed by the central government. However, since the national bank was still up for debate, the Federalists saw the Constitution as guidelines as a way of enforcing their idea. Although the Republicans only saw a national bank as a way of giving too much power to the central government, the idea of a national bank was to make the states less dependent on imported manufactured goods.…

    • 803 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Hamilton being the first Secretary of Treasury devised a plan to get rid of the debt of the war. With this plan the debt was settled but with an increase in social tensions with the North and South. Hamilton’s other idea of a National Bank created major discontent with the people and the Political leaders. This creates a catalyst of separation between the political parties, which is the defining moment of the split political parties we see today. With this split the idea of different interpretations of the Constitution played a huge role with the Federalists taking a loose stance and the Republicans a stricter view. Because of Hamilton’s continued economic changes it sparked the Whiskey Rebellion. This gave the government a test of its ability to enforce its power. This was a great change because a few years earlier the government couldn't subdue Shays Rebellion. Later on the early domestic affairs escalated with the incoming of foreign affairs. Thus proving that without the first dealings with domestic affairs the fact of facing and oncoming threat from foreign affairs gave us an advantage/plan of action to take to fight and solve the upcoming…

    • 611 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    He asserts that “no government has a right to do merely what it pleases” (178). Hamilton argues that the establishment of a national bank will not violate the rights of the people and does fall under the necessary and proper clause. Alternatively, Jefferson believed that the necessary and proper clause did not provide sufficient support for the establishment of a national bank. Jefferson claims that, “The Constitution allows only the means which are ‘necessary,’ not those which are merely ‘convenient’ for effecting the enumerated powers” (194). Since the Constitution did not allocate the power to the national government to erect a national bank, Jefferson believed that the problems without a national bank could be solved by banks from individual states.…

    • 526 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Although Jefferson often showed a strong dislike for the Federalist laws and programs, when he took office he left many of the Federalist programs intact, and except for revoking the excise tax, the Hamiltonian system was mostly left as it was. However, this act of Jefferson’s went against many of the political beliefs held by his party and himself. Jefferson and Hamilton’s philosophies differed greatly in that Jefferson adhered to a weak central government, with most of the power in the hands of the states. He believed that the federal government’s power should be restrained and limited, so that it would not be able to become tyrannical or try and undermine the power of the states and the people.…

    • 937 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Thomas Jefferson: “Men, today we choose if America will have liberty or allow private banks to control our money and country.” Alexander Hamilton: “No, we must have a national bank in order to collect debt from each state during the war and pay it off in an orderly fashion” Thomas Jefferson: “Hamilton, you have failed to realize the purpose of our revolution which was to rid ourselves from heavy regulations and control of a central government. The introduction of of a bank will cause an abuse of power and would do so in the future.” Alexander Hamilton:…

    • 367 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Hamiltons Economic Plan

    • 333 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Hamilton’s economic plan had many brilliant ideals. In Hamilton’s plan there was this idea of popular rule. Popular rule is the concept that the rich had to be enthusiastic about the plan. I believe that this was untrue and unnecessary because the southern, less well too due states, were the ones that actually paid back their debt. Next, the national bank was a thing put into place in order to foster the manufacturing side of America and it was also a way to secure money and collect taxes. This part of Hamilton’s plan was a great idea because it helped to stimulate the economy. State rights were the part in which the states had the right to charter their own banks. These banks again furthered Hamilton’s idea of making America a manufacturing country instead of an agricultural one. Finally, the political ideas was the difference between the interpretation of the “necessary and proper” clause. Hamilton stressed the “proper” part and Jefferson stressed the “necessary” part. Both had different views on this power. Personally I agree with Hamilton. I believe that the national government has the right to make…

    • 333 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    These resolutions say that it is the state’s duty to restrain the centralized government’s power, and the states should not allow the Federal government to have any more power than what was explicitly provided to it in the Constitution. This ultimately allowed the Federal government to do what it was intended to do and nothing more- regulate, not rule. Once the Constitution was ratified and the Federal government was established, Madison began to lose his belief in pro-banking Federalism. He then met with Jefferson, and later helped found the Democratic-Republican Party. In 1790, Hamilton’s Assumption Bill was at a Congressional stalemate.…

    • 513 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Hamilton was a brilliant man who used his time very wisely and did not waste a second doing something he felt was unimportant. Hamilton knew how to use his knowledge to his own advantage. An example of this could be when he teamed up with James Madison and John Jay to create the Federalist Papers. Under a pseudonym, or fake name, the three men wrote a total of 85 essays in the span of six months (Kent 68). James Madison and John Jay did not write many compared to Hamilton. John Jay got very ill after writing five and was unable to write more. Madison wrote 25 of the essays, and Hamilton wrote an astonishing 51. In addition to the Federalist Papers, Hamilton also created the most important thing he will be remembered for. Hamilton was sure that with the start of a new country, they were going to need a good and stable financial system. The United States had already piled up a large amount of national debt, and also had the state debts to deal with. After becoming Secretary of the Treasury in George Washington’s presidential cabinet, Hamilton had to come up with a plan to get rid of the debt. At a cabinet meeting, Hamilton proposed that the nation consumes the state debt and establish a national bank. Thomas Jefferson, as he…

    • 1186 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays