Summary: John Holt is a former teacher who shares personal anecdotes in his essay “How Teachers Make Children Hate Reading.” Holt remembers taking a traditional approach to teaching as a beginning elementary school teacher. He initially thought that quizzing students over assigned readings and requiring them to use a dictionary to look up unfamiliar words was a best practice. However, a conversation with his sister challenges him to think critically about the effectiveness of his style, and he realizes his “methods were foolish” (359). An avid reader, Holt recalls he never looked up words in a dictionary as a child, but the lack of a dictionary did not make him any less intelligent or appreciative of language. He, like many other literate people he met, developed his vocabulary by encountering the same words “over and over again, in different contexts” (359). Holt’s understanding of what it takes to nurture a love of reading in children from an early age evolves throughout the essay. He argues that reading would be a more enjoyable experience for children if parents and teachers allowed children to read stories that interest them and not expect them to understand every word or interpret every meaning behind it.
Critique: I discovered several strengths and weaknesses in Holt’s argument. I agree with him that it is unrealistic to expect children to look up words in a dictionary to appreciate words. Holt is not against using a dictionary as long as the reader uses it practically to look up words that interest him or her. To look them up in order to fulfill an assignment, however, will not promise vocabulary development. It is possible that forcing words upon a beginning reader will do more harm than good. For most children, learning how to read is similar to learning a new language, and this skill set improves with practice and patience. I also agree when he says we must s careful not to embarrass students if they make mistakes; this method usually causes the student to give up altogether.
However, Holt’s argument at times seems biased and over generalized. For example, he asserts “that for most children school was a place of danger, and their main business in school was staying out of danger as much as possible” (360). His implication that children hate reading because they fear making mistakes is valid, but I disagree that most of them view their teachers as literary predators. Children’s attitudes about reading and education in general are affected by a number of factors such as learning styles, personality, the acquired habits, and intrinsic and extrinsic motivation. To place the blame on “us” teachers in his inclusive comments about how we humiliate and shame children through our teaching methods is unfair because I can think of several examples where this is not always true or was not necessarily true during the time he wrote the essay. His suggestions about how teachers should assess and evaluate student writing contradicts many of the modern teaching guides I have read, which posit that holistic grading includes teacher and student feedback.
Application: Holt’s essay allowed me to think critically about my own teaching methods and reflect on what has worked successfully in the classroom and what has not. Many college students take English because it is a requirement and their attitudes toward writing are much like the freshman that Holt describes in the conclusion of the article. They are very anxious about their writing even if they are strong writers, and they seldom write for pleasure rather than for necessity. Holt discourages teachers from using reading as a tool for public humiliation and promotes student-centered learning, which I advocate. While I realize there are students who depend on being told exactly what to do for each assignment they are given, I have observed that most students thrive when they have control over what they learn and discover new ideas independently and collectively. This is type of learning is supported by positive reinforcement. Rather than settling on any one way to motivate students, I realize that effective learning comes from an array of different approaches, and sometimes old-school teaching methods still are useful.
Works Cited
Holt, John. “How Teachers Make Children Hate Reading.” The Norton Reader. Eds. Peterson, Linda et. al. 13th edition. New York: W.W. Norton & Company, 2012. pg. 358 - 366.
Writing a Summary and Response: Some Definitions
Summary: a short statement in your own words of the reading’s main points (without your opinion, evaluation or judgment).
Paraphrase: a restatement of a passage using your own words and sentences.
Quotation: a noteworthy expression or statement in the author’s exact words, presented in quotation marks and correctly cited.
Personal response: a statement and explanation of your reaction to the reading.
Critique: your evaluation of the strengths and weaknesses of the reading.
Application: a connection between the reading and your experience.
Question: a point of curiosity or uncertainty that you wish the writer had covered.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
The novel begins at the funeral of a young boy’s grandfather in the year 1949. The boy is introduced as sixteen-year-old John Grady Cole who lives in San Angelo, Texas. John Grady is not close with his father but he meets with him and his father gives him a special saddle. Also, John Grady tries to buy the family ranch from his mother but she refuses. (IM)-John Grady decides he does not have anymore use in Texas so he and his friend Rawlins plan to run away. The boys leave and ride south into Mexico. Along the way they meet a young boy who looks around thirteen but says that he is older. He also claims that his name is Jimmy Blevins. It is obvious that he lies a lot so Rawlins does not trust him and keeps telling John Grady that they should…
- 814 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Francine Prose, the author of “I Know Why the Caged Bird Cannot Read”, develops her stance that present day literature is stunting student’s abilities when it comes to reading. Prose develops credibility on the subject as she is a mother of two sons in school and an active reader. Research has been done to support her claims as she supplies irrefutable evidence as tp why reading in school has declined. Overall, I agree with Prose’s point of view that literary standards are falling due to the fact that certain books appeal to the lazy teachers, and that present day literature does not develop enthusiastic readers. First off, teachers nowadays choose to teach their students about values through the reading rather than focusing on literary merit.…
- 625 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The article, 4 Ways to Raise Kids Who Love to Read by Derek James, is intended to persuade parents into understanding the importance of inspiring their child’s love to read at an early age and also provides strategies for encourage children to read. The first is to have them “be an investigator” by looking up questions they have using books rather than google. The second strategy is to “create a reading nook”. This gives the kids a safe and comfortable environment in which to read. The third piece of advice is to “act it out” by participating with your kids in acting out the characters and the plot of the story.…
- 244 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
* Main idea of piece – the power of reading to shape a love of words and how parents can influence the love of reading (par. 1)…
- 2243 Words
- 9 Pages
Good Essays -
