She asks Holden why did he do it (got expelled form Pencey)? She makes Holden feel guilty for doing what he did, and she constantly repeats “Daddy’ll kill you" (Salinger 165). She tries to get Holden to admit what he likes. Holden thinks and says Allie (his younger brother that died), which is one of the few things he can think of. Now Phoebe is trying to get Holden to think about what he would like to be when he gets older. Holden replies he would like to catch everybody if they start to go over the cliff. You may think his reply is weird, but that is where she has Holden actually thinking about his future. Holden does not realize it but he is maturing during this
She asks Holden why did he do it (got expelled form Pencey)? She makes Holden feel guilty for doing what he did, and she constantly repeats “Daddy’ll kill you" (Salinger 165). She tries to get Holden to admit what he likes. Holden thinks and says Allie (his younger brother that died), which is one of the few things he can think of. Now Phoebe is trying to get Holden to think about what he would like to be when he gets older. Holden replies he would like to catch everybody if they start to go over the cliff. You may think his reply is weird, but that is where she has Holden actually thinking about his future. Holden does not realize it but he is maturing during this