Preview

harold kushner response

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
947 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
harold kushner response
Shannon Devlin
FYS: The Truth of Suffering
Professor Forte
October 2, 2013
Harold Kushner Response Most people are bothered by the fact that we suffer undeservedly. Any person with an ounce of moral sensitivity is outraged by the injustices of our world. In the Book of Job: When Bad Things Happen to Good People, this thought-provoking examination of Harold Kushner’s own and others’ reactions to the most painful experiences in life, Harold Kushner addresses the difficult questions that inevitably arise. Kushner stresses an argument about whether the misfortunes that befall ostensibly from the hand of God. Until the premature death of his son from progeria (rapid aging), Rabbi Harold Kushner believed, as many do, that God was all-good and all powerful. This tragic death caused a reexamination of these traditional beliefs and resulted in a best selling book, When Bad Things Happen to Good People. Using the book of Job as a background Rabbi Kushner suggests there are three things all of us would like to believe, which are that God is all powerful and causes everything that happens, God is just and fair, giving everyone what they deserve, and that Job is a good person. As long as Job is healthy and happy one can believe in all three of these. But in view of Job’s righteous suffering Kushner concludes we cannot hold both the first and second one. Why do good people suffer such bad things? “God wants the righteous to live peaceful, happy lives, but sometimes even he cannot bring that about...” (p. 43). Kushner suggests that we must come to the conclusion that God is not all-perfect or all-powerful, if that then our misfortunes are none of God’s doings(p. 44). God is not perfect. If God were all-perfect the world would not be so imperfect as it obviously is. An imperfect world indicates an imperfect God. Of course it is always possible that God would like to do better but that he is hampered by his limitations in power. “There are some things out of

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    If this is the case, the students should have no reason to believe that the management team is perfect the same way we shouldn’t assume God to fit that description given all of the suffering going on around the world. Although I understand his views, Blackburn’s argument should’ve also addressed the good in the world because only mentioning the bad from one scenario creates a preconceived notion of God’s intentions and…

    • 726 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    protocol paper 1

    • 831 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Summary: In the chapter, "The problem of evil," James Rachles and Stuart Rachles arise the problem of evil by Job’s story. Although logical problem of evil are distinguished evidentiary problem of evil, both of them are play a key role religious belief. The Authors were not focus on used the problem of evil to prove or disprove God’ existence. But they elaborated on the response to various ideas about how to reconcile God with evil. According to authors, none of them were successful.…

    • 831 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    “As for me, I had ceased to pray. I concurred with Job! I was not denying His existence, but I doubted His absolute justice.” (Wiesel 45)…

    • 1363 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Harold Kushner illustrates ways of coping with unfortunate events that occur at inconvenient times to individuals who do not deserve them. In order to convey his message effectively he used The Book of Job as an example to his audience. He then made a point to discuss three propositions that go along with the reading. However, only two may be accepted whilst the third be denied. The propositions consisted of: 1) God is all-powerful 2) God is just and loving and 3) Job is good and innocent, and in order to comprehend the story, one must choose two of the propositions to accept and deny the third, according to Kushner.…

    • 895 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A Prayer for Owen Meany

    • 598 Words
    • 3 Pages

    A requirement of the human condition is to believe in something. Some people choose to believe in a single god, or many gods, or absolutely nothing at all. Everyone must “believe” in something, because with no tangible proof of our purpose or afterlife, it is impossible to truly “know” anything. Thus, we believe. This requires faith. Seemingly random evils, such as the unfair death of a loved one, can put one’s faith to the test. It helps if what one believes in has the capacity to rationalize some of these harder to swallow realities. In answer to this, a comforting idea of thought is quite popular among spiritual people: fate. The idea of fate walks hand in hand with the belief that God is in control and has a plan, which takes the pressure of responsibility off of believers’ shoulders. In this sense, God maneuvers the arms of people to his will. Owen’s belief that he is God’s instrument manifests itself in the motif of armlessness, which represents the helplessness of people in the face of divine fate and the surrender of the individual to God.…

    • 598 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    If God is all powerful and all good, then why is there evil in the world? Why did the holocaust happen if God cares for his people? Why are women treated unequally if we are all made in God's image? Why do some still starve to death because of their inability to buy food? Why does racism exist? Viktor Frankl in Man's Search for Meaning offers an answer to those struggling with these questions. Frankl explains that all else can be taken away from a Holocaust victim except his ability to respond positively in a situation (87). Though his career, fortune, and family might be ripped from his hands, he can still turn suffering and hardship into something beautiful and meaningful. Victor explains "Even though lack of sleep, insufficient food and various mental stresses may suggest that the inmates were bound to act in certain ways...it becomes clear that the sort of person a prisoner became was the result of an inner decision" (87). Those experiencing hardship around the world today can still choose to respond positively and create a life worth living and fighting for. In fact, suffering helps one to grow. Frankl says, "The way in which a man accepts his fate and all the suffering it entails, the way in which he takes up his cross, gives him ample opportunity-even under the most difficult circumstances-to add a deeper meaning to his life"(88). Suffering allows one to add this "deeper meaning to his life". If they choose to, one can become stronger and deeper through their hardship. Frankl quotes Fyodor Dostoevski saying, "There is only one thing that I dread: not to be worthy of my sufferings" (87). How one responds to inequality and disparity in the world, determines if he/she is worthy of suffering. One might choose to respond morally and with a goodness inherent to the human condition, or act grievously. Those struggling with inequality can find meaning in their…

    • 1029 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Why Is Blackburn Wrong

    • 1019 Words
    • 5 Pages

    He further argues God’s unwillingness to solve the issues at hand in the first place such as how the survival of some creatures are undeniably based upon the suffering of others; he goes as far as even giving…

    • 1019 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Religious folk claim that God is all-benevolent. If this is the case, then why is evil permitted to exist? When faced with this question, believers state that evil exists to promote “the greater good”. The greater good is the idea that some pain and suffering must exist in the world for us as humans to access our second and third level “good” platforms. These levels consist of human qualities such as courageousness, charity and sacrifice. Believers claim that life would not be as good, or as whole, without knowing these feelings, however, I argue that if we never knew any of the “higher level” qualities, then we wouldn’t miss them. If, from the beginning, we only knew the first level good, and knew no pain and suffering, then we wouldn’t know any different. Could it not be a better life, a better world, with absolutely no pain, suffering or evil? So, the question remains, if God is wholly good then how does evil exist? It is possible that God is not completely good, it may be that He permits some evil to exist so we can reach our “greater goods.” On the opposing side of that theory, is it actually that there may not be a God and that evil is a product of our human nature, as well as the good in the world.…

    • 690 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The question stands: how is it that a seemingly flawless deity allows evil and sin in the world? Is it possible? These questions and beyond will be opened up for further discussion, rather than a simple answer with the works of J. L. Mackie’s Evil and Omnipotence and John Hick’s An Irenaean Theodicy. These philosophers may not have all the answers, but they have an argument--whether it is sufficient enough or not is open to interpretation. Their arguments seem to reason one side or the other--God cannot exist or God most definitely does exist.…

    • 950 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Crimes and Misdemeanors

    • 2557 Words
    • 11 Pages

    For the past fifty years, director and actor Woody Allen has evoked much laughter from his neurotic-style comedies. Less recognized, however, is his fascinating ability in utilizing both his stunning, humorous wit along with several philosophical concepts. Such a combination creates an engaged and thoroughly entertained audience, as well as a mentally-stimulated one. In his movie “Crimes and Misdemeanors,” the philosophical concepts Allen touches upon deal with ethical and moral issues. What does 'do the right thing ' really entail; why not do the opposite if it leads to one 's personal success? In the absence of a God, who 's to say whether the choices we make are right or wrong? Answering these questions say much about the way one sees the world. This movie investigates such questions by intertwining two separate, parallel plots: the tragic story of Judah, and the comedic story led by Cliff Stern .There are two key moral positions that underlie the entire movie: Those with faith in God perceive the world as morally structured, forgiving, and full of true meaning. Those who do not believe in a God see the world as empty, pitiless, and devoid of meaning. After watching this movie for the third time, a consistent metaphor that integrates these positions revealed itself. Throughout the movie, nearly every scene visually and verbally involves the use of 'eyes ' to symbolize our perceptions on how we see the world, and how people do not see themselves and events the way others may see it. Although there are several elements, characters, and events worthy of an individual analysis, this paper will concentrate on how Allen 's film represents eyes to unveil hidden truths. To illustrate the use of 'eyes ' in this film I will investigate its role in the lives of Judah, Cliff, and Rabbi Ben. Keep in mind that all four of these characters each wear over-emphasized glasses.…

    • 2557 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The work in the world of negotiation has been traditionally seen as something that cannot possibly contribute anything to God worship. Ambitions and wealth, property owning and exploitation of human labor (however slight and well rewarded) are considered sinful in the opinion of representatives of the traditional branches of Christianity, such as the Orthodox and Catholic churches. Yet Wayne Grudem claims that an effective work of any businessman can be a proper way to glorify the Holy Father. I suggest that we investigate some of the ideas provided by the author in his book “Business for the glory of God: the Bible’s Teaching on the Moral Goodness of Business”. They will be criticized from a few points of view, and certain remarks will be included based on the ideas of Karl Marx and John Kaynes.…

    • 1812 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Candide

    • 590 Words
    • 3 Pages

    * In “The Shows of Kilomengaro”, the wife of the protagonist says “what have we done to have that happen to us,” accusing God of all his sufferings instead of having faith in God.…

    • 590 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The theodicy of suffering is a theme that Levinas rips apart. Suffering as a means to a greater good manifests uselessness in its very definition. “It is not meaningful as a means with an end in which results from it?” Soul-Making, pain as a means for progress, original sin, and every other rational theodicy can never make a higher power or “God” an innocent entity or cover the historical evidence that good and evil are both imminent in worldly and human nature. The unpleasant adventures of life cannot find their roots solely in sin but are instead found on a larger scale of nothingness that we have no control over and must submit to.…

    • 574 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    What is the Problem of Evil? Is it reasonable to believe a Perfectly Good God, or even a Good God exists if there is suffering in the world?…

    • 1612 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Our Town God

    • 1159 Words
    • 5 Pages

    “I hate you, God!” I thought to myself. “I want nothing to do with you. You might be real, but you are not the good Creator people portray you to be.”…

    • 1159 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays