Preview

How Different Is Old Labour from New Labour

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
883 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
How Different Is Old Labour from New Labour
How different is New Labour from Old Labour?

The Labour Party was formed to represent the working class at a time when the franchise had not yet been extended to such groups. The party’s origins in the unions and socialists societies that meant it originally pursued an agenda centered on socialism, being more left wing on the political spectrum. However changes in the class and occupational structure of the nation since the 1960s, saw the party looking to broaden its appeal beyond this core idea. Firstly, Old Labour characterizes the party prior to the modernization programme begun by Neil Kinnock in 1983 and completed by Tony Blair. Old Labour refers to the party’s historic commitment to socialism and its links with socialist societies, trade unions and the old working class.
The core ideology of Old Labour was the outcome of equality. Therefore it believed in the redistribution of wealth from the rich to the poor, putting heavy taxes on upper-class citizens. They had a strong belief in collectivism, emphasizing the interdependence of every human being. It stresses the priority of group goals over individual goals and the importance of cohesion within social groups. Old Labour believed in nationalization, which is the process of taking a private industry or assets into public ownership and the redistribution of wealth. They wanted to manage the economy in co-operation with the trade union and big businesses. Old Labour also took the Bank of England into state control, enabling them to control interest rates. The Old Labour party was in favor of universal welfare benefits. They supported comprehensive school, giving children of mixed abilities the availability and opportunity to go to school. During Wilson’s time in office from 1964 to 1970 housing was a major issue, new houses were built which made low-income house buyers eligible for subsidies. They tried to enable the people equal opportunities to ensure social justice. They also emphasized upon

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    Wilson had been voted into government with the promise of central planning and “the white heat of new technology”, catching the mood of the moment, and making the public believe he was not just another old bumbling politician, but one who showed some promise in getting the country moving, and reinvigorating the lumbering economy. However when Wilson was appointed prime minister these issues got pushed back from the centre stage; dumped off into the newly created Department of Economic Affairs. The majority of research and development funds were being channelled into a few large scale projects which had no real impact on the economy, leaving the new department short on options and in conflict with the treasury over the power to control economic affairs. However the external image the government was giving out was promising, the signing of the National Plan by the government and the trade unions showed potential to the nation, an indication that the new leadership was active in its attempt to bring the suffering economy back to its feet. However this act in reality did very little to help, and paired with the discovery that the previous conservative establishment had played off the economic situation better than was the reality, it was clear that the labour party would have to make some big changes to how they were going to operate. In this situation the party really started to become unstuck, changes in the party manifesto were coming thick and fast. Priorities such as house building, and changes in the welfare state were postponed. Alongside an increased taxation rate and…

    • 1722 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Class dealignment can be described as the relationship between social class and voting behaviour weakening, meaning that the electorate are beginning to vote for political parties which are not generally associated with their social class. The extract quotes “In the 1960s, Peter Pulzer concluded that, 'class is the basis of British party politics.'” The 1970s showed how the electorate strongly stuck to voting for parties based on their social class, and confirms Pulzer's ideas. In '74, 56% of the Conservatives support was from ABC1 classes, whilst the majority of Labours was from C2 and DE classes. The table in the extract shows how the percentage change of C1, C2 and DE class votes for the Labour party has decreased greatly – 11% for C2 and 8% for DE - which confirms the idea of class dealignment, as people from working class backgrounds such as C2 and DE have been more likely to vote for Labour in the past.…

    • 862 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    During 1997, the Labour party developed a series of manifesto’s stating constitutional reforms which later on came into effect in 2005. They believed the British politics needed to be modernised and brought up to date. Labour also believed that the citizens lacked protections towards their human rights due to the unentrenched uncodified constitution. Lastly, Labour argued the executive to have too much power, with a weak legislature to restrain this power. In 1997, Labour was successful as they won a landslide victory and created a majority government. Many may argue they were successful through the modernisation process, this is shown through the separation of…

    • 861 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    On the other hand, Labour have been seen to completely change Thatcher’s ideas. For example, the Labour party have different views on welfare than the New Right. The New Right believed that welfare and benefits created a dependency culture and were a deterrent from working as people would simply rely on benefits alone. Whereas the New Labour believed that welfare and benefits should be used to motivate people to work and to take responsibility for one’s own prosperity. This shows that the New Labour have not followed the ideas of Thatcher exactly. However, some of Thatcher’s policies have been followed by Labour.…

    • 460 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Want' aimed to provide cash benefits to the people who needed them; 'Disease' aimed to provide the National Health Service; Ignorance aimed to provide free compulsory education; Squalor aimed to help people who were homeless due to the war by providing more houses; Idleness aimed to provide full employment. These were all major issues during wartime Britain and the Labour Party's support in their cleansing was a huge factor in their victory at the 1945 general…

    • 685 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The main act concerning the elderly was the Old Age Pension Act of 1908. It was established to provide a pension of five shillings per week for a single person and seven shillings and six pennies for a married couple. However, on the elderly over the age of 70, when the average life expectancy was 50 years old for a man and 54 years old for a woman and they also had to be amongst the poorest to receive the full amount. Pensioners also had to be of good character if they wanted to receive, they could never have been charged for or known to have committed a crime. These pensions, then, were rarely given and only covered the cost of the bare minimum for survival. While the Liberals may have been seen to be trying to promote welfare for the elderly they were not fulfilling their aim successfully.…

    • 1013 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Perhaps, the most ‘revolutionary’ reform that Labour introduced was the NHS. Although there was liberal influence and consensus between the parties over welfare, the clear historical fact remains that Atlee’s Labour party introduced this. The public were in dire need of better healthcare – especially those who couldn’t afford it. Unfortunately, the majority of the population after the war were still living on a very small income and not many people in society could afford health services.…

    • 566 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Progressive Era was the turn on the 20th century where different groups wanted to reform our nation economically, socially, and politically. Many people were suffering from The Great Depression during this time. The progressives had four main goals; the government should be more accountable to its citizens, its should curb the power and influence of wealthy interests, it should be given expanded powers so that it could become more active in improving the lives of its citizens, and it should become more efficient and less corrupt so that they could completely handle an expanded role. Henry George proposed that the government should start charging landowners single taxes because he thought people were becoming poor because the would buy land and hold onto it until the price went up. Progressives sought more social welfare programs such as unemployment benefits, accident and health insurance, and social security systems for the elderly and disabled. Another big change in the Progressive Era was the Women’s Suffrage where women finally had the right to vote. Just like the Great Society and The New Deal Eras, the Progressive Era wanted to help people and provided the people…

    • 922 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Between the years of 1945-1970 social class dominantly shaped the voting behaviour of individuals. Whilst there has been a decline in prominence of class voting: Labour remains the most popular working class party and Conservatives perform best among middle-class voters. Social classes are defined by economic and social status, i.e. working class typically consists of blue-collar workers, and in the past a strong link existed between voting behaviour and social class. This link existed due to entrenched ideals within social classes and lack of upward social mobility, meaning stable, long-term relationships would form to a particular party that best reflected the interests of an individual’s socio economic group, i.e AB social classes were seemingly intertwined with the fabric of the Conservative party. This party identification, or partisan, led to 64% of the vote in the mid 1960’s compromising of B support for Conservatives and C1/2 support for Labour. Yet since the 1970’s there has been both class and partisan dealignment. This can be accredited to changes in employment patterns, educational opportunities and rising standards of living. This means that the core vote of the two main parties is reduced and there are more floating voters, who are sans allegiance or attachment to any political party, less than 40% of voters say they have a strong attachment to any party compared with 90% in post-war Britain. To compliment this, albeit Labour was founded upon a commitment to a class, in 1997 New Labour made significant gains across the middle-class…

    • 1348 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The enfranchisement of the working classes meant the newly formed Labour party together with socialist ideologies were beginning to put pressure on the Government to introduce reform. (2/3)…

    • 1097 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The inadequacies of These political figures are only partly to blame, ‘liberalism itself also needed to be reformulated in a sense relevant to a new era’. (Clarke, P 1971 p4.) Part of this need to restructure was actually due to the incredible success of Gladstonian Liberalism, as it achieved the majority of the goals it set out in record time, ‘in short, with the political capital of Gladstonian liberalism fast becoming exhausted, there was need for a new liberalism which could more effectively engage the support of working-class voters’. (Clarke, P. 1971 p4) By the 1900 the Liberal hold on power was growing, in a bid to secure their grasp they formulated the Labour Representation Committee.…

    • 574 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    he economic, social, and agricultural phenomena that spiraled out of control in 1929 decimated the artistically characterized luxurious lifestyles of many Americans and destroyed any existing prosperity for the general population eradicating billions in assets overnight and exacerbating the looming problems of lower class instability from years of depression of farm prices after the first world war. In an attempt to reprimand the effects of both the short-term economic and decade-long economic rifts, in 1932, the newly elected Roosevelt administration implemented a series of federal reforms, regulations, and established new agencies in a wave of centralization of government that transformed the function of the federal government of the United…

    • 1134 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The Liberal government introduced a series of reforms aimed at moving away from the Laissez-faire ideology and toward a more self help scheme aiming to move people away from poverty and to make Britain a better country both in health and prosperity; Churchill said “If we see a drowning man we do not drag him to the shore, instead we provide help to allow him to swim ashore”. To do this the Liberals aimed at giving aid to the young, the old, the sick, the unemployed and the workers; these groups will be discussed throughout the essay. These reforms were later regarded as the foundations for the welfare state.…

    • 1436 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    History

    • 892 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Do you agree with the view that Labour governments in the years 1945–51 established a society with ‘a significantly greater degree of social equality’?…

    • 892 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    During the New Deal, many government planners and leaders drew inspiration for their policies from Progressive era reforms. New Dealers saw in the early twentieth century Progressive movement an innovative campaign to address the social and economic dislocations which were directly relevant to the crisis of the Great Depression. New Dealers also found in the Progressive movement an example of gradual reform through democratic institutions. In addition, the Progressives had insisted upon the need for government to promote social justice, to preserve democracy, and to provide security to Americans, all principles that New Dealers championed as well. But the New Deal was not simply a continuation of Progressivism. In several important ways, the New Deal of Franklin Roosevelt set the United States on a course that diverged substantially from the vision of Progressivism. In particular, The New Deal accepted that the United States was a pluralist nation and moved away from the overbearing program of assimilation that had characterized the Progressive era solution to national identity. And the New Dealers did not revive the imperialist ambitions that had led the United States into intervention throughout the world during the Progressive era. In the end, the differences between the New Deal and Progressivism are no less important than the similarities.…

    • 1846 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays