Preview

Homeopathy And The Placebo Effect

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
2049 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Homeopathy And The Placebo Effect
9 April, 2013

Homeopathy’s Perceived Effects are the Result of the Placebo Effect

Homeopathy is a paranormal form of alternative medicine that relies on natural remedies to cure illnesses. Much of the current scientific community is skeptic of homeopathy’s effectiveness as it is rooted in unconventional beliefs of healing that do not necessarily involve medical treatment with an active ingredient. Homeopathy is based on the paranormal belief that maladies may be treated by medicine absent of an active ingredient. This means that the results of homeopathy, by reason, are based only on the placebo effect, or the quantifiable and observable improvement in health or behavior that is not attributable to the medication. In this essay I will
…show more content…
It is difficult to find a reasonable explanation for the support that the paranormal practice of homeopathy garners. This essay has shown that homeopathic effect is owed to the placebo effect. Homeopathy is based in paranormal beliefs that have miniscule evidence of being true, if any at all. The law of similars has been proven to be unscientific and is at its core against reason. There is no reason to believe that Hahnemann’s cures would be effective against illness, as they are not based in scientific research and are founded in shallow observations made with poor provings. The absence of control groups in homeopathic provings suggests badly carried-out science and general ignorance of how medicine works in the body, which Hahnemann might be forgiven for, given his place in history, but which cannot be allowed today with our current knowledge of medicine. The actual effectiveness of homeopathy is questionable at best as the dilutions of the medicine would reasonably make it much weaker and therefore less effective. The degree to which the medicines in this practice are diluted suggest that they would be completely ineffective in themselves and that any effect that they might have on a patient would be attributed to the placebo effect, not the medicine. The homeopathic argument for water memory is weak in that science has proven this phenomenon to be implausible. Furthermore, the fact that a homeopath would suggest that the water is able to remember what has been in it, and then claim that the only thing the water remembers is the single homeopathic ingredient, and not all the other possible substances it may have been in contact with in its existence is simply ridiculous. Additionally, homeopathic medicine does not hold up in trials against allopathic medicine, and is in fact shown to be as effective as placebos, which is to say not

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    Whilst many complementary therapies are ancient they are a relatively new addition to conventional treatments for illness and disease in the west. As people take more personal responsibility for their health and well-being, the prevalence of complementary therapies has spread and it is increasingly likely that users of health and social care services will want to use them as a complement or alternative to conventional Western medicine to treat or alleviate illness and disease.…

    • 623 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Positivism in medicine restricts the medical methods being used to the idea that all ailments are objective and quantifiable, and any subjective elements are not useful (Lyng 1990:10). This restriction limits to the healing only of the physical body and the mind, with the mind regarded as being on a spectrum of what the human mind is capable of with chemical imbalances and neurological pathways being disturbed. Holism sees the body and mind as a continuum of the whole individual and this makes it difficult to try to treat one while ignoring the other (Lyng 1990:78), which can be both a pro and a con for treatment depending on the circumstances presented. Both biomedicine and holistic medicine have their advantages and disadvantages, but holistic medicine is starting to become integrated into our highly biomedical society in the West more and…

    • 869 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The following paper will define alternative medicine, complementary medicine, and integrative medicine. It will describe how conventional medicine plays a role in these three terms. In addition, it will review the philosophy of Complementary and Alternative Medicine (CAM) and how it is different from conventional Western medicine and a description of the five domains of therapy. Finally, it will show how CAM treatment modality Ayurveda is used as an alternative therapy and a complementary therapy for obesity.…

    • 808 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The particular society to which the writer belongs holds certain beliefs such as disease is caused by God Karma. Karma is the belief that what one did in the past can have a positive or negative impact on his or her life in the future, respective to one’s action in the past. This leads the patient into believing that his or her sickness is a result of Karma. Traditional treatments known as Homeopathy and Ayurveda are the treatment modalities people use to support, maintain, and regain health. Meditations and other prayers, hot and cold applications, medicinal water, and the use…

    • 1369 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Tin Man had always been kind and gentle and awfully sentimental, but not until “Dr. Oz” administered his treatment did the Tin Man believe that. Few know that the Wizard of Oz is a modern parable about pathological effects. The Tin Man’s story relates well to the contemporary subject of placebos. Placebos are inactive pills or pretense procedures that have a seemingly miraculous healing effect. But miraculous doesn’t accurately describe its effect. The placebo effect is as natural as it is familiar. “It's like kids and Band-Aids... ‘“When you put a Band-Aid on a child… it can actually make the kid feel better by its soothing effect, though there's no medical reason it should make the child feel better.”’(11). But children and tin men aren’t alone. Band-Aids, sugar pills and sham operations have healed people for centuries, and for centuries doctors have studied why. The conclusion shows a direct relationship between belief and better health. Placebos instill belief by seeming to be real medication. This allows many doctors to use placebos to effectively heal patients. But some people oppose these doctors and claim that placebos are unethical in every case. They want the government ot end…

    • 1412 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In conducting my research I have found many controversies surrounding my topic. I have chosen the following two controversies to talk about. The first controversy surrounding this topic would be how closely the FDA (Food Drug Administration) regulates homeopathic medicines. These medicines are regulated in many different ways which are not as complex as prescription drugs. The manufacturers are not required to submit any new drug applications when producing a new homeopathic medicine in a timely…