In “I Know Why the Caged Bird Cannot Read” Francine Prose confronts this plummeting interest in literature among teenagers. The United States has been afflicted with this disinterest for some time—young students are instilled with passion for math and science yet care little for English and literature. Attempting to explain this disparity, Prose argues that mediocre literature options and shoddy teaching methods leave students without any connection to the material they read. Unfortunately, while Prose’s ideas have some merit, her fallacious arguments, forceful tone, and jumpy logic negate any real impact her words could have.…
- 1098 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
John Holt was a fifth grade English teacher. He once felt that he needed to push reading on his students so they would grow up into a world of great vocabulary and knowledge. Vocabulary tests and quizzes on the stories. He also encouraged them to look up every word in the dictionary that they were not sure of the meaning. Once confronted by his sister, who had a rough situation with her sons seventh grade teacher, he began to see what he was doing. John saw that he was pushing these kids further from the desire to read than he thought. People cannot be forced to do something they…
- 641 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
This is discussed in Francine Prose essay, “I Know Why the Caged Bird Cannot Read.” Prose explains how not only is education important and that we have good teachers to teach but also that the teachers are teaching good material. Prose says in her essay, “... I find myself, each September, increasingly appalled by the dismal list of texts that my sons are doomed to waste a school year reading.” ( Prose, 1). In this quote Prose very clear passion for proper education is shown. Prose helps to state the fact that we must not waste our time of education reading literature that is bland and bad for the education of students. It is most crucial that we instill a passion of wanting to read and learn into students. Without this passion then we cannot properly educate children. And without properly educating them then they can not attain their highest ability of functioning in…
- 774 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Francine Prose believes that reading is extremely important in learning, therefore it is “important to make sure that high school students are actually reading literature.” (p.90) She is discontented when she found out that educators are not giving students the…
- 256 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
"Just simply teaching a child to read is not enough; we must provide them something that is worth reading. Material that will make their imaginations grow - materials that will help them to understand their own lives and push them towards interacting with others who 's lives are completely different than there own" (Paterson).…
- 1219 Words
- 5 Pages
Powerful Essays -
We need to reflect on how our children are really being educated, and create that adventurous and mysterious aspect of reading a…
- 345 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
From Beyond the Struggles: A Literacy Narrative Looking back at my childhood, I can tell you things were not as they seem. As a child, many of my neighbors assumed my sibling and I were perfectly happy spending hours outside playing around the neighborhood. However, this is not true, I would have preferred to be hidden in the corner of my bedroom curled up with a Judy Bloom or Hardy Boys book away from the constant battling between my brothers and sister. When I was in the third grade my mother whom I loved so much, started locking us out of the house. Reading or doing homework was an impossible task to accomplish when you are stranded outside.…
- 1457 Words
- 6 Pages
Powerful Essays -
CIEP 206 Final Reflection: The Role of Literacy in Learning Amparo Vélez Echavarría Loyola University Chicago Looking back onto my life, I always think about the time that I spent in elementary school. I remember feeling my heart clench as I watched everyone reading with ease while I would hide in the play area. I did not think that I was not good at school after I was diagnosed with dyslexia and ADHD. Every recess my classmates excluded me when I asked to play with them. I heard them laugh at me while they walked away screaming “what a dumb weirdo!”…
- 1428 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
As I write this, I have my four year old niece sitting next to me saying, “Wow, you have a lot of drawing on your page!” All I can do is laugh to myself and think that was once me, not knowing the meaning of each word and innocently intrigued by the simple presence of words on a paper. This interest would soon turn into the curiosity to read. Hoping to read as gracefully as my mother when she read bible stories before my twin sister and I would drift off to sleep, I was devastated to find out I didn’t read as well as the other children. In fact, I had to be pulled from my reading class to a remedial class with one on one interaction between the teacher and student. As disappointed as I was then, I’ll…
- 922 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Some children have difficulties finding a good book to relish. I did not typically have a hard time. I enjoyed reading my entire elementary school life. I used to enjoy reading books because I felt I was strong at it; now I cannot find any books that interest me the way they used to. During my kindergarten year, my mother bought the “Hooked on Phonics” set. “Hooked on Phonics” is a tool for children to learn how to read. I did not need the extra help, but my parents did not think the extra help was the worst idea. It had a series of levels and learning difficulties. All my siblings partook in this reading tool.…
- 453 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
In many instances, students cringe when the words "reading" and "school" are said concurrently. Fear immediately arises in most children at the sound of their teacher's announcement that they will be reading a book in class. There are two main reasons why children dread a reading assignment: knowing that they must answer tedious questions and knowing it might be a possibility that they will read aloud. Many teachers give their classes questions over the reading in order to be confident that the students comprehend. John Holt, an English teacher, would ask similar questions to his students; he would assign "questions designed to bring out the points that [he] decided they should know (436). Yes, if the students understand the material they read, they should be able to answer the questions; however, to the students this is frustrating. Corresponding with Holt's students, other children like to know exactly what is being asked of them by their teacher and will try to get hints from their teacher (436). This becomes an annoyance as much as for the children as the teacher. In addition, vocabulary and quizzes are given. This also hinders the joy of reading. One child was assigned a dull, elaborately written book, and if that was not bad enough, the teacher wanted the students to the definitions and the origins of every large word (Holt 437). Under those conditions, how can a child appreciate and enjoy a book? It is not necessary to look up every word in a dictionary or ask question periodically for a child to grasp and enjoy what they read. Children should learn how to retain what they read and more importantly find a hunger for more. If the hoards of questions and vocabulary drive the child away from reading, they are not doing their purpose. Humans on average have thousands upon thousands of words in their vocabulary. People do not gain all of their vocabulary by looking up their definitions; it was acquired through years of practicing our language. Reading as well…
- 713 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays