Herman Roth's Decisions

Herman Roth, father of two, always seems to make the “right” decisions. For example, in the opening chapter, Herman denies a proposal that “would answer a Depression family’s yearning” (Roth pg8). After being informed of the potential relocation that comes along with his job, Herman comes quick to his instincts and ultimately makes a difficult decision one of simplicity. Yes, money in the bank is crucial, but Herman looks beyond the economic value of life. Herman reveals that happiness is what he wishes upon him and his family and happiness in any other place but Newark, New Jersey, isn’t genuine. Later on, when another moving program begins to carry neighbors away, Herman quits his job so he can remain in Newark yet again. Working with
his Uncle Monty, Herman is okay with being paid less and keeps a positive outlook. His decisions in life make it easy to look at Herman and see a gentle, extraordinary man. However, when Alvin, a hot headed anti Lindbergh fanatic, is fed up with working for “Steinheim and sons”, a popular Jewish construction firm, Herman reacts differently. Herman’s belief that his nephew, Alvin, should remain working doesn’t go well. Alvin says “[Herman doesn’t] want [him] to be a thief but its okay…if [he] works for a thief” (Roth pg 50). Herman could’ve been more sympathetic toward Alvin in expressing his opinion, for in all the situations where he made “right” decisions, nobody was arguing with him. When somebody is against you, the “game” changes, and one person always wins. Herman should’ve taken that into consideration.