    • 747 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    While there are more and more people trying homeopathic medicine there are still people who have conflicting views about how and when it is effective and when it should be used. For example some women like to have their babies at home instead of a hospital. This creates a barrier between health care providers and patients. Not all health care providers see that home birth is a safe way to have a child and so on.…

    • 461 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Flexner Report

    • 476 Words
    • 2 Pages

    This one act changed the course of Medical history. The controversy of this one event in the early 20th Century is paramount to how the alternative field of medicine can still be portrayed in our modern times. Quackery is a term that is often linked to many of the natural modalities and is still often used by many Medical Doctors who are closed minded to anything that is not pharmaceutical based. The amounts of money offered to these allowed Medical schools at the turn of the century in monetary comparison today is unimaginable. How could any of the smaller complimentary schools compete? What a different world it would be today if the same amount of money was offered to research and scientifically dissect ‘folk medicine’. Humanity sadly lost a great opportunity and many people died in the face of modern medical research. A great injustice has befallen all of us due to these historic events and in the last 100 years, we have become a nation sicker than ever before. We must, therefore, give thanks to the minority who continued their research and teachings in the complementary medicine fields for doing so many would have faced extraordinary barriers and judgements. Their dedication to the ‘healing power of nature’ has progressively allowed the patient to have more freedom of choice when choosing their paths to wellness in the 21st…

    • 476 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    “We fought the enemy hard and were successful in effecting cures in three-fourths of the cases, but found it impossible to save all…” One aspect of the difficulty in treatment at the time was an ongoing debate about the cause of disease and how best to treat it. There were two basic sides to each argument. The continuing debate between miasmic, a holdover of earlier medical theory which believed that bad humors or smells created disease, and bacterial, via germ theory, as modes of transmission delayed medical response. Medical experts stood firmly entrenched on both sides of each argument. Treatment options were just as divided between allopathic and homeopathic methods.…

    • 2448 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Placebo Effect

    • 984 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Scottish philosopher David Hume claimed that contents of the mind are made up of perceptions, and there are two types - 1. Impressions and 2. Ideas. Impressions are likely perceptions that we hear, see, and feel, ideas are the remains in our brain, after impressions, and are often vague notions. The placebo effect is relative to this theory because our mind during the “treatment” thinks that we are getting medicine to help fight the sickness, because before our mind had an impression of taking medicine to get better. Moreover since the mind thinks that this medicine will help the mind has the ability to “heal” or “cure” someone of the sickness because they though that the medicine was “real”. In addition, if we have an impression that previous treatments had worked than the “treatment” or the placebo will because as proven by experiments in the past if one believes that the placebo will work than they have a higher chance of getting healthy. In conclusion even though there are not any philosophies about the placebo effect, it still applies to some theories developed by…

    • 984 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The Constitution has provided us with separation of powers. The powers of our federal government have been divided into three branches. One branch is the Legislative branch they make the laws. The second is the Executive branch they make sure the laws are carried out. The third is the Judicial branch they evaluate the laws to make sure they do not infringe on our constitutional rights. Then we have our state government which have their own set of laws to follow as well.…

    • 304 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Best Essays

    Medical Marijuana

    • 3142 Words
    • 13 Pages

    Complementary medicine and describe an ethical or legal issue regarding its use in treatment and what it brings to healthcare providers…

    • 3142 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    Medications are what is taken to heal or treat symptoms of illness and disease. In the care of our health, Allopathic and Naturopathic Medicine, are a few of the options available. Allopathic medicine or allopathy is an expression commonly used to refer to mainstream medicine, the broad category of medical practice that is also called Western medicine, biomedicine, evidence-based medicine, or modern medicine. Specifically it refers to the use of pharmacologically active agents or physical interventions to treat or suppress symptoms or pathophysiologic processes of diseases or conditions. Naturopathic medicine is known as alternative and preventive medicine. It has its beginnings more than 2500 years ago. It is a holistic system of healing with a remarkable safety record and a reputation for yielding excellent results. It employs the use of plants vitamins, minerals, tinctures, and homeopathies as healing agents. Homeopathies are small doses of naturally occurring substances, which are prescribed in accordance with the principle of similars: A treatment is chosen on the…

    • 1248 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Kaptchuk (2008), Components of Placebo Effect: Randomised Controlled Trial in Patients with Irritable Bowel Syndrome. (PRO)…

    • 413 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Placebo Effect

    • 1505 Words
    • 7 Pages

    In our twenty first century, various remedial methods and mechanisms are presented due to the evolution of paramedical science. The healing process of the body works together with the mind. Hence, the treatment process has two dimensions; specific such as placebos and general like psychotherapies (Sheets-Johnstone, 1992, 69). Placebos are used everywhere, and backed up by a psychological tool: the Placebo Effect. A Placebo Effect is based on the illusion of pain relief or recovery created in an ill person’s mind. Nowadays, the field of placebo effect has made an important progress and has become a major focus of discussions. Through the years and all the way back to the first decades, people experienced and relied on placebo effects with or without even noticing, such as the ultimate mechanism of all: the remedy when there’s no healer. The advantage of a placebo effect lies not in the healing powers of the medication itself, but in one’s virtual perceptions and behavior towards that ordinary fictitious-power pill (Wager, 2005, August, 175). This procedure has been more and more studied and implemented, for it creates an optimistic view in the patient’s mind, ignoring therefore any negative stimulus such as physical pain or moral disturbance.…

    • 1505 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